Pilgrim’s Rest

by Patricia Wentworth

  “Well, what can I do for you?”

  “You can tell me who was in the house when Mr. Clayton disappeared.”

  He gave her the names, ticking them off on his fingers.

  “Mr. Pilgrim-Miss Columba-Miss Janetta-Roger-”

  She stopped him with a cough.

  “You did not mention him before.”

  “Didn’t I? Oh, well, he was there-seven days’ leave. Jack was abroad out east, so he wasn’t… Where was I?” He ticked off the fourth finger of his left hand-“Roger,” and went on to the fifth-“Jerome-Lona Day-Henry himself-and the staff.”

  She wrote down the names and looked up at him.

  “Of what did the staff consist?”

  “At that time? Let me see… Mr. and Mrs. Robbins-two young village girls, Ivy Rush and Maggie Pell-that’s the lot. But Maggie and Ivy didn’t sleep in, so they’re a wash-out.”

  Miss Silver wrote that down.

  “And who were in the house when Mr. Pilgrim met with his fatal accident?”

  “The same as before-but not Roger. He was in the Middle East being taken prisoner about then.”

  “And who is in the house now?”

  He cocked an eyebrow, and thought, “Roger must have told her that. What’s she up to?” Aloud he replied,

  “Same lot again plus Roger and minus the two girls, who have both been called up. Maggie’s younger sister has taken her place. Their grandfather, old Pell, is gardener at Pilgrim’s Rest-been there since the year one.”

  “And the other girl has been replaced by Miss Judy Elliot?”

  Looking up to ask this question, she observed a slight change in his expression. It was so slight that with anyone else it would have passed unnoticed. It did, however, prepare Miss Silver for the fact that his voice as he answered her was also not quite as usual, the difference being hard to define.

  He said, “Oh, yes.” And then, “She’s a friend of mine, you know. But I had nothing to do with her going there-in fact, I did my best to stop her. She’s got a child tagging along-her sister’s. I don’t like their being there-I don’t like it a bit. That’s one reason why I’m so glad you’re going down.”

  It wasn’t the slightest good-he was giving himself away right and left. Maudie could see through him like a pane of glass.

  Whatever she saw, Miss Silver showed no consciousness of its being anything unusual. The friendly attention of her manner was unchanged as she said,

  “There should not be any risk for them.”

  He leaned towards her with a hand on the table.

  “Look here, what are you driving at with these three lists? You’re not trying to make out that Henry’s disappearance has anything to do with Roger’s bonnetful of bees?”

  Miss Silver gave her slight habitual cough.

  “My dear Frank, in the last three years a number of unusual things have happened at Pilgrim’s Rest. Mr. Henry Clayton disappeared on the eve of his wedding. Mr. Pilgrim met with a fatal accident which his groom and his son believe not to have been an accident at all. And this son is now convinced that two serious attempts have been made upon his own life. I do not assert that these things are connected, but so strange a series of coincidences would certainly seem to call for careful investigation. There is just one thing more I wished to ask you. When Mr. Henry Clayton disappeared, was he known to have any money with him?”

  Frank straightened up.

  “Well, yes, I ought to have told you about that. It’s one of the strongest reasons for supposing that he was doing a bolt. Mr. Pilgrim had given him a cheque for fifty pounds as a wedding-present. Henry asked if he could have it in notes because he would need the cash for his honeymoon. Everyone in the family knew that old Pilgrim kept money in the house. Well, when Henry asked him if he could have the cash he took back the cheque and tore it up. Roger told me about it-he was there. Said his father went off upstairs and came back with four ten-pound notes and two fivers, and Henry got out his wallet and put them away.”

  “Was anyone else present?”

  “Robbins came in with some wood for the fire whilst Henry was putting the notes away. He said he saw Mr. Henry putting his wallet away in an inside pocket, but he didn’t know why he had had it out, and he didn’t think anything more about it.”

  “What about the notes, Frank-were any of them traced?”

  He lifted a hand and let it fall again.

