The Cowboys' Cure (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour)

by Jenny May

“I told you both that I wanted this.” Austin welcomed the odd sensations, letting them build the pleasure that was tight in her core. “I want one of you to try tonight. I don’t think I’m ready, but I’m willing to try.”

  “Shit.” William thrust his finger into her pussy faster as he continued to move the toy inside of her. “I think if you’re taking it this easy, we might be able to pull it off. We’ll just have to go very slow that way you don’t end up getting hurt.”

  Sweat was beginning to break out across her skin as he picked up the pace. “What are we waiting for? I’m ready.”

  “Not yet,” Scott whispered against her ear. “You’re nowhere near to the point where I want you. By the time William and I finish what I have planned, you’re going to be begging us for release. Only then will we take you.” He put her legs together and hooked them on one of his arms. “Faster, Will.”

  More lube poured over her ass and Austin felt her eyes go big as Scott reached around and started rubbing the pads of his fingers over her clit. The speed of the thrusts seemed to triple as William obeyed Scott’s order. Austin gasped for air against all the sensations.

  “You’re going to get close to coming.” Scott’s teeth pulled against her ear lobe. “You’re not going to. You’re going to hold it in until I tell you.”

  Mindlessly, Austin’s hands jerked up and clutched to his biceps. With every flex of his muscles, the ache in the pit of her stomach increased.

  “Tell me you understand.”

  “I do.”

  The front of her thighs crushed against her breasts while Scott angled her higher. Squirming was almost impossible, yet Austin couldn’t help but try. The orgasm that was building was going to pack a punch. She could tell the longer she held it at bay.

  “William.” The name trembled from her mouth. “Scott.” She looked up, holding to his arms tighter.

  “Not yet, baby.” William kept the fast pace while Scott tormented her clit with deliciously amazing circles.

  “Please.” Austin tried to pull up to make it back off, but the friction only caused her to cry out. “I can’t.” Her head swung back and forth. If she didn’t come soon, she was going to die or explode. She just knew it.

  The bed shifted as Scott rose to his knees. “Don’t stop, William.” The weight of his cock left her back and she felt his hand leave her clit to pull down his shorts. The change in consistency gave a brief moment of relief, but within seconds he was back to rubbing over her upper slit.

  “William’s going to fuck you, and you’re going to come on his cock. But be wise, darlin’. The moment your orgasm stops, so does he. Then we build you up again. Next time, I’m going to make you hold out even longer.”

  * * * *

  William eased the toy from Austin’s ass and handed it to Scott. His cock was throbbing. Tonight was the night. He just knew it. The way she’d accepted it with no problem…it wasn’t going to take much more work to have one of their cocks replacing the dildo.

  The shorts that hung loosely around his hips were easy enough to remove. William tossed them on the floor and took his position in the middle of the bed. “Come here, baby.”

  Scott lowered her to the mattress. His hand was still locked to the mound of her pussy. Still moving. “Remember, Austin. You come, we start over.”

  “I remember.” Shakily, she leaned forward and her hand grasped around his long length. A moan poured from his mouth as Austin licked across his tip. Fuck, he couldn’t wait to be inside of her.

  The bed shook while Scott increased the rhythm over her clit. To say that Scott was more the dominant of the two would have been an accurate assessment. William was more laid back, but Scott demanded. He loved to push the limits and draw out the pleasure. With Austin, his true self was finally becoming exposed, and it was refreshing to see. This was the Scott he knew, and William was glad they were starting their new relationship off right.

  He couldn’t believe it. If anyone were to ask, he could actually admit he was seeing Austin. That she was girlfriend. Wow, what a weird word. Girlfriend. He felt like he was in high school all over again. Which wasn’t necessarily a place he wanted to be. But it was the last time he’d had a steady partner. And that’s what he’d been craving, wasn’t it? They had to start somewhere. Girlfriend now. Maybe if things turned out right over the next few months or years, possibly something more. Who was he kidding? From the beginning he could feel there was something special about her. The last month, spending almost every day with Austin, he knew she was going to be the one. The feeling stretched so deep and wide inside of him that there wasn’t a shadow of a doubt.

