Cocky: A Reverse Harem Romance

by Ashlee Price

  “Good morning Dyson. Sorry I kept you up last night. So yeah, this is pretty awkward so I am going to go.”

  She turned to David and thanked him for breakfast. Her eyes snuck a glance at the redhead and his green eyes flamed at her. She made a half-ass comment of them all getting together before she walked out of the glass doors. Forgetting that she was a mile from her house, she sighed as she started down the road. Nikki needed some time to think about the strange couple of days she was having. She also secretly reminded herself repeatedly to yell at Conrad for introducing her to someone to begin with.

  Chapter 3

  “I don’t know. He is really nice. Well they both are.”

  “They?”

  “Yeah I was introduced to one guy from Conrad, thank dad for that because I know he had something to do with it and then I met his business partner in front of Milley’s the other day.”

  “I can’t believe you are having sex with two guys at once Nikki. I knew that the city was going to change you. Are you even going to church anymore?”

  The sound on the other end of the phone sounded incredulous and Nikki smiled to herself, knowing that she would make that assumption.

  “I am not, jeez. I don’t plan to do that till I am married or at least until I find the one.”

  “Don’t you think it is about time you gave up on prince charming and find yourself a nice guy?”

  “Mom…”

  “What? I want grandbabies before I die. Is that too much to ask?”

  “Don’t you want me to find my true soul mate instead of settling?”

  “There is no such thing as only one person you can be happy with. You can be happy with lots of people, so you need to pick one before you are too old.”

  “I am 22. Not like I am growing barren. Why am I glad that arranged marriages are not legal here?”

  “Because I would have married you off long ago.”

  Nikki chuckled, yet there was a scary truth to her words. She hung up with her mother, her words still looming in her brain. Nikki needed another opinion and called her friend Carla. Carly wanted to meet at her house, so Nikki agreed. Spotting a taxi coming her way, she waved it down and gave the man an address. She sat back in the seat and could smell incense burning in the front. Right before her friend’s house came into view, Nikki got a call. She opened it when she saw who it was from.

  The name that came up was Prince Charming and she didn’t recognize the number. She had not put it into the phone, so as she answered she was not quite sure who it was. Nikki should have known it would be Dyson.

  “Hello?”

  “Hey Nikki. Good to know that the dinosaur phone of yours actually works. So do you want to go out with me and David tonight?”

  Nikki paused and told him to hold on. The cab had stopped and she dug the money out of her pocket. She thanked him and handed him the bill. Getting out she took several deep breaths before she got back on the phone.

  “Sorry about that. Um, what were you guys planning?”

  Nikki was shocked that he was calling, convinced that she wouldn’t hear from either of them from the awkward position from the week before. She had not expected that they would take her up on her offer for them all to go out. The idea of it was awkward, but she couldn’t think of a better excuse to get out of it. She liked them, but felt herself wanting to do things she shouldn’t.

  “I want to show you my favorite place.”

  “Oh? That sounds interesting and what about David?”

  “He is going to meet us there.”

  “Oh. Well, okay. I will give you a call in a while when I am back at the house.”

  “I was really hoping to see you now.”

  “It is going to be a little while. I will have to get home and change.”

  “I am sure you look great. Where are you? I will just pick you up.”

  Nikki gave him the address and by the time she got off the phone with him, she could hear a familiar sound. She looked behind her to see a helicopter touching down a little ways down the street. She saw a flash of red as a man came running towards her, ducking until he was far enough away from the moving blades.

  “Come with me.”

  “You are really just showing off now!”

  She had to yell over the sound of the aircraft. Taking his offered hand, she ran towards the machine. Strapping in and putting on some headphones, they took off towards the coast. The day was getting longer and by the time they landed, the sun was setting into brilliant colors. A boat was docked close to where they got off and she was on the deck of a rather large yacht staring at the sunset. Dyson came up behind her and she laid her head back onto his chest.

  “This view just might beat mine Dyson.”

  Instead of twinkling light from the city below, there it was only a few lights as they left the marina, but nothing but blue darkness ahead. She couldn’t help but return the soft kiss from him. David popped up almost immediately at their first contact and interrupted one of the best kisses of her life. She would have sent him off if he wasn’t just as damn gorgeous as before. He was wearing a white blazer that really set off the darkness in his tan.

  She pushed away from Dyson and looked back at David. “So do you guys want to go swimming?”

  They looked at her like she was crazy, but the boat had stopped and there was water all around them. Her water sign was coming out and it had been a while since she had swam at night. She urged them on as they looked at them incredulously. Nikki was feeling particularly feisty and soon had her hands on her shirt, prepared to pull it up. She had never done anything like that before, especially not with two men, but she figured that her bra and panties were close enough to a bikini. There was no one else around and when she pulled the shirt off, the looks on their eyes was enough.

