The Atlas of Middle-earth
Page 22
3 S, 87.
4 S, 89, 90.
5 S, 107.
6 S, 100.
7 S, 108, 109.
REALMS—BEFORE THE GREAT DEFEAT
(p. 19)
1 S, 97.
2 S, 111.
3 S, 119.
4 S, 120.
5 S, 123.
6 S, 115, 124.
7 S, 124.
8 S, 124, 142.
9 S, 114.
10 Foster, 561.
11 Foster, 562, 563.
MENEGROTH
(p. 20)
1 S, 93.
2 S, 93.
3 S, 172.
4 Beckett, 50.
5 Collingwood, 128.
6 S, 93.
7 S, 93, 166.
8 S, 233.
9 S, 234.
10 Foster, 563.
11 S, 234, 235.
12 S, 236, 237.
NARGOTHROND
(p. 21)
1 S, 114.
2 Refer to Atlas, p. 10.
3 Thornbury, 326.
4 S, 204.
5 S, 230.
6 S, 114; III, 247.
7 Lobeck, 140.
8 S, 114.
9 S, 170; III, 68, 69.
10 S, 173.
11 S, 215.
12 P, 33, 34, 38.
13 S, 169, 211, 213, 217, 230.
14 S, 213.
15 S, 217.
16 S, 169.
17 Foster, 563.
GONDOLIN
(p. 22)
THANGORODRIM AND ANGBAND
(p. 22)
1 S, 125.
2 S, 115.
3 S, 125. IV, 192 explains these dates were an editorial change as the original founding was much later and was never rewritten by Tolkien.
4 Refer to Atlas, p. 23.
5 Curran, 44.
6 S, 243.
7 II, 156, 157.
8 Foster, 561.
9 S, 136, 137; UT, 46–49.
10 S, 237.
11 P, 35.
12 S, 138.
13 II, 164, 172, 180, 183, 186.
14 II, 176.
15 II, 176.
16 S, 125.
17 P, 35.
18 Curran, 44.
19 S, 241.
20 S, 241, 242.
21 S, 47, 118. Accounts of the were still not shown. history of Utumno and Angband are contradictory (IV, 259, 260).
22 S, 118.
23 Foster, 483.
24 S, 118.
25 S, 108.
26 S, 197.
27 IV, 22, 101.
28 V, 409. The mountains were still not shown.
29 P, 36.
30 S, 107.
31 S, 179.
32 McWhirter, 253.
33 Refer to Atlas, p. 12, 14.
34 Mt. Everest is 29, 228 (Espenshade, 228).
35 III, 282.
36 S, 180; III, 282, 283, 294–296.
COMING OF MEN
(p. 24)
1 S, 103.
2 S, 140.
3 S, 142, 143. It is said on UT, 377–378, that a few Wild Men moved into Beleriand with the Haladin, and there they were eventually named the Drúedain.
4 S, 142; Foster, 562.
5 S, 143.
6 S, 145.
7 S, 145.
8 S, 144.
9 S, 143, 148.
10 S, 143, 147.
11 S, 145–147.
12 Foster, 562.
13 S, 157.
14 S, 195.
TRAVELS OF BEREN AND LÚTHIEN
(p. 25)
1 S, 170, 176, 183; Foster, 563.
2 S, 163, 164.
3 S, 144, 164.
4 S, 167.
5 II, 3–68; IV, 150–308, 331–363.
6 S, 168.
7 S, 152.
8 S, 170.
9 S, 173.
10 S, 174. In the Lay the encounter occurs at various times (III, 263, 273).
11 S, 177.
12 S, 178.
13 S, 179–184.
14 S, 184–188. The original version places them instead in the Hunter’s Wold near Nargothrond (IV, 223).
TRAVELS OF TÚRIN AND NIENOR
(p. 26)
1 S, 197.
2 Foster, 562, 563.
3 S, 198, 199.
4 S, 200–205.
5 S, 206–208.
6 S, 209.
7 S, 211.
8 S, 214.
9 S, 215, 216.
10 S, 217–219.
11 S, 221, 222.
12 S, 223.
13 UT, 143–145, 149.
14 S, 224–226.
THE BATTLES OF BELERIAND
(pp. 28, 30, 32)
