The Promise of Amazing

by Robin Constantine

  “Gray, I wanted to be alone with you,” I said.

  “Alone,” he echoed, trying on the word for size.

  “I felt bad leaving the party last week, and when you didn’t text or call—”

  “Wren, I’m sorry about that, I told you—”

  “I know. I get it, really. It’s okay if you just want to be friends.”

  He squinted and shook his head. “Where would you get that idea?”

  “When you introduced me to Luke,” I said.

  “That’s why you left, isn’t it? I introduced you to Luke as a friend because you’re none of his business. I didn’t mean . . .” He trailed off.

  I waited for more of an explanation.

  “Wren,” he said softly, shaking his head. I stepped toward him, putting my hands on his chest again. He wouldn’t look at me.

  “Our timing sucks,” he said.

  “Why?”

  “It’s . . . I . . . hard to explain. I’d just rather be with you when my life is less . . . complicated.”

  “Then you want to be friends,” I said, letting my hands fall. I knew I should be okay with it, but my heart felt like it was free-falling down to my feet. Complicated . . . Damn, what a cliché.

  His fingers trembled as he swept loose strands of my hair away from my face, tucking them behind my ear with his index finger, tracing my earlobe. He breathed out hard.

  “Oh, screw it.”

  He pulled me against him. Our mouths touched, lips parted, my breath disappearing into his. My body sparked to life again, the disappointment from moments earlier replaced by a warm, liquid whoosh that filled me up. His hands were on my face, in my hair, snapping off the elastic that held my braid together.

  I fumbled with the zipper of my coat. Grayson’s fingers covered mine and unzipped it fiercely, pushing the coat off my shoulders in one swift motion. Eyes on mine, he tugged at his pullover. His hair fell across his face as he brought it forward. I peeled the pullover from his arms and dropped it to the floor as he moved toward me. He shook his hair off his face, practically growling as he reached for me again.

  Our lips couldn’t meet fast enough.

  I closed my eyes, ran my fingertips across his jaw, into his hair. Firm hands caressed my back, untangled my braid. We swayed backward, mouths still touching, toward the sofa, where only hours before Bridezilla and her friends had toasted her marriage. I reached behind me to soften our downward plunge onto the cushions. We fell diagonally, feet hanging off the edge.

  Part of me was aware that things were getting wildly out of hand. That the Wren and Grayson who existed before this moment—the harmless flirtation—was over. There would be no going back to friends or coworkers. This changed everything.

  Grayson burst out laughing.

  He rested his forehead on my shoulder, his body convulsing with each new round.

  “What?”

  He grinned. “Wren, help me look for a corkscrew? That’s the best you could come up with?”

  I clapped my hand to my forehead, spreading my fingers to cover my eyes.

  “Oh, God, I know . . . I know. It’s ridiculous.” He coaxed my fingers away from my face.

  “Nah, I love it,” he said, pausing to kiss the tip of my nose. “You’re so adorable, it kills me.”

  I maneuvered my body so we faced each other, side by side. He reached for my hand, entwining our fingers.

  “So if I had said, I’ve got a key to the cottage; we can be alone, you would have said, Sure, let’s go?”

  “Are you nuts? I would have said, No way, I’m out of here,” he answered, pretending to get up.

  “Stop.”

  His eyes got serious again, and he gently nudged me to my back so he was on top of me, the pressure of his body making me weak and warm at the same time. He kissed me lightly on the cheek, nuzzled my neck.

  “I’d go anywhere for you, Wren,” he whispered.

  And then he kissed me.

  SIXTEEN

  GRAYSON

  WREN.

  Wren. Wren. Wren. Wren.

  I couldn’t stop thinking.

  About.

  Her.

  But I had to. In order to do what I needed to do, I had to put her out of my thoughts, at least for the morning.

  It was so hard. The night before had been so . . . sweet.

  Yes, sweet. Me. Grayson Barrett, former male slut, kissing, just kissing. Well, and getting a preview of Wren’s curves with my hands. I fought back a grin. Pop noticed.

