Appeal Denied: A Cliff Hardy Novel

by Peter Corris

  ‘Don’t you want to know who killed her and why?’

  ‘I don’t give a shit about why.’

  ‘Understood. Well. I have got a police source and what I’m told makes me want to look into Lily’s death as closely as I can.’

  ‘What does he tell you?’

  Townsend picked up his glass, rattled the ice and took a drink. ‘Just a minute. You’re making assumptions. Two things. I’m after a story of course, but I liked Lily. She never put me down for being a short-arse and I admired her work.

  And did I say my source was a male?’

  A smartie. I was a bit drunk and a bit annoyed. ‘Okay, okay. You liked Lily and some cop’s been blabbing to you. So what?’

  ‘We’re getting off on the wrong foot here.’

  ‘I’m a bit pissed.’

  ‘Not surprising. Why don’t we leave it till tomorrow.’

  I was about to grab him when I realised how silly it’d look. I was twenty-plus centimetres taller and would’ve outweighed him by twenty kilos. He stood his ground.

  ‘I’d rather talk now,’ I said. ‘Please.’

  Townsend glanced around to make sure there was no one within earshot. ‘As you’d expect, the police took away her computers—desktop and laptop—and two thumb drives. I’m told they were wiped clean beyond any point of data recovery. That brought the detectives to a full stop. Their only working theory was that Lily was killed because of something she was writing, or was going to write.’

  ‘That’s logical. She’d brought down some high-fliers.’

  ‘Sure, but I think there’re holes in the story. Why wouldn’t the killer just take the computer stuff? How likely is it that the person who shot her had the IT skills to clean the drives?’

  ‘An accomplice?’

  ‘Which means a witness. Remember she was shot with a .22—that’s a professional job, as you’d know. How many professional killers are happy to have some computer nerd hanging around the workplace?’

  I could see his point. And Lily’s work station was on the glassed-in balcony attached to her bedroom. She liked to be able to jump out of bed and go straight to the keyboard when an idea struck her. I knew that when she’d had the house rebuilt after a fire had destroyed the previous one, she hadn’t wanted any doors between the bedroom and the balcony. A friend had talked about feng shui and I could remember Lily’s response.

  ‘Bullshit,’ she’d said. ‘Breezes and access.’

  I told Townsend about the layout. ‘Even assuming that the computer guy came in after Lily was killed, he’d have to be working for some time in full view of her.’

  ‘I can’t see it, can you?’ Townsend said. ‘A computer whiz who’s that much of a hard case?’

  I shrugged. ‘It’s possible. They let them play with computers in jail. And they reckon some of the game players are so desensitised to violence that they could play while their mothers’ throats were being cut.’

  ‘D’you believe that, Hardy?’

  ‘No. So what do you think happened?’

  ‘I told you I have a police source. It’s all a bit vague at the moment, but my suspicion, based on the little I’ve been told, is that the police cleaned the decks.’

  4

  ‘You’ve got me confused,’ I said. ‘The police’re covering up a murder. Why?’

  ‘I told you before the why was important.’

  ‘I’m trying to follow you. Lily was killed because of something she was writing that involved police?’

  ‘Perhaps, perhaps not. It wasn’t her area, was it? More likely some dirty business deal.’

  ‘Comes back to the same question—what’s the police motive for a cover-up?’

  ‘Raises interesting possibilities, doesn’t it? Say the detective looks through Lily’s stuff and sees he can go in for some blackmail for the big bucks on the basis of what she’s written. Say he’s got gambling debts, say he’s being blackmailed himself for something else.’

  I hadn’t finished the drink and was sucking in some of the rapidly cooling fresh air. Scepticism was setting in. ‘You’re a conspiracy theorist.’

  ‘Have to be. The blank drives need explaining. The killer wants to eliminate Lily. Not worried about what she’s writing. The cop sees possibilities in what she’s writing. He doesn’t care about who killed her. What’s one unsolved murder more or less? He gets the police IT guy onside. They copy the incriminating material and cook up the story about everything being wiped. Who’s going to contradict them? Look, it’s speculation, I admit, but I really think police are involved—criminally. Of course, I could be quite wrong. I’ll have to work harder on my police informant.’

