Undeniable - Book One: The Oregon Trail Series

by Laura Stapleton

  “You hid your disgust really well. Thank you for that.”

  “Thank you for bathing at last.” She wrapped her arms around him, leaning against him. “I’m glad Mr. Granville insisted you accompany him. I like having you as a friend.”

  The action comforted Nick, and her soft admission made him feel like mashed potatoes inside. Eloquent speeches escaped him, and all he could say was, “I feel the same.”

  He enjoyed the feeling of contentment within him, having done without it for far too long. They rode on with her arms around him for the rest of the morning and into the afternoon. Around midday, he asked, “Do we need to stop?”

  “I’d like to stretch my legs and maybe have some privacy,” Beth said as if just awakened.

  “We can do that.” He directed Buck closer to some scrub brush, pulled the reins to stop, and held out his hand for her. When both of them were on the ground he added, “If you need to, I’ll keep my back turned.”

  “Thank you,” she murmured. “We could have the biscuits and maybe a drink of water?”

  “I’ll have them ready by the time you’ve returned.” He watched as she nodded and laughed when she made a turnaround gesture to him. He obliged and found their luncheon, even breaking out the preserves in case she’d ask. Beth returned and they ate without talking. After a final drink, they both returned to the trail. He rather wished she’d put her arms around him again. Nick also wanted to hear more of her life on the farm. A few abortive attempts to start a conversation later, he decided to wait until her mood improved. Her sweet, quiet, but short answers let him know her feelings.

  The sun inched ever closer to the horizon. When the light dipped behind the mountains, he had to admit they’d not find water this evening. “I hate to say this, but tomorrow is our best bet for refilling the canteen.”

  “I was wondering if we’d ever reach a spring of some sort.” She patted his shoulder. “There’s still water left and if we reach a creek by tomorrow noon, we should be fine, right?”

  “We should. We’ll rejoin the Platte River tomorrow.” He looked back at her, stopping the horse at a dry gulch. “Would you mind sharing with Buck? Not much, but some?”

  “Of course we’ll share.” She took his offered hand and dismounted. “There’s not a lot of anything for him to eat either, so he’ll need the moisture.”

  Nick smiled at her consideration for his animal. “I’m sure he’d appreciate that.” He began the now familiar ritual of bunking down for the night and she helped. With nothing liquid to spare, he didn’t bother with a fire. “How about you and I share what’s left of the bread, and tomorrow, when we stop for noon we’ll have a big meal.”

  Beth shrugged, hands on her hips. “I don’t see how we have much of a choice.”

  He didn’t want her feeling trapped. “There’s always a choice. We could cut across to the Platte. It would take an extra few days….”

  “No, I can make do until tomorrow, certainly.” She took the jam and biscuit he offered. She ate in a hurry and took a quick drink before holding the water out to him. “Too bad you didn’t bring whisky.”

  The idea amused him and he retorted, “A big enough bottle and as thirsty as we are, who knows where we’d be?” Her grin felt like a reward to him. He accepted the canteen from her and drank. A quarter remained, and while he loathed using all of it right now, Buck needed water as well. He let the horse drink straight from his palm so little was wasted.

  “I’m rather tired,” said Beth. “May we just sleep after I have a little privacy, first?”

  “Sure,” he stopped himself short of calling her sweetheart. “It’s late, we’re tired and hungry. I don’t mind getting a head start toward tomorrow.” He watched for a moment as she walked up the ravine. Wanting to respect her wishes, he focused on getting ready for the night. Nick unsaddled Buck and staked him out to a tall sagebrush. He got into bed, struggling to stay awake until Beth returned. Only after she settled in could he sleep.

  The next day began cold. Neither wanted to wake, or at least Nick didn’t, but the lure of food and water motivated him. He shook Beth, saying, “Rise and shine, dearest. We get to gallop for our supper today.”

  “Ummm,” she groaned, turning to face away from him. “I’m tired.”

  “I know, and probably hungry too. The sooner we get started the sooner we’re finished.” He patted her on the arm, resisting the urge to kiss her awake. “There’s some critter out there needing to wear our cook pot for lunch.” He heard her stomach growl and chuckled.

