A Private War

by Brenner, Marie

  Jewell was annoyed that press descriptions of him always emphasized his “overzealousness”; he considers himself a man of details. Often, when he’s watching movies at home, he freeze-frames in order to study props in scenes. The second weekend he was considered a suspect, he told me, “I walked in and I noticed white powder all over the telephone table in the conference room.” It was a Saturday morning, and Jewell had been with his lawyers until late the night before. He told me he was convinced that the FBI “had lifted a ceiling tile,” and that the white powder was “dust that came down.” Bryant and Jewell made light of it and did not sweep their phones, believing that any tap the FBI would use would be of a laser or satellite variety and impossible to trace. “In the beginning of every conversation, Watson would curse for about a minute and tell them what lowlifes they were. And then he would say, ‘By the way, this is Richard’s lawyer. Y’all can cut your tape players off,’ ” Jewell said. “I would call them dirty scumbags,” said Bryant. But the local U.S. attorney, Kent Alexander, insisted that their phones were not tapped. “There are no wiretap warrants,” he said.

  The FBI did turn up one bit of potentially troublesome evidence in the Jewells’ apartment—fragments of a fence that had been blown up in the explosion. After a telephone conversation with Watson Bryant, Kathy Scruggs quoted him saying, “Yes, he did have a sample of the blown-up bomb.” Bryant accused her of egregiously misquoting him. He remembered saying to her, “Yes, Richard had souvenirs of the bombing.” Scruggs had not taped their conversation. “She cut the ‘ing’ off of ‘bomb,’ ” Bryant later told me, but Scruggs strongly denies this. The day the story broke, Bryant criticized Scruggs on local radio. That afternoon she appeared at his office to attempt to clear up the misunderstanding. “I don’t like your reporting,” Bryant recalled telling her. “I’m human, too,” she said. The next day, Ron Martz inserted a quote from Bryant in an unrelated news story: “Oh, man, it’s not even a scrap of the bomb—it’s a piece of damned fence, for God’s sake.” But the quote would have little impact. Scruggs’s version had been picked up; gathering force, it was eventually related by Bill Press on Crossfire on the evening of October 28: “The guy was seen with a homemade bomb at his home a few days before.” (The next day CNN would be forced to apologize for the mistake.)

  By this time Bryant had grown enraged by the media coverage. The New York Post had called Jewell “a Village Rambo” and “a fat, failed former sheriff’s deputy.” Jay Leno had said that Jewell “had a scary resemblance to the guy who whacked Nancy Kerrigan,” and asked, “What is it about the Olympic Games that brings out big fat stupid guys?” The AJC’s star columnist, Dave Kindred, had compared Jewell to serial murderer Wayne Williams: “Like this one, that suspect was drawn to the blue lights and sirens of police work. Like this one, he became famous in the aftermath of murder.”

  Television journalism was also a revelation to Bryant; he felt he had “landed on Mars,” and spent hours channel-surfing. On CNN, one criminologist said “it was possible” that Jewell had a hero complex. Bryant told his brother, Bruce, “I know I am going to sue someone. I just don’t know who.” Bruce Bryant searched for Jewell’s name on the Internet three weeks into his ordeal and found ten thousand stories. The tone many of the journalists took was accusatory and predetermined, with a few rare exceptions, such as that of CBS correspondent Jim Stewart. “Don’t jump to any conclusion yet,” he said sharply in a broadcast at the height of the frenzy.

  In his first week as Jewell’s lawyer, Bryant went to the CNN studio to be interviewed by Larry King. After the broadcast, he was asked to stop in at the office of CNN president Tom Johnson. “They wanted to know what I thought of their reporting so far.” Art Harris was in the room. “I turned around and I said to Art Harris, ‘Who the hell are you and the rest of the media to make fun of how Richard Jewell and his mother live? Who are you to make fun of working people who live in a $470-a-month apartment? Is there something wrong with that? Who are you to say that he is a weirdo because he lives with his mother?’ ”

  * * *

  According to Jack Martin, the FBI spent weeks on one erroneous early theory—that Richard Jewell was an enraged homosexual cop-hater who had been aided in the bombing by his lover. Jewell had purportedly planted the bomb; the lover then made the 911 phone call warning that it would go off in Centennial Park. The rationale behind this idea was that Jewell was “mad at the cops and wanted to kill other cops,” Martin told me.

