BFF Breakup (mix)

by Taylor Morris

  At home later that night, after checking in with Mom and Dad about how the dance went, I sat at the kitchen computer to see if Madeline was on IM. She wasn’t. She was probably staying at Susanna’s or one of the other girls’. Earlier in the evening I’d been kind of hurt that Corrine and Lily hadn’t invited me to sleep over—I assumed they were spending the night together. Now I was glad to be alone. Too much had happened.

  I couldn’t stop replaying the scenes in my head, picking over every word in the bathroom, every look in the gym. There was definitely something about the way Madeline looked at me, especially at the end of the night, that felt genuine. She looked sad and a little bit hopeful. Or maybe it was the new haircut that was throwing me off. It looked cute on her. I still couldn’t believe she chopped it, but she wore it well.

  After washing my face and putting on my pajamas, I went back to the kitchen and got on the computer again. I thought about writing back to Madeline. She had, after all, taken the first step toward us making up, even if it was kind of a lousy step. I guess she meant well. I started to realize that a part of me never really believed that our friendship was totally over. How could it be, just like that? Maybe we’d never been through a major fight before, but we were true best friends, not just two girls who hung out because we lived near each other. I couldn’t stop thinking about her, and that had to count for something, too. She was my best friend, forever.

  I started to write, unsure I would send it even as my fingers danced across the keyboard.

  Hey. I liked seeing you tonight. I know a lot has happened, but if you want to hang out sometime, let me know. We were always good at finding something to do.

  I stared at the screen and asked myself if I wanted to be friends with Madeline again, and then if I could be friends with her. Finally I asked myself if I needed to be friends with her. I liked Corrine and Lily, even if they weren’t my best friends. I trusted them and had fun with them. I wondered if that was enough. Could you live your life BFF-less, having only good friends? Would I be okay with that?

  29 MADELINE

  WE WERE ALL IN OUR PAJAMAS, OUR FACES washed and teeth brushed, sitting in Susanna’s room with junk food spread around us and a stack of scary movies on the floor, ready to choose which one would scare us to sleep.

  Even though Natalie and Julia had air mattresses and sleeping bags on the floor, we all piled on Susanna’s queen-size bed to watch the movie about a killer who decapitates his victims with hedge clippers. Julia’s piercing screams had Susanna’s mom running into the room every time until she finally asked us to try to keep it down.

  After the movie, Julia swore it was a true story. “Based on one, anyway,” she said. To prove she was wrong, I Googled the killer’s name and MO and found it wasn’t true.

  “Still, it could totally happen,” she maintained.

  While I was at the computer I logged into my account and checked my e-mail.

  I hadn’t told the girls about talking to Brooke in the bathroom. I’d kept it all to myself, mostly because I still wasn’t sure what it meant.

  When I saw Brooke’s name in my in-box, I let out an audible gasp.

  “Did you find something?” Julia said, scrambling over to the computer. “I knew it—hey. What’s her name doing in there?”

  “Whose name?” Susanna said, craning her neck toward us.

  Julia nudged my arm. “Open it.”

  “What is it?” Susanna asked and she and Natalie joined us at the computer.

  “Nothing, you guys,” I said, trying to close out.

  “Brooke’s name was in her in-box,” Julia said.

  I saw Susanna’s face light up with news. “Oh my god, you must open it. Now. What’s the hold up?”

  “It’s just . . . I don’t know what it says.” I said.

  “Well, duh, you don’t know what it says,” Julia said. “You have to open it to find out.”

  Susanna eyed me and said, “Madeline, we’re all friends here. You’re not trying to hide something from us, are you?”

  “Of course not,” I said.

  “Then let’s see it.”

  They all stood around me, staring. The same girls who’d made school so much fun, who I’d connected with and laughed with, and who’d been there for me during my nightmare home situation. They were my friends. I had nothing to hide from them—or I shouldn’t, anyway. So I clicked open the message and read it, along with three other girls standing over my shoulder.

  “Oh my god,” Julia said. “What is she—a stalker or something?”

