The Haunted Abbot sf-12

by Peter Tremayne

  ‘How can you believe that Sister Fidelma is capable of that which you accuse her of?’ he asked softly, realising, as he asked the question, that it was a weak argument.

  ‘I have given my reasons. They are plain enough. And it seems that your irreligion makes you blind to her guilt. These mysterious happenings only occurred after you both arrived in this kingdom. That is the reason I accuse her. I believe that she is one who works for the devil, or by some devilish and curious art has conjured images which the devil has devised to entangle and ensnare the souls of the pious brethren in this community. It is my responsibility to save them from damnation!’

  ‘Without the trial of her whom you accuse? While she lies ill and in no position to defend herself?’ Eadulf was seething with anger. ‘I tell you, Cild, you exceed your authority. You believe in an eye for an eye. So be it. Should harm befall Sister Fidelma, you will truly know what vengeance is. I swear it.’

  Abbot Cild sat back and examined Eadulf’s angry features. His mouth turned down.

  ‘One thing you do not lack, Eadulf of Seaxmund’s Ham, and that is courage. You threaten me in the sanctuary of my own abbey? I could have you taken out and flogged, aye, and even burnt as a pagan heretic for daring to ignore the holy words of the Scriptures. I have armed brethren within call. What do you think I should do in the face of your threats, Brother Eadulf?’

  Eadulf stared back defiantly.

  ‘I do not know what you will do, Cild. I cannot predict whatyou will do, for you do not seem to be answerable to anyone for your actions. I will tell you this, though. If anything happens to Sister Fidelma or to me, then the retribution that you will bring down on yourself might be more than you bargain for.

  ‘Sister Fidelma is blood sister to the King of Cashel. She is highly respected in the faith having been a delegate at Whitby. She attended the Lateran Palace at Rome, and is a lawyer of her people. Do you think that you can act against her with impunity? I, an emissary of Archbishop Theodore, am as of no consequence compared with her. However, of little worth as I am, Archbishop Theodore will want an accounting of King Ealdwulf if harm befalls me, and Ealdwulf will want to know why his tranquillity is disturbed by Canterbury.’

  There was a lengthy silence after Eadulf stopped speaking.

  Then Abbot Cild actually smiled. It was not a pleasant smile.

  ‘You have put your case very well. I shall now tell you what I shall do. I shall wait until Sister Fidelma is recovered from her illness and then we shall have a formal hearing about the matter. If it is proved that she has had no hand in conjuring spirits in this abbey, then you may continue on your journey. Whatever whispers of the dead brought you hither can be consigned back to the dead. Do you understand me?’

  ‘How can one defend oneself against such an intangible accusation as conjuring images of the dead?’ demanded Eadulf.

  Abbot Cild spread his hands. ‘That is not my concern. If she is innocent then let her prove it.’

  ‘And who will decide her innocence or guilt?’

  ‘I will,’ returned the abbot blandly.

  ‘And if you decide that she is guilty?’

  ‘The punishment is prescribed by the laws of the Wuffingas, the laws of our people handed down to us by Wuffa son of Wehha.’

  A coldness went through Eadulf. As a gerefa he knew the laws well, but what was more terrifying was the fact that it was obvious that Abbot Cild was demented, and in his state of mind the man was without mercy.

  ‘As amended by the ministration of the new faith?’ he asked hopefully.

  Abbot Cild shook his head. ‘I see no reason why the laws of the Wuffingas should be amended. The penalty for conjuring demons and ghosts is clear … the guilty woman is placed face downwards in a grave and buried — alive!’

  Chapter Nine

  As Eadulf was leaving the abbot’s chambers he encountered the flaxen-haired Brother Higbald, the abbey’s apothecary. Higbald greeted him in a concerned but friendly fashion, still wearing the bright and humorous appearance he had that morning. Humour seemed a natural attitude to him. He had that ease of manner which reminded Eadulf of Aldhere’s jocular attitude to the world.

  ‘So, Brother Eadulf, you have heard that mass hysteria has taken over our poor community?’

  Eadulf halted, frowning. It took him a moment to realise what the apothecary was referring to. His eyes lighted.

  ‘Then you do not believe in this ghostly apparition?’