  He’d finished his drink and was standing there, all 160 centimetres of him, in his neat suit. I decided I didn’t like him much.

  ‘Tell me this,’ I said. ‘Is your main interest in who killed Lily, or in your theoretical blackmailing cop?’

  ‘And in what he had to sell, you should add.’

  Still the smartarse. ‘Consider it added.’

  ‘I’m interested in all of it, Mr Hardy, but it’s complicated and dangerous and difficult. That’s why I need your help.’

  I thought about the proposition as I stood there with the party going on noisily behind me and the boats below starting to head for home as dark clouds gathered overhead and the wind sprang up. Lily had advised Tony against building a McMansion somewhere and recommended buying this place instead. We were here because of her in two ways and I was missing her in every way. Finding who had killed her wouldn’t bring her back of course, but looking would keep me in touch with her in a way, while doing what I did best.

  ‘You’ve got my interest,’ I said.

  ‘Good. When you think about it, apart from the stuff I’ve told you, is there anything that strikes you as odd about the police behaviour to date?’

  ‘Yeah. I can account for my movements in the early part of the night but not after that. I thought they might have been a bit tougher on me.’

  ‘You had someone to alibi you? Did they question him?’

  ‘Her. A woman I play pool with at my local. I don’t know. I just assumed it.’

  ‘That’s one starting point, then. You should ask her if they got onto her and how hard they pushed.’

  ‘Okay. What other starting points are there?’

  ‘The senior investigator, Inspector Vincent Gregory.

  Your mate Parker should be able to tell you something about him.’

  ‘What about your informant of undisclosed gender?’

  ‘I’m sorry about that. Must’ve sounded like a prick. I didn’t know how much to tell you until I got your reaction. It’s a woman, Constable Jane Farrow—very junior, very concerned.’

  ‘Why’s she talking to you?’

  ‘D’you want another drink?’

  ‘No. C’mon, let’s get this straight.’

  ‘I met her at a party three weeks ago. Turns out she likes small men. Gregory is also a small man and she liked him, too. Not as much as before.’

  ‘Before you?’

  ‘Yeah, but more so since the investigation into Lily’s murder.’

  The light dropped as the clouds moved west and blocked out the weakening rays of the sun. In a way, against what I’d been feeling just before this latest titbit of information, I wanted to get clear of Townsend, the house, the city, the country if need be. Use up some frequent flier points and get as far away as … where? Norfolk Island? Lord Howe? Wouldn’t help.

  ‘Has she told you who the IT guy is?’

  ‘No, but she might.’

  ‘What happened to DS Williams? I thought he was in charge. He’s the one who talked to me initially.’

  ‘Apparently he’s out of the picture. There’s your next starting point.’

  I still didn’t like his one-upping style. He was dedicated but quite what to was hard to say. I agreed to work with him as best I could—finding out about Gregory, having a talk to Williams, while he got what he cou
ld from Constable Farrow. We exchanged numbers and agreed to stay in touch. I was sure he was holding something back but so was I. Lily had used my computer from time to time, and recently. And she’d always carried a thumb drive with her.

  I had a few words with various people as I made my way out and found Tony sitting by himself, staring at his orange juice. He was stone cold sober, so the drink was exactly what it seemed.

  ‘She was so good to me, Cliff. Always there, even when I was doing fucking stupid things.’

  ‘I know.’

  ‘I can’t believe she’s gone. It just doesn’t seem right.’

  ‘It isn’t.’

  ‘I’ve been thinking. You’re a detective, right? I’ve phoned the cops a couple of times but they don’t tell me anything. Maybe you can find out …’

  ‘I’m on it already, Tony. I’ll let you know how it goes and I know I can call on you if I need any help.’

  He nodded. ‘Yeah. You bet.’

  The party was winding down but a mob of stayers was settling in. Coffee was being served and I stopped to get some and eat two more sandwiches, thinking that after a bit of a walk I’d be okay to drive. As I was finishing the coffee a middle-aged man approached me.

  ‘Mr Hardy, I’m Patrick Henke.’