  “Yeah,” Natalie said. “‘I liked seeing you tonight’? What, was she lurking in the corners, staring you down or something?”

  Susanna stood back and said, “Did you guys talk or something?”

  Natalie and Julia paused, and three sets of wide eyes were on me, hoping I wouldn’t say what they didn’t want to hear.

  “I ran into her in the bathroom,” I said. “She mentioned my hair.”

  Susanna crossed her arms and said, “Does she think you’re going to be friends again?”

  “I don’t know what she thinks.”

  “Because if you’re thinking of forgiving her, you better think twice.”

  “What’s that supposed to mean?”

  “She’s just saying,” Natalie said. “After all that Brooke did—”

  “And after all we did,” Julia said. “To her, I mean.”

  She looked at Susanna, who shrugged and said, “It’s true. After all that, do you really think she’d just e-mail you and be like nothing ever happened?”

  “I don’t know,” I said. Because I didn’t.

  “All I’m saying,” Susanna said, “is to think about it. Like, why would she choose to do this now? The same week I wore that necklace? The timing seemed a little convenient.”

  “Susanna’s right,” Julia said. “It might be a trick. She might be setting you up or something.”

  I wasn’t sure I believed that, but I also hadn’t thought of it. I’d, no, we’d, been pretty horrible to Brooke, and she wasn’t exactly the kind of person to sit back and take it. She seemed so genuine when we talked tonight, but maybe I should take some time to think about it.

  I closed out the message. “You’re right. I wasn’t going to respond to her anyway.”

  This seemed to relieve Natalie and to Julia and satisfy Susanna. I, on the other hand, was more confused than ever.

  Frankly, I couldn’t wait to get home the next day. It’s not like I looked forward to that depressing house, but I needed time alone to think about Brooke and what was happening. Except when I got home, Dad said Mom had called and wanted me to come see the new apartment. My stomach dropped out from under me, and I wished everyone would just leave me alone.

  “I’m not going without Josh,” I said.

  Dad nodded. “I think he’s got tickets to the game tonight.”

  “Then we’ll go tomorrow, or some other time. He has to see her, too.”

  Dad said okay, he’d talk to him. Then, maybe noticing my mood, he said, “I know it’s not easy, but we’re all going through this. Even your mom.”

  I wondered how he could talk about her like that when she’d supposedly done what she did to him and to us.

  I went up to my room and reread Brooke’s message. I wasn’t so sure there was a hidden meaning there, but maybe. We’d never had a fight this big and I really didn’t know how she was handling it. Maybe I should do what Susanna said and just ignore it, at least for now.

  I wanted to spend the weekend ignoring everything. Instead, I was getting sucked into having dinner with Mom and touring her new apartment.

  “You can start thinking about how you want to decorate it,” she said over the phone, with what I could tell was forced enthusiasm.

  Josh tried to weasel out of it with new excuses, but I wasn’t letting him stick me with her alone. “If you bail tonight, I’m telling Dad you took his car last weekend when he was out with Adam,” I told him. I’d heard him
drive away in it instead of his own car.

  “You little tattletale,” he sneered.

  “I don’t care. I’m not going alone.”

  “Brat,” he snapped, but I wouldn’t back down. He seemed to love dropping bombshells of bad news, then bailing on it all. This time he’d have to face it, just like I had to.

  Josh drove us to Mom’s new place, a gated complex near the Brentwoods shopping area, which I figured meant the place was expensive. She buzzed us in at the gates and told us where to park. She stood on the sidewalk in front of the space, shading her eyes from the sun with one hand, while waving with the other.

  Josh sighed. “Well, here we go.”

  Mom had my door open before Josh could even shut off the engine.

  “Your hair!” she said. “It looks so pretty! Goodness, I thought Josh had brought one of his girlfriends with him instead.” Mom’s eyes started to well up with tears, and I had to look away.

  She walked over to Josh, arms outstretched, and gave him a big hug. He made minimal effort to hug her back, his arms barely touching her waist and his hands in steely fists.

