And She Was

by Alison Gaylin

  ALISON GAYLIN

  and she was

  A NOVEL OF SUSPENSE

  Dedication

  For my beloved dad Bob Sloane

  and favorite aunt Myrna Lebov,

  alive forever in my heart—and memory.

  Contents

  Dedication

  Acknowledgments

  Prologue

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  Chapter 27

  Chapter 28

  Chapter 29

  Chapter 30

  Chapter 31

  Chapter 32

  Epilogue

  Author’s Note

  An Excerpt from And She Was sequel

  About the Author

  By Alison Gaylin

  Copyright

  About the Publisher

  Acknowledgments

  Many thanks to my wonderful agent Deborah Schneider, as well as everyone at HarperCollins—especially the great Lyssa Keusch and Wendy Lee.

  For their law enforcement/investigation expertise—and patience with stupid questions—Lee Lofland, Gisele Fraseur, City Island expert Marcelle Harrison, Joel Ludlow, Carol Gray, and Sergeant Josh Moulin, Commander of the Southern Oregon High Tech Crimes Task Force.

  For their support, writing advice, and all-around awesomeness throughout all phases of this book—Abigail Thomas, Karen E. Olson, Jeff Shelby, Lori Armstrong, Megan Abbott, Jason Starr, Paul Leone, Claudette Covey, Bar Scott, Rik Fairlie, Ann Patty, Austin Metz, James Conrad, artist/manga expert Hali Barthel . . . plus anyone not mentioned who should be. You know who you are. This is the one and only time I wish I had Brenna’s memory.

  Finally, thanks goes out to my dear mom Beverly Sloane, first-rate in-laws Sheldon and Marilyn Gaylin—and, most of all, Marissa and Mike. I love you guys.

  Prologue

  September 20, 2009

  Carol Wentz’s life now had a “before” and an “after.” She’d never thought of it that way, but the passage of time brings perspective, and ten years later, Carol could see it—the moment before she made the Neff girl disappear and the moment after.

  A clear, clean mark.

  For forty-one years, Carol’s life had moved from day to day with no real marks at all—no children, a marriage that Carol had eased into gradually, with a whimper of a city hall wedding that took place on a Wednesday at lunch hour and for health insurance reasons, after she and Nelson had been living together for almost a decade. She supposed she could track time before and after Nelson—her single years versus her conjoined ones—but the truth was, before Nelson wasn’t really all that different from after Nelson, each day stretching out and ending with Carol still the same old Carol—the Carol she’d been in grade school, reedy and knock-kneed and mostly alone.

  But then Labor Day, 1998, happened and everything was different. Carol was different. Well, she supposed she’d always been different—she’d just never known it before. How would she have described herself in book club? An unlikable character. Too weak and petty. I don’t believe her motivations. The girl was only six, after all . . .

  Carol didn’t like to think about it, the actual day. But there was a long list of things that Carol didn’t like to do—cooking the turkey for her church’s Thanksgiving dinner, feeding her neighbors’ cats when they were out of town, jump-starting their cars or picking their kids up from school on a moment’s notice—yet she did all those things anyway, and without complaint. Carol didn’t used to be like that. Before she made the Neff girl go, she did her part for others by staying out of their way. But now she was a helper, a go-to gal, and everyone on her block—even Nelson—treated her as if this was nothing new. As if it had always been a defining quality of Carol’s, when really, it was just part of her penance. A symptom of “after.”

  The day, the important part of it, began with the Neff girl approaching Carol at Theresa and Mark Koppelson’s barbecue. Carol had been alone. The last she’d seen of Nelson, he’d been speaking to the girl’s mother, Lydia, who was helping out with the cooking. “You look incredible,” he had said. Incredible, as if Nelson hadn’t seen Lydia Neff in years and she was wearing something other than jeans and an apron smeared with barbecue sauce.