  The rumor began at Piedmont College, perhaps invented by several of the students Jewell had turned in for smoking pot, but it had a chilling consequence. In mid-August, three agents appeared at the Curtis Mathes video store in Cornelia, where Chris Simmons, a senior at Piedmont, worked part-time. Simmons, a friend of Jewell’s, who was engaged to be married, was a B student, but he displayed the same porcine blankness as Jewell and spoke in a slow drawl. He had a deep distrust of the government and carried a card in his pocket that read: Christopher Dwayne Simmons—campaign support for conservative candidates.

  The agents questioned Simmons in the store for one and a half hours. “They asked me if I was a homosexual. They asked me if I had accessed the Internet. . . . They later wanted to wire me. They said, ‘If he is really a hero, we will find out, and if not, he has killed someone and injured a lot of people.’ ” Simmons was short with the agents and denied everything. They accused him of lying and said they could take him to Atlanta. The agents told someone Simmons had once worked with that Simmons might be involved in the bombing. “They kept wording questions differently. They kept saying: Do you think Richard Jewell could have done this if he believed that he could get people out in time and nobody would get hurt?” Simmons later called one of the FBI agents and said, “I hear you don’t believe my story.” He recalled their conversation: “ ‘I think you are sugarcoating your answers,’ he said. I said, ‘Next time I talk with you, it will be with a lawyer.’ And he asked me if I was threatening him. Then he hung up on me.” Ultimately, Simmons volunteered to take a polygraph, which he says he passed. “I was a nervous wreck,” he said. “I had only seen this on TV.”

  What was not known outside a small circle of investigators was how deadly the Centennial Park bomb really was. It was well constructed, with a piece of metal shaped like a V, and inside, it had canisters filled with nails and screws. Jack Martin, who had spent time in Vietnam, compared its construction to that of a claymore mine, a sophisticated and lethal device. The bomb weighed more than forty pounds. It was “a shaped charge,” FBI deputy director Weldon Kennedy would announce in December. It could blast out fragments from three separate canisters, but only one of the canisters exploded on July 27. Someone had moved the Alice pack slightly before the bomb detonated, causing most of the shrapnel to shoot into the sky. The composition of the bomb did not suggest the work of an amateur, Kathy Scruggs would ironically later report, after interviewing an ATF chemist.

  * * *

  As the weeks went by, Richard Jewell withdrew into a state of psychological limbo; he began to try to analyze what the agents might think of his behavior within the small apartment. “I would be watching a spy show on TV or something like a John Wayne movie. Someone would be talking about blowing something up, and I would think to myself, My God, that is going to sound really bad if they think I am listening to that.” He worried that “they would think I was some kind of a nut,” and often, when he could not sleep, he would find himself consciously switching to exercise videos and soap operas.

  Over Labor Day weekend, he drove up to Habersham County for a picnic with his ex-girlfriend’s family, the Chastains. As usual, three FBI cars followed him, but he had gotten adept at picking out the unmarked vehicles. As Jewell drove into town, he noticed that white ribbons hung from hundreds of trees; the Chastains had organized a campaign in his behalf. On the way home, Jewell drove with his friend Dave Dutchess. For the first time, he did not see an FBI car following him, but he noticed an airplane flying low overh
ead. He drove another twenty miles, and the plane was still on him. “I said, ‘Dave, do you think the FBI would be following us in an airplane? It wouldn’t be that hard to do, if they put some kind of beeper on the car.’ ” The plane followed them through Gainesville all the way to Atlanta—an hour’s drive. “Just to make sure, we got off on an exit ramp and went about five miles back north. And I got out and took a picture. They followed us all the way back to the apartment! And they circled the apartment for about fifteen minutes, until the FBI car showed back up. I got very emotional. My cheeks got beet red. And Mom came home and said, ‘What is going on? What is the matter?’ It just destroyed the whole day.”