  Beth sat up, giving him a sleepy smile. “I suppose there’s no denying that.”

  “Can you be ready in a few minutes?” Seeing her nod, he continued, “All right, I’ll get Buck saddled up and we’ll get going.”

  She nodded again before packing their beds. They kept to the new routine, except without refreshment, and continued on for sixteen miles or so. Tired and hungry, neither said much. He kept an eye out for anything to hunt, seeing eagles at times, but not much else. As they drew closer to water, he’d hoped to see something substantial for maybe lunch and dinner. The green haze of vegetation in the distance gave him hope.

  He felt Beth lean against his back, falling asleep. Nick smiled at her touch. After an hour or so, he spotted a herd of pronghorn grazing. He waited until the last possible moment to rouse her, not wanting to scare her with shooting an animal. “Beth, sweetheart? It’s time to wake.”

  “Hm?” She lifted her head. “Oh! I drifted off. Please excuse me. I didn’t mean to use you as a pillow.”

  “I didn’t mind at all.” He looked back at her. “I might get a chance to hunt and didn’t want to scare you.”

  She stared past him at the foothills. “Are those deer?”

  “Of a sort. More like pronghorn antelope. See the antlers?” He faced the front. “Smaller than deer.”

  “How do they taste?”

  “Good. Not as good as bison but better than deer, I think.”

  “Should I be ready for a gunshot the closer we get?”

  “Yes, and so should Buck. He knows what to expect when I pull my rifle. Nick stayed quiet as they approached the herd. Some of the animals started, looking at them. The more wary eased away while others went back to grazing. Nick kept an eye out for a healthy male. He slid the rife into position against his right shoulder. A perfect animal stood off at a slight distance, unconcerned about being a meal. The pronghorn foraged as Nick raised his weapon and aimed.

  Buck snorted, a quiet sound but enough to catch the prey’s attention. Nick tapped the horse with his right toe, warning him of the impending noise. Holding his breath, he brought the sight up in line. The animal remained still as if a lack of motion rendered him invisible. Once the small male continued eating, Nick held the aim and pulled the trigger. He felt Beth start at the noise as the animal fell to his knees.

  “You got him,” she said.

  He grinned back at her, “You’re acting as if wanting a feast.”

  “I do! Shall we get started?”

  Nick nudged his horse forward. “Let’s do. Just over that next rise is the Platte.”

  Both dismounted when they reached the animal’s side. Nick took out a hand cloth and knife to butcher the pronghorn. “I’m not happy at having to waste so much. The bobcats and coyotes will eat well with no effort. If I’d paid more attention to what my wife did with our kills, we’d use every bit.” He laid out the cloth beside the dead animal, using the knife to cut into the legs.

  At first, Beth remained quiet while he stripped away the meatier parts. “Your wife hunted too?”

  He laid out the slabs of antelope on the cloth. “Not often, but when she did, she was an excellent shot.”

  “Hm,” Beth replied, lips pursed.

  He glanced up at her, seeing her face and the sour expression she wore. Nick didn’t want to take Beth’s silent reaction as a criticism of Sally and said, “I know, it’s not what a lady does, but I’m glad she had the skill.”

&
nbsp; “Of course. I’m sure her abilities were a great asset.”

  Her voice had an even tone now. So maybe, Nick thought, she’d just been reacting to him slicing the kill. “I agree. Hunting is something we did together and I miss it.” He sat back on his heels. He’d cut almost too much for them, and yet, so much remained. He wrapped up the meat, holding it away from him as he climbed onto Buck. She followed him up to ride a quick half mile to the Platte River.

  As they neared the water, the scent of damp and fish grew stronger. Their horse kept trying to trot the rest of the way there. Holding back on the reins, Nick said to Beth, “If you’ll start this cooking, I can get Buck staked out. The sooner we all eat something, the better.”

  She slid off, taking the saddlebags and meat he handed her. Beth gave him their cooking pot from one of the bags. “Could you bring this back half full of water, please?”

  “Sure.” He took the offered pan and allowed Buck to gallop the short distance to the riverbank. Nick did as requested only after the animal finished drinking. He left him tethered to a sage brush, grazing, and went back to camp.