  “What’s up with you?” he asked. We sat around the breakfast table, him with a bowl of cereal that resembled something you might find in a horse’s feed bag, me with two well-done English muffins dripping with butter. Tiffany put three shots of her acai-berry wonder juice on the table and then sat down, cup of Greek yogurt in one hand, Ladies’ Home Journal in the other.

  My father picked up his shot. “Salut,” he said, tossing it back and wincing.

  I did the same.

  Wren.

  “So have you given any more thought to what we talked about yesterday?” he asked.

  Wren. Wren. Wren. Wren.

  “Um, what?” I asked, taking a bite of one of the muffins, butter dripping down my chin.

  “Going to your mother’s next week,” he said, then looked at Tiff for backup.

  “Oh, that,” I said, catching the butter drip with my thumb. “Um, yeah, maybe.”

  “Maybe?” Tiffany asked.

  “I do think I’ll ask Wren though. Have some fun like you said, Pop.”

  Saying Wren’s name out loud, tossing it into casual conversation, felt good.

  “Wren,” Tiff said. “Maybe that’s why you’re in such a good mood this morning?”

  I put my coffee mug to my lips and shrugged. I hadn’t planned on last night being a good one. As a matter of fact, I’d wanted to put off hooking up with Wren until I’d finished up my business with Luke. When I went into work last night, I tried to play it cool, but I could see how much it bothered her. I hadn’t planned on our hour-long gropefest. And while I initially resisted, the thought of touching her, of her wanting me to touch her . . . Well, damn, I just wasn’t strong enough to abstain from that.

  But I still had to find a way to separate the two: my life with Wren and my life with Luke.

  And I had no clue how I was going to pull it off.

  “Of course that’s why he’s in such a good mood. You think he got that job because he likes to wait tables?”

  “Pop.”

  “I told you, even from my deathbed I could see you two were diggin’ each other.”

  “Cool it with the deathbed,” Tiffany said. “Gray, it’s just nice to finally see you getting serious about a girl. You’ve been running around for so long.”

  “Running around?” I asked, laughing. “Why would you think that?”

  “Well, you must have been doing something. You’re too much of a catch to spend your Saturday nights alone.”

  “He and Luke were racking ’em up and forgetting names, like his old man back in the day.”

  Tiff leaned over and gave Pop a pinch on the arm.

  He chuckled. “Honey.”

  “We’re going out together later,” I said.

  “A date?”

  “They don’t label it anymore, Tiff. Don’t you know that?” Pop said, laying out the paper beside his cereal bowl.

  “No, it’s a date,” I said, trying to tame my lame-ass grin. “I’m taking her ice-skating.”

  “Skating? How retro,” she said.

  “Not retro. Perfect. Movies are a gamble. Dinner breaks the bank. When you skate you can hold hands without looking like you want more. And, well, if she falls, you can help her up, be the hero.”

  Tiffany smiled. “That sounds like classic Blake Barrett.”

  “You must like this girl,” Pop said casually, flipping over the paper.

  Ice-skating had been his advice when I’d asked where I should take my twelve-year-old crush, Bethany Fr
azier, on our first (and only) date. It worked like a charm—and we shared our first kiss by the snack bar as we waited for hot pretzels. When I’d asked Pop later how he knew it would work, he told me it was one of the first dates he’d had with my mom.

  “Maybe, we’ll see.” I scarfed the rest of my remaining English muffin and got up from the table.

  “Well, Grayson Matthew, I think it’s great,” Tiffany said, beaming.

  If she only knew how much running around I’d done. Being with Wren was something else entirely, and it was something I wanted so bad, it scared me. So bad, I was willing to hold back, to take things at a snail’s pace, to jump this final hurdle with Luke so it would be smooth sailing ahead. And I almost believed it would all work out as I climbed up the stairs to shower, before boxing up all these innocent feelings so I could find my inner deviant.

  The soulless freak known as Mike Pearson.

  Mike had a date with the Hollister chick.

  For the record, I loathe Hollister.

  It’s a pretentious, overpriced, assault-of-the-senses nightclub of a store for middle schoolers who think this is what you need to dress cool.

