Plenty of Chances [Plenty, FL 6] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Lara Valentine

  Gabe chuckled. “I bet she was tougher than any therapist I might have been seeing.”

  “She kicked my ass, that’s for sure. She was right. It was time to stop crying in my beer and live again. So that’s what I did.”

  Jason straightened his legs out and pulled Sami on to his lap. “All this emotion sure wears a man out. Maybe we should hit the sack.”

  Sami looked from Gabe to Jason and back again. “That’s it? You spill your guts and you’re done?”

  “What else do you want to talk about?” Gabe asked. “We’ve told you about Iraq. We’ve all apologized for our part in what happened. What else is there to say?”

  She stood, her hands on her hips. Men were idiots and these two took the prize. “There’s a lot to say. Like, I love you, okay? Both of you. It’s not like it was before. It’s different now. Deeper and, well, I don’t know, but it feels better. More real. Gabe has become the man I’d always hoped he could be, and Jason is even more of what he was and then some. You make me feel safe. You make me feel happy. Mostly, you just make me feel things, and I haven’t felt anything for a really long time.”

  Jason smiled. “We’re declaring our love? I’m in. Gabe, you ornery son of a bitch, I love you like a brother. The brother I never wanted and got anyway. I forgive you for running and I’m glad you’re back. This woman is too much trouble to handle alone. She’d run me into an early grave without you.” He turned her face so she was looking into his eyes. “Sunshine, I love you. I love the girl you were, and the woman you’ve become. I thought I needed to keep the innocence in your eyes, but I see now that you need to see the world not be protected from it. I love how you’ve survived and can still see the good. I love how you see the good in me.”

  Sami sniffled as she looked up at Gabe. It was all up to him now. He crossed his arms across his chest with a smile. “I’m not a man given to words, as you both know. Actions usually say things better. I let you take a swing at me, Jason, so you know you’re my brother and best friend. I never wanted a brother either, you know. I was perfectly happy with one sister.” He grinned at Jason then looked at Sami. All she could see was the love he felt. “As for you, Samantha, I do love you. Fuck, I let you take a crop to me. I don’t know how to express my love, but it’s there. It’s always been there, even in my darkest moments. It’s what got me through some bad times. The thought of never seeing you again was like a shadow over all the good things.” He stepped closer. “I’m proud of you. You went through something that could have broken someone weaker. You didn’t fold. You fought and scrapped and came out the other side of it a better person.”

  Jason was laughing now. “He let you take a crop to his ass? How did I miss this? I would have paid money to see that.”

  Gabe picked up his beer and took a long drink. “I couldn’t crop her ass, she wasn’t ready. So I let her crop mine. She barely hit me but I got the reaction I was going for.”

  Sami remembered she’d broken down into tears. “You did that on purpose? That was mean. I cried.”

  “You needed to cry,” Gabe declared. “You needed to cry badly. If beating on me with a crop helped, then I’m glad I let you.”

  “When are going to beat on me with a crop?” Sami held her breath as her two men exchanged a glance.

  Gabe rubbed his chin. “Are you saying what I think you’re saying? You want to play some games with us?”

  “You both said you should have spanked me back then. Maybe you should do it now. We are trying to clear the air.” Sami watched their reaction closely.

  Jason pushed to his feet. “Samantha Jane, if you want a spanking, we’re the men to give it to you.” She sucked in a breath as he bent over and put his shoulder in her stomach so he could lift her in a fireman’s hold. He strode over to the tent and dumped her down on the air mattress he had set up.

  “Strip and get ready.” He rubbed his hands together. “I can’t wait to spank your ass a bright red.”

  Sami gaped up at him. What the hell had she gotten herself in to? These men were her life and she was theirs. She’d grown up and finally seen them as they truly were. They weren’t heroes, perfect in every way, fixing every little thing for her. They were men. Ordinary men who tried and sometimes failed. All three of them didn’t always make the best decisions but they’d been given a second chance at love and Sami wasn’t going to squander it.

