When the People Fell

by Cordwainer Smith

  In the first ten seconds of the turnaround, twenty-seven soldiers, two nurses, three patients, and one orderly were killed. One hundred and nine other people were wounded in that first exchange of fire.

  The troop commander had never seen battle, but he had been well trained. He immediately deployed his reserves around the external exits of the building and sent his favorite squad, commanded by a Sergeant Lansdale whom he trusted well, down into the basement, so that it could rise vertically from the basement into the women's quarters and find out who the enemy was.

  As yet, he had no idea that it was his own leading troops turning and fighting their comrades.

  He testified later, at the trial, that he personally had no sensations of eerie interference with his own mind. He merely knew that his men had unexpectedly come upon armed resistance from antagonists—identity unknown!—who had weapons identical with theirs. Since the Lord Crudelta had brought them along in case there might be a fight with unspecified antagonists, he felt right in assuming that a Lord of the Instrumentality knew what he was doing. This was the enemy, all right.

  In less than a minute, the two sides had balanced out. The line of fire had moved right into his own force. The lead men, some of whom were wounded, simply turned around and began defending themselves against the men immediately behind them. It was as though an invisible line, moving rapidly, had parted the two sections of the military force.

  The oily black smoke of dissolving bodies began to glut the ventilators.

  Patients were screaming, doctors cursing, robots stamping around, and nurses trying to call each other.

  The war ended when the troop commander saw Sergeant Lansdale, whom he himself had sent upstairs, leading a charge out of the women's quarters—directly at his own commander!

  The officer kept his head.

  He dropped to the floor and rolled sidewise as the air chittered at him, the emanations of Lansdale's wirepoint killing all the tiny bacteria in the air. On his helmet phone he pushed the manual controls to top volume and to noncoms only and he commanded, with a sudden flash of brilliant mother-wit:

  "Good job, Lansdale!"

  Lansdale's voice came back as weak as if it had been off-planet. "We'll keep them out of this section yet, sir!"

  The troop commander called back very loudly but calmly, not letting on that he thought his sergeant was psychotic, "Easy now. Hold on. I'll be with you."

  He changed to the other channel and said to his nearby men, "Cease fire. Take cover and wait."

  A wild scream came to him from the phones.

  It was Lansdale. "Sir! Sir! I'm fighting you, sir. I just caught on. It's getting me again. Watch out."

  The buzz and burr of the weapons suddenly stopped.

  The wild human uproar of the hospital continued.

  A tall doctor, with the insignia of high seniority, came gently to the troop commander and said, "You can stand up and take your soldiers out now, young fellow. The fight was a mistake."

  "I'm not under your orders," snapped the young officer. "I'm under the Lord Crudelta. He requisitioned this force from the Manhome Government. Who are you?"

  "You may salute me, captain," said the doctor. "I am Colonel General Vomact of the Earth Medical Reserve. But you had better not wait for the Lord Crudelta."

  "But where is he?"

  "In my bed," said Vomact.

  "Your bed?" cried the young officer in complete amazement.

  "In bed. Doped to the teeth. I fixed him up. He was excited. Take your men out. We'll treat the wounded on the lawn. You can see the dead in the refrigerators downstairs in a few minutes, except for the ones that went smoky from direct hits."

  "But the fight? . . ."

  "A mistake, young man, or else—"

  "Or else what?" shouted the young officer, horrified at the utter mess of his own combat experience.

  "Or else a weapon no man has ever seen before. Your troops fought each other. Your command was intercepted."

  "I could see that," snapped the officer, "as soon as I saw Lansdale coming at me."

  "But do you know what took him over?" said Vomact gently, while taking the officer by the arm and beginning to lead him out of the hospital. The captain went willingly, not noticing where he was going, so eagerly did he watch for the other man's words.

  "I think I know," said Vomact. "Another man's dreams. Dreams which have learned how to turn themselves into electricity or plastic or stone. Or anything else. Dreams coming to us out of space-three."

