Filthy Appeal

by Ramona Gray

  Theo leaned forward and pressed a kiss against my mouth. “Understood, love. Come back to the bed.”

  We returned to the bed. Seth cupped one breast and toyed with my nipple as Theo sat on the bed before reclining on his back. I was shaking my head before the words were out of his mouth.

  “I’m not riding you,” I snapped. I could hear the anxiety and shame in my voice.

  Seth rubbed my lower back as Theo said, “I don’t want you to ride me, love. I want you to sit on my face.”

  My jaw dropped and I pulled away from Seth. “You what?”

  “I want to taste my kitten’s sweet cunt,” Theo said.

  “No.”

  “It’ll be fine, Libby,” Seth said. He tried to guide me closer to the bed and I tore away from him. Adrenaline was rushing through my veins and Theo sat up and gave me a look of concern.

  “Love, it’s okay.”

  “It’s not,” I said. “I’m-I’m yellow right now and if you try and make me do this, I’ll be red. Do you understand? It all stops, and I won’t come back to your place.”

  “We understand,” Seth said immediately.

  “We’ll do a different position,” Theo said. “It’s okay, love.”

  I stared wide-eyed at them before whispering, “I’m sorry.”

  “Don’t be,” Theo said. He crossed to me and took me into his embrace, pressing kisses against my face and my mouth. “Don’t ever apologize for telling us exactly how you feel. That’s why we have a safe word, right?”

  “Right,” I said shakily.

  “Do you want to stop, sweetheart?” Seth had joined us and he gave me a solemn look.

  “No,” I said. “No, I don’t want to stop.”

  Theo and Seth glanced at each other and I shook my head. “I’m good now. Just – I don’t want to sit on your face.”

  “Okay,” Theo said before giving me another gentle kiss.

  He led me back to the bed and I didn’t protest when he and Seth had me sit at the head of the bed with my back leaning against the headboard, my knees bent and my feet resting on the bed. There was added pressure on the plug and I shifted a bit as Theo pushed my thighs apart before stretching out between them. He kissed the patch of curls on my pussy as Seth kneeled next to me. One hard hand was stroking his cock and I stared at the bead of pre-cum at the tip of it before leaning down and licking it away.

  “Fuck!” Seth muttered. He cupped the back of my head and I sucked at his cock with enthusiasm as Theo licked my inner thighs. I moaned around Seth’s cock when Theo kissed the wet lips of my pussy. When his tongue wandered over my clit, I arched my hips and clutched at his head as I stared up at Seth.

  He gathered up my hair and pulled roughly on it. “Suck harder, Libby.”

  I tried to concentrate on Seth’s dick, but Theo’s tongue was goddamn magic. It didn’t take long before I was moaning and thrusting my hips against Theo’s face. I pulled Theo’s hair with one hand and stroked the base of Seth’s cock with the other as he pushed his dick in and out of my mouth.

  I was already close to a second orgasm. When Theo reached under me and wiggled the plug in my ass, my climax was hot and immediate and lasted incredibly long. Wave after wave of intense pleasure flooded my lower body. My scream was muffled by Seth’s cock and he shoved it in deep as I writhed against Theo’s tongue and lips.

  Seth pulled out and I gasped in some much-needed oxygen as I pushed at Theo’s head. I was shaking all over and was so weak I slumped against the headboard. I barely noticed when Theo sat up and rolled a condom onto his dick before lying on his back next to me.

  Seth was urging me to my knees and I pouted and whined, “Tired, Sir.”

  “I know, sweetheart. Theo’s going to fuck you and then you can sleep.”

  I smiled at the thought of being fucked as Seth pulled on my right thigh. “Come on, sweetheart. Leg over Theo, now.”

  Feeling almost drunk from my unbelievable orgasm, I did what he asked. It wasn’t until I was straddling Theo, my knees pressed against his hips as Seth pulled my arms behind my back and held them firmly, that I realized what was happening.

  Theo was beginning to press his dick against my opening and I froze as fresh adrenaline pumped through my veins.

  “I can’t be on top!” I shouted like an idiot. “Stop, wait, I’m going to hurt…oh fuck!”