  “We couldn’t get the numbers. The Pilgrims own a lot of farm property, and the old man collected the rents himself. He used to ride round, have a bit of a friendly chat, come home with the cash, and stuff it away anywhere. Didn’t think much of banks-liked to have his money where he could put his hands on it. Roger tells me they found over seven hundred pounds in the house after he died, most of it in a tin box under his bed. Lord knows how long he’d had the notes he gave Henry, or where he got them.”

  When, presently, after this, Frank Abbott took his leave he got as far as the first step into the hall and then came back. After all, what was the odds? If Maudie knew, she knew. He might just as well have the smooth with the rough. He said in his most detached manner,

  “By the way, you could trust Judy Elliot. She’s got a head on her shoulders and she’d be good at a pinch. As a matter of fact, I’ve told her about you. She knows you may be coming down.”

  Miss Silver looked right through him. That at least was his impression-a very probing glance which reproved, admonished, and, a good deal to his relief, condoned. She said,

  “My dear Frank! I trust that she will be discreet.”

  chapter 10

  Miss Columba announced Miss Silver’s forthcoming arrival at the evening meal which everyone except Miss Janetta and Robbins now called supper. That is to say, in reply to Roger’s jerky “When are you expecting your friend Miss Silver?” she produced the single word “Tomorrow.”

  There was immediately a slight domestic stir. Lona Day looked up as if she were going to speak, and then down again. Miss Netta turned upon her sister with a flounce of heliotrope silk.

  “Your friend Miss Silver? I’ve never heard of her. Who is she?”

  It was Roger who supplied the answer.

  “An old schoolfellow. I met her in town. She wanted to get down into the country for a bit, so I asked her here.” He crumbled a bit of bread with a nervous hand, whilst Judy pricked up her ears, and thought what wasteful creatures men were.

  “Schoolfellow?” said Miss Netta in an exasperated voice. “My dear Roger! Collie, who is this person, and why haven’t I ever heard of her?”

  Miss Columba continued to eat fish in a perfectly collected manner. In contrast to her sister’s bright rustling silk she herself wore a voluminous garment of tobacco-coloured woollen material which had once been an afternoon dress. It was still warm, and nothing would have induced her to part with it. She said,

  “I suppose she would be about my age. She has been a governess.”

  After which she went on eating fish.

  Later, in the morning-room, used instead of the big drawing-room because it was so much easier to warm, Lona Day said to Judy what she had stopped herself saying at the table.

  “I do wish he hadn’t asked anyone else down just now. Of course I can’t say anything-or at least I don’t like to. I don’t know Roger so well as the rest of the family, but it isn’t-no, it really isn’t good for Captain Pilgrim.”

  Judy thought, “How odd-she says she doesn’t know Roger, but she calls him by his name, and she talks about Jerome as Captain Pilgrim. If there’s anyone in the world she must know inside out, it’s him. Of course he’s older than Roger, and so is she. I wonder how old she is-thirty-fivish? She ought always to wear black velvet.”

  Here she had to repress a giggle at the idea of all the things a nurse has to do. It petered out, because the likeness which had bothered her on her first evening came sharply to her mind, and this time she caught it. Lona Day in a long black velvet housecoat, with her auburn hair taken loosely back off her
forehead, bore a quite undeniable resemblance to the portraits of Mary Queen of Scots. There was the look in the eyes, the look that charmed. There was the warm and winning way. Of course, she ought to have had a ruff, and one of those entrancing little caps, or a Scots bonnet with a feather at the side. Judy found the idea so beguiling that she lost everything except Lona’s voice flowing on in a rich undertone.

  When she came to, Miss Day was saying,

  “I know he likes to have her, and I hate to deprive him of the least pleasure, but I can’t help feeling anxious. You do understand, don’t you?”

  Judy hadn’t the faintest idea what she was talking about, and hoped for a gleam of light. It came.

  “She is such a darling child, but I do feel perhaps it would be wiser if you could keep her out of his room.”

  “But, Miss Day, he loves having her, and honestly, I think it is doing him good.”