1 Foster, 564.
2 S, 96.
3 S, 106.
4 Foster, 561.
5 S, 115.
6 S, 96, 97.
7 S, 116, 117.
8 S, 150.
9 S, 151.
10 S, 151.
11 S, 153.
12 S, 152.
13 S, 153.
14 S, 152.
15 S, 152.
16 S, 153, 154.
17 S, 188.
18 S, 188, 189. IV, 324 points out that the Havens of the Falas had reportedly been ‘ruined’ prior to this time.
19 S, 190.
20 S, 192.
21 S, 192.
22 S, 190.
23 Foster, 562–564.
24 S, 251.
25 S, 252.
The Second Age
INTRODUCTION
(p. 37)
1 I, 209, 224; V, 243.
2 S, 285.
3 RK, 259.
4 S, 230.
5 UT, 13, 14; IV, 159, 199; VII, 302; S, 285.
6 UT, 13; VI, 302, 303.
7 IV, 251; Atlas, p. 3.
8 RK, 364.
9 S, 261.
10 S, 261.
11 IV, 410 states some go to the shores of Valinor, but not to Kôr; but IV, 72 questions this.
12 S, 260.
13 I 13, 14.
14 I, 25, 95; II, 121, 272, 292.
15 II, 328. One idea, obviously abandoned, was that Tol Eressëa was destroyed during the Downfall of Númenor (V, 16, 23, 30).
REFUGEE RELOCATION
(pp. 40-41)
1 S, 247.
2 S, 153, 193; IV, 199.
3 S, 252.
4 S, 254.
5 RK, 363, 364.
6 S, 260.
7 S, 286; RK, 364. Some of those from Doriath may have established Edhellond, UT, 247.
8 RK, 363.
9 H, 183.
10 S, 123.
11 Foster, 194.
12 Foster, 245.
13 S, 286; RK, 331. Although ‘Mithlond’ may only be the bay, while Forlond and Harlond are the actual Grey Havens (V, 423).
14 See UT, “The History of Galadriel and Celeborn.”
15 S, 286; RK, 363, 364.
16 S, 144.
17 RK, 364.
18 RK 352.
19 RK, 319; UT, 252; VII, 302.
20 RK, 364.
21 S, 235.
22 TT, 72.
23 S, 254.
24 S, 251.
25 S, 195.
26 S, 259; RK, 326.
27 S, 192, 195.
28 Refer to Atlas, p. 78.
29 S, 93.
30 RK, 353, 368. Although at one point the balrog’s origin was considered to occur much later (VII, 186, 247).
31 TT, 106.
32 H, 227.
33 6; RK, 353.
34 FR, 202.
35 H, 293; RK, 355.
36 RK, 364.
ADVENT OF THE DARK YEARS
(p. 42)
1 RK, 364.
2 S, 287.
3 RK, 364.
4 S, 288.
5 RK, 364.
6 UT, 238.
7 RK, 363, 366.
8 UT, 238.
9 S, 289.
10 RK, 364.
11 S, 267; RK, 31
6; UT, 239.
12 RK, 55.
NÚMENOR
(p. 43)
1 S, 260.
2 S, 260, 261; RK, 315.
3 S, 261; UT, 165.
4 S, 270, 279.
5 Ginsburg, 45.
6 UT, 169.
7 S, 260.
8 UT, Map of Númenor; Espenshade, 229.
9 S, 261, 272; UT, 167.
10 V, 57–59.
11 S, 268; RK, 364.
12 S, 276.
13 S, 261.
14 S, 263.
15 S, 273; Encyclopaedia Britannica, 725.
16 S, 281; RK, 365.
VOYAGES OF THE NÚMENÓREANS
(pp. 44-45)
