Rival Rails: The Race to Build America's Greatest Transcontinental Railroad
Page 1
ALSO BY WALTER R. BORNEMAN
Polk: The Man Who Transformed the Presidency and America
The French and Indian War: Deciding the Fate of North America
1812: The War That Forged a Nation
Alaska: Saga of a Bold Land
A Climbing Guide to Colorado’s Fourteeners
(WITH LYNDON J. LAMPERT)
Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe locomotive no. 280, a 2-8-0 consolidation with balloon stack, attracted a crowd on the turntable atop Glorieta Pass; this section between Lamy and Las Vegas, New Mexico, was tough mountain railroading, and helper engines were routine. (Denver Public Library, Western History Collection, A. Frank Randall, Z-5460)
Copyright © 2010 by Walter R. Borneman
All rights reserved.
Published in the United States by Random House, an imprint of The Random House Publishing Group, a division of Random House, Inc., New York.
RANDOM HOUSE and colophon are registered trademarks of Random House, Inc.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Borneman, Walter R.
Rival rails : the race to build America’s greatest transcontinental railroad / Walter R. Borneman.
p. cm.
eISBN: 978-0-679-60392-4
1. Railroads—United States—History—19th century. 2. Railroads—United States—History—20th century. I. Title. HE2751.B67 2010
385.0973′09034—dc 2009047297
Maps by David Lambert
Locomotive drawings by Henry Comstock
www.atrandom.com
v3.1
For
Alexander C. Hoyt,
with cause
Contents
Cover
Other Books by this Author
Title Page
Copyright
Dedication
List of Maps
Introduction: Railroad Battleground
Railroads and Railroaders: A Cast of Characters
Major Events in Building the Southwestern Transcontinental System
Part I:
Opening Gambits (1853-1874)
Chapter 1. LINES UPON THE MAP
Chapter 2. LEARNING THE RAILS
Chapter 3. AN INTERRUPTION OF WAR
Chapter 4. TRANSCONTINENTAL BY ANY NAME
Chapter 5. THE SANTA FE JOINS THE FRAY
Chapter 6. STRAIGHT WEST FROM DENVER
Chapter 7. “WHY IS IT WE HAVE SO MANY BITTER ENEMIES?”
Part II:
Contested Empire (1874-1889)
Chapter 8. SHOWDOWN AT YUMA
Chapter 9. IMPASSE AT RATON
Chapter 10. BATTLE ROYAL FOR THE GORGE
Chapter 11. HANDSHAKE AT DEMING
Chapter 12. WEST ACROSS TEXAS
Chapter 13. TRANSCONTINENTAL AT LAST
Chapter 14. BATTLING FOR CALIFORNIA
Chapter 15. GOULD AGAIN
Chapter 16. TO THE HALLS OF MONTEZUMA
Chapter 17. CALIFORNIA FOR A DOLLAR
Part III:
Santa Fe All the Way (1889-1909)
Chapter 18. MAKING THE MARKETS
Chapter 19. CANYON DREAMS AND SCHEMES
Chapter 20. THE BOOM GOES BUST
Chapter 21. STILL WEST FROM DENVER
Chapter 22. TOP OF THE HEAP
Chapter 23. DUELING STREAMLINERS
Afterword: American Railroads in the Twenty-first Century
Acknowledgments
Notes
Bibliography
About the Author
List of Maps
General Routes of the Pacific Railroad Surveys of 1853
Early Transcontinental Contenders, Circa 1863
Kansas Pacific Construction, 1865–1870
Western U.S. Transcontinental Routes, 1869
Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Construction, 1868–1872
Competition in Colorado, Early 1870s
San Francisco Bay Area Railroads, Circa 1870
Western U.S. Transcontinental Routes, 1877
The Drive for Southern California, Mid-1870s
The Tehachapi Loop
Yuma Crossings
Southern Colorado Battles, 1878–1879
Raton Pass Shoo-fly and Tunnel, 1878–1879
The Royal Gorge
The Santa Fe Meets the Southern Pacific at Deming
Texas and Pacific Construction
Western U.S. Transcontinental Routes, 1883
The Santa Fe Meets the Southern Pacific at Needles
Needles Crossings
The California Southern
Colorado Battleground, 1888
The Georgetown Loop
Santa Fe Expansion into Texas
American-Backed Railroad Ventures in Mexico
Santa Fe Racetrack to Chicago, 1887
The Battle for Southern California, 1887–1890
Western U.S. Transcontinental Routes, 1910
San Francisco and San Joaquin Valley Railway
Western Pacific Extension
The Santa Fe’s Belen Cutoff, 1908
Introduction
Railroad Battleground