  “I know. But he really does have to be kept very quiet. Those stories he tells her-I’m afraid of the effect it may have on him. You see, he used to write. I’m afraid of his wanting to start doing it again.”

  “Why shouldn’t he? I should have thought it would be a very good thing.”

  Lona shook her head.

  “I’m afraid not-too exciting. That is what we have to avoid at any cost-he mustn’t get excited.”

  Judy felt a queer sort of antagonism rising in her. How could it do Jerome Pilgrim any harm to make up stories for a child of four? She thought, “They’ve all got into a regular fuss about him. I should think the most of what’s the matter with him now is being nearly bored to death. I won’t stop Penny if he wants her.”

  As if Lona Day was aware of what was passing in her mind, she smiled rather sadly and said,

  “You think it’s nonsense, don’t you? I suppose that’s natural. But we are all so fond of him, and so sorry-we have all tried so hard to help him. And of course you don’t know how much care he needs. If you were to see him in one of his attacks you would understand-but I hope you never will.”

  Judy felt as if a cold finger had touched her spine. She was being warned. She was being warned about Penny.

  As if she had spoken the name aloud, Lona said,

  “Don’t leave her alone with him, my dear.”

  Then she got up and went over to sit by Miss Janetta.

  Miss Silver came down next day, arriving in time for tea, at which she appeared in indoor dress, her hair neat under its net, her feet in beaded slippers, her knitting-bag upon her arm. She might have been in the house for weeks. Avoiding the difficult question of Christian names by the use of an occasional “My dear,” she further placated Miss Columba by addressing to her only such remarks as were in no need of an answer. For the rest, she found something to say to everyone else, and when tea was over won Miss Janetta’s heart by her interest in the current chair-cover. The interest was perfectly genuine. She could, and did, admire the pattern, the colour-scheme, the small fine stitches, the pink and blue roses on a ground of pastel grey. Very charming-very charming indeed. Really most beautiful work.

  With Miss Day she conversed upon other topics. A nurse has such an interesting life. Such opportunities for studying character. And sometimes for travel. Had Miss Day travelled at all?… Oh, in the East? How very, very interesting! China perhaps?… No? India?… How intensely interesting! Such a wonderful country.

  “I have not had the opportunity of travelling myself. The scholastic profession is, to that extent, rather limiting.”

  “Do you still teach?”

  Miss Silver gave her slight cough.

  “No, I have retired.”

  Jerome Pilgrim kept his room that afternoon. When Judy came down to supper she found her feet halting and reluctant. The farther they took her from Penny, the more clearly did Lona Day’s words come echoing back in the empty spaces of her mind-“Don’t leave her alone with him, my dear.”

  “Don’t leave her alone-” But she was leaving Penny alone, and just along at the end of the passage was the door behind which Jerome Pilgrim sat in his big chair. She knew quite well by now just how he would look, sitting there, his head propped on his hand, staring into the fire. Suppose he really wasn’t sane. Suppose he was dangerous. Suppose-no, she couldn’t even suppose that he would hurt Penny. But… Her feet stopped of their own accord, and she found that she was turning round and going back. Frank hadn’t wanted her to come here-Frank had begged her not to come. And she had been obstinate about it.

  She had almost reached her own door, when the door at the end of the passage opened and Jerome came out in a dark suit, with the rubber-shod stick he used about the house. As she stood uncertain and a little afraid, he called out to her in a friendly manner,

  “Are you going down? Then we can go together.”

  Judy had a change of mood. Her fear of a moment ago seemed monstrous. She felt so much ashamed of it that she made her voice extra warm as she said,

  “Oh, how nice! Are you coming to supper?”

  She went to meet him, and kept pace with him along the corridor.

  “Lona’s furious,” he said. “She’d like to lock me in and take the key. She’ll come down presently draped in sweet reproach. She’s marvellous at registering the emotions. She’s wasted as a nurse of course-she ought to be at Hollywood.”

  Judy said cautiously, “She’s attractive-”

  He nodded.

  “Oh, very. And a most excellent nurse-I owe her a lot. But one likes to escape once in a way, and if you must know, I’m dying to see Aunt Collie’s school friend. What is she like?”