  Seth had pushed me down, impaling me on Theo’s thick cock. I moaned and wiggled and tried to ignore how good it felt to have my pussy filled to the brim with dick.

  “Stop,” I whispered unconvincingly. “Theo, I’m too heavy.”

  “You’re not,” he rasped as he reached up and cupped my tits. He pulled hard on the nipples and I arched my back. “Baby, your soft curves feel like heaven. I need you to fuck me right now before I go insane.”

  “Are you sure?” I whispered as Seth tightened his hold on my arms.

  “Fuck, yes,” Theo groaned. “Seth, let her go.”

  He released my arms and Theo tugged me down until I was bent over him with my hands resting on the bed above his shoulders. He kissed my upper chest and I rubbed my nipples against his chest as his hands cupped my tender ass. He thrust in and out and I moaned with pleasure before bouncing enthusiastically on his dick.

  “Fuck,” he muttered again, “the plug makes her even tighter.”

  “Libby, look at me.”

  I turned my head and automatically opened my mouth for Seth’s cock. He was kneeling next to my head again and I sucked on his cock as Theo fucked me hard. His rhythm was rough and out-of-control and I cried out when one of his hands pushed on the plug in my ass and the other rubbed furiously at my clit.

  Seth held tightly to my hair, guiding my mouth back and forth over his dick as Theo made another hoarse groan. “Fuck, I’m not going to… I can’t…”

  His body arched beneath mine and he pinched my clit hard. It should have hurt, and it did, but the pain brought on a third and completely unexpected orgasm. I forgot completely about hurting Theo and ground my pelvis against his as he grabbed my hips and came deep inside of me. Seth pulled me away from his cock and into a sitting position with a hard tug to my collar. He pumped his dick with his hand and came with a loud roar of pleasure, his cum splattering all over my breasts.

  Panting harshly, Theo helped me ease off of him. I fell to the bed on my side, my entire body quivering and pulsing. Theo disposed of the condom as Seth used a towel to wipe my chest clean. I kept my eyes closed and moaned happily when both men slid into the bed on either side of me. Seth was at my back and I jerked when he touched the plug still in my ass.

  “Take it out,” I whispered.

  “No, sweetheart,” he said.

  “Please, Sir?” I asked.

  “No,” Seth repeated.

  I must have been pouting because Theo made a low chuckle before pressing a kiss against my mouth. “The longer you wear it, the sooner you can take Seth’s dick in your ass.”

  “But it’s getting late and I should go home.”

  “No,” Seth said. “You’re spending the night with us, Libby.”

  I should have argued. I should have gotten up, taken the plug out of my damn ass, dressed and driven home. Instead, I snuggled in closer to their hard bodies and sighed with pleasure when Theo cupped my breast and Seth kissed my back.

  “Sleep now, Libby.”

  “Yes, Sir,” I murmured.

  Chapter Six

  “Libby?” Mario knocked on my office door. “Why are you still here? The office closes at five thirty, or did we forget to tell you that?”

  He grinned good-naturedly at me and I laughed. “I wanted to finish up a few things.”

  “Ah, well since you’re still here, can I take a few minutes of your time?”

  “Of course,” I said as I leaned back in my chair. “What’s up?”

  “Did anyone go over the Christmas office schedule with you?” He asked as he sat in the chair across from my desk.

  “Sandra sent me the emai
l,” I replied. “I told her I would be more than happy to be the partner at the office between Christmas and New Year’s.”

  “She mentioned that,” Mario said. “But I talked to Jeff and Emmett and we’ve made the decision to close the office completely.”

  “Oh,” I said.

  “We’ll have a couple of the support staff come in for a few hours each day between the 27th and the 2nd, and Jim has offered to be on call if anything should come up.”

  “As the newest associate partner, shouldn’t I be the one to get the ‘work during the holidays’ job instead of Jim?” I asked with a small smile.

  Mario laughed. “We don’t want to scare you into quitting your first month.”

  “I don’t mind working,” I said. I didn’t. I hadn’t been here long enough to make any friends so the prospect of having a week off with nothing to do wasn’t exactly appealing.

  Maybe you could spend it with Seth and Theo.