Among my earliest memories are those of being down at the railroad depot with my grandfather, watching the trains come in. It was the 1950s, and I wish I had realized then what an era was passing before my eyes. I grew up dreaming of airplanes and space travel, but my fascination with railroads never left me. Ironically, fifty years later, there has been a great resurgence in America’s dependence on rails. It will never be the same as the Santa Fe Super Chief, of course, or the California Zephyr that I rode west from Chicago with Grandpa and Grandma, but America’s commerce still rides the rails—no more so than on the direct Los Angeles-to-Chicago super route across the American Southwest.
Much has been written about America’s first transcontinental railroad, but driving the golden spike at Promontory Summit in 1869 signaled merely the beginning of the transcontinental railroad saga. The pre–Civil War notion that only one rail line would cross the continent vanished on the prairie winds. The rest of the country was suddenly up for grabs. Dozens of railroads, all with aggressive empire builders at their helms, raced one another for the ultimate prize of a southern transcontinental route that was generally free of snow, shorter in distance, and gentler in gradients.
The Denver and Rio Grande Railway’s gentleman general, William Jackson Palmer, put his railroad’s three-foot narrow gauge rails up against the big boys. The Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe’s William Barstow Strong and Edward Payson Ripley made sure that the routes were staked and won, and then created a textbook example of efficiency upon them. Collis P. Huntington, having already won half the West for the Central Pacific, determined to control the other half for the Southern Pacific. Above them all floated the shadowy hand of Jay Gould, a man who bought and sold railroads as readily as some men traded horses.
Meanwhile, tens of thousands of ordinary men waged a different type of war: the herculean task of constructing the bridges, tunnels, cuts, and fills of these empires and hurriedly flinging track across wild and wide-open country. Among their challenges were vast distances, high elevations, tortuous canyons, unruly rivers, and two towering walls of mountains. The better routes were often not to be shared—admitting no passage wider than the ruts of a wagon or the steel rails of a single track of railroad.
From wagon ruts to a railroad empire, this is the story of the battles to control the heavily contested transportation corridors of the American Southwest and to build America’s greatest transcontinent
al route through them. When the dust finally settled, the southern route linking Los Angeles and Chicago had become the most significant of the nation’s transcontinental railroads.
Railroads and Railroaders
A Cast of Characters
RAILROADS
There are hundreds, perhaps thousands, of railroad names scattered about the American West. The vast majority were “paper” railroads, incorporated legally to hold a route, bluff an opponent, or appease local economic interests—all without laying a single railroad tie. Many of the companies that incorporated and actually laid track went through a succession of names because of mergers, acquisitions, and reorganizations after bankruptcy. Sometimes the change was no more than for Railroad to become Railway or vice versa. Many of these, too, drifted into oblivion or became part of larger enterprises. Finally, the principal contenders were frequently forced by state or territorial laws to incorporate separate corporations within certain boundaries.
References herein are usually to the major railroads without distinction to their numerous controlled affiliates, subsidiaries, or joint ventures. This list is by no means definitive—nor even comprehensive of the railroads in this book—but it is an effort to identify the key roads.
A note about ampersands: The ampersand (&) is a staple of railroading, but its usage was varied and highly inconsistent. Consequently, and is used herein in railroad names to avoid confusion.