  Nelson and Lydia hadn’t noticed Carol, and so she’d been able to step away and feign searching for the bathroom—another one of those times when she felt so intensely awkward, as if someone were holding a giant magnifying glass to her body, amplifying every gesture.

  Carol had just pushed through the kitchen door when she felt the tap on her leg. She stopped, and saw Lydia Neff’s daughter, whose first name was Iris, staring up at her with those eyes, her mother’s black eyes, slick and hard and knowing. Carol’s jaw tensed up. Her scalp tingled. She thought of that word again. Incredible.

  “What do you want, Iris?”

  “Juice box.” No “please,” but she hadn’t been rude. Actually, Iris Neff had said it meekly, if Carol’s memory was to be trusted. And so Carol had made for the red ice chest that Theresa Koppelson had placed next to her refrigerator. The sign on it read “Drinks for Kids.” Carol had lifted the lid and gazed at the bright little boxes littering the cans of Sprite and orange soda like confetti, all of them bearing pictures of happy cartoon fruit. Carol wasn’t familiar with the brand. Of course, she wasn’t a mother and hardly ever entertained memories of her own childhood, and so they all confused her, these youth-aimed products. Why did children need to drink juice from a box, anyway? What was the appeal of fruit with eyes?

  She’d yanked one of the boxes out of the cooler—green, with a smiling, bucktoothed apple on the label.

  “Here you go,” she said, handing it to Iris.

  The girl scrunched up her face.

  “What?”

  “This is apple juice,” Iris said. “I like orange pineapple.”

  Carol’s gaze moved from the girl’s face to the kitchen door, the small window affording a view of Lydia Neff’s shiny black hair and Nelson, leaning in close, as if to hear her better . . .

  “Orange pineapple,” Iris said again.

  “I am not your mother. Get it yourself.”

  The black eyes widened.

  Carol’s skin heated up. Her voice hung in the air like an odor. What am I? she thought. What am I turning into? For some reason, this made her angry with Iris, which, in turn, shamed her even more. “I’m . . . I . . . I’ll get the juice for you.”

  But by the time she’d gone back to the ice chest and pulled out a new juice box—this one with a winking pineapple in a baseball cap and a doll-faced female orange—the little girl was gone.

  Carol stared at the stack of papers in her hand—another symptom of “after,” but this one more painful. Carol had built a fire—her first fire of the fall—and she nearly threw the papers in, just for the pleasure of watching them turn to black dust. It would have been better than reading them, that was for sure. Why read nothing? In five years of searching for a girl that wouldn’t be found, she’d at least learned that much.

  Carol could never burn the papers, though. And so she moved over to the closet near the bookshelves—Carol’s crafts closet as far
as Nelson was concerned—and slid out the small black trunk she kept under her knitting bags. She threw back the lid and removed the layer of bright fabric scraps and squares sewn together in festive clusters, removed the spools of thread and pattern books and the wooden needle box (all remnants of the quilting phase she’d gone through fifteen years ago). Then she removed the piece of cardboard she’d cut to fit the floor of the box, and she placed the stack of papers in. Placed it in without reading it, on top of all the other stacks of papers she never should have read, repositioned the cardboard, and arranged everything back on top until it was her quilting supply box again.

  These new papers had come from Mr. Klavel—a ferrety man with a basement office in neighboring Mount Temple, a large, sweaty forehead, and breath so foul that it almost felt intentional. Mr. Klavel, latest in a line of cheap private investigators Carol had hired in secret, and possibly the least sensitive man she’d ever met. The fruits of my search, he had said as he handed Carol the ten-year-old police files, the photocopy of Iris’s first grade class picture, and phone call transcripts and addresses of known pedophiles living within a twenty-mile radius of Carol’s home in Tarry Ridge, New York, a decade ago. All rotten. Carol still couldn’t believe he’d said that.

  After Carol had gotten the trunk closed and everything back in the closet, she stood staring at the door, Mr. Klavel’s words still ringing in her head.

  “You built a fire?” Nelson said.

