The Second Shift: Working Families and the Revolution at Home

Home > Other > The Second Shift: Working Families and the Revolution at Home > Page 34
The Second Shift: Working Families and the Revolution at Home Page 34

by Arlie Hochschild, Anne Machung


  and repercussions of second shift, 8

  Holt, Nancy

  and career strategies, 194

  and changes in the workplace, 250

  and comparison groups, 51-57

  and cultural pressures, 52, 57, 64, 240

  daily routines, 34-38

  and divorce, 209-10

  and economic logic of gender roles, 223

  and family myths, 19, 127

  and feminism, 47-48, 54, 58, 59, 75

  and gender ideology, 16, 40-42, 58, 190

  and gender strategies, xxiv, 192, 198

  and generational changes, 235, 256-57

  and housework, 38-44, 44-51, 103, 109, 188, 252

  and marital tensions, 11, 57-60, 201, 207, 246-47

  and resentment, 253

  and supermom strategy, 32-33

  and upstairs-downstairs myth, 44-46, 48, 54-55, 58-59, 75, 102, 112, 203

  and workplace pressures, 249

  Home Economics Movement, 241

  Horner, Matina, 249

  household incomes, 25

  housekeepers

  and cultural pressures, 25

  and the Delacortes, 66

  and gender strategies, 196-97

  and the Myersons, 104

  and the Shermans, 178-79

  and the Steins, 116-17, 121-23

  and supermom stereotype, 1

  and women’s careers, 82, 83

  housekeeping standards, 26

  housewives, 4, 77-78, 221-22, 239-40, 249

  housework. See also second shift

  and the Alstons, 148-49, 195, 213

  and conflicting pressures, 105-6

  direct approaches to, 192-93

  and divorce, 207-12

  and gender equity, 13, 48-49

  and gender roles, 26-27

  and the Holts, 38-44, 44-51, 103, 109, 252

  and the Livingstons, 162-63, 214

  men’s participation in, xvi-xvii, 7-9, 289n6 (see also specific individuals)