  I ignored my inner voice. Seth and Theo would have holiday plans with their families. I wasn’t asking them to spend Christmas with me. That was ridiculous. Christmas was Tuesday and after this weekend I wouldn’t even be seeing them outside of work anymore.

  “Libby?”

  “Sorry, what was that?” I apologized.

  “I asked if you were going home for the holidays?”

  “No, which is why I can work.”

  “We’re going to keep you busy enough after the holidays,” Mario said with a laugh. “Enjoy your free time while you still have it. Sandra has sent out the email to our clients with our holiday office hours. I asked her to add Etco Drilling Ltd. to the email so that Charles knows.

  “Perfect, thanks,” I said. Not that it mattered. Charles had my personal cell number and wouldn’t hesitate to call it if he couldn’t get a hold of me at the office.

  “You bet.” Mario glanced at his watch. “It’s almost seven now. You should get out of here.”

  “I’m about to head home,” I lied.

  “Good. See you tomorrow.”

  “Bye, Mario.”

  He walked out of my office and I packed up my laptop and shut off the lights to my office before heading to the elevator. I was going to Seth and Theo’s place for sex, butt stretching and if I was lucky, multiple orgasms.

  I shivered all over as I walked to my car. My ass was sore, more from being spanked than the plug, not to mention my thighs ached. Hell, all of my muscles ached but it wasn’t stopping me from going back to them. Fucking two men I worked with was a mind-numbingly stupid idea, but I was addicted to what they did and said to me.

  What happens when they blackmail you over this? When they demand better pay and bigger clients or they’ll tell the other partners what you let them do to you?

  I ignored my inner voice. They wouldn’t blackmail me. I didn’t know them very well and maybe it was stupid to go with my gut on this one, but I knew instinctively that blackmailing me or using this brief affair to get them ahead at the office wasn’t their style. Trying to convince me to keep fucking them though, was an entirely different story.

  I climbed into my car and threw my purse on the seat beside me. The thought of allowing Seth and Theo to convince me to keep going with our affair was intoxicating. What if I liked fucking both of them at once? It hardly seemed fair to try it and then never get to do it again.

  I started my car. One, I couldn’t keep fucking them and two, I was being presumptuous. Just because Seth and Theo were willing to help me live my fantasy of fucking two men at once, didn’t mean they were willing to keep going once we actually fucked.

  You got that right. You’re too fat to keep them interested. You know that, don’t you, Libby? In fact, I’m pretty sure they’re throwing you a pity fuck. Men who look like them are not chubby chasers.

  My stomach rolled with nausea and I forced deep breaths of cold air into my lungs. They weren’t throwing me a pity fuck. They thought I was gorgeous and sexy and they loved my curves. Just because inner me had suddenly turned into a stone-cold bitch who apparently reveled in making me feel bad, it didn’t mean I had to listen to her. They didn’t believe I was fat. Hell, Theo had even let me ride him and he was fine afterwards.

  Are you sure? You didn’t see him get up and move around, did you? He was still in bed when you left this morning. You didn’t even see him at the office today. Maybe he didn’t come in. Maybe he’s at the hospital getting those crushed ribs checked out. You didn’t even think about your goddamn weight, did you? You rode him like the world’s fattest cowgirl and he had a prime viewing of every single part of you that jiggles. Of your fat rolls and the way your tits sag. I bet you crushed his need for you and his ribs in one single –

  “Shut up!” I snapped out loud. “They still want me. Would they have asked me to come over tonight if they didn’t?”

  My inner self had nothing to say to that. I tried to will my nausea away. I had planned on stopping and grabbing a bite to eat but the nausea had driven away my appetite. Instead, I drove directly toward Seth and Theo’s house. It was fine. Everything was fine. Theo and Seth wanted me. They thought I was beautiful. They wanted me, and I was going to let them have me.

  * * *

  “Libby,” Seth smiled at me when I stuck my head into the kitchen. I had used the key he gave me this morning to let myself into the back door after parking a street over and walking down the alley. “How are you?”

  “Good,” I said. He took my jacket and disappeared down the front hallway. When he returned, he pressed a warm kiss against my mouth and squeezed my ass. I winced and a wicked little grin crossed his face. “Sore bottom?”