  We shook hands. ‘I seem to know the name,’ I said.

  ‘Ms Truscott’s solicitor.’

  ‘Right.’

  ‘This is a terrible thing, terrible. Such a … such a very able woman.’

  ‘Yes, well …’

  ‘She mentioned you a few times over the past couple of years as I handled some things for her. I’ll be sending you a formal letter, but since you’re here it seems appropriate to tell you now. Ms Truscott’s will divides her estate, which consists of a considerable number of very solid shares and her house in Greenwich, between her brother Anthony and yourself.’

  I walked the Hunters Hill streets for over an hour without knowing where I was or where I was going. I was stunned by what Henke had told me. It made me rethink my relationship with Lily. It had seemed to me to be equally loose and open-ended on both sides. But perhaps it wasn’t.

  I’d never given a thought to leaving anything in my will to anyone other than my daughter Megan. All it’d amount to was the Glebe house. That was worth a fair amount even in its neglected state, but I wasn’t planning to shuffle off for quite some time. Lily would have thought the same, but she’d made a different decision.

  I wondered if Henke had told Tony. Probably not, given Tony’s fragile state. I wondered how he’d take it.

  Why hadn’t she told me? Was she waiting for me to say something along the lines of putting our relationship on a different footing? It made me wish we’d talked more about ‘us’, something we almost never did, as if we were both afraid that to talk about it would spoil it. And now it was spoilt well and truly. Again, I felt guilty: I hadn’t paid proper attention to her work, and now it seemed I hadn’t paid proper attention to her feelings.

  But one thing was for sure: licence or no licence, I was going to give the investigation into who killed her everything I had.

  5

  I got home late, tired and depressed. There were a few messages on the answering machine—one from the bank about my MasterCard, a couple of condolences. Hilde Stoner had rung to apologise for Frank and her not making it to the funeral. They liked Lily a lot and had wanted to be there, but there was some kind of crisis with their son Peter, who was aid-working in Asia with his wife and their infant twin girls. Hilde and Frank were waiting on a phone call. Understandable.

  I went upstairs, looked at the computer but couldn’t find the motivation to turn it on. Not now. I opened the wardrobe in the room that doubles as a study and guest bedroom and saw some of Lily’s clothes—a couple of pairs of pants, a blouse, a dress, a jacket. Her toothbrush and a few bits of makeup were in the upstairs bathroom. There’d be a few of her books lying around. I’d be willing to bet I’d find a pair of shoes kicked under a chair. Probably some knickers and tights in the dirty clothes basket.

  I was overseas in the army fighting for freedom when my mother died. My sister told me later how disposing of her clothes and other things had broken my father up, even though they’d been at odds with each other for decades. Different in every way. It’d be the work of a few minutes for me, but I had some idea now of how he must have felt. The emptiness was making me think back further than I cared to go. Filling in the spaces. It’d been a strange household to grow up in, requiring deception and negotiation between the parents every step of the way. Perhaps it had stood me in good stead for my profession.

  I drank some wine and didn’t taste it. I had no appetite. Lily had given me a book for my birthday—1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die. I sat with it on my lap, turning over the pages, looking at the pictures. It helped: I thought about some of the films—Casablanca, The Magnificent Seven, The Third Man, Rocco and His Brothers, Chariots of Fire, Manhattan—and the images took me away from where I was and what would never happen again with Lily and what I was going to do next.

  Eventually, the tiredness became terminal, but, after the day’s events, I was afraid of dreams and disturbances. My most recent injury—of many—had been a badly sprained ankle when I’d attempted a triple jump, something at which I’d once been a good performer, on the sand at Byron Bay. Showing off for Lily. The ligaments were damaged and the ankle hurt like hell for a couple of weeks. Ian Sangster had prescribed some sleeping pills, which I’d taken for as long as I’d needed to. Now I found a few left over in their foil in the bathroom cupboard and took one with a light scotch and soda. I tidied up a bit, erased the phone messages, put the movie book on the shelves and made it up the stairs to bed. Just.

  Hilde rang in the morning to say that the crisis for Peter and his family in Bangladesh was over.