  Suction pulled William deeper inside of Austin’s mouth. He reached out with both hands, lifting the hair out of her face. The moment she met his stare, William had to rein in his desire. Damn, he’d never had this problem with a woman before. He was the one always in control of his reactions. Yet, with Austin, all it took was a look, a touch, and his body was quick to betray him.

  “Come up here. Let’s take care of you, baby. I can see how much you need me.”

  A soft cry left her lips as he took the condom from Scott and rolled it down his length. The trembling had increased and he had to help lift her leg over. Only then did Scott break away from her clit.

  Wet heat met the tip of William’s cock. The burn left him impatient to fill her. She was positively on fire. As the warmth encircled him, gripping more of his width, he held tightly to her hips.

  “Lean forward, Austin. Come kiss me while Scott gets you ready with the toy.”

  A kiss, something William had never cherished before, had turned into one of the most important things he could ever give. Scott’s words had never meant so much. With Austin, every meeting of their lips was a gift, and he wanted her to feel that. With every caress of his tongue, he tried show her how much she truly meant to him. Even if he couldn’t express it in words just yet. William was ready to fight for her, prove to her that this was where she was meant to be. Love her…it wasn’t a question. He’d try his best to relay that to Austin, too.

  Eagerly, she met his tongue while he pushed into her pussy nice and slow. The sounds that filled him up, he embraced like a starving man. William’s fingers laced through her hair and he held her to him, afraid to let go. Whether this lasted for minutes or hours, it would never be enough.

  Austin broke from his lips, sucking in air. The ecstasy she felt was written all over her face. He knew Scott was fucking her with the toy. Could feel the movement of it as he made his own thrusts. The way her pussy tightened around him, it wouldn’t be long before she caved. Screams would echo off the walls and William would bask in them, too.

  “Oh…fuck.” Austin rotated her hips, increasing her speed by the second. William reached up, mesmerized at her beauty. “Look at me.” He traced her lips with his finger while she met his stare. “You know those nails you try your best to hide?” He adjusted her hands to rest over his chest. “Mark me with your pleasure. Give me a reminder of this moment right here. Do not hold back.”

  William pushed in his finger until it connected with the tip of her tongue. Sucking drew him in deeper, and the wetness had him closing his eyes. Everything he felt suddenly came crashing over him like a tidal wave. Fire flared in his chest and he fed off of it, letting it drive him faster. Harder.

  Warmth seeped from the scratches and it wasn’t until the sound of her voice filled his ears and began to die down that William slowed and opened his eyes. Sweat beaded her flushed skin and he couldn’t do anything but stare, entranced.

  * * * *

  There was no way Scott was going to be able to hold off much longer. Watching William with Austin was the most erotic, amazing thing he was sure he’d ever see. The two of them…they meant more to him than anyone ever had. Women were something that hadn’t been in his life much, and this one had certainly made her home deep within his heart. Whether it was a good thing, or one that would tear him to shreds, was something he decided he’d leave to
fate.

  Scott wanted to trust her as much as William did, but his past didn’t help with the issues. Not to mention the ways of Crush. The residents had to be his biggest fear. They’d done their damage already by targeting him and William. Was it possible the townsfolk would bring on round two, this time including Austin? God, he prayed not. If he lost her over after what they’d shared…no. He couldn’t think about that right now. Couldn’t ruin this beautiful moment by his deeply rooted insecurities. He had to trust that she’d be honest with them and wouldn’t run at the first sign of trouble. If the three of them just stuck together, they could do this. It seemed like she wanted to.

  Austin tried to catch her breath while William ran his hand down her hair, smoothing the length back from her face. Gently, Scott removed the fake cock from her ass. A small sound came from her throat and she sat up straighter.