ATCHISON, TOPEKA AND SANTA FE—Organized in 1860, the railroad finally started construction in 1868 and eventually became the dominant transcontinental system in the southwestern United States.
ATLANTIC AND PACIFIC—Forced into early receivership, the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad emerged as a joint venture of the Santa Fe and Frisco railroads and eventually became the key link in the Santa Fe’s main line across Arizona.
CALIFORNIA SOUTHERN—With capital from Santa Fe investors, the California Southern built north from San Diego to San Bernardino and eventually over Cajon Pass.
CENTRAL PACIFIC—The western end of the first transcontinental, the Central Pacific was the foundation of the “Big Four” ’s (Crocker, Hopkins, Huntington, and Stanford) empire and became an important part of the Southern Pacific system.
CHICAGO, BURLINGTON AND QUINCY—Known most readily as “the Burlington,” the railroad had pre–Civil War origins but became a transcontinental contender when it built west to Colorado and later pioneered the Zephyr streamliners.
COLORADO MIDLAND—Built by mining tycoon J. J. Hagerman from Colorado Springs to Aspen, this road through the heart of Colorado was sold to the Santa Fe just before the panic of 1893.
DENVER AND RIO GRANDE—Initially a narrow gauge incorporated by William Jackson Palmer to run south from Denver and serve as a north-south feeder line, the Denver and Rio Grande developed its own transcontinental ambitions.
DENVER AND RIO GRANDE WESTERN—Incorporated in 1881 and known simply as the Rio Grande Western after 1889, this segment between Grand Junction, Colorado, and Ogden, Utah, remained under William Jackson Palmer’s control until sold to the Denver and Rio Grande in 1903. After a reorganization in 1920, the entire Rio Grande system was called the Denver and Rio Grande Western Railroad.
DENVER, SOUTH PARK AND PACIFIC—This was a feisty narrow gauge with which founder John Evans and Denver investors hoped to tap the mineral riches of central Colorado and then connect Denver to the Pacific.
GULF, COLORADO AND SANTA FE—This railroad made halfhearted progress north through Texas from Galveston until it was absorbed into the Santa Fe system, giving that road access from the Midwest to the Gulf of Mexico.
KANSAS PACIFIC—Begun as the Union Pacific, Eastern Division, its completed line between Kansas City and Denver eventually became part of the Union Pacific.
MEXICAN CENTRAL—A standard gauge concession granted by Mexico to Santa Fe interests, its main line stretched from El Paso, Texas, to Mexico City.
MEXICAN NATIONAL—A narrow gauge road built under concession to William Jackson Palmer and his associates, it ran from Laredo, Texas, to Mexico City.
MISSOURI PACIFIC—A sleepy local road until bought by Jay Gould, the Missouri Pacific evolved into the centerpiece of the Gould empire, extending west to Colorado and south to the Gulf of Mexico via the Texas and Pacific Railway.
ST. LOUIS AND SAN FRANCISCO—Despite transcontinental dreams, the Frisco, as it was called, remained a Midwest regional road, but its western land grants made the Atlantic and Pacific possible.
SOUTHERN PACIFIC—Acquiring a number of small Bay Area railroads, the Southern Pacific built east across Arizona and New Mexico and was the domain of Collis P. Huntington.
TEXAS AND PACIFIC—Saved from early bankruptcy by Thomas A. Scott, who later sold it to Jay Gould, the road built across Texas to link up with the Southern Pacific.
UNION PACIFIC—The eastern end of the first transcontinental, the Union Pacific slipped into receivership before becoming a powerhouse under E. H. Harriman.
UNION PACIFIC, EASTERN DIVISION—Always a separate entity from the original Union Pacific, this road became the Kansas Pacific and reached Denver by 1870.
WESTERN PACIFIC—Not to be confused with an early Bay Area venture absorbed into the Southern Pacific, this was George Gould’s twentieth-century effort between Ogden and Oakland via the Feather River Canyon.
RAILROADERS
MARY JANE COLTER (1869–1958)—Architect and designer whose buildings and interiors tied the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe to the landscape it served.