  Beth still struggled to cut the meat. A bead of sweat dripped from her nose and he saw how she’d not started the fire. He both didn’t want to wait to eat and didn’t want to see her use so much effort. In his sternest voice, he said, “Why don’t you get a drink and freshen up? I can finish this and start cooking.” She nodded, standing with difficulty, he noticed, and went to the water.

  Years of practice helped, and soon their food cooked over the open flame. Stretching, he went to find Beth. Nick walked down to the bank, looking both ways up and downstream. When he spotted her, Nick halted, knowing she’d not seen him approach. Beth stood beside the water, bent over, looking at the river’s bed. He smiled, supposing she watched the minnows dart or maybe a crayfish scurrying across the bottom, but couldn’t be sure at this distance.

  The bun she kept her hair in had loosened and a French curl of a sort fell down against her shoulder. He wanted her hair to wrap around his forearm and to his elbow. The lock resembled a rich wood sanded to a silky texture. He shook his head. The woman didn’t know he found her beautiful inside and out. Had he ever told her? Nick couldn’t remember and resolved to fix this at the best time. A breeze carried the aroma of food and his stomach growled in response.

  Not wanting to be sneaky, he took a few scuffling steps forward, intending to cause a ruckus. The water birds cried a warning, causing Beth to look up at him. She smiled a greeting at first, which faded. Something bothered her, Nick suspected, but he didn’t quite know how to ask what it was. He instead decided to keep the topics safe and see if she told him on her own. “See anything down there bigger than a frog?”

  “No, not really.” She let her hem fall. “I like how the water is so clear.”

  “Figured you might.” Nick watched as she stepped back.

  “I suppose you have our dinner started?”

  He held out his hand for her. “You figure correctly.”

  “I’m sorry I couldn’t do more.” She accepted his help up the riverbank.

  “Don’t be. I’m sorry I didn’t send you for a drink first.” Nick saw the sadness in her eyes. He needed to brighten her mood. “You’ve been a good traveling companion through all this and I’m grateful.”

  “You are?” She smiled at him as they neared their camp. “I’m the one who’s been rescued. You could have gone on and left me to my own devices.”

  “Ha! No, I couldn’t have.” He sat, glancing over at Buck while Beth dished up the meals. The horse still grazed, not as intense now. Taking the plate she handed him, “Thank you. I hope it’s as good as it smells.”

  “You’re welcome.” She took a bite, chewing. “Very good, but then, hunger makes a good sauce.”

  He laughed, “I’ve heard it does.” They continued to eat until nothing remained. By facing the east, they didn’t see the rainclouds. Not until showers began did Nick notice the approaching thunderstorms. “Hope you’re in the mood for a washing.”

  She held out a hand to catch the drops. “I don’t mind. The rain is warmer than the Platte.” They cleaned the dishes in the river while the storm drenched them. When the drizzle eased, Beth said, “The water is still rather clear. But I’m not sure I want to wash so soon.”

  “I understand,” he replied. “I’ll take the chance to get cleaned up instead.” He went to the saddlebags and retrieved his soap, razor, and washcloth. While walking back to the river, he saw her lead the horse to a fresh patch of grass. She must be tired, he thought, thinking he saw her eyes water. He was too, and wanted to get settled in, despite the sun still being so far above the horizon.

  At the river, he stripped down to his pants. The water wasn’t high enough for him to feel comfortable being nude. At least not yet. Nick would feel more secure with a lookout posted. He shaved the stubble from his face and considered what to do once reaching the group. A lot depended on what the Beth wanted. But then, he admitted, he had wants of his own. He knelt to sit in the water and paused when catching movement out of the corner of his eyes. Beth approached, gaze lowered for his modesty, he supposed. “Hello, care for a swim?”

  “I should. Is it safe?”

  “It is with me here.” She kicked off her boots and sat to remove her socks. He watched her walk as if on a tightrope. She made her way through the brambles to the water. He almost stood to help, but she reached the riverbed before Nick could do anything. As she neared him, he said, “You could have gotten closer to the water like you did before.”

  Beth shook her head. “Flash floods. I don’t want to lose my boots, just in case.”