  Brother Higbald shook his head. If anything it seemed his smile broadened.

  ‘I cannot believe we have a wraith or phantom wafting through these dismal corridors. I believe that young Redwald was imagining things. Yet I have to point out that it was you who first raised the image of a woman who, by poor Brother Willibrod’s account, bore a striking resemblance to the dead wife of the abbot. Perhaps young Redwald overheard you talking about the matter and then, with an overfull imagination, he embroidered something he saw in the shadows. That’s all.’

  Eadulf put his head to one side reflectively.

  ‘That is a possibility, though I have spoken to young Redwald and his fear is genuine enough.’

  ‘It might well be. It is possible to convince yourself that you have seen something when you have not. Youth is impressionable.’

  Eadulf smiled grimly. ‘Granted that is so. Can the same explanation be ascribed to my sighting of the lady?’

  Brother Higbald chuckled. ‘I do not know you, Brother, and therefore I cannot say. All I know is — as I told you this morning- we are a small community and I would know if there was a woman in this place.’

  ‘But would you know if it were a shadow, an image from the Otherworld?’ demanded Eadulf.

  Brother Higbald shook his head firmly. ‘You do not believe in such things, my friend. Neither do I.’

  ‘Unfortunately, your abbot and many of the brethren here do.’

  ‘That is a difficulty, I know. In fact, I was just on my way to see how Sister Fidelma is faring. I’ll accompany you, if I may?’

  ‘She has fallen into a fever,’ Eadulf said as they walked together along the corridor.

  Brother Higbald did not appear perturbed.

  ‘It is usually the way with such agues. The fever comes and must break naturally, although we can help with some medication. Usually, the fever breaks in the early hours of the morning. There is nothing we can do but wait.’ Higbald paused and glanced at him. ‘Where did you disappear to this morning?’

  ‘I rode out after Abbot Cild and his party,’ Eadulf replied. ‘I did not catch up with them, but I caught up with the abbot’s brother.’

  Brother Higbald halted almost in mid-stride and stared at Eadulf.

  ‘You met and spoke to Aldhere?’

  Eadulf nodded. ‘An interesting man. Not quite as the abbot would describe him. There seem some interesting undercurrents here. If I had my way, I would turn the matter over to the King’s high steward to investigate.’

  Brother Higbald resumed the walk and Eadulf fell in with him.

  ‘I try to avoid fraternal strife. But you are aware of where Abbot Cild’s accusation against Sister Fidelma may lead?’

  Eadulf nodded grimly.

  ‘Would you accept some advice?’ Brother Higbald asked.

  Eadulf gave him a curious glance. ‘Advice?’

  ‘As soon as your companion’s fever has broken, I would leave this place.’

  Eadulf sighed with resignation. ‘I think that is exactly what you counselled me this morning.’

  ‘It is the best advice I can give,’ replied Brother Higbald. ‘I will show you a means through which you may pass out of the abbey unnoticed; one which is not generally known to the brethren. With luck, you could escape Cild’s wrath with ease. I, for one, do not want innocent blood on my hands.’

  Eadulf glanced at him in surprise.

  ‘If you are so sceptical of your abbot, why do you stay here, Brother Higbald?’

  The apothecary chuckled dryly.


  ‘We all have reasons for being where we are in life. I choose here. My reasons are of no consequence to this matter.’

  A thought suddenly struck Eadulf.

  ‘Didn’t you tell me this morning that Brother Botulf had been a witness to the lady Gélgeis’s death? I have heard that she was returning alone to the abbey one night and wandered into a quagmire, Hob’s Mire, and disappeared. No one saw the body afterwards. So who told you that Botulf was a witness to her death?’

  Brother Higbald paused again and turned to Eadulf. There was a frown on his face.

  ‘I never heard that she was alone when she met her death,’ he said with some hesitation. ‘Indeed, I think that it was Brother Botulf himself who told me the story.’

  ‘Tell me what Botulf actually said. Can you remember?’

  Brother Higbald thought for a moment.

  ‘It was several months ago. The subject of the abbot’s wife came up, I can’t recall why. Brother Botulf said … oh, something about failing the lady. That it was his fault that she was killed. Something like that. That … ah, I recall now! Botulf said that he had failed to protect Gélgeis from the evil she had found here. That her face, in death, haunted him. Then … that was all. He ended the conversation abruptly.’