1 IV, 251 suggests Belegaer was comparable to the Atlantic.
2 S, 270.
3 S, 262, 263.
4 S, 263, 266, 267, 269, 274; RK, 364, 365; UT, 219.
5 UT, 176, 261—264.
6 S, 263; RK, 316.
7 RK, 316, 364.
8 S, 267.
9 RK, 364.
10 S, 266.
11 S, 267, 268.
12 S, 267, 291; RK, 364.
13 S, 268.
14 S, 269–271, 290; RK, 364.
15 S, 276.
16 RK, 365.
17 V, 15.
18 S, 278, 279.
19 S, 280
20 S, 290, 291; RK, 55.
THE REALMS IN EXILE
(p. 46)
1 RK, 365.
2 RK, 319, 320.
3 S, 291, 292.
4 FR, 141; RK, 321.
5 FR, 213.
6 S, 292; TT, 203.
7 Foster, 21.
8 S, 292; FR, 16.
9 S, 291, 292; Foster, 399.
10 TT, 249, 311; FK, 22.
11 S, 291.
12 S, 291; TT, 203; RK, 327, 367.
13 S, 280.
14 S, 293; RK, 325.
THE LAST ALLIANCE
(p. 47)
1 RK, 365.
2 S, 293.
3 S, 293.
4 S, 294.
5 TT, 75.
6 RK, 365.
7 FR, 197.
8 RK, 365.
9 S, 294; UT, 258.
10 S, 293; FR, 256.
11 TT, 235.
12 RK, 365.
13 FR, 256.
14 S, 294; FR, 256.
The Third Age
INTRODUCTION
(pp. 51)
1 S, 279.
2 S, 281.
3 S, 280; UT, 13, 14.
4 V, 153, 154.
5 UT, 262.
6 FR, 141, 278; TT, 71, 72.
7 H, 216.
8 TT, 239; RK, 375.
9 H, 203.
10 TT, 235.
11 S, 299.
12 FR, 354, 355, 363; RK 148; UT, 248; Foster, 140.
13 RK, 366–370.
KINGDOMS OF THE DÚNEDAIN
(p. 54)
1 RK, 330.
2 RK, 330; Foster, 32.
3 FR, 257; UT, 271, 274.
4 S, 290, 291; RK, 320.
5 RK, 319, 405.
6 RK, 321.
7 RK, 320.
8 RK, 320.
9 S, 290.
10 FR, 257.
11 FR, 141.
12 RK, 321.
13 FR, 158.
14 FR, 213.
15 RK, 55, 325, 326, 345; UT, 260, 369. Note that the Éothéod did not move into the Vale of Anduin until after the Wainriders attacked, UT, 289.
16 Foster, 127.
17 UT, 369.
18 RK, 324.
19 RK, 324, 366.
20 RK, 326, 244; UT, 288.
21 RK, 325
22 RK, 325
BATTLES (1200–1634) AND THE GREAT PLAGUE
(p. 56)
1 RK, 320, 321, 366, 367.
2 RK, 326.
3 RK, 319, 327.
4 RK, 328, 329, 367.
5 RK, 328.
6 UT, 289.
7 RK, 367.
8 RK, 321.
9 RK, 367.
10 RK, 328; UT, 289; Foster, 227
WAINRIDERS AND ANGMAR
(p. 58)
1 RK, 329, 367.
2 RK, 329; UT, 293, 294.
3 RK, 320, 321, 366, 367.
4 RK, 331.
5 RK, 322, 323.
6 RK, 321.
7 RK, 321, 322.
8 RK, 323, 331.
9 RK, 331.
10 FR, 233; RK, 323.
DEEPENING DIFFICULTIES
(pp. 60-61)
1 Rk, 368–370.
2 RK, 332.
3 S, 297.
4 RK, 333.
5 S, 300.
6 RK, 368.
7 RK, 333, 368, 372.
8 RK, 334.
9 RK, 334.
10 RK, 335; UT, 298–300.
11 RK, 345.
12 RK, 349.
13 H, 26; FR, 14; RK, 369.
14 RK, 346, 347.
15 RK, 347.
16 RK, 347, 349.
17 RK, 348.
18 RK, 370.
19 RK, 360.
20 Refer to Atlas, pp. 65, 110.
MIGRATIONS OF HOBBITS
(p. 64)