  “That was intense. I can’t even see straight right now.” Austin squirmed a little, taking William’s cock in all the way. He could tell she wanted to keep going. Scott twisted his mouth, debating on what he should do. Although he’d had plans to draw this out, he wanted her way too much to wait any longer. The small taste they’d had of her before was only a tease to his appetite. The week of withdraws left him roaring to fuck her at the first opportunity, and what better time than now?

  “Lean forward, darlin’. I’ve changed my mind. Time to see if you’re ready to take both of us.”

  The obedience was automatic. She bent more toward William, and Scott added lube to his fingers, letting some pool on the top. He poured a little on the outside of her ass, watching it drip down to where William’s length was resting.

  “Fingers first.” Scott knew the width of two of his fingers was larger than what she’d just taken. If she was able to accept them without much trouble, they might have a chance.

  William withdrew a little and began to thrust into her at a leisurely pace. Just seeing her pussy pull at his cock greedily had Scott cursing under his breath. Pre-cum oozed from his cock and he collected it on his finger. “Open, sweetheart. Taste what you’re doing to me.”

  The dark curls spun over her shoulder as she turned to him. Austin grabbed his wrist and sucked his finger so deep into her mouth that he could feel the back of her throat.

  “More.”

  William gripped her hips and grinded into her. As Scott pushed one finger into her ass, he got on his knees and led her head to his cock. Seeing her connected to him while his best friend pleasured her was heaven to witness. The essence that made him who he was seemed to be exactly what Austin craved. It didn’t get better than that.

  The tip of his other finger pushed against her back entrance. He made sure to place it on top of his other, just to make the insertion easier. Once she got up to his first knuckles, he began to ease them side by side. A sound came from her mouth while he let her adjust.

  “How you doing, Austin? Does it hurt?”

  A moment of uncertainty passed her face, only to change when he began to withdraw.

  “Wait. Keep going. Now that you’re moving it feels better.”

  Gently, he proceeded to make small movements, mostly letting her lead.

  “Yes.” She rocked her hips faster until his fingers were buried inside in her ass.

  “You got this, darlin’.” He smiled and looked at William. “Our girl is good to go. Just take it easy. Let her control until she’s ready to hand over the reins.”

  William nodded and brought her chest to lie against his. “Kiss me and let your body lead you, baby. Don’t worry if it takes a while. We got all night.”

  Scott tore open the package to the condom and rolled it down his length. As he covered it in lube, he made sure to add extra to her ass. She was going to need all the help she could get. Although his fingers were the biggest she’d had, he was still larger than that.

  “Keep relaxed. This may hurt a little. I’m going to go extra slow until I’m in a good inch or two. Then you can take over.”

  She nodded as he rubbed the head of his cock over her ass. Slowly, Scott pushed forward, feeling her stretch around his thickness. Austin’s breathing increased, but her body remained loose against the feel of his hand.

  “Fuck, you’re tight. Little more, sweetheart.” The head of his cock slid inside. A sound between pleasure and pain came from her mouth and she reached back, clutching to his arm.

  “We good?” William leaned his head over.

  Scott lowered and kissed her back. “We’re good.” William began to move inside of her again and within seconds the moans returned. More and more of Scott’s cock entered her until he realized he was halfway there.

  He reached around, squeezing her nipple between his fingers. “How is it feeling? Are you enjoying having both of us? Because I have to say, I fucking love being in your ass.” Scott grazed his teeth down her earlobe feeling her shudder beneath him.

  “I want more. Give it to me, Scott.”

  “Damn. Say it again.” He pushed a little deeper, beginning to thrust. The weight of her breast in his hand suddenly became his anchor. He held onto her while he inched more in.

  “Fuck my ass, Scott. Just like you do in your dreams. Show me whose ass that belongs to.”

  A growl vibrated his throat as he felt himself bury inside of her. “This is mine and William’s ass only. Any man who thinks he’s going to try to take it away will have us to deal with. And it won’t be pretty. No one touches or mess with what is ours, Austin. No one.”