  I also happen to loathe the mall on Saturdays, but to Mike . . . hell, it was like spring break. At 11:00 a.m., parking was a bitch. I found a spot about a half-mile away from the entrance. The walk helped me get back into a Mike Pearson frame of mind.

  The Hollister chick’s name was Allegra. We met at a billiard hall on Staten Island. Me, Andy, and Luke had heard from a couple of St. Gabe’s guys that Jake’s Bankshot, just a quick ride over the Bayonne Bridge, was a decent place to shoot pool, scope out chicks, and throw back a few without too much ID scrutiny. Staten Island was a little too close to home for a hit, so I figured we were taking it easy, just going out to chill, something we hadn’t done in a while.

  It wasn’t until Luke introduced himself as Brinker Hadley to a girl who’d come up to talk to us that I realized we were “on.” Brinker was Luke’s alter, picked from the book A Separate Peace. Whenever I brought up the fact that someday, someone might call him on that, he dismissed it, saying that the first girl who recognized the name Brinker Hadley was someone he’d fall madly in love with and take to Amsterdam.

  Allegra didn’t give us the time of day at first, maybe because we were staring at her with our tongues hanging out. She was about half my height with this perfect, little body that she didn’t mind showing off. She wore a denim jacket over a top that looked more like underwear, which she filled with juicy C-cup perfection. Judging by the noise from across the room, she knew how to shoot a decent game—although they could have been cheering about the view every time she bent low to take a shot, too.

  She wasn’t the queen bee of her group; that was the obnoxious girl who latched herself on to Luke/Brinker. Andy hooked up with some blond chick and they each teamed up and played a game of doubles for a while. I was content with just taking in the scene. I didn’t want to be Mike Pearson that night. The lying was a constant mental strain, and with my term-paper business booming and the lacrosse team undefeated, I just wanted to be Gray.

  Then I felt someone tug on my shirtsleeve.

  “Hey,” I said. She was a knockout even close-up.

  “Hey, yourself,” she said, touching my chest with a manicured finger. “A few of us are getting out of here. Party at my place. Wanna come?”

  “They don’t seem too happy over there,” I said, motioning to the group of juicehead guys she’d been playing pool with.

  “Screw them. Carpe scrotum, right?”

  “What?” I didn’t think I heard her right.

  “You know, seize life by the balls, live a little,” she said, grabbing my hand. She spun herself around, her dark hair swaying behind her. “C’mon. You won’t regret it.”

  Hot and funny. Just. Wow.

  “Sounds good, um . . .”

  “Allegra.”

  We followed Allegra and her bright yellow Miata through the winding Staten Island roads to a two-story brick house with a U-shaped driveway.

  “Score,” Luke said as Andy pulled in front of Allegra.

  “You’re designated driver, Mike,” Andy said, tossing me the keys. Our unspoken rule was that whoever was hooking up with the hit stayed sober. Tired as I was, I was glad to be our DD. A few beers, and I was sure I’d be sloppy with the details.

  The backyard was sunken, with one of those pools that looked like you’d wandered into a private oasis. A rock waterfall emptied into the deep end. The patio was spacious, with heaters and lounges and a built-in fire pit that Allegra ignited with a flick of a switch. A house this bank had to have a security system the likes of which we’d never dealt with, and Luke had an instant hard-on about the challenge.

  I’d been lounging in a chaise, enjoying my fly-on-the-wall status. Both Andy and Luke were in the hot tub with their hookups. Everyone else who’d wandered in from the billiard place seemed to know one another and took no interest in me. I felt myself drifting off when someone straddled me on the chair. I opened my eyes to Allegra. Her denim jacket was off; just the little black top and a lot of tanned skin poured into white shorts. She had a belly ring with a crystal dangling from the end of it. I put my hands on her smooth hips, ran my thumb across that jewel, and she shivered.

  “Are you always this quiet, Mike?” she asked.

  “No, had a rough week, that’s all.”

  “The hot tub is great for that.”

  “Uh-uh. Don’t need a staph infection.”