  Carol jumped. Nelson had a way of sneaking up on her. It wasn’t that he had any interest in spying on his wife. Nelson rarely even asked her questions and when he did, it seemed more out of habit than curiosity. It was simply the way Nelson moved—as if he didn’t want to disturb the carpet by putting too much weight on it.

  Still, Carol felt a tinge of worry. How long have you been here? she almost asked. What did you see? But then she noticed the look on his face, that same bland acceptance he always wore, and it was enough to calm her. “I was cold.” Carol put her back to her husband and moved toward the window . . .

  After the Koppelsons’ barbecue, the setting sun had poured through this window, made it glow gold like something out of a dream. If she concentrated, Carol could still feel that otherworldly glow from eleven years ago, she could still hear Nelson’s feet hurrying up the stairs, fleeing for his computer as he always did, as he still did to this day whenever they came home, rushing to stare into a screen.

  Incredible. Had Nelson called Carol that, ever, once? In the before or in the after?

  If Carol closed her eyes tight, she could travel back to the before—to the very last moments of it, with the setting, glowing sun and the breeze through the open living room window and herself, moving to close it. She could look through that window and she could see the two little girls crossing the street, walking hand in hand. Two children alone at sunset, the taller one’s hair shining black like her mother’s . . .

  Carol squeezed her eyes shut. “Go away,” she told the memory.

  “What?” Nelson said.

  She swallowed hard. Her mouth was very dry. “Nothing.”

  For days, weeks, months after Iris’s disappearance, Carol had waited, her heart dropping whenever the phone rang.

  But no call came, and Carol was able to keep her secret, keep it for months and then years as the search parties thinned and Lydia Neff grew quiet and heavy, the fire dimming in her black eyes, her hair graying until she was a faded copy of herself, until she aroused nothing but pity and even Nelson couldn’t look her in the eye. Two years ago—three years after the police had officially closed the case—Lydia had left town. For where, nobody knew.

  You got what you wanted, said the mean little voice in Carol’s head. No Iris. No Lydia. You made it happen, and you will never be able to set it right.

  “I’m going up to bed,” Nelson said.

  Carol squeezed her eyes tight. “Okay. I think I’ll read for a little while.”

  No answer. Nelson was already upstairs. Carol picked up the book she’d been reading for her group—a memoir called Safekeeping. She opened it to the page she’d marked and let her eyes run over the words as she listened to the rush of water in the upstairs bathroom, the groan of the pipes, the hum of Nelson’s electric toothbrush . . . As adept as she’d grown at keeping secrets, Carol was still a terrible liar and somehow, going through the motions of what she claimed to be doing made it feel closer to the truth.

  Finally, the bathroom noises stopped. Carol heard the light squeak of the floor in the upstairs hallway, the bedroom door brushing the carpet, and finally the creak of the bed as Nelson slipped in. Carol closed the book. She crept up the stairs and paused there, waiting for Nelson’s breathing to slow, waiting for sleep. Only then did she walk into Nelson’s office, turn on the computer he thought she didn’t know how to work; only then did she go online and call up her chat room and sign on. Families of the Missing, New York State, the chat room was called and now, just two months after she’d found it, they felt like Carol’s family, her only family. There were eight of them in the room tonight, and when Carol typed in her greeting, it was as if they’d all been waiting for her. Welcome, they typed, and Carol imagined them shouting it in unison. Welcome, Lydia!

  Carol fell asleep in front of the computer. Only for about ten minutes, but it scared her. What if it had been more than ten minutes? What if the sun had risen and Nelson’s alarm had gone off and he’d woken up in an empty bed and walked across the hall to find his wife at his computer, asleep at the keyboard he never knew she could use, remnants from last night’s chat scrolling up the screen?

  Don’t give up the fight, Lydia. We’re here for you.

  Lydia, you’re the strongest person I know.

  Lydia, I found my daughter after twelve years. You can find your daughter, too.