  Eadulf was silent for a moment or so, reflecting on the words. He could find nothing substantial in them but much to give him food for conjecture. He sighed softly.

  They had reached the guests’ chamber but the burly silent brother still stood guard outside. Eadulf had realised by this time that the man was a mute.

  Brother Higbald greeted him with mockery in his voice.

  ‘How is your prisoner, Brother Beornwulf? Has she tried to escape and overpower you with the forces of the Evil One?’

  Brother Beornwulf shifted his weight from one foot to the other and scowled at the jocular apothecary.

  ‘I know, I know,’ Brother Higbald said pacifically, patting him on the arm. ‘You do what you are told. The abbot told you to remain here and so you remain here until he tells you not to.’ He shook his head at Eadulf. ‘It is good to know one’s place and duty,’ he said, still smiling. Then he opened the door to the guests’ chamber and went inside, motioning Eadulf to follow him. As he closed the door he turned and grimaced at Eadulf. ‘A good strong arm is Brother Beornwulf. But what he possesses in strength, he lacks in mental agility. He does what he is told. No more, no less.’

  Fidelma still lay in the cot, huddled under blankets, and still in the grip of the fever.

  Brother Higbald felt her moist forehead with the back of his hand. She moaned softly but did not open her eyes.

  ‘Ah, febricula incipit — still feverish. There is no change as yet, Brother Eadulf,’ he said. ‘That is to be expected. You understand these things, don’t you?’

  Eadulf nodded. ‘I would prescribe something to help her fight the fever and reduce it, though.’

  ‘I agree. What would you suggest?’

  ‘An infusion of wormwood, catnep …?’

  ‘I would suggest devil’s bit,’ replied Brother Higbald firmly.

  ‘Equally good,’ agreed Eadulf.

  Brother Higbald took the small sack-like bag he carried over his shoulder. ‘It so happens that I have already made up a potion of it.’

  Eadulf took the miniature amphora that the apothecary gave him, unplugged the cork and smelt the contents. Then he nodded.

  ‘Shall I administer it?’ he asked.

  Brother Higbald indicated his assent.

  Eadulf carefully placed his hand behind Fidelma’s hot, perspiration-soaked head and lifted her up. She groaned in protest but Eadulf placed the small amphora at her lips, gently forcing them open and making the liquid trickle into her mouth.

  ‘A good swallow or two,’ instructed Brother Higbald.

  Eadulf painstakingly administrated the dosage.

  ‘You may give her another dose later if the fever is not abating. But she is a strong, healthy woman. I think that is something we should be thankful for.’

  Eadulf put the amphora on a side table.

  ‘Now we must wait,’ Brother Higbald said approvingly. ‘I will leave you to your watch, my friend, but I earnestly believe that you should take my advice and leave this place at the first opportunity.’

  He crossed the room rapidly to a wall where a large tapestry denoting some religious scene was hanging. He turned and looked about him with a conspiratorial air.

  ‘Behind here you will find a small passageway which will lead you outside the walls of the abbey. Remember it.’

  He pulled the drape aside. To Eadulf’s surprise, there was a small doorway behind it. It opened inwards and was not locked. Brother Higbald opened it and pointed through into the darkness.

  ‘Following the passage, take the first two left turnings and then the first right. Remember that. Two left turns and one right. The abbey has several such tunnels, for it was built on an old Welisc fortress that was overthrown by Tytila, son of Wuffa, when our people conquered this area.’

  ‘I’ll remember that, Brother Higbald, and your advice, for which I am most truly grateful.’

  The apothecary said nothing but shut the door and returned the tapestry to its original position. Then he smiled briefly and raised a hand in a gesture of farewell before leaving the chamber. Eadulf heard him speaking to Brother Beornwulf outside. He hesitated for a moment and went to look down at Fidelma. Then he crossed to sit in the chair near the hearth.

  He suddenly realised how tired he was. It had been a long day. He had ridden far on muleback and ached all over. He sat back, hands resting his lap, and closed his eyes.

  The events of the day revolved slowly in his mind and he tried desperately to connect them.