CHARLES CROCKER (1822–1888)—One of the Central Pacific’s Big Four and the construction expert behind the effort to build the Southern Pacific across the Southwest.
JOHN EVANS (1814–1897)—Principal founder of the Denver, South Park and Pacific Railroad and the Fort Worth and Denver City Railway between Colorado and Texas.
GEORGE GOULD (1864–1923)—Jay’s son and ruler of his own considerable empire of the Missouri Pacific, Denver and Rio Grande, and Western Pacific.
JAY GOULD (1836–1892)—Wall Street banker who at one time or another controlled the Union Pacific, Texas and Pacific, Denver and Rio Grande, Frisco, and Missouri Pacific.
E. H. HARRIMAN (1848–1909)—New York banker turned rail baron, he revitalized the Union Pacific and began an acquisition program that included the Southern Pacific.
FRED HARVEY (1835–1901)—The Santa Fe’s marketing ace in the hole as the purveyor of solid, reliable food in Harvey House restaurants and hotels up and down the Santa Fe line.
CYRUS K. HOLLIDAY (1826–1900)—Visionary behind the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe, and a longtime member of its board of directors.
MARK HOPKINS (1813–1879)—Big Four accountant and money counter whose attention to detail and underlying conservatism made them all millionaires.
COLLIS P. HUNTINGTON (1821–1900)—The Big Four’s insatiable expansionist who championed the Southern Pacific and extended a railroad empire across the continent.
WILLIAM RAYMOND MORLEY (1846–1883)—The Santa Fe’s man on the scene at the pivotal battles for Raton Pass and the Royal Gorge.
THOMAS NICKERSON (1810–1892)—Sea captain turned railroad investor, he led the Santa Fe through its turbulent expansion during the 1870s.
WILLIAM JACKSON PALMER (1836–1909)—Construction manager of the Kansas Pacific’s drive across the plains and guiding light of the narrow gauge Denver and Rio Grande.
EDWARD PAYSON RIPLEY (1845–1920)—Foremost an “operations” man, he guided the Santa Fe out of the panic of 1893 with steady expansion and sound management.
A. A. ROBINSON (1844–1919)—The engineer and implementer of much of the Santa Fe’s expansion, he made the decision to seize Raton Pass.
WILLIAM S. ROSECRANS (1819–1898)—Civil War general who went west to seek his fortune in railroads and real estate, particularly in Southern California and Mexico.
THOMAS A. SCOTT (1823–1881)—Thomson’s right-hand man at the Pennsylvania Railroad, he sought to extend it
s network with the Texas and Pacific.
LELAND STANFORD (1824–1893)—More politician than railroader, he handled the political strings of the Big Four as California governor and U.S. senator.
WILLIAM BARSTOW STRONG (1837–1914)—The president of the Santa Fe from the battle for Raton Pass through the completion of its line across Arizona and into California.
J. EDGAR THOMSON (1808–1874)—The man many call “the father of the modern railroad network,” he led the Pennsylvania Railroad with the mantra “Build west.”
Major Events in Building the Southwestern Transcontinental System
AT&SF—Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railroad
D&RG—Denver and Rio Grande Railway
SP—Southern Pacific Railroad
1853 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers leads railroad surveys of the West. Gadsden Purchase ensures U.S. control of 32nd parallel route.
1858 Butterfield Overland Mail begins.
1860 Cyrus K. Holliday and others incorporate AT&SF.
1862 Congress passes Pacific Railroad Act.
1864 Amendments to Pacific Railroad Act increase land grants.
1865 Civil War ends; railroad construction renews with a flurry.
1866 Union Pacific reaches the 100th meridian, in mid-Nebraska. Congress approves land grants for still-trackless SP.
1867 William Jackson Palmer surveys 35th parallel for Kansas Pacific.
1868 AT&SF begins construction southwest from Topeka, Kansas.
1869 Completion of first transcontinental railroad at Promontory, Utah.