  He watched her as she stood on the bank and scanned the horizon. He loved everything about her. Her moss green eyes drew him in like nothing else, and he loved burying his nose in her beautiful hair at the nape of her neck. “You’re beautiful, did you know?”

  Startled, she stared down at him. “Oh! No, I didn’t know because I’m not, but appreciate you thinking such a thing.” She smiled, her chin trembling, “You’re quite handsome too.”

  “Thank you, I’m glad you think so.” He got to his feet and held out the soap. “Your turn?”

  “Very well.” She took the bar, just holding it.

  “What is bothering you?” he asked after a moment of watching her remain motionless. “Don’t tell me it’s nothing because I won’t believe you.”

  “If you want me to be honest…” At his nod, she continued, “I don’t know what will happen when I see Daggart next. I’m afraid he’ll think I’ve betrayed him.” Before he could protest, she added, “He will. He’ll think I’ve betrayed him and now can’t go back to being Lizzy. I don’t know what he’ll do when I tell him we won’t continue.”

  His heart broke when seeing her eyes fill with tears. “Whatever he does, I’ll be there to help you. He will never hurt you again, not while I’m alive.”

  “I appreciate that.” She sniffled, eyes still downcast. “I also ask for time to think about how I want to tell him to go on to California without me. I don’t want to be a burden to anyone. If he’ll let me take only what’s mine, maybe I could travel with another family to Oregon Territory.”

  Nick saw the glow of late afternoon reflected onto her sweet face. Another family, he thought. Like pulling the hammer back on a pistol, something clicked in him. His family. He wanted her as his own, and needed to belong to her as well. He went over and stepped up onto the bank. “Whatever you need, I’m here for you.”

  She smiled and sobbed at the same time. “Thank you.” As he wrapped his arms around her, she continued to cry, saying, “You’re such a good friend. I don’t know how…”

  “I don’t want to be a friend, Elizabeth.” Nick said the words as he felt them in his soul, “I want to be your husband.”

  Chapter 16

  Beth’s mind and heart felt split in two. How else to describe her desire to say yes and her need to say no? “I can’t marry you.”


  He chuckled before saying, “Yes, you can.”

  His amusement annoyed her. She stepped back, intending to press home her seriousness. “No, I can’t and won’t. Accepting your proposal is not an option.”

  “The hell it isn’t!” He took a step closer to her, keeping his voice low and insistent. “Your marrying me is more than an option, it’s a necessity.”

  If this had been Daggart who argued with her in such a stern manner, Beth would have been terrified of being hit. Instead, she smiled at him, glad to have him as a friend. “I don’t see how.”

  Nicholas frowned at first before returning her smile. “Because I love you, and I think you love me.”

  Her insides squirmed like tadpoles in a jar because he’d said the words. She had to be honest with him. “Yes, that’s true, but love isn’t enough in this case.”

  His jaw dropped a little before he recovered to say, “Beth, there’s nothing else. We make a good team in a lot of ways.” Nicholas crossed his arms. “Bartlett’s not an issue, or won’t be once I’m done with him, and marrying you is the practical thing to do.”

  “Practical?” Beth narrowed her eyes at him, wondering why the love talk was over.

  “Of course. We’ve been out here long enough. People will suspect what’s happened, and it did, so I might as well make an honest woman of you and marry.”

  “What about Sally?” She saw the flash of pain cross his face and knew the answer. Sally held his heart. Beth never would.

  “She…is gone. I’ve mourned her for a long time and always will.” He shrugged, “But that doesn’t mean I can’t or don’t love you.”

  Beth crossed her arms for warmth in the cooling air. Considering how easily he claimed to care for her, she wanted to believe his words as much as he did. Yet, fear held her back from accepting his proposal. “I love you as well. Give me time to consider what I want for my future, and I’ll give you an answer when we reach the others.”

  “Fair enough. I can wait.” He went to where his shirt draped over some brush.

  Nicholas’s bare torso distracted her as did his damp pants clinging to his legs. She looked out into the fading light and suppressed a sigh. To go a lifetime without love seemed unbearable, but the notion of being with any other man felt intolerable to her as well. She glanced at him as he rifled through the saddlebag. Had he felt the same the first time they lay together? That he’d betrayed Sally and sullied their love?