  “Well, come on in! Let me show you around!”

  We followed her, and I noticed how dressed up she was, in slim pants and mint-colored high heels that matched the top she wore. Josh and I had barely made the effort, both wearing baggy jeans and untucked shirts.

  She used a key card to get through wrought iron gates that clanged shut behind us; she showed us the pool area complete with hot tub and barbeque area (“You can bring your friends over any time!” she told me); a workout facility (“You can bring the boys over any time!” she told Josh); and even a yoga studio. (“They have an instructor come twice a week,” she told us. “I should probably give it a shot, don’t you think? De-stress a bit!”)

  Her upbeat attitude was so fake. She was trying too hard, like she was desperate to make up for what she’d done. Josh and I followed behind her, turning our eyes to whatever she pointed out, but showing as little interest as possible.

  Inside it was a simple place: kitchen off to the right, which led into a living room, and the bedrooms on either side of it.

  “Well, here it is!” She stretched her arms out like a game show hostess. It was decorated like a mini-version of our house, with the round end table that was her aunt’s and the black picture frames she always used for vacation photos. “It’s not much, but it’s good for now. And this is your bedroom,” she said, looking at both of us. “I’m sorry I couldn’t get a three bedroom, but it was a little out of my price range, for now anyway. But you can both decorate it however you want.”

  I tried to imagine Josh’s girlie posters with my stuffed animals in the same room. I also thought that, if she hadn’t gone for such a swank building, she might have been able to afford a three bedroom.

  “So!” Mom clapped her hands together. “Who’s hungry?”

  I looked at Mom, who still held that eager, forced-happy look on her face, and I started to feel bad for her. It would never be my home, but she was trying so hard—that had to count for something. I thought of Brooke, and how maybe she was trying, too. I wanted to be careful, but I didn’t really think she’d trick me, even after all that had happened. Watching Mom fall all over herself to make us comfortable, I thought that since everyone was working to make things right, maybe I should join in, too—and I’d start with Mom.

  “Mom, your apartment is really nice,” I said. Right away she let out a breath like she’d been waiting for a nice word from me or Josh.

  She touched my should and smiled. “Thanks, honey.”

  As we walked out to dinner I realized that I should let go and accept things as they were offered to me—like Brooke’s e-mail. It wasn’t as if things between us could get any worse. I’d respond to her e-mail as soon as I got home. What harm could it do?

  30 BROOKE

  SHOULD I HAVE BEEN SURPRISED? REALLY? Maybe I shouldn’t have been, but I was. She didn’t write me back. I thought we’d had a real moment on Friday—ugh, I feel dumb even thinking that. Like, yeah, a real moment on Friday. In the bathroom, no less!

  I walked into school on Monday feeling so stupid, like I had gone groveling back to Madeline, even though I know I didn’t. She and her friends probably had a good laugh at how pathetic I was. Now I had to go through another day and pretend like she didn’t exist. I was sick of playing this game. So over it.

  When I saw her at her locker I didn’t slow down and try to wait until she left like I’d done before. Instead I marched right up to my locker, nudged her aside, and worked my combination.

  I thought I heard her say, “Hey,” but I wasn’t sure I and wasn’t about to look at her since she hadn’t been able to do me the same courtesy these last weeks. Besides, if she’d really wanted to say hello to me and I didn’t respond, she would have spoken up, repeated herself, done something to get my attention. Instead she did nothing—as usual—and I slammed my door shut just as Susanna walked up. I felt like they were both staring at me—so ironic since they’d been experts at blatantly ignoring me—but I turned down the hall as if they didn’t exist. As far as I was concerned, Madeline was dead to me.

  “Next Monday, on Lil’s birthday, her mom is bringing in pizza and cupcakes. You in?” Corrine asked at lunch.

  “What?” I quickly tried to pretend I wasn’t looking at Madeline’s table. “Oh, yeah. I’m in.”

  “Because she needs to know how much to bring,” Corrine said.