  The young officer nodded dumbly. This was too much. "Space-three?" he murmured. It was like being told that the really alien invaders, whom men had been expecting for fourteen thousand years and had never met, were waiting for him on the grass. Until now Space3 had been a mathematical idea, a romancer's daydream, but not a fact.

  The Sir and Doctor Vomact did not even ask the young officer. He brushed the young man gently at the nape of the neck and shot him through with tranquilizer. Vomact then led him out to the grass. The young captain stood alone and whistled happily at the stars in the sky. Behind him, his sergeants and corporals were sorting out the survivors and getting treatment for the wounded.

  The Two Minutes' War was over.

  Rambo had stopped dreaming that his Elizabeth was in danger. He had recognized, even in his deep sick sleep, that the tramping in the corridor was the movement of armed men. His mind had set up defenses to protect Elizabeth. He took over command of the forward troops and set them to stopping the main body. The powers which Space3 had worked into him made this easy for him to do, even though he did not know that he was doing it.

  IX

  "How many dead?" said Vomact to Grosbeck and Timofeyev.

  "About two hundred."

  "And how many irrecoverable dead?"

  "The ones that got turned into smoke. A dozen, maybe fourteen. The other dead can be fixed up, but most of them will have to get new personality prints."

  "Do you know what happened?" asked Vomact.

  "No, Sir and Doctor," they both chorused.

  "I do. I think I do. No, I know I do. It's the wildest story in the history of man. Our patient did it—Rambo. He took over the troops and set them against each other. That Lord of the Instrumentality who came charging in—Crudelta. I've known him for a long long time. He's behind this case. He thought that troops would help, not sensing that troops would invite attack upon themselves. And there is something else."

  "Yes?" they said, in unison.

  "Rambo's woman—the one he's looking for. She must be here."

  "Why?" said Timofeyev.

  "Because he's here."

  "You're assuming that he came here because of his own will, Sir and Doctor."

  Vomact smiled the wise crafty smile of his family; it was almost a trademark of the Vomact house.

  "I am assuming all the things which I cannot otherwise prove.

  "First, I assume that he came here naked out of space itself, driven by some kind of force which we cannot even guess.

  "Second, I assume he came here because he wanted something. A woman named Elizabeth, who must already be here. In a moment we can go inventory all our Elizabeths.

  "Third, I assume that the Lord Crudelta knew something about it. He has led troops into the building. He began raving when he saw me. I know hysterical fatigue, as do you, my brothers, so I condamined him for a night's sleep.

  "Fourth, let's leave our man alone. There'll be hearings and trials enough, Space knows, when all these events get scrambled out."

  Vomact was right.

  He usually was.

  Trials did follow.

  It was lucky that Old Earth no longer permitted newspapers or television news. The population would have been frothed up to riot and terror if they had ever found out what happened at the Old Main Hospital just to the west of Meeya Meefla.

  X

  Twenty-one days later, Vomact, Timofeyev, and Grosbeck were summoned to the trial of the Lord Crudelta. A full panel of s
even Lords of the Instrumentality was there to give Crudelta an ample hearing and, if required, a sudden death. The doctors were present both as doctors for Elizabeth and Rambo and as witnesses for the Investigating Lord.

  Elizabeth, fresh up from being dead, was as beautiful as a newborn baby in exquisite, adult feminine form. Rambo could not take his eyes off her, but a look of bewilderment went over his face every time she gave him a friendly, calm, remote little smile. (She had been told that she was his girl, and she was prepared to believe it, but she had no memory of him or of anything else more than sixty hours back, when speech had been reinstalled in her mind; and he, for his part, was still thick of speech and subject to strains which the doctors could not quite figure out.)

  The Investigating Lord was a man named Starmount.

  He asked the panel to rise.

  They did so.

  He faced the Lord Crudelta with great solemnity. "You are obliged, my Lord Crudelta, to speak quickly and clearly to this court."