  * * * *

  Samantha’s expression was priceless. Half excited and half “oh shit,” she was stripping off her clothes as he and Jason watched. Gabe reached out and squeezed the back closing of her bra before she could reach it and it flicked open with a satisfying pop. Samantha’s eyes got big and he grinned.

  “Just trying to help.”

  “I didn’t know you could do that.”

  “It’s only two hooks, babe. A child could do that.”

  She held the bra up in front of her like a shield. “You did it so fast.”

  “Samantha Jane.” Jason shook his head and chuckled. “Drop the brassiere.”

  Color flew into her cheeks and she drop the bra onto the ground, then tugged her panties down her legs. She stood in front of them, bare to their gazes. She’d never had the courage to do that in the past and Gabe admired her bravado now.

  “Beautiful, isn’t she, Jason? So damn gorgeous I don’t know what I want to kiss first.”

  She did look beautiful with her long golden hair and her big blue eyes. She was slowly getting her curves back and he savored each line and plane of her body in the low light. Her waist was impossibly tiny and her hips and bottom perfect for a spanking. If she wanted one, he’d be more than happy to give it to her. Just the thought had his cock hard and aching inside his jeans.

  “You stay high, I’ll go low,” Jason said before he fell to his knees and pushed her thighs apart. He had Samantha mewling with pleasure in seconds, his tongue working on her pussy and clit. Gabe positioned behind her, cupping her full breasts and kissing and nipping at her neck and shoulders. He could feel her getting heavy in his arms and knew her knees were turning to jelly. He nodded to the floor and they laid her out like a feast, their mouths devouring her flesh. Her skin was soft and fragrant and he breathed in her sweet scent mixed with the musk of her arousal. It made his cock pulse against his zipper and his balls draw up.

  Gabe licked at a taut nipple watching it crinkle even tighter before drawing it into his mouth. He scraped his teeth across one then the other and listened to her keening with pleasure. He kissed his way down her belly and over a hipbone before nudging Jason.

  “Trade?”

  Jason grinned and Gabe kissed a wet trail to the inside of her thighs then up to her already drenched cunt. His tongue trailed through the folds of her pussy and flicked at her clit. She shuddered in response and more cream landed on his tongue. She tasted like honey and he pressed two fingers inside of her and felt her cunt flutter in response.

  He hooked the two fingers and found her sweet spot while he licked at her clit with the flat of his tongue. It was like he’d hit her with a bolt of electricity. Her body stiffened and then she shook and moaned as her orgasm ran through her. He stayed with her until her body went slack before pulling back to look into her eyes.

  “I’m going to fuck and spank you now. Is that what you want, Samantha?”

  Her eyes were glazed over from her climax but she nodded. “Yes, I want it.”

  “We will always give you what you need. Let’s get her turned over, Jason.”

  They easily turned her onto her belly and Gabe pulled her back so she was on her hands and knees. Jason ran his fingers through her hair and caressed her jaw.

  “Give us a minute to get rid of our clothes and we’ll give you what you’ve been needing.”

  They shucked their clothes in record time and Gabe caressed the creamy skin of her ass. It was going to be bright red by the time he was done with it.

  “This spanking is for all the spankings we didn’t give you before because we thought you were
too young or wouldn’t enjoy it.”

  He smacked a round ass cheek leaving a red handprint behind. Damn, it looked hot. He smacked her bottom again and she wriggled in response.

  His woman liked it.

  * * * *

  Sami sucked in her breath as the heat from the spanking spread from her bottom directly to her pussy and clit. She hadn’t known how much she’d like being spanked but after only Gabe’s palm landing twice on her backside, she was going to be begging for it all the time. It was hot and raunchy and she wriggled her bottom to entice him to keep spanking her.

  He didn’t make her wait, his hand coming down over and over until honey was dripping down her thighs and her entire body was on fire with the conflicting sensations of pleasure and pain.