  Dyson was the first to move, though David was not far behind and they were in the water seconds after she jumped in from the bow. Nikki did not come up for some time and she broke the surface several feet away from them. The water was cool on her skin, but did not seem to affect the heated tingling in her body. Dyson was swimming towards her and she swam away in a playful mood, yet could not deny the need for distance. The two men made her want to do things that she had never done before. The conversation with others did not help her decision to wait. Nikki was beginning to think that she did not want to wait at all. She tried to push the feelings and thoughts out of her head, but when Dyson got to her and wrapped her up in his arms, it was harder and harder to deny her feelings.

  His hands were everywhere, yet nowhere that they shouldn’t have been as he touched her. David swam to them and he pulled her face to his, before Dyson could have a kiss. There was a shiver that ran up her spine as the two men’s attention was on her. It was surreal and magical all at once and the feelings inside of her were intense, bursting to come forth. Dyson kissed and nibbled her ear as he held her up with his arms. David kissed her lips and massaged her ribs and any other place that was not rubbed up against Dyson. Nikki could hardly control her body as it moved between them with a mind of its own.

  “Since we don’t want to make you choose between us, we want to share you Nikki.”

  Nikki could not believe the words coming out of his mouth. And what was harder to understand was the way they made her feel. She had her mouth forming the word yes, but she could not bring herself to say it out loud. Her ass pushed back against the hardness wedging between her cheeks. The man growled behind her and pushed against her as his hips pulled her to him.

  “Is that a yes Nikki?”

  David was busy licking on the bobbing breasts, still covered, but by see-through fabric. She felt a pressure on the top of her core and she jumped back against Dyson. She was feeling overloaded and her breath was coming out in short gasps.

  The hand between her legs pressed harder and started to move in a mind-numbing pace that sent her over the edge. She called out loudly, her shooting essence trapped in her tight cotton panties that were pushed deep with
in her folds.

  “Yes.”

  Her whole body shook with the intense pleasure of the first orgasm she had ever had with someone else. That there had been two men there to witness it seemed more natural to her than it should have been. Being touched, teased and pawed at was better than she could have imagined. An after-shock ran through her body, pushing her back against Dyson’s muscular length.

  Chapter 4

  “You’re shivering. Are you cold?”

  Nikki was anything but cold, but she shook her head and followed the men up to the boat. They let her go first and she wondered then how transparent her panties were as she felt the heat from their gaze. She could feel someone on the ladder right behind her and she did not have to look back to know that it was Dyson. He was so close to her that she could feel the warmth emanating off of him.

  She got back on the boat and looked down at her now-clear panties and bra. Nikki covered her top with an arm that covered barely more than her turgid tips and a hand over the patch of hair in view in between her legs. She could tell that he was as turned on as she was, though his excitement stuck out a whole lot more than hers. Her eyes stared down for a moment too long and her cheeks turned red when she was caught.

  “You wouldn’t happen to have any towels so I could get warm huh?”

  He shook his head and she mumbled under her breath. The blonde man was out of the water and the two contrasted against each other. Nikki had come to find that they were utterly different, but she liked them both the same. Dyson was so straight forward and charming, while David had a smile that made her forget to breathe. They both had hot chiseled bodies and as they dripped in front of her on the deck, she could help but wonder what they looked like underneath.

  Nikki needed a few moments and she asked if they had anything to drink. Dyson was the one who went to the bar, David following to make himself a drink as well. Nikki was thankful for the few minutes it afforded her alone. She moved her hands away and looked down at her coverings. She could see the dark hair in between her legs, as well as her nipples. She blushed as she got caught uncovered, but she had to reach out to grab the drink, so the only thing that was covered was her core. The eyes on her jiggling tits, made her even more uncomfortable behind her hand. She tipped the glass up and drank the two shots in the tumbler. David came forward and grabbed her glass to refill it. The fire in the liquor burned down her body and she felt a lot more relaxed when he handed her the second one. She took another nervous sip, enjoying the fiery burn a lot more than the first time. Nikki was not sure what would happen next, but she knew that it would feel good, as anything with Dyson had to. David was just gorgeous and she still remembered the way he had fed her. It was followed with teasing and she surprised them both by making the first move.

  Dyson was shocked as he watched Nikki wrap her arms around David’s neck and push her lips to his. David was quickly pushing his tongue deep and his body molded against her. The redheaded man felt a surge of jealousy, though he knew he had agreed to it. Sharing her had not been something that he had wanted to do, but it was better than losing her all together.

  Instead of being upset and pouting like he wanted to. Instead of ripping her out of the man’s hands, his own fingertips touched her back, tracing pictures lightly down her curves. He was losing the battle for her and decided to take it to the next level, to hurry it along. Dyson went to his knees, moving her legs open with his hand and pulling her thick round ass towards him. As her hips moved and adjusted how he wanted, he was the first to ever take a taste of her. His tongue flicked out and licked her hole and clit from behind. Dyson noticed her barrier and his heart slammed into his chest.

  It became more than being the first between the two of them, but he would be first ever. The idea was almost more than he could handle and he knew then that he wanted to do more than be her first, he wanted to fill her with his seed. Dyson could imagine the beauty that would come between Nikki and himself. He tried to shake the thoughts in his head, but each lap of his mouth made him want her that much more. His hands pushed her cheeks wide as she bent into his mouth, moving against him as she kissed the blonde-haired man.