  * * *

  On September 2, Dave Dutchess and his fiancée, Beatty, were driving to their house in Tennessee. It was raining hard, and they noticed they were being followed by several FBI cars. The storm grew worse, and they stopped at a hotel for the night. The next day, while getting coffee at a McDonald’s, they were surrounded by FBI agents. “We just want to talk to you. We are trying to be discreet.” One agent, Dutchess recalled, spoke into his radio: “We have the suspect in hand.” As they walked back toward their car, Dutchess said to Beatty, “They think I am his accomplice. I heard on the news they were looking for his accomplice!”

  After the interview, which lasted several hours, Dutchess spoke to Watson Bryant. “What did they ask you that concerns you?” Bryant asked him. “Well, I decided that I had to tell them the truth. Me and one of my friends used to set off pipe bombs for fun,” Dutchess told him. “What?” Bryant exclaimed, incredulous. “Yeah, I told them we liked to throw pipe bombs down gopher holes when we lived out in West Virginia.”

  “Did Richard know this friend?” Bryant asked apprehensively. “Hell, no. He never met him,” Dutchess said, but Bryant knew that this could prolong the FBI’s investigation perhaps by months. “I hung up and I was thinking, I cannot believe that I even know anyone who throws pipe bombs into gopher holes.”

  * * *

  As part of their strategy, Wood and Grant decided to mount a strong counterattack against the government. Wayne Grant had come up with the idea: Bobi Jewell should hold a press conference during the Democratic convention and make a direct plea to Bill Clinton. The day before she was to appear, Grant rehearsed her. It was difficult to work with Bobi; she was exhausted and could not stop crying. Confined under siege for almost a month, she could not see an end to it, since every day brought a new humiliation. The resident manager had threatened to take away their lease, and the manager’s son was out selling pictures he took of them. A close friend from church was dying, Bobi said, and Richard could not go to see him, because of the swarm of FBI agents and reporters who followed him everywhere. All of it came out in a rush in the conference room with Wayne Grant: Bobi had even had to give Bryant and Nadya Light the Olympic basketball tickets she had won as colleague of the year, and every night she and her son were stuck together, staring at each other across the kitchen table. They were often irritable, and Richard sometimes lost his temper. “Mother, just shut up,” he would tell her when she nagged him about the case. Then, Bobi later recalled, she would go into her bedroom and lie on the four-poster bed hoping that the photographers who rented an apartment across the way for $1,000 a day had no way of knowing what was going on.

  Grant kept careful notes on the session. Bobi was terrified about appearing in front of cameras. She sobbed and told him, “If I go on TV Monday, I’ll be embarrassed. It will be, like, whenever I go anywhere, people will be looking at me: ‘Did he do it or didn’t he do it?’ ”

  “If you talked to the person who is in charge of the investigation, what would you say?” Grant asked her calmly. Bobi’s voice was halting, but she was firm: “He is innocent. Clear his name and let us get back to a life that is normal.”

  A few weeks later, Wayne Grant went to a party for a Bar Mitzvah, and a guest cornered him. She asked him if he had told Bobi Jewell to cry at the end of her press conference, and then added coldly, “Nice touch.”

  * * *

  The lawyers’ strategy worked: After Bobi’s press conference, the Jewells were deluged with interview requests. Bryant often received one hundred phone calls a day. Bobi soon developed a system: Letters from Oprah Winfrey, Sally Jessy Raphael, and TV producers were stacked on the console in the living room; flowers and baskets of Godiva chocolates and cheese and crackers from the networks were sent to the offices of Wood & Grant and then on to a children’s hospital.

  * * *

  At the U.S. Attorney’s Office, it had become increasingly clear to Kent Alexander that something had to be done about Richard Jewell. Janet Reno had seen Bobi Jewell on TV and was moved by her sincerity. Privately, Reno and Deputy Attorney General Jamie Gorelick were said to be concerned about the heavy-handed tactics of the FBI. “The case had become a total embarrassment,” a Justice Department official told me, but Alexander was in a complicated situation. He was working closely with the FBI, and there was no sign that the bureau was ready to let go, despite growing consternation among the local agents that the Washington command center had mishandled the case. And there was another problem: Alexander did not trust Lin Wood.