  ‘Good news,’ I said.

  ‘How are you making out, Cliff?’

  ‘I’m okay. I need to speak to Frank. Is he around?’

  Frank came on the line. I said, ‘What can you tell me about Vincent Gregory?’

  ‘What do you need to know and why?’

  ‘I’m looking into Lily’s murder.’

  ‘You’ve got no standing, mate.’

  ‘You think I care about that? Anyway, I’m working with someone who has got standing.’

  That was stretching it, but at least it got past Frank’s first objection. He was silent for a while. Once a cop, always a cop. Frank hadn’t exactly been squeaky clean for the whole of his time in the force. Back in the seventies it was almost impossible to avoid a bit of this and a bit of that. Do a Nelson. Turn a blind eye, go with the flow, set a thief to catch a thief. Frank had never taken a dollar and he despised those who did, but there was still that thing called the police culture. In the past, Frank had given me information about ex-cops, some of whom had gravitated to my profession, but Gregory was a serving officer and Frank knew what pressures that implied.

  ‘You’d better tell me what you’ve got and maybe I can contribute something.’

  ‘I’ll have to think about that. Thanks. I’ll get back to you.’

  ‘Hey, Cliff—come on …’

  ‘Listen. Lily left me half of what she’s worth. That’s a lot and I never gave a thought to doing the same. I feel ratshit about that on top of everything else, and I reckon the police investigation’s a dud. I don’t give a flying fuck about Inspector Gregory’s reputation or his future or the New South Wales Police Service in general. Why should I? They scrubbed me for doing my job. I’ll find out some other way.’

  I hung up on my best friend.

  I had to get out of the house. I drove to the Redgum gym in Leichhardt and threw myself into a workout routine much more severe than usual—double sets on the machines, longer on the treadmill. I worked up a sweat and stuck at the free weights until I reached ‘fail’—when you can’t do another lift—something I usually avoid like the plague. Wesley Scott, the West Indian proprietor and
trainer, gave me a massage. Deep tissue. Hurt like hell.

  ‘You’re strung tight, man,’ he said. ‘What’s troubling you?’

  I told him with as few details as possible.

  ‘That’s tough. So you think putting yourself through this kinda pain is going to help?’

  ‘I’ll tell you something, Wes,’ I said as I rolled off the table. ‘I’m going to put some bugger through pain, no mistake.’

  I showered and went home, denying myself the usual after-workout coffee in the Bar Napoli a few doors away. The activity had done me good. I went straight to the computer and began to look for Lily’s files. I didn’t find any current ones, just a couple of incomplete drafts of stories already published.

  Lily could be secretive about her work, one of the reasons I never questioned her too closely. Had she been more so lately? I couldn’t remember. I got up and opened the wardrobe, thinking I’d better do something about the clothes. St Vincent de Paul seemed the best bet—Lily hadn’t gone in for Donna Karan power dressing. I took out the hanger holding the jacket and prepared to drop it over the back of the typing chair while I reached in for the next hanger. Something fell out of the jacket pocket—a packet of cigarettes. Like me, Lily had given up smoking years before. I hung the jacket back up, retrieved the packet from the floor and opened it. Hard pack. Twenty-three king size filter cigarettes. Two missing. Had she taken to the fags on the q.t.? I doubted it. But then I didn’t know she’d put me in her will.

  The packet felt funny. I’d lapsed myself once or twice and had also bought them often enough for informants to know what they felt like, even though my own preference had been for rollies. I took the packet to the desk and shook it. Twenty-three cigarettes about two-thirds of their true length came out, then a layer of foil. Wedged in the bottom of the packet was a thumb drive.

  Lily’s files were a chaos of notes, interview transcripts, downloaded material and draft paragraphs. How she honed them into the clear, insightful stories she produced was a mystery. The stuff bore her unmistakable imprint— frequent swearwords, wry asides and capitals for emphasis, the way she’d written in notes left for me and in her emails and postcards. I made a pot of coffee and sat down to work out what she’d been doing. One thing was clear: she’d kept a running record of the dates of the writing and research in reference to the deadlines she entered at the top of the files. This was all very recent work.