  research on, 271-78

  time spent on, xvi, xxiv, 3-4, 9

  and traditionalism, 72

  and the Winfields, 183

  and women’s careers, 87

  housing costs, 12

  Huber, Joan, 210-11

  Huffington Post, 263

  Hughes, Gwendolyn, 251

  illness

  and career pressures, 167-68

  and fatigue, 84, 193

  and gender strategies, 73-74

  and sleep deprivation, 263

  ulcers, 132

  income. See wages and income

  incompetence strategy, 72-73, 73-76, 193, 199, 205

  industrial economy, 11-12, 235-39, 259

  Italy, 259-60

  Japan, 260

  Judson, Anita

  career of, 235, 237

  and changes in the workplace, 250

  divorce, 130, 133-34, 141-42, 261

  and economic pressures, 189

  family life described, 129-32

  and gender strategies, 132-42, 195, 257

  and generational changes, 235

  and marital tensions, 11

  and second shift work, 188

  separation, 208

  Judson, Eric, 129, 130, 261

  Judson, Ray

  and changes in the workplace, 250

  divorce, 130, 133-34, 141-42, 261

  and economic pressures, 189

  and family background, 190-91

  family life described, 129-32, 134-40

  and gender strategies, 142, 198

  and housework sharing, 173, 215

  and marital tensions, 11, 203

  and second shift work, 188

  separation, 208

  work day described, 137-38

  Judson, Ruby, 129, 133, 139, 261

  Juster, F. T., 21

  Kaplan, Elaine, 4, 24

  Karasak, Robert, 138

  Kessler, Ronald, 208

  Kuttner, Bob, 222-23

  Lasch, Christopher, 250-51

  latch-key children, 227

  leisure time

  and divorce rates, 4

  and economic logic of gender roles, 217

  and family myths, 20

  and gender differences in the workplace, 138-39

  and hobbies, 99-104, 105, 147, 197, 214-15

  and the Holts, 38, 49-50, 55, 56, 197, 214-15

  and housework sharing, 217

  leisure gap, 265-66

  and the Steins, 118-19, 123

  and support for women, 247

  and wage gaps, 130, 277-78

  lesbian couples, 5, 52

  Levinger, George, 211

  Livingston, Barbara

  and child care, 160-61, 164-72

  family life described, 160-64

  and gender ideology, 191

  marriage counseling, 208

  separation, 261

  and supermom strategy, 162, 194

  Livingston, Cary, 160-64, 164-72, 191, 228, 261

  Livingston, John

  and child care, 160-61, 164-72, 227, 228

  and economic logic of gender roles, 163, 217

  family life described, 160-64

  and gender ideology, 191

  and gender strategies, 197

  and housework sharing, 162-63, 214

  marriage counseling, 208 separation, 261

  Machung, Anne, 4, 19, 255, 258

  MacIntyre, Duncan, 23

  maids. See housekeepers

  manhood ideology. See also gender ideologies

  and career environment, 113

  and child-care standards, 225

  and class issues, 189

  and cultural change, 250, 252

  and gender ideology, 15

  and gender strategies, 157-58

  and the Holts, 45, 54

  and household participation, 12

  and the Judsons, 140

  and money, 130-31, 237

  and nurturance, 119

  and the Shermans, 180

  and the Steins, 125

  and the Tanagawas, 78, 85

  and third stage of fatherhood, 186-87

  marital tensions, 11, 164-72, 201-12. See also divorce

  Marx, Karl, 237

  matriarchal families, 23-24

  McRae, James, 208

  Megatrends (Naisbitt), 261

  men, 213-34. See also specific individuals

  child care done by, 9, 215, 219-21, 224-25, 225-28, 231-34, 254, 2244

  and class issues, 62-63

  comparisons between, 51-57

  and control of their own time, 9, 281n1

  cooperation strategies of, 43, 49-50, 98

  and decline of domestic culture, 242-43

  earnings of, xxiv, 215-17, 217-24, 237, 244-45, 247-49, 277-78

  and economic development in US, 11-12

  fathers and upbringing of, 213-15

  and gender ideologies, 15-17

  and history of American fatherhood, 185-87

  housework done by, xvi-xvii, 7-9, 289n6 (see also specific individuals)

