Twins Make Four: A Mistaken Identity Secret Baby Romance

by Nicole Elliot

  “Yes,” she breathed out.

  “How about this?” I moved my finger over her entrance and reached her anus, smearing her juices over it.

  “Mmm, yes.”

  She started squirming, moaning loudly each time I moved my finger over her sensitive skin. She was sopping wet, and I was getting more impatient to be inside that liquid heat.

  I probed her entrance with one finger and pushed it all inside. Her walls wrapped around it immediately, gripping it like a vice. I fingered her fast, adding two more fingers when she began rocking her hips uncontrollably, her desire pouring out of her non-stop.

  Just seeing her juices on the sheets and all over her pussy and thighs was more than enough to make me lose control, but I didn’t want to let this game end too early. She was seconds away from orgasming, already convulsing as if she was experiencing an unbearable pleasure. Once again, I refused to let her orgasm, removing my fingers right before it happened.

  “No! Tobias!”

  She tried turning around, but I pressed her shoulders on the mattress and left a trail of kisses down her spine.

  “Not yet.”

  “It’s not fair. Stop playing with me like this.”

  “That’s what you get for being a naughty girl and teasing me in the restaurant. Two can play that game.”

  I bit her shoulder and gripped her waist, pulling her up to her fours. “Now, you’ll stay like this and won’t move. Right?”

  Her only response was a whimper. I loved seeing her worked up like this, shivering and desperate for more. My lips progressed up her thigh, slowly reaching her wet hole, and her pants filled the air.

  “Tobias!” she screamed when my mouth connected with her pussy.

  I was instantly engulfed in warmth and wetness, and the scent was intoxicating. I lapped at her juices, picking up every single drop as I licked her whole mound. My heart was beating furiously in my chest, my twitching cock reminding me that I couldn’t keep up with this game much longer.

  “Ah... Please Tobias... Please...”

  I thrust my tongue right inside of her, and she screamed, moving her ass across my face. She couldn’t stop squirming, becoming louder with each second. I slid my tongue over her puffy outer lips and sucked her clit into my mouth, bringing two fingers into her warm hole.

  “Yes! Ah! Keep doing that! Just don’t stop!”

  I fingered her fast, sucking her clit with equal ferocity, bringing her close to her climax once again. More juices poured out, which was simply incredible, and I knew I wasn’t going to last long. I needed to be inside of her now.

  Pulling her clit forcefully into my mouth, I almost triggered her orgasm, but then I straightened up abruptly and slammed my dick right into her pussy, pushing to the brim.

  “Tobias!”

  “Now, you can come.”

  At that, she let a piercing cry out, her pussy squeezing me tightly when her orgasm hit her, and it was the best fucking feeling ever. With an animalistic growl, I plunged into her and set a rough rhythm, fucking her brains out.

  “That’s so deep! Ah... So deep...” She was whining and whimpering, calling my name as I ripped her pussy apart, but I couldn’t stop. I grabbed her tits and kneaded them, enthralled with the sight of her ass jiggling each time our bodies connected against each other. The sounds of our bodies slapping against each other mixed with our moans, and it made my dick even harder.

  I grabbed her arms and jerked them toward me, pulling her upper body against mine. I drilled her without stopping, reaching even further inside, and only moments separated me from a mind-blowing orgasm. Grabbing a handful of her hair, I yanked her head backward and buried my head into her neck.

  “You’re so fucking good, Scarlet!”

  She came again, her pussy gripping me in a way that was too good to be true, and it set my orgasm off. I wasn’t able to control it anymore.

  I pulled out of her and pushed her to the mattress, holding her in place as I positioned my cock right over her ass, spurting my creamy load on it.

  “Fuck!” I growled and squeezed her hip, watching my sperm slide down her ass and thighs. So hot.

  She ended falling face down on the mattress, as if her limbs couldn’t hold her any longer. I chuckled, lying right next to her. My arms wrapped around her, and I let my gaze wander across her face, admiring her sensual features.