  “Yes,” I replied.

  “I guess you’d better be a good girl tonight then,” Seth said with another wicked smile.

  “Sure,” I said absently. I yelped when Seth gave me a hard slap to the ass.

  “Misbehaving already,” he said.

  “I’m not!”

  “You are. You’re distracted and unfocused which means you’re thinking about work. You don’t think about work when you’re here, sweetheart.”

  “I’m not thinking about work,” I protested.

  “No?” Seth raised his eyebrows. “Then what are you thinking about?”

  I worried my bottom lip with my teeth. “Where’s Theo?”

  “He had an errand to run,” Seth said. “He’ll be back soon.”

  “Is he, I mean, does he feel okay?” I asked.

  Seth gave me a puzzled look. “What do you mean?”

  Oh God, he was going to make me say it. My cheeks burning, I said, “Is he sore or, ah, injured?”

  “Why would he be injured?” Seth was looking at me like I had grown two heads, but I was positive he was being deliberately obtuse. Anger flared in me and I scowled at him.

  “Because I’m heavy and you two assholes made me ride him last night!” My nausea grew and I felt frantic and angry and out of control. I shouted foolishly, “I told you I didn’t want to be on top and now Theo probably has crushed ribs and you’re being too polite to tell me!”

  I yelped again when Seth turned me and pushed me over the island. He held me down with one hand in the middle of my back as his other hand shoved up my skirt. I was wearing thick tights and he yanked them down to my knees, dragging my underwear down with them.

  Without saying a word, he spanked my already-sore ass with heavy slaps. It burned like fire and I immediately began to cry and plead for him to stop. He ignored me, and I slumped across the table as his rough hand kept up a steady rhythm of spanks.

  Within minutes, my anger and fear had left and despite how much it hurt, a weird kind of peace consumed me. I pressed my hot cheek against the cool marble as I accepted the spanking. I floated happily in the bubble, still feeling the stinging pain of each of Seth’s spanks but the pain was tinged with sweetness and pleasure.

  I hadn’t realized it but all day long I’d been stressed and overwhelmed. My desire to do well at my new job and prove I was worthy of par
tnership, my fear that I had hurt Theo, even my hard-to-shake belief that Seth and Theo weren’t actually attracted to me had weighed on me. But for the first time, I wasn’t worried about proving myself at my job, or stressed about my looks or even feeling shame for possibly hurting Theo. I couldn’t be. Right or wrong, Seth’s firm discipline of my outburst had sent me to my happy place and I felt…free.

  “Spanking already?”

  I was only vaguely aware of Theo’s deep voice, but I whined a little when Seth stopped spanking me and ran his hand over my ass.

  “She was being disrespectful and raising her voice,” Seth said.

  “Why?” Theo asked.

  “She has this silly idea that she hurt you when you were fucking her last night.” Seth’s voice was dark with disapproval, but I didn’t notice. I was still floating.

  “Are you kidding me?” Theo forced me to straighten up from the table. He smelled like snow and pine trees and I inhaled deeply as he studied me. “Christ, is she in subspace?”

  “She can’t be,” Seth said as he turned me to face him. “She can’t possibly trust us enough yet to…”

  He trailed off and I smiled dreamily at him.

  “Sweetheart, you okay?”

  “Yes, Sir,” I said. “Can I please come now?”

  My peaceful, dreamy state was already starting to subside, and I caught the look between Theo and Seth. “What?”

  “Nothing, love,” Theo said. “Come to the bedroom.”

  He peeled off my tights and underwear as Seth pulled my skirt down over my ass. Theo took my hand and I followed him to his bedroom. I wanted to stay in that dreamy floating state forever but by the time I was standing in front of his bed, it was gone completely. The frustration was almost overwhelming, and I blinked back the hot tears. What the hell was wrong with me? I would not cry in front of Seth and Theo. I was their goddamn boss and I wouldn’t fucking cry in front of them.

  Are you kidding me? You let them put a collar around your neck and a plug up your ass. You call them both Sir and suck their dicks until your jaw aches, but you won’t cry in front of them?