1 FR, 12.
2 FR, 12.
3 TT, 163; RK, 407, 408.
4 FR, 12.
5 RK, 366.
6 FR, 12.
7 FR, 12; RK, 366.
8 RK, 321, 367.
9 FR, 62.
10 FR, 13, 161.
11 FR, 13.
12 RK, 367.
13 FR, 162.
14 FR, 13; RK, 412.
MIGRATIONS OF DWARVES
(p. 65)
1 S, 43, 44; RK, 352.
2 S, 289; RK, 346, 355
3 S, 91.
4 RK, 353, 368.
5 RK, 353’ 368.
6 S, 289; RK, 353, 357
7 H, 33; RK, 354, 369.
8 RK, 355, 369.
9 RK, 357, 358
10 H, 34.
11 FR, 254, 337; RK, 371.
12 FR, 360.
Regional Maps
INTRODUCTION AND THE SHIRE
(p. 69)
1 FR, 257; TT, 244; Foster, 243, 281.
2 FR, 13; RK, 345; UT, 305, 306.
3 Although my decisions were independent, the reader may be interested in the discussions of Porteus, and especially Reynolds.
4 VI, 300, 302, 305, 309.
5 FR, 14.
6 FR, 18; RK, 368, 378.
7 The exceptions were Breredon and the Grindwall, mentioned only in The Adventures of Tom Bombadil, p. 9
8 RK, 378; S, 292; V, 28—30; VI, 93, 105.
9 RK, 381.
10 FR, 14; TT, 180; RK, 292, 295.
11 RK, 413.
12 VI, 284.
13 RK, 292; UT, 347, 354.
14 TT, 217; RK, 383.
ERIADOR
(pp. 72-73)
1 RK, 319.
2 FR, Map.
3 FR, 26.
4 Thornbury, 133.
5 FR, 197.
6 FR, 201.
7 FR, 140; Lobeck, 49.
8 FR, 146, 147, 149, 150.
9 FR, 149.
10 FR, 159. Note that this location differs from that on Tolkien’s map.
11 FR, 54.
12 Meland.
13 FR, 82.
14 FR, 26.
15 FR, 168.
16 FR, 119.
17 VII, 33, 34, 36.
18 RK, 319.
WILDERLAND
(p. 78)
1 FR, Map.
2 H, Map.
3 H, 160.
4 H, 179, 183, 188.
5 TT, 152.
6 H, 201.
7 H, 204.
8 H, 204.
9 UT, 288.
10 H, 31, 243.
11 RK, 353.
12 Refer to Atlas, p. 22.
13 S, Map.
14 FR, Map.
15 H, 6; RK, 353.
16 H, 293; RK, 355.
THE MISTY MOUNTAINS
(pp. 79, 82)
1 Carpenter, 49, 50.
2 S, 54.
3 Espenshade, 164, 229.
4 H, 66.
5 Strahler, 486.
6 FR, 212, 278.
7 H, 56.
8 FR, 294, 295.
9 RK, 261.
10 Strahler, 391–393.
11 FR, 296.
12 TT, 106.
13 FR, 303.
14 FR, 349.
15 FR, 347–349.
16 FR, 315.
17 H, 121.
18 H, 118.
19 TT, 32.
20 FR, 225.
21 Foster, 346. Note that the color of the river was included in the original edition (and also in the Ballantine edition, p. 43), while the revised story omitted the color clue (H, 41; VI, 203).
22 FR, 314.
23 FR, 296, 318.
24 FR, 296.
25 FR, 331.
26 Strahler, 486; Riley, 143.
27 Strahler, 278, 279; Juhren, 5.
28 FR, 330.
29 National Geographic, 37.
30 VII, 183.
31 Refer to Atlas, p. 134.
32 TT, 160.
33 H, 83; FR, 63.
34 H, 107.
35 H, 119.
36 P, 9.
37 VI, 302.
38 VI, 302.
39 VI, 200.
40 VI, 201.
THE BROWN LANDS, THE WORLD, THE DOWNS, AND THE EMYN MUIL
(pp. 83-84)
1 VI, 314.
2 VII, 316, 318, 320, 360, 424.
3 VI, 317, 319.
4 Lobeck, 519.
5 TT, 30.
6 TT, 30.
7 Lobeck, 49.
8 FR, 397.
9 TT, 29.
10 TT, 30.
11 FR, 396.
12 UT, 260, 299.
13 TT, 23.
14 TT, 25.
15 TT, 25.
16 FR, 407.
17 FR, 409.
18 FR, 411, 423.
19 FR, 410, 416.