  "Yes, my Lord," he answered.

  "We have the summary power."

  "You have the summary power. I recognize it."

  "You will tell the truth or else you will lie."

  "I shall tell the truth or I will lie."

  "You may lie, if you wish, about matters of fact and opinion, but you will in no case lie about human relationships. If you do lie, nevertheless, you will ask that your name be entered in the Roster of Dishonor."

  "I understand the panel and the rights of this panel. I will lie if I wish—though I don't think I will need to do so"—and here Crudelta flashed a weary intelligent smile at all of them—"but I will not lie about matters of relationship. If I do, I will ask for dishonor."

  "You have yourself been well trained as a Lord of the Instrumentality?"

  "I have been so trained and I love the Instrumentality well. In fact, I am myself the Instrumentality, as are you, and as are the honorable Lords beside you. I shall behave well, for as long as I live this afternoon."

  "Do you credit him, my Lords?" asked Starmount.

  The members of the panel nodded their mitred heads. They had dressed ceremonially for the occasion.

  "Do you have a relationship to the woman Elizabeth?"

  The members of the trial panel caught their breath as they saw Crudelta turn white. "My Lords!" he cried, and answered no further.

  "It is the custom," said Starmount firmly, "that you answer promptly or that you die."

  The Lord Crudelta got control of himself. "I am answering. I did not know who she was, except for the fact that Rambo loved her. I sent her to Earth from Earth Four, where I then was. Then I told Rambo that she had been murdered and hung desperately at the edge of death, wanting only his help to return to the green fields of life."

  Said Starmount, "Was that the truth?"

  "My Lord and Lords, it was a lie."

  "Why did you tell it?"

  "To induce rage in Rambo and to give him an overriding reason for wanting to come to Earth faster than any man has ever come before."

  "A-a-ah! A-a-ah!" Two wild cries came from Rambo, more like the call of an animal than like the sound of a man.

  Vomact looked at his patient, felt himself beginning to growl with a deep internal rage. Rambo's powers, generated in the depths of Space3, had begun to operate again. Vomact made a sign. The robot behind Rambo had been coded to keep Rambo calm. Though the robot had been enameled to look like a white gleaming hospital orderly, he was actually a police-robot of high powers, built up with an electronic cortex based on the frozen midbrain of an old wolf. (A wolf was a rare animal, something like a dog.) The robot touched Rambo, who dropped off to sleep. Doctor Vomact felt the anger in his own mind fade away. He lifted his hand gently; the robot caught the signal and stopped applying the narcoleptic radiation. Rambo slept normally; Elizabeth looked worriedly at the man who she had been told was her own.

  The Lords turned back from the glances at Rambo.

  Said Starmount, icily, "And why did you do that?"

  "Because I wanted him to travel through space-three."

  "Why?"

  "To show it could be done."

  "And do you, my Lord Crudelta, affirm that this man has in fact traveled through space-three?"

  "I do."

  "Are you lying?"

  "I have the right to lie, but I have no wish to do so. In the name of the Instrumentality itself, I tell you that this is the truth."

  The panel members gasped. Now there was no way out. Either the Lord Crudelta was telling the truth, which meant that all former times had come to an end and that a new age had begun for all the kinds of mankind, or else he was lying in the face of the most powerful form of affirmation which any of them knew.

  Even Starmount himself took a different tone. His teasing, restless, intelligent voice took on a new timbre of kindness.

  "You do therefore assert that this man has come back from outside our galaxy with nothing more than his own natural skin to cover him? No instruments? No power?"

  "I did not say that," said Crudelta. "Other people have begun to pretend I used such words. I tell you, my Lords, that I planoformed for twelve consecutive Earth days and nights. Some of you may remember where Outpost Baiter Gator is. Well, I had a good Go-Captain, and he took me four long jumps beyond there, out into intergalactic space. I left this man there. When I reached Earth, he had been here twelve days, more or less. I have assumed, therefore, that his trip was more or less instantaneous. I was on my way back to Baiter Gator, counting by Earth time, when the doctor here found this man on the grass outside the hospital."