  How would she ever explain that?

  Carol shuddered. She said a quick Night to her friends and signed off, standing up before she could drift again.

  AlbanyMarie had mentioned the name of a private investigator specializing in missing persons cases—Brenna Spector, who had an office in New York City. Marie’s husband had been missing for five years, presumed dead in a small plane crash, and Brenna Spector had just found him. In Vegas of all places, Marie had typed. If all goes as planned, I’ll see him in a few days!

  Without thinking, Carol had typed, Are you happy about that?

  After LIMatt61 had typed, Wouldn’t you be happy, Lydia, if your husband was found alive? Carol had sat there for what had to be a full minute, her fingers hovering over the keys. Finally, she’d come up with this:

  Brenna Spector. That name sounds familiar.

  Carol winced. Had that sounded strange? Cold? Oh well. Can’t take it back. She shut down Nelson’s computer and switched off the lights.

  Gazing into the bathroom mirror as she applied moisturizer to her face, Carol realized that she did, in fact, know the name Brenna Spector. She wasn’t sure from where, but she did.

  In the middle of the night it came to Carol, jolting her out of a dream in which she was chasing a tiny, scared puppy through a computer screen, the two of them running wildly between lanes of typed words . . .

  Brenna Spector. It was from one of her book club books, a nonfiction account by a psychiatrist (Lieberman? Leo-pold?) about children with special mental abilities. The case studies had all been from the seventies and eighties and one was a teenage girl named Brenna Spector. Could it have been the same . . .

  Carol heard an electronic trill, and she realized it wasn’t the name recognition that had woken her up at all, but the ringing phone at her bedside. She looked at the clock: 3 A.M.

  Carol’s breath caught. Nelson was sound asleep as she picked up the phone, and she was aware of the contrast. Her husband’s deep, easy breathing and her own pounding heart. “Hello?”

  She heard nothing, just static. A cell phone maybe. “Hello? Is anyone—”

  The reply was barely audible—a push of air with no voice behin
d it. Words she couldn’t distinguish, one with an “el” sound. It could have been “hello” or “hell” or “cell” . . . It could have been “help.”

  Carol’s chest tightened. “Who is this?”

  Beneath the static, more whispered words—still all breath, but clearer now. Carol could hear what was being said.

  There was a click on the other end of the line, and for several seconds after the phone disconnected, she sat there frozen, the receiver in her hand, unable to hang it up or stop the tingling in her skin or the rush of blood to her ears.

  “You’re not my mom,” the caller had said. “You’re not my mom, Carol.”

  Chapter 1

  “Are you ready, Brenna?” Dr. Lieberman says.

  “Yeah.”

  Dr. Lieberman presses play and record on the tape recorder that sits on the far left edge of his desk. Lots of tape recorders in this office, Brenna thinks. It’s June 29, 1985. This is her forty-sixth trip to this psychiatrist, and each time she comes here, the tape recorders seem to multiply.

  There are three small, battery-operated ones in his top desk drawer, and then there’s the reel-to-reel on the wall behind the desk, next to the black-and-white photo of Bob Dylan in a cowboy hat—an original Elliott Landy, according to Brenna’s mother (whoever Elliott Landy is supposed to be. And then there is the plug-in on the desk with the big silver microphone attached that Dr. Lieberman uses to record all of Brenna’s sessions. Such a weird feeling that recorder gives her. Like Lieberman is Friday from Dragnet, and she’s some hippie he’s interrogating. (Brenna likes reruns.)

  “Your name,” says Dr. Lieberman.

  Brenna shifts in her chair. The air-conditioner is up full blast, but it’s a hot day outside, and she’s wearing her aqua Dolphin shorts. When she moves, the leather sticks to the back of her bare legs and then releases, making an embarrassing snapping sound. She’s sweating. Who wouldn’t be, when he’s about to . . . Well, Mom calls it “important research,” but Brenna prefers “screwing with my brain.”