  “You’re beautiful, Scarlet.”

  Her lips formed a content smile, her captivating eyes never looking away from mine. “I’m exhausted,” she muttered and closed her eyes, still smiling.

  I bit her shoulder. She whimpered. “Hey! What’s that for?”

  “Stop complaining. You enjoyed it as much as I did.”

  Her smile grew. “Exactly. Which is why I wouldn’t complain at all if you were to do it again.”

  I raised my eyebrow, amused and turned on at the same time. My cock was already fully erect and ready for more.

  “I think that’s exactly what I’m going to do now,” I said and stood up, scooping her up in my arms.

  She squealed. “What are you doing?”

  “Let’s take a nice, long bath. And then, we’ll see what else can happen. After all, the night is young.”

  CHAPTER 12

  Scarlet

  I woke, the sound of a light snore jerking me right out of my sleep. The second my eyes opened, they landed on Tobias’s face. A smile spread over my lips.

  For the second time in a row, my night had been incredible. I felt a warm and tingly sensation thinking about the way he had made me feel. Yet, I also felt a hallow feeling that accompanied facing the realization that our fling had undoubtedly come to an end since he would leaving soon. The past two days with him had been like something out of a fairytale, but now it was almost time to face reality again, whether I was ready to or not.

  Beneath all of that, I couldn’t deny feeling quite a bit of guilt as well. Something about the fact that I had firmly believed him to be Preston and had failed to be upfront with him about it made me feel dumb. After all, Tobias had been truthful with me; it wasn’t his fault that I hadn’t believed him.

  I stared at his sleeping face, his long eyelashes, and thick dark hair. I watched the way his bare chest rose and fell with each breath he took. He was so breathtakingly handsome, I couldn’t resist reaching touching him. Gently, I placed my hand on the side of his face, letting my thumb caress his cheek, feeling the stubble that had started to grow in there.

  He stirred slightly and his eyes cracked open. That sexy smile of his slid into place. “Morning,” he said.

  “Morning.”

  Rolling onto his side, he placed a hand on my hip. “Did you sleep well?”

  I nodded. “Yes. Did you?”

  “Best two nights of sleep I’ve had in a long time,” he said with a chuckle.

  “Is that all that was good?” I said, raising my eyebrows. “The sleep?”

  His laughter filled the room. “No. Believe it or not, some other things were even better than the sleep.”

  “Okay, good to know,” I said, joining in on the laughter. I rolled onto my back, feeling so content that I wanted to stay there forever.

  Tobias began to trail his fingers along my stomach, his touch so light that it tickled. “Scarlet?” he said.

  “Yeah?”

  “What is it?”

  I looked sideways at him. “Huh?”

  “I get a feeling something’s bothering you,” he said. “I mean, unless it’s just that I’m leaving? But I’m not so vain as to think you’d be bothered by that. I already told you that I was only in town for a few days. We both knew this was just a…”

  “Fling,” I finished for him. “Two-night stand.”

  He nodded. “Yeah a fucking great one at that.”

  I swallowed, because that was indeed one of the things that was bothering me, but just slightly. I had been careful not to apply more meaning to our fling than what it was worth.

  The real thing that was botherin
g me though…

  I knew I shouldn’t let our time together end without admitting to it.

  I sighed. “That’s not what’s bothering me.”

  “Then what is it? You’re not still upset about the bill you’re leaving me with, are you?” he asked, although some humor had returned to his voice.

  I smiled. “No.”

  “Then elaborate. Please.”

  “Tobias…” I said, and took a deep breath, “I really did think you were Preston.”

  “Yeah, I know. That’s why you came over to me at the bar in the first place.”

  I shook my head. “No…I mean, I still thought you were him even after that. I…” I paused a second before resuming. “I still thought you were him when I left with you. That’s why I left with you.”

  He stared at me for a moment, his eyes narrowing.