  Vomact raised his hand. The Lord Starmount gave him the right to speak. "My Sirs and Lords, we did not find this man on the grass. The robots did, and made a record. But even the robots did not see or photograph his arrival."

  "We know that," said Starmount angrily, "and we know that we have been told that nothing came to Earth by any means whatever, in that particular quarter hour. Go on, my Lord Crudelta. What relation are you to Rambo?"

  "He is my victim."

  "Explain yourself!"

  "I computered him out. I asked the machines where I would be most apt to find a man with a tremendous lot of rage in him, and was informed that on Earth Four the rage level had been left high because that particular planet had a considerable need for explorers and adventurers, in whom rage was a strong survival trait. When I got to Earth Four, I commanded the authorities to find out which border cases had exceeded the limits of allowable rage. They gave me four men. One was much too large. Two were old. This man was the only candidate for my experiment. I chose him."

  "What did you tell him?"

  "Tell him? I told him his sweetheart was dead or dying."

  "No, no," said Starmount. "Not at the moment of crisis. What did you tell him to make him cooperate in the first place?"

  "I told him," said the Lord Crudelta evenly, "that I was myself a Lord of the Instrumentality and that I would kill him myself if he did not obey, and obey promptly."

  "And under what custom or law did you act?"

  "Reserved material," said the Lord Crudelta promptly. "There are telepaths here who are not a part of the Instrumentality. I beg leave to defer until we have a shielded place."

  Several members of the panel nodded and Starmount agreed with them. He changed the line of questioning.

  "You forced this man, therefore, to do something which he did not wish to do?"

  "That is right," said the Lord Crudelta.

  "Why didn't you go yourself, if it is that dangerous?"

  "My Lords and Honorables, it was the nature of the experiment that the experimenter himself should not be expended in the first try. Artyr Rambo has indeed traveled through space-three. I shall follow him myself, in due course." (How the Lord Crudelta did do so is another tale, told about another time.) "If I had gone and if I had been lost, that would have been the end of the space-three trials. At least for our time."

  "Tell us the exact
circumstances under which you last saw Artyr Rambo before you met after the battle in the Old Main Hospital."

  "We had put him in a rocket of the most ancient style. We also wrote writing on the outside of it, just the way the Ancients did when they first ventured into space. Ah, that was a beautiful piece of engineering and archeology! We copied everything right down to the correct models of fifteen thousand years ago, when the Paroskii and Murkins were racing each other into space. The rocket was white, with a red and white gantry beside it. The letters IOM were on the rocket, not that the words mattered. The rocket has gone into nowhere, but the passenger sits here. It rose on a stool of fire. The stool became a column. Then the landing field disappeared."

  "And the landing field," said Starmount quietly, "what was that?"

  "A modified planoform ship. We have had ships go milky in space because they faded molecule by molecule. We have had others disappear utterly. The engineers had changed this around. We took out all the machinery needed for circumnavigation, for survival, or for comfort. The landing field was to last three or four seconds, no more. Instead, we put in fourteen planoform devices, all operating in tandem, so that the ship would do what other ships do when they planoform—namely, drop one of our familiar dimensions and pick up a new dimension from some unknown category of space—but do it with such force as to get out of what people call space-two and move over into space-three."

  "And space-three, what did you expect of that?"

  "I thought that it was universal and instantaneous, in relation to our universe. That everything was equally distant from everything else. That Rambo, wanting to see his girl again, would move in a thousandth of a second from the empty space beyond Outpost Baiter Gator into the hospital where she was."

  "And, my Lord Crudelta, what made you think so?"

  "A hunch, my Lord, for which you are welcome to kill me."

  Starmount turned to the panel. "I suspect, my Lords, that you are more likely to doom him to long life, great responsibility, immense rewards, and the fatigue of being his own difficult and complicated self."