  “She’s got a little bit of masochist in her.” Gabe rubbed a sore ass cheek and she arched back in to his hand to spur him on. She didn’t want him to stop. It felt like her body had woken up and she needed more and more of what he had to offer.

  Jason chuckled, a warm sound in the dim light of the tent. “You’ve got a little sadist in you so it’s a match made in heaven.”

  Gabe’s fingers delved into her cunt and she pressed back on his fingers, trying to impale herself deeper. He responded by pulling them out and smacking her bottom again making her moan with pleasure.

  “You want your turn? She seems to want more.”

  Jason bent down to whisper in her ear. “Do you want more, sunshine? Do you want me to take a turn spanking your cute little rear end?”

  “More.” Her voice was like gravel but he heard her message loud and clear, taking up where Gabe left off. His hand cracked down on her ass cheeks over and over while Gabe’s fingers reached under her and found her swollen clit. He barely touched her and she went off like a sparkler in July. Wave after wave ran through her until she slumped on the mattress, spent and panting.

  Gabe praised her, running his hands up and down her back. “Good girl, Samantha. That was excellent. I’m so proud of you.”

  She rolled over on her back and giggled. “What are you proud of? All I did was have an orgasm.”

  He leaned over her and kissed her long and slow, his tongue playing with her and leaving her breathless. “I’m proud of you because you took your spanking like a big girl. Not everyone could take a good, hard spanking like that. You should be proud of yourself.”

  When he put it like that, she was kind of proud. She had taken a spanking and without a complaint. She’d liked it way too much to complain, but she wasn’t quite ready to admit it yet. She had a feeling he knew anyway how much she liked it. She also liked the warm feeling his praise gave her. She’d always craved approval from these men.

  She reached up, running a hand up each of their chests. “I want you both.”

  Jason grinned. “Sunshine, you have us both. We’re all yours.”

  “No.” She shook her head. “I want both of you at the same time.”

  Both men frowned and exchanged a worried glance. She’d always said no to this particular intimacy in the past. She’d been too shy, too uptight to enjoy it with them, but now she craved it. She wanted to make love to both of them at the same time.

  “Now, Samantha,” Gabe began. “Are you sure about this? You’ve never wanted to before.”

  She lounged back on the blankets enjoying their discomfiture. “I’m sure. I’m very sure. Don’t you want to?”

  Jason grinned. “Of course we want to. We love you. We just don’t want you to feel pressured to do anything you don’t want to do.”

  “I don’t feel pressured. I feel ready.”

  The men exchanged glances again, smiles spreading across their faces. Gabe pointed to the far side of the air mattress. “Then move so I can lie down. Jason can do the honors. There should be lube in my toy bag.”

  Sami scooted to the side while Gabe grabbed a small leather bag from the far corner of the tent. He held it up. “This is the portable version. The full size version is at the club.”

  “You were pretty sure of yourself,” Sami pouted.

  Gabe laughed and pulled out the bottle of lube, tossing the bag aside. “Never leave home unprepared. I was a Boy Scout.”

  “You were never a Boy Scout.”

  “I wanted to be a Boy Scout.”

  Jason groaned and rolled his eyes. “You never wanted to be a Boy Scout. I was a Boy Scout. You had your chance to join with me, but you weren’t interested.”

  Gabe settled himself on the mattress. “There weren’t any girls. If there had been girls, I might have joined.” Gabe patted his stomach. “Come here, babe. Straddle me so Jason can get into position.”

  She moved so her thighs were on each side of Gabe’s. He started playing with her nipples and she moved restlessly as her arousal started growing again.

  “That’s it, babe. Concentrate on what I’m doing while Jason does what he needs to do.”