  “Ick, you’re not one of those freaks who washes his hands like a million times, are you?”

  I shook my head and moved my hands to her waist.

  “What do you want to do then?”

  You, is what Mike would have said, but I didn’t. Maybe my conscience had already begun its ascent from the underworld that was my brain. Or maybe I knew this chick . . . girl . . . was the kind of person I could see myself with . . . for real. My silence didn’t seem to faze her.

  “C’mon, you didn’t come here to go to sleep,” she said, tugging the collar of my shirt.

  “Big house. Are we all alone?”

  “Yep, house-sitting for Daddy while he’s in Vegas with wifey número tres.”

  “And he lets you party?”

  “Are you kidding? If he were here, he’d be in the hot tub with us. Mucho guilt for missing years of dance recitals and soccer games. I get to use the place whenever I want.”

  “Ah, so you’re a daddy’s girl,” I said.

  She straightened up and swung her leg around, so she was sitting at the foot of the chaise.

  “Don’t call me that. I make my own way.”

  “Hey.” I nudged her with my foot. She flinched, then crossed her arms.

  “Allegra, I was just teasing,” I said. “My parents are divorced. My stepfather is such a friggin’ tool. I get it, really, I do. And I don’t even get the benefit of a pimped-out swimming pool.”

  She faced me, still frowning.

  “Sorry?” I reached toward her.

  A gleam returned to her eyes, and she pulled me to standing.

  “Fine. I’ve got a way you can make it up to me,” she said, leading me into the house.

  I woke up then.

  After we did it, she snuggled up against my chest.

  She fit so perfectly, one leg draped over mine. For a moment I felt a stab of regret that I wasn’t just Grayson. That I wasn’t just a guy meeting a girl. A girl I could be myself with; someone who would trust me enough to open up to. And as I lay there, stroking Allegra’s hair, I allowed myself to imagine that this was the start of something. Even if it wasn’t.

  “Well, that was phenom,” she said, pushing herself up.

  “Can I see you again?” I asked.

  “I’m counting on it.”

  I left that night with her digits, work schedule, and the feeling that I was the ruler of the free world. A week later my term-paper business blew up in my face. In private the guys rallied around me
. In public I was the plague. I was cut from lacrosse and kicked out of St. Gabe’s. And soon, one by one, my phone calls went unanswered. I couldn’t even bring myself to go to Andy’s house.

  Months later, as I wandered through the mall, listening to Johnny Mathis sing about a marshmallow world, the conscience that had grown since I’d stopped being Mike Pearson was screaming in my head: You don’t have to do this.

  At the same time, there was an insistent competitive sliver that wanted . . . no, needed . . . to prove to Luke that I wasn’t pussying out. That he couldn’t intimidate me. That Wren was worth fighting for. I tried to fan that spark to a flame as I walked toward Hollister. The dim lights and pounding beat in the store helped me get my inner swagger back. I ran a hand through my hair, checked out the register. Allegra was there, wearing far more clothing than she’d had on when we first met. I sauntered up to the counter, by the end, and leaned on my elbows. Waiting. Until she saw me.

  She did a double take—good sign. Then she smiled. Even better. She said something to her coworker on the register and wandered over to me, hips swaying deliberately.

  “Hey, I know you, don’t I?” she said, leaning toward me.

  “I know you,” I answered.

  “Where’ve you been?”

  “Around.”

  “And why should I even talk to you?”

  “Because you want to,” I said, leaning closer.

  She pursed her lips to one side. “Yeah, maybe I do, but I don’t know why. It’s been months.”

  “Too long, Allegra,” I said.

  “So I get a break in about fifteen. Want to get some lunch?” she asked, running a finger along my forearm. “It’s the least you can do after blowing me off.”

  “Sounds good,” I answered, playing with a strand of her hair, not really knowing where I was going to take it after this. I hadn’t thought past just making contact. Stupid. Playing it as I went along.

  She turned to someone who stood about a foot away from us.

  Putting on her Hollister-girl perky voice, she said, “Hey, want to try those on? Great! Let me just get the keys.” She raised her eyebrows at me before she left.