  minority, 63

  needs-reduction strategy of, 199, 252

  and “new man,” 29, 30-32, 181, 186

  resentment toward, from wives, 253

  resistance strategies of, 199, 252

  “substitute offerings” of, 49, 199

  token chores of, 49

  young, 256-58

  Milkie, Melissa, 265-66

  Mixed Blessings (Cowen), 125

  MomsRising, 268

  Mothers in Industry (Hughes), 251

  Moynihan, Daniel Patrick, 23, 24

  Myerson, Ann

  and career pressures, 106-10, 194

  and child care, 156, 227

  and class issues, 241, 242

  and conflicts over housework, 105-6, 147

  and cultural pressures, 239-40

  and devaluation of time, 253-54

  and economic logic of gender roles, 217

  family life descr
ibed, 96-99

  and family myth, 99-104

  and gender ideology, 188-89, 191

  and gender strategies, 200, 253

  and leisure gap, 197

  and marital tensions, 203

  as “new peasantry,” 242

  and workplace pressures, 96-99

  Myerson, Elizabeth, 97, 100, 102-4, 108-9

  Myerson, Nora, 97, 100

  Myerson, Robert

  and divorce, 203

  and family myth, 99-104

  and gender ideology, 188-89, 190, 191

  and housework sharing, 105-6, 147

  and leisure time, 197

  and marital tensions, 195

  and second shift work, 188

  and value of career, 106-8

  and weekly routines, 97-98

  Naisbitt, John, 261

  Nash, John, 187

  National Academy of Sciences, 232

  National Children’s Survey, 244

  National Telework Week, 268

  The Negro Family: The Case for National Action (report), 23

  Netherlands, 268

  “new man,” 29, 30-32, 181, 186

  New York Times Magazine, 22-23, 227

  Norway, 260, 267

  O’Malley, Tom, 209-10

  parenting. See also children and child care; fatherhood

  and the Alstons, 148-52

  emotional support strategy, 79

  and gender roles, 8

  and gender strategies, 155, 195-96

  and the Myersons, 102

  single parenthood, 133, 230, 248-49

  and the Steins, 117

  and step parents, 184-85

  and workplace pressures, 178-80

  part-time employment, 2, 266

  Pasquera, Beatrice, 242

  paternity leave, 261

  patriarchal families, 205-7, 246, 252

  peasantry, 238n, 241

  personnel policies, 91-95

  Pillsbury, Susan, 193

  Pleck, Joseph, 208, 221-22

  Radin, Norma, 232-33

  Raley, Sara, 265-66

  Reagan, Nancy, 66

  Redesigning the American Dream (Hayden), 12, 260

  The Remembered Gate (Berg), 243

  The Reproduction of Mothering (Chodorow), 155-57

  Robinson, J. P., 139

  Sagi, Abraham, 233

  salaries. See wages and income

  Sanchez, Consuela, 241

  second shift. See also entries for specific activities such as housework.

  and changing roles, 192-93

  and child care, 159, 195-96

  and cutting back at work, 194-95

  and cutting back on domestic responsibilities, 195-96

  described, 4

  and divorce, 207-12

  extra workload of, 4, 7-10, 14, 20-21, 22, 30, 246, 248, 254, 265, 270, 272

  and gender ideologies, 41-42, 154, 190-92

  and gender roles, 104

  hired help for, 196-97 (see also baby-sitters and day-care workers; housekeepers)

  and housework sharing, 175

  impact on men, 7-8

  men’s participation in (see specific individuals)

  origin of term, 7

  personal meanings of, 188

  research on, 3, 271-78

  and supermom strategies, 33

  women’s strategies for, 192-97

  self-care children, 227, 260

  self-esteem, 4, 41, 42

  separations, 44, 139-40

  service sector jobs, 216, 237, 250

  Sex and the Single Girl (Brown), 26

  sex life

  and children, 165-66

  and the Delacortes, 67

  and the Holts, 43-44, 46, 50, 189

  and indirect strategies, 193

  and the Steins, 124-25, 189

  Shaevitz, Marjorie Hansen, 27-28

  Shaevitz, Mort, 27-28

  Sherman, Adrienne, 174-81

  and child care, 156

  and cultural pressures, 240

  and direct approaches, 192

  and divorce, 205-6

  and economic pressures, 218

  and generational changes, 257

  and negotiation of housework, 252

  retirement, 261

  Sherman, Michael

  and career tensions, 205-6

  and child care, 156-57, 228

  and economic logic of gender roles, 217, 218, 223

  and fatherhood, 181, 186, 187, 224-25

  and gender strategies, 197

  and housework sharing, 7, 173-81, 213, 214, 215

  retirement, 261

  and second shift work, 189

  Sims, Dan, 20

  Sims, Dorothy, 19-20, 21

  Sims, Timothy, 20

  single parenthood, 133, 230, 248-49

  sleep deprivation, 10, 20, 162, 263-64, 279n2

  social class. See class, social

  Soviet Union, 24-25, 208, 259

  Spitze, Glenna, 210-11

  Staines, Graham, 208

  Stein, Jessica

  and children’s behaviors, 123-24

  and class issues, 241

  and cultural pressures, 240

  and domestic help, 116-17, 121-23

  and economic pressures, 189

  family life described, 111-16

  and gender strategies, 124-28

  and gratitude, 118-19, 128

  and marital tensions, 11, 201, 202, 208

  and nurturance, 119-20

  Stein, Seth

  and child care, 123-24, 156, 254

  and class issues, 241

  and domestic help, 116-17, 121-23

  and economic pressures, 189

  family life described, 111-15

  and gender ideology, 130, 190

  and gender strategies, 124-27

  and gratitude, 118-19, 128

  and housework sharing, 173, 213

  and marital tensions, 11, 201, 202, 208

  and nurturance, 119-20

  sacrifices of, 180

  and second shift work, 189

  and workplace pressures, 180

  Stein, Victor, 112, 114, 116-17, 119-24, 255

  Stein, Walter, 114, 120, 123-24, 255

  Steinem, Gloria, 66, 68-69

  stress, 138-39, 167-68, 216, 263

  superdad(s), 17, 162, 197

  superkid(s), 226-27

  supermom(s)