  Jason came up behind her, kissing her neck and nibbling on her ear before pressing on her back so she was lying on top of Gabe. Gabe never stopped his campaign of distraction even as she felt the cold trickle of lube down the crack of her ass and Jason’s thick finger pressing her back hole for entry. She puffed out a breath as the digit breached the tight ring of muscles. She’d heard enough from other women to know to try to relax, but doing it was different than hearing about it. He only had one finger inside her and she already felt full. She couldn’t imagine having an entire cock shoved up there.

  More lube and then the press of two fingers. Gabe was doing his damndest to distract her but her brain was firmly fixated on her ass and what Jason was doing with his hand. She felt the burn just as she’d been warned and then his fingers began rubbing dark and naughty nerves in her backside and a moan popped out of her mouth before she could stop it.

  Gabe patted her bottom. “That’s a good girl. Just relax and enjoy it.”

  It felt good but strange, and she wondered what Gabe would say if he had something up his butt. Before she could ask him, Jason started scissoring his fingers and stretching her until she pressed her forehead into Gabe’s chest, concentrating on taking one breath after the other. There was more lube and more fingers but Sami got lost in the sensation. When Jason pulled his fingers from her bottom she mewled in frustration.

  “Easy, sunshine. It’s time.”

  She heard the crinkle of the condom, the trickle of more lube, then the head of Jason’s cock pressing forward.

  “Deep breath,” Jason instructed. “Just go limp and let it happen. I’ll take this really slow so I don’t hurt you.”

  “Easy for you to say,” Sami muttered but she did as he asked, letting Gabe play with her nipples and kiss her lips to take her focus off what was happening behind her. She was surprised when the head of his cock breeched her opening and was lodged tightly inside her ass. Jason’s hands were gripping her hips and she heard him curse softly under his breath.

  “Don’t tighten up on me, sunshine. Relax those muscles.”

  She forced herself to breath and relax and soon Jason’s own breath was coming easier. She must have clamped down on the head of his cock and almost strangled it in her panic.

  “I feel full.” It was an understatement.

  Jason chuckled. “You’re about to get even more full. Just relax and let it happen. You don’t have to do anything.”

  It was hard but she did as she asked. He pushed forward slightly, then pulled out a little, before pushing in, just a little further. Each stroke filled her more and more until he was finally seated to the hilt with a grunt. Their bodies were covered with sweat and she was shaking with the maelstrom of sensations she’d never felt before. No one had told her it would feel this good. She tried to move but this time Gabe’s fingers clamped down on her hips.

  “Easy, honey. Stay still while I saddle up. You’re going to be filled to the brim with cock in a minute.”

  She lifted slightly so Gabe could roll on a condom then slowly lowered herself on his hard cock.
She could feel every ridge of his cock as she took him an inch at a time. By the time she’d taken him all, her pussy was stretched wide and her world was starting to tilt on its axis. The pleasure from being so completely filled was dizzying and it only intensified when they started to move. She closed her eyes and savored every thrust of their cock, every stroke on the sweet spots in her pussy and ass until she was consumed with the fire they stoked inside her.

  “I need, I need—” She couldn’t verbalize what she needed. She only knew she needed more of them, harder and faster, giving her what only they could. Her body was stretched as taut as a bow string waiting for the touch on her clit that would send her over the cliff. When it finally came it was like a bomb had been detonated inside her. She screamed with the intensity of the pleasure, the waves making her shake and shudder. Jason thrust into her, his body stiffening, his cock seeming to swell as it shot hot jets of cum into the condom. Gabe let go a string of filthy words, his eyes closed, his jaw tense. They all lay very still, a tangle of arms and legs covered in sweat and her juices.

  Eventually, Jason stirred and carefully pulled from her body, with Gabe following. They wrapped her in blankets and left her alone in the tent for a few minutes only to return with a damp cloth to clean her up. She protested at first, but Gabe simply kissed her to stop her talking. When they were done, they joined her in the sleeping bags, their bodies curled together. No one spoke, but they didn’t have to say any words. They all knew something momentous had happened tonight. Love words had been exchanged, stories told, bodies shared. It was a new beginning for the three of them. It was their second chance.