  “Yeah,” I said again. “Sure.”

  I refocused on eating my sandwich and not looking at Madeline.

  “I thought it was so cute,” Lily was saying, while I wondered what Susanna was saying and if it was about me. “He likes you. And did you notice what he’s not wearing today?”

  I couldn’t believe it—Madeline was staring at me again. Why ignore me for weeks, then talk to me in the bathroom, then ignore my message, only to stare at me all day in school?

  Corrine nudged me. “Hey. Zombie. You okay? Lil asked you something.”

  I looked at Corrine and Lily. “Huh? Sorry. What’d you say?”

  “Christopher isn’t wearing a tie today—of any kind. I think he may have finally ditched them, and all because of you. Do you like him? Because I think you’d make the cutest couple.”

  “It’s Chris,” I said. “And I feel like an idiot.”

  “Why?!” Lily looked as if someone had just told her they were taking away all her cardigans. “I think he’s sweet, and you do look cute together. I mean that in the nicest possible way.”

  “Not about Chris,” I said.

  “Hey, what gives?” Corrine asked.

  They both looked at me with concerned expressions, and I knew I should take comfort in that, but I worried about how they might react. I knew they actually cared about me and hated seeing me so miserable.

  “Okay,” I began. “If I tell you something, will you swear not to give me any flak about it?”

  “Of course!” Lily said without thought. That’s what I loved about her: She was ready to support you first and ask questions later.

  “What is it?” Corrine asked.

  “I talked to Madeline on Friday night at the dance. We ran into each other in the bathroom. We only talked for like two minutes. But it was . . . nice.” I shrugged.

  “Oh,” Lily said.

  Corrine eyed me and said, “Well, what’d she say?”

  “I don’t know,” I said, wondering if I was going to regret bringing this up. “Just, you know. Said hello. And, um, talked about her hair. And Derek.” Was that all we’d talked about? After all this time, that was our conversation? Even though I’d thought about it all weekend, I realized I couldn’t remember any significant moments of our conversation. Only slight looks that were up for interpretation.

  “Did she apologize?” Corrine asked.

  “No,” I said. “But she seemed sorry.”

  “How did she seem sorry?” Corrine asked.

  “
Well,” I said, “she just seemed like, nervous. Like she was afraid to face me.”

  “Because she felt bad,” Lily said. “Right?” Lily looked at me so hopefully, and I knew she wanted to find the right answers for me so that I could go back to being friends with Madeline and we could all live happily ever after.

  But Corrine wanted straight answers. “She should be afraid of you. She should also be on her knees begging for your forgiveness.”

  “Maybe she will,” Lily said. “I don’t mean get on her knees, but maybe she’s just working up the nerve. Or maybe she’s looking for the right opportunity.”

  “I sort of gave her that already,” I said. I figured if I’d told them this much, I might as well tell them everything. “I sent her an e-mail that night.”

  “You what?” Corrine said. Even Lily looked pained by my confession.

  “I was just all mixed up,” I said, feeling like a sucker. “I really thought she seemed, you know, remorseful or something. And she did message me before, so really the ball was in my court.”

  “You mean that horrible, ‘I’ll allow you to be my friend’ thing?” Corrine said, and I cringed. “That hardly counts as reaching out to you.”

  “I know,” I said. “Look, I feel like an idiot. She didn’t even respond, so that’s it. It’s done. We’re not friends and it looks like we’re not ever going to be friends. Let’s just drop it.” I took a bite of my sandwich and tried to chew, but it felt like sawdust in my mouth.

  “Look,” Corrine said, taking a gentler tone. “I’m just looking out for you.”

  “I know,” I said.

  “She really burned you, and I don’t want to see her do that again. Maybe it’s for the best you didn’t hear back from her. But we’re here no matter you decide to do. Okay?”

  “Yeah, we’re here,” Lily said.

  “Thanks,” I said. “You guys are the best.”

  This is it, I realized. These are my friends. My only friends. And that, I decided, wasn’t just good enough—it was great.