  and black women, 24

  and Carol Alston, 147

  and child-care standards, 225-26

  critiques of, 29-30

  and cultural images, 22-33, 32-33

  and division of labor, 94

  emotional cost of, 59-60

  as gender strategy, 194

  image, 22-23

  language of, 55

  and the Livingstons, 162, 194

  motivations for, 13

  parodies of, 29-30

  and role models, 22

  and social changes, 251-52

  and Soviet women, 24-25

  stereotype image of, 1

  and women’s careers, 99

  The Superwoman Syndrome (Shaevitz), 27-28, 29

  Sweden, 208, 268

  Szalai, Alexander, 3, 4

  Tanagawa, Alexandra, 79-82, 84, 87-88, 90-91

  Tanagawa, Diane, 79-80, 81

  Tanagawa, Nina

  career of, 81-88, 91-95, 144, 249

  and changes in the workplace, 250

  and concerns with children, 90-91

  and cultural pressures, 240

  and divorce, 88-90, 203

  and economic logic of gender roles, 218

  family life described, 77-78

  and family myths, 81, 127-28

  and gender strategies, 78-81, 147, 194, 199, 200

  and generational changes, 235

  and housework sharing, 109, 188

  illnesses, 84, 193

  Tanagawa, Nina (cont.)

  and indirect approaches, 193

  and leisure ga
p, 197

  and marital pressures, 246-47

  Tanagawa, Peter

  and changes in the workplace, 250

  and concerns with children, 90-91

  and cultural change, 250

  and divorce, 88-90, 203

  earnings, 130

  and economic logic of gender roles, 218

  family life described, 77-78

  and family myths, 81, 127-28

  and gender ideology, 190

  and gender strategies, 78-81, 112, 125, 147, 198-200, 252

  and gratitude, 84-86, 118

  and housework sharing, 103, 147, 154, 173, 215

  sacrifices of, 180

  and second shift work, 188

  and workplace pressures, 81-88, 93-95

  Thoits, Peggy, 4

  traditional gender ideology

  and the Alstons, 154-55

  and comparison groups, 52

  and the Delacortes, 61-71, 71-73, 73-76, 193, 199, 205

  described, 15-17

  and the domestic heritage, 243

  and gender strategies, 188

  and high-earning women, 216

  and the Judsons, 140

  and marital tensions, 201, 204-5

  and the Myersons, 102

  and patriarchal families, 205-7

  transitional gender ideology

  described, 15-17

  and the domestic tradition, 243

  and the Holts, 58

  and the Judsons, 132, 140

  and male share of housekeeping, 75, 276, 282-83n1

  and marital tensions, 201, 204

  repercussions of, 8

  and the Tanagawas, 77, 83

  and women’s careers, 83, 94

  Trudeau, Gary, 200

  True magazine, 239

  unemployment and underemployment among African Americans, 23-24

  and family relationships, 266

  and the Holts, 42

  of men, 219-20, 223, 227

  and race issues, 251

  UNESCO, 266-67

  unmarried couples, 5, 52

  urbanization, 235-39

  US Bureau of Labor Statistics, 141

  Vanek, Joan, 25

  wages and income. See also economic pressures

  and the Alstons, 145

  and changes in the workplace, 237, 250

  and cultural pressures, 23

  and economic logic of gender roles, 217-24, 219-21

  and family myths, 127-28

  and gender ideologies, 85-86

  and gender strategies, 135

  and housework sharing, 215-17

  and income disparity, 14, 23, 130,

  179, 243-47, 248

  and the Judsons, 130

  and leisure gap, 277-78

  limits of economic logic, 217-24

  and women’s careers, 85-87

  “A Week Like Any Other”

  (Baranskaya), 24-25

  Welter, Barbara, 236-37

  Western Europe, 3

  Whipple, Thomas, 26

  Williams, Joan, 141

  Wilson, Katherine, 229-30

  Winfield, Adam, 181, 228, 234, 255

  Winfield, Art

  and child care, 156-57, 181-85

  and economic logic of gender roles, 218, 222, 223

  and fatherhood, 181-85, 186, 187

  and gender strategies, 197, 199

  and housework sharing, 7, 213, 214, 215

 

‹ Prev