  Loud moans poured from her as he began to thrust in earnest. In that moment, everything suddenly changed within Scott. Claiming her out loud had set things into motion that he hadn’t even realized were missing. He knew she was his when they’d decided to make it official, but now, he felt it. God, help him. Austin belonged to him just as much as William, this ranch, and everything else he owned. There was no more holding anything back. No more wall shutting her out. Here she was, and for him, she was here to stay.

  Sweat dripped down onto Austin’s shoulder as he felt himself suddenly clutching to her. Shit. What was this tempestuous need that was suddenly overpowering him? Emotions he couldn’t remember ever feeling slammed into him like someone had swung a sledge hammer full force. This woman, broken once by a man, was between him and William, giving them everything she was capable of. Who was he to deserve her?

  Scott clutched to her tighter, surging as deep as possible. He knew who he was. He was honor. Responsibility. The man meant for Austin. He wouldn’t hurt her. Wouldn’t degrade her or make her feel unworthy of his love. No. This was right. And it was about damn time something good came his way.

  “I can’t hold out anymore.” Austin’s head came to the side and he took the opportunity to do what he’d longed to since they’d started. He kissed her. That’s where love stemmed from. It was the only place two souls could intertwine and mark what was permanently theirs. A lasting memory that would dowse out all others.

  Scott felt himself swell inside of her. Not once did he think about holding back. Cum shot from his cock with such force that he wasn’t sure who was moaning so loud, him or Austin? Hell, for one second, he thought it was William. Only when he began to resurface from the fog he’d been pulled into, did he hear his friend, separate from him.

  “Oh…shit.” William’s voice sounded deep as he lifted his head. “I could get used to this. I don’t even have words for how absolutely phenomenal that was.”

  Scott kissed Austin’s cheek and smiled down at him. “I do. It’s called fucktastic.” He withdrew from Austin’s ass and couldn’t help but kiss her again. “I do believe we’ve reached a whole new level, and if it’s all right with you two, I’d like to stay here for one hell of a long time.”

  Chapter 14

  Whispering brought Austin out of a deep sleep and pulled her into dark half consciousness. Aching raced through her body as she turned onto her stomach. Memories of her and her men’s late night stargazing rendezvous filtered through, causing her to s
mile.

  What started as an innocent look at the sky had quickly become a hot and heavy sexcapade in the great outdoors. Austin couldn’t even remember making it inside the house. The moment they’d finished, Scott and William had curled up against her on their blanket, and she’d fallen asleep. Now, here she was, with the two of them plotting something in the background. She could tell by the way they were laughing that the two of them were up to something.

  After a few moments of silence Austin felt herself getting pulled back into heaviness. The brink of sleep was coming on hard. Tingling danced across her skin and she was giving into the feeling with every breath she took.

  “Shh. Stop walking so hard.” Footsteps neared. Although the heavy thuds lightened, the click of the boots against the wood floors couldn’t be ignored.

  Two things suddenly became obvious as Austin lay there with her eyes still closed. One, she could smell coffee. Two, bacon. The mattress shifted while more clanking walked around the bed, make the other side dip down under one of their weight.

  “Morning, darlin’. We made you something.” Scott’s voice had her smiling. It took everything she had, but Austin managed to force her lids to lift. The room was still dark and she glanced around, confused. William leaned over and gave her a big kiss.

  “We made you a three-month anniversary breakfast.”

  The food was sitting next to her on a tray, but her attention got stuck to the clock. Five fifteen… in the morning! “You did this for me before you went to work. How sweet of you.”

  William laughed. “Told you she would like it,” he said, looking at Scott. “I figured since today was three months since we made it official that we should celebrate. We made reservations at a fancy place that I think you’re going to like, so be ready to head out at around six.”

  Austin was throwing herself into William’s arms before she could think about the tray sitting next to her. “Thank you. This means so much.” Scott placed it on the edge of the bed just as she turned. The moment his hands were free she wrapped her arms around his neck. “Thank you. You both treat me so good.” Tears came to her eyes, but she held them in.