  Judy looked over her shoulder and said,

  “Ssh! She’s got the room next mine.”

  He actually laughed.

  “Couple of conspirators-aren’t we? Is she a dragon?”

  They had begun to negotiate the stairs. Jerome had to take his time. Judy thought, “He’s quite easy with me now-I might have been here for years. He’d get used to seeing people-I’m sure he would. It can’t be right to keep him shut away. He’s friendly. You can feel it when he comes out of his hole.” She said with a little laugh,

  “Oh, no, not a dragon at all-prim and Victorian, like the people in Aunt Cathy’s nineteenth-century books. I was brought up on them. She makes you feel like schoolroom tea.” She paused, and added with a warmth that surprised herself, “She’s nice.”

  At supper Jerome actually talked. Miss Columba, delighted to see him, found herself a good deal embarrassed by the interest he displayed in the school-days which she was presumed to have shared. Judy, tickled, could not help admiring the dexterity displayed by Miss Silver.

  “To tell you the truth, Captain Pilgrim, those days seem now so very far away-quite like a dream, or something one has read about in a book. They do not, if you know what I mean, seem to be at all actual. Your aunt will, I am sure, bear me out. I could not myself give you the names of half a dozen of my contemporaries at school, yet I recall the personalities of many more, and am aware of the manner in which each of them affected me.”

  She had caught his attention. He said musingly,

  “Names are just a label. They’re nothing-like clothes, to be changed. Individuality is what counts. That goes on.”

  She gave him one of her really charming smiles.

  “A rose by any other name would smell as sweet.”

  His interest deepened. There was something in the look and the quality of the smile which enabled her to get away with about the most hackneyed quotation in the whole range of literature. He was conscious of annoyance when Miss Janetta said fretfully,

  “There really ought to be a law against people calling their children after film stars. Lesley Freyne has two Glorias amongst her evacuees. It’s bad enough of the Pells, but when it comes to three Glorias in one village!”

  Miss Silver said brightly, “I heard of some people called White who had their son christened Only Fancy Henry. So it made Only Fancy Henry White. Not very considerate to mark a child out in that way. N
ames present a great many pitfalls. There are, of course, such charming ones for girls.” She smiled at Miss Columba. “Your name, for instance-most unusual and attractive. And your sister’s too. But when it comes to boys, I must own to a preference for what is solid and plain-William, George, Edward, Henry-all good names, and all, I am informed, quite out of fashion at present.”

  Miss Columba looked up from a baked apple.

  “My father’s name was Henry.”

  Miss Silver gave her the look with which she might have encouraged a diffident or tongue-tied child and said,

  “An excellent name. Has it been passed on to the present generation?”

  There was one of those pauses. Roger muttered something that sounded like “Yes-a cousin,” and Miss Janetta began in a hurry to deplore the prevalence of Peters.

  “I’ve nothing against the name, but there really are too many of them.”

  Miss Silver agreed.

  They went on talking about names.

  As they talked, Miss Silver’s eyes went from one to another, seeing all that was on the surface and searching for what might lie beneath. When Robbins came and went she watched him too. Such a secretive face-but a well-trained manservant will look like that for no reason at all. In his own way a goodlooking man-straight regular features and an upright carriage. Perhaps off duty and in his own quarters he could relax and be off guard. The word kept coming back to her. He was on guard. Over what? It might be his professional good manners, his dignity as an old family servant, or it might be something else. She felt a good deal of interest in Robbins.

  chapter 11

  Miss Columba conducted her school friend all round the house next morning. She did it with an air of gloom, because it is impossible to take anyone over an interesting old house without more conversation than she cared about. It was also an exceptionally good day for the garden and she wished to put in a row of early peas. Pell said it was too soon, but she didn’t intend to let him down her. If the weather was to change over night, it would give him a very unfair advantage, and he would certainly make the most of it. She knew her duty, and she did it without a protest, but certainly not in any spirit of cheerfulness, and she wore her gardening slacks and fisherman’s jersey so as to be ready to go out and confront Pell at the first possible moment.