  I averted my eyes. I wanted to make a full confession, but I suddenly felt like I couldn’t do it looking into his pretty gray eyes. “You see, I thought you were playing with me. So I had decided to play along and let you be…this other character you had invented. Except, now I know you weren’t just inventing another character. Now I know that you were telling the truth. I didn’t realize it until room service came and the server called you Mr. Gentry.”

  Tobias sat up and looked back at me. “Are you serious?”

  “Yes,” I said, finally looking at him again. “I honestly thought you were Preston Walker, pretending to be someone else.”

  Tobias shook his head. “Hold on a second. Let me get this straight. Even after I told you that I wasn’t Preston, you still thought I was him, and that I was just trying to fool you?”

  “I didn’t think you were trying to fool me…I just thought you were, you know, role playing or something. Pretending to be a sexy stranger. Trying to…to make our night more interesting…”

  “Was Preston into that kind of thing?”

  “Well, he could be goofy at times. I wouldn’t have put it past him.”

  There was a long pause before Tobias suddenly started laughing. He laughed so hard that he tipped over onto his back again. I stared at him, not quite sure how I felt about him laughing so hard at my expense. It had taken a lot for me to confess to him, and now he was laughing at me…

  I folded my arms across my chest, offended. Yet, as I continued listening to his laughter, snickers started rising from my own throat. I tried to hold them in, but not before long, I was laughing right along with him, the humor of the situation finally dawning on me.

  “I guess I owe Preston a thank you,” Tobias said, once his laughter finally died down. He looked at me and smiled, running a hand down the side of my face. “Looks like I’m forever indebted to him because he gave me two of the most amazing nights I’ve had in a long time. So next time you actually see him, give him my regards.” He winked.

  I laughed again. “Yeah. Sure,” I said, shaking my head.

  Tobias’s gray eyes began to smolder. He leaned over, leaving a soft lingering kiss on my lips that nearly set me on fire. I wrapped an arm around his neck, hoping that we’d share one last passionate moment together before it was time for us to go our separate ways.

  But then his cell phone rang, interrupting. I sighed as he pulled back from me to answer it.

  “Hello?” he said, and then paused, listening intently. His brows furrow in concentration. “Right now?” he asked. He swore, running a hand through his hair. He then closed his eyes and pinched the bridge of his nose. “All right. I’m on my way. I’ll head out now. Bye.” He ended the call and sighed looking down at his phone. “Shit.” He looked back at me, “I’m sorry, there’s an emergency at the office that needs my immediate attention,” he said. “Looks like I need to leave a little sooner than expected.”

  I nodded and swallowed against the lump forming in my throat, reminding myself that I knew this moment was coming all along. There was no need to be surprised by it.

  I watched Tobias slid out of bed. My eyes trailed over him, admiring his body for what would likely be the last time as he headed to the bathroom. I then got out of bed myself, gathering what little belongings I had with me so that I could be ready to leave when he did.

  “Do you have a ride?” he asked an hour later, when we were both packed and ready to go.

  “Yeah. Uber.” I shook my phone with the app pulled up.

  He nodded. “Okay,” he said. “Well, it’s been fun.” He gave small smile as he pulled his suitcase out the door of the hotel suite.

  I followed him out into the hall. “Yeah, it has,” I agreed.

  “So, I guess this is goodbye then.” He stretched out his hand to me, and I looked at it hand for a moment, somewhat taken aback that he wanted to end things between us with a formal handshake, as if we had been doing nothing more than business or something.

  Oh well, I thought, and took his hand.

  Suddenly, his smile widened and he pulled me in toward him, releasing my hand to wrap his arm around me in a hug instead. He leaned down, kissing the top of my head. “It was a pleasure meeting you, Scarlet. Thank you for spending some time with me.”

  The lump formed in my throat again, making it difficult to speak. “Same here. Thank you for everything,” I managed to choke out.

  Several long seconds later, he released me and stepped back, picking up his suitcase. “Take care of yourself, all right?”

  “You too,” I said.

  And then we went parted ways, knowing it would likely be the last time we ever saw each other.