  Dyson slurped and sucked behind her until she moved her mouth away from David, crying out as another wave of pleasure ran through her. While it was Dyson causing all the pleasure, it was David that was rewarded with rubbing stimulation on his hardened cock. Her hand touched his tight boxer briefs in the front, her hand grasping his length. David made a desperate sound and thrust into her encircling hand.

  “Oh Nikki, that feels so good when you touch me like that. You hand is so soft.”

  She squeezed harder, trying to get the same high-pitched sound as before, though Dyson had her forgetting what she was doing, her hand going limp. Her eyes closed and all she could do was feel his hot mouth and hands on her. David bent to take in one of her nipples in between his teeth and she was soon shaking in between them. David pulled her closer to a chair, while Dyson was left panting with a wet face on the floor.

  David sat down on the boat seat, his weight pushing him down into the soft leather. Pulling his shorts down to his ankles, he beckoned her forward. He wanted to feel her soft lips wrap around his shaft and was more than ready when she bent down. Nikki made sure that her legs were straight and she opened her thighs slightly to give Dyson a full view and access to her heated core. While the idea of sucking such a large specimen was turning her on, the redhead’s mouth was heavenly and it was making her ache inside for something more than just his magical tongue. Nikki felt a gnawing at her center and she would have begged for it if her mouth wasn’t stuffed full of the seated man in front of her.

  David’s hands held her silken strands of long brown hair, holding her in place while his hips thrust up into her slowly. She did not seem to know what she was doing in the beginning, but she was quick to learn what he liked. David did not leave much to fate and his hips and hands guided her up and down on his length quickly. When she started to moan and push away, he thought he may lose his load too soon and pushed her back. She used it to get in several breaths of air before he pushed her back down on his gagging length. He mumbled how good it felt and yanked her tits out from her still sopping bra.

  The boat engine lurched forward and the fat cock that was positioned against her virgin quim, thrust forward as the ship swayed. While Dyson had wanted it to be gentle and loving, his eagerness and the rocking waves made that not a reality. She screamed out, even with the muffling dick and Dyson stilled, lodged inside of her and painfully squeezed by all angles. He gritted his teeth and only when David was pushing her up and down on his length, was her body slowly moving him in and out of her. He saw a flash of red when he pulled out and grabbed her hips. The streak proved what he already knew and somehow, made it that much sweeter.

  Possession rocked his body and he pulled her back against him by pulling her arms back behind her. The new position pulled her away from David and gave him leverage with his hold to slam into her fully. It also left Nikki’s mouth opened to squeal and cry out as her orgasm ripped through her body. His constant fucking brought her to several climaxes, before he finally filled her full with his hot seed. Dyson pushed deep and held her still as he pumped her womb full. It was several moments before he released her and David pulled her over to him on the couch.

  Pulling her down with his arms, Nikki’s eyes fluttered closed as another long length filled her full. She was still slightly sore from Dyson ripping her virgin flesh, but there was a pure satisfaction in being so filled to the brim. She also felt like even though he stretched her wide as she lowered down onto him, she had a little more control as she was on the top. She tested her movement several times before she had to stop with quivering legs and panting breath.

  “You are not done with me already, are you?”

  David’s voice was gruff and low. His hips started to rotate underneath her and her breath hitched in the back of her throat. Her insides clenched hard, trying to stop his move
ment, but only succeeding in driving herself mad. Her engorged clit was sensitive to the touch and his grinding was causing his pelvic to massage the intimate part of her.

  “A moment. Fuck.”

  Someone usually so full of words, Nikki was left to babbling like an idiot as his hips continued their slow ascent inside of her. He touched places in the new position that she had not felt before. While Dyson had been a tad larger, David was able to go deeper, her own weight working against her. She felt hands behind her on her back and then wrapping around to pull and twist on her sore breasts. Nikki moaned and whimpered as one thrusts and the other man toyed with her. Both ends were increasingly tender, though she would not have wanted it to stop, no matter how overwhelming it all became.

  Dyson pushed her forward from behind and she took a sharp intake of breath as David’s thick cockhead crashed against her womb. She could not have been any more stuffed, she thought. She would be wrong though and she did not know by how much until she felt more pressure at her quim. She instantly knew what it was, but her mind had her convinced that it wasn’t so.

  When Dyson grabbed a handful of her brown locks and pulled back, he added more pressure as his cock tried to push in alongside David’s. Her voice pierced the air with a loud moan, but her noise was silenced by a kiss from David. He held her down and stilled to allow the other man in. Nikki closed her eyes to the sudden widening at her opening and then deeper as Dyson pushed deep. Nikki felt ready to explode, her pussy walls trying to clench the lengths inside of her, but she found herself too full to do so.

  “Fucking hell.”

  Dyson moved out and she moved with him, pulling David’s buried cock almost to the point of coming out. She sighed a moment of relief before she was slammed back down and pierced from behind. Strong hands pulled on her hair and her mouth was met with a sloppy kiss from Dyson. She moaned into his mouth as David found himself preoccupied with her bouncing tits.