  By late September, there was a tremendous strain within the team Bryant had hastily assembled. The other lawyers accused Jack Martin of cutting private deals with his friend Kent Alexander, pulling focus, and not being tough enough. For his part, Alexander, according to Martin, admired Bryant even though he believed he was a loose cannon, but he was fed up with Lin Wood.

  “Alexander would say something fairly candid to me, and I would report it to the attorneys, and the next day he would see it on TV,” said Jack Martin. “Alexander had checked out Lin, and he knew that he was a take-no-prisoners guy.” The lawyers often argued among themselves. Wood insisted on a full-blowout press-attack strategy. Bryant had mastered his sound bite: “The FBI is a five-hundred-pound gorilla who will kick the shit out of anyone.” Martin wanted the lawyers to ease up on the hyperbole: “I would say, ‘We do not need to do this.’ And Lin would say, ‘Let’s go public with this.’ He was manic about it.” In one argument, Wood told him, “Goddamn it, Martin, you’re like my ex-wives. There isn’t anything you can say I won’t object to.”

  * * *

  There was an atmosphere of extreme apprehension between Bryant and Jewell as they drove to FBI headquarters on the afternoon of October 6. They were on their way to what would seemingly be a session with conclusional overtones, but Jewell was worried: What if this meeting was a trick? It was difficult to believe that the bureau was really ending its two-month-long investigation into his life. For weeks, Jack Martin and Bryant had been going back and forth with Kent Alexander. Finally, Jewell had agreed to an unusual suggestion: If he submitted to a lengthy voluntary interview with the bureau, and if Division 5 was satisfied, then perhaps the Justice Department could issue a letter publicly stating that he was no longer a suspect. Jewell tried to imagine the questions he would be asked. “I wanted to look at everything from their angle,” he told me, “trying to assess it and reassess it in my head.”

  Kent Alexander had set a firm ground rule: Only one lawyer representing Jewell could be in the room. It had been agreed that Jack Martin, the criminal specialist, would be the man, which enraged Lin Wood. “You could really see how these guys did not like each other,” Jewell said.

  “I am not comfortable with the one-lawyer agreement,” Wood told John Davis, Kent Alexander’s second in command, when they were assembled. “We have an agreement. If you attempt to renegotiate it, I will have egg on my face,” Davis said, adding, “You are not a man of your word.” With that, Wood recalled, he rose from his chair and started screaming, “You are not going to say that to me, you son of a bitch!” Kent Alexander interrupted, saying, “This is deteriorating. We aim to stop this. Let’s just regroup.”

  When Jewell, Davis, and Martin finally sat down for the interview, Larry Landers, a special agent with the GBI, and FBI special
agent Bill Lewis had lists of questions with blank space for answers in front of them. On the wall of the windowless room, there were extensive aerial photographs of the park and, as a prop, an actual park bench was later brought in. Martin believed that the agents intended to resolve areas in the affidavits and other questions: Had Richard ever accessed Candyman’s Candyland for information on the Anarchists’ Cookbook? Had Richard picked up any pieces of pipe when the park was under construction? Had he told anyone, “Take my picture now, because I am going to be famous”? None of this had happened, Jewell said. All he could remember telling someone was that he was off to Atlanta and “going to be in that mess down there,” meaning the traffic jams. They pressed him about seemingly inconsistent statements he had made on the morning of the bombing: Why had he told Agent Poor everything was normal when he checked the perimeter of the fence? Jewell explained that he had been walking the “inside of the fence.” He once again explained that he had wanted to work the sound-and-light tower so that he could watch the entertainment; he had arranged for his mother to hear Kenny Rogers four days before the explosion.

  The area, he told Landers, was “a sweet site” and a great place to look at girls. During a break, Martin asked about all his references to women. Jewell said he wanted them to know he wasn’t gay. On several occasions, Landers became annoyed: Why couldn’t Jewell pin down the times? Had he seen the drunks on the bench between 10:30 and 11:00 or between 11:00 and 11:30? Why hadn’t he looked at his watch? Jewell later recalled, “I said, ‘I don’t go through my life looking at my watch. I don’t care about time. When the bomb went off, I did not look at my watch.’ They were wanting to know what time I went to the bathroom and stuff like that. When you have the runs, you are not really concerned about what time it is. You are concerned with getting to the bathroom.”