  CHAPTER 13

  Scarlet

  I sat in the backseat of my Uber, thoughts of the past two days saturating my mind. The more I thought about it, the harder it was to believe the past days had actually been a part of my life.

  Who would have thought my boring night out with the girls would result in a fun and exciting tryst with a rich and handsome stranger? Nothing so adventurous had ever happened to me before. I knew without a doubt that Tobias Gentry had permanently engraved himself in my memory. When I became old and gray, I would remember the handsome gentleman I’d met on accident, and the time we had shared together for two brief days. Those nights would likely bring a smile to my face for the rest of my life.

  Except for when it came time to tell my friends about them.

  I sighed, envisioning Mila waiting for me to call her. She would want to know every scandalous detail, and she would relish gossiping to the rest of our friends about it afterwards.

  I frowned, knowing that I simply couldn’t allow it, which meant she couldn’t know. I couldn’t tell her. I knew I couldn’t tell her because I couldn’t even stomach the thought.

  I couldn’t tell anyone.

  Granted, I didn’t like lying to my friends, but this felt like something personal and it was perfectly permissible for me to keep some aspects of my life private. Tobias Gentry would be one of those aspects. For as long as I lived, he would remain my little secret.

  I stared out the window, seeing my neighborhood coming closer.

  Back to reality, I thought. The real world was awaiting me; I just hoped that I could readapt to it without much trouble. I knew it would be hard though. Even though our time together had been short, Tobias had changed something about me in ways I couldn’t even seem to fully comprehend yet.

  Too bad it was all over. There was something special about that man. I could tell that he was one of the good ones, a hard find these days.

  Why can’t I be lucky enough to have a man like that in my life? I thought bitterly. I sighed again as the Uber driver pulled up to my apartment.

  CHAPTER 14

  Tobias

  4 months later

  I looked up from my computer after hearing a knock at my office door. One of my employees, Libby, poked her head through the door.

  “You got a minute?” she asked.

  “Sure,” I said, watching her enter.

  She came in, delivering a set of reports to my desk. “Already?” I said, stunned. Sh
e hadn’t had much time to pull this all together, yet, there she was.

  “Been busting my butt to get that to you early,” she said. “But I know you’ve been busting yours too lately, especially with Anderson and Joanna not being around as much. So I thought you’d appreciate having the reports early.” She winked.

  “Goodness, Libby, I could kiss you for this,” I said, flipping through the pages.

  “You sure could, but who says I’ll let you?” She laughed, trying to appear nonplussed, although a faint flush had formed over her cheeks.

  “Touché,” I said, still glancing over her work. As far as I could tell, everything looked to be in perfect order. “You did a really great job with this, Libby. It may seem like overkill, but I really can’t thank you enough for how much you’ve stepped up to help me out over these past few months.”

  “Don’t mention it,” she said, waving her hand dismissively.

  About a year ago, when my sister had moved into town to flee her abusive ex, I’d hired her to work at my firm, and Libby had become really good friends with her. When my sister got pregnant and had her baby with my best friend, Libby had started helping me out as much as possible, completing any additional tasks she could to ease the burden I felt in trying to take over both Anderson’s and Joanna’s roles in the office. While I was capable of doing their jobs, I couldn’t deny it was rough. I would have been spreading myself far too thin if I didn’t have Libby’s help.

  Plus, I had been needing Libby’s help more than usual over the past four months because time and distance hadn’t aided in removing Scarlet Kale from my mind. I was almost ashamed to even admit to myself that I hadn’t stopped thinking about her from the moment we went our separate ways.

  It wasn’t like I hadn’t had a few meaningless flings in my day. Yet, there was something about Scarlet that I just couldn’t shake. I had even deleted her number from my phone in an attempt to get her off my mind, not to mention eliminate the temptation I’d constantly felt to contact her again. But it had all been useless.

  Not even the severely busy days at the office kept her off my mind for long. It was always just a matter of time before I found myself reliving the nights we’d spent together, thinking about the feel of her silky hair and soft lips…