  Above all, the danger to Fidelma kept nagging at his thoughts. She lay on the bed before him oblivious of that danger, fightingthe more immediate threat of her fever. His first duty was to protect her. Brother Higbald had, at least, shown him an alternative to waiting for Abbot Cild’s inquisition. But flight from Aldred’s Abbey was surely the last resort?

  What had he learnt of this mystery? He had been summoned by his good friend to the abbey. That friend had been murdered hours before he arrived. He found the abbot and his blood brother locked in a deadly quarrel and the abbot blaming that brother, Aldhere, for Botulf’s murder. In return, Aldhere accused his brother, the abbot, of the murder. In addition, Garb, from Maigh Eo in the kingdom of Connacht, had appeared to accuse the abbot of the murder of his wife, Gélgeis, who had been Garb’s sister. A ritual fast against the abbot had been announced. The facts of Gélgeis’s death seemed unclear. A woman had been seen in the abbey, by both Eadulf and young Redwald. Brother Redwald claimed the woman was the dead Gélgeis. And now the most ominous fact of all — Fidelma was accused of conjuring the spirits of the dead.

  Eadulf could have dismissed Brother Redwald’s tale of seeing the ghost of Gélgeis as some hysterical reaction of youth. However, he was unable to reconcile the fact that he, too, had seen a woman outside the chapel on the previous night. Both Abbot Cild and Brother Willibrod had appeared to recognise his description. It was evident that both men thought that Eadulf was describing Gélgeis, the dead wife of the abbot.

  Eadulf groaned slightly and shook his head.

  Nothing seemed to have a logic to it; nothing made sense. It was at that moment that he suddenly remembered the piece of paper he had taken from the book satchel in Brother Botulf’s chamber. He fumbled with the sacculus hanging on his belt and took the paper out, spreading it on his knee. It consisted of a few notes in Latin and Eadulf recognised the firm hand of his friend Botulf.

  The first sentence Eadulf saw was from the Book of Samuel. ‘The Lord sees not as a man sees; for man looks on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart.’

  Eadulf frowned. There seemed something familiar about this admonition and he could not recall why.

  The next line he did not recognise but Botulf had written thename Lucr
etius beside it: ‘Whenever a thing changes and quits its proper limits, this change is at once the death of that which was before.’ Then added and underscored: ‘The change is definite — how long before the death?’

  Then there followed a passage almost revealing but totally perplexing. ‘God willing, my friend will be here soon. Is it not written that mercy is the support of justice? Not so in the man of Merce. We will be destroyed by the people of the …’ Eadulf paused, trying to make out the word, which was distorted by an ink blot. It looked like ‘marshes’. He thought of Aldhere and his marshland outlaws and shivered slightly. ‘God willing, my friend will be here soon.’ It could only be a reference to Botulf’s wait for Eadulf’s arrival, and he had arrived too late to help his friend.

  The final note was also curious and again Brother Botulf had noted its provenance. ‘Can a man carry fire in his bosom, and his clothes not be burned? Or can one walk upon hot coals, and his feet not be scorched? Proverbs.’ Added was the line: ‘Thus is it with Bretta’s son.’

  Eadulf sat back frowning and trying to make sense of these notes by his dead friend. What was going on in Botulf’s mind? The only thing that made some sense was the comment about Bretta’s son. As he had learnt, Aldhere and Cild were Bretta’s sons and both certainly had ‘fire in his bosom’, but nothing else made sense. He put the paper back in his sacculus.

  He stood up thoughtfully and walked to the bed to have another look at Fidelma. There was no change. Perhaps Higbald was right. His wisest course was to leave the abbey with Fidelma as soon as she was able.

  He returned to his seat and tried to relax.

  What choice would Fidelma make in the circumstances? He knew that she would want to get to the bottom of the mystery which permeated this dark, brooding abbey. He also knew that safety must come first. It was evident that Abbot Cild had no compunction about fulfilling his threat. Rank or station did not cause him a second thought.

  Eadulf had come back to the abbey intent on going to find Garb and his men. He had learnt that the most likely place would be among a community in the forest of Tunstall which lay south of the abbey. That had been his intended goal. Perhaps that oughtto be where he should take Fidelma when she was sufficiently recovered? At least, she would be with her own kind who would protect her because of her rank and office.