Hearts on Fire 7: Claiming Catalina (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Dixie Lynn Dwyer

  Cooper released her lips and began to feast on her breasts.

  “Holy fuck, you’re gorgeous, Catalina. I want to taste you, too,” Jeremy said, and the look in his eyes was so dark, so deep, she felt a shiver run through her system. He leaned forward from behind her, traced gently along her jaw as he held her gaze. It was a strong contrast to the deep, hard sucks on her breasts from Cooper and Cody, as well as the hard, fast strokes from Don. She felt so alive, so desirable it had her shaking with need for more, but as Jeremy gently cupped her face and kissed her from above, suckling her lower lip into his mouth, nibbling on her chin and then plunging his tongue into her mouth, the sensations overwhelmed her system. She felt her body explode as the orgasm rocked her from head to toe.

  “I need a taste,” Cooper said as he released her breast.

  Like some sort of assembly line, they rotated. Jeremy kept kissing her. Cody moved into Don’s position, and Cooper helped Cody.

  She moaned into Jeremy’s mouth, and he just kept kissing her and then ran his hands along her shoulder to her breast, cupping it. She ran her hands through his hair and held him to her breast as she tilted her head back and let go, relishing the effects on her body.

  A moment later she felt Cody’s fingers thrust up into her cunt. Thick, hard, and long, his finger stroked her, hitting a sensitive spot that made her pussy spasm some more.

  “So fucking wet and tight. Damn, baby, you are perfect and so giving,” Cody said while he thrust his fingers and then licked along her lips.

  He alternated tongue and fingers, and she moaned again and lifted her hips upward. Jeremy released her lips and moved along to the side, where he cupped her breast and then began to feast on her breast, tugging on her nipple.

  Cooper was back exploring her other breast and nipple, and then Cody’s mouth suckled hard on her pussy, eliciting a squeal from her throat, and she came again.

  He slurped and licked, cleaning her up, and then lifted up, smiling. “Fucking delicious.”

  She turned away, feeling embarrassed and turned-on, and she locked gazes with Don. He sat in the chair right to the side, his pants unzipped and his cock in his hand. Their gazes locked, and he looked so carnal and needy. She wanted to go to him and ease that ache, but then Cody was moving and Cooper was taking his place. There was no preamble, just fingers thrusting into her cunt and Cooper’s lips, tongue, and teeth feasting on her pussy lips and then her anus. She nearly shot off the table when he touched her there, but Jeremy held down her shoulder and gripped her chin.

  “What’s my brother doing to you, baby?”

  “Oh God, this is wild. Too much.” She moaned as Cooper suckled her pussy with his mouth, and then she would feel his tongue roll between her pussy lips and over her anus. Back and forth, every stroke made her feel so needy and aroused.

  “Oh God. Oh, Cooper.”

  “What is he doing? Tell me,” Jeremy demanded, and she felt her pussy cream.

  “Fuck, I think she likes your tone, Jeremy. She’s leaking like a fucking faucet,” Cooper said and then licked again.

  Jeremy held her gaze and leaned down closer.

  “Where is his tongue stroking?”

  She felt her chest tighten, and she knew she loved this. She was turned on by his demanding tone, his big muscles, and his need to hear the dirty talk.

  “My pussy,” she whispered, and Cooper slowly pressed a finger to her anus.

  She thrust upward.

  “And?” Cooper pushed.

  “My ass. Oh God I never…” She moaned, and then she shook as she came.

  She was panting for breath as Jeremy held her gaze.

  “Ever been with more than one man?”

  She shook her head fast.

  “Ever have a cock in your ass?” he asked, and she shook her head fast again.

  “That’s fucking hot. We’re going to be your firsts, aren’t we, Catalina? You want us to be your firsts? You want me to fuck this ass while Cooper fucks that pussy and Don strokes his cock into your sweet, sexy mouth?”

  “Oh God!” She screamed another release.

  “And then I get to make love to you last. Just when you think you can’t go anymore, I’ll give you another orgasm,” Cody told her as he leaned down and nibbled her shoulder.

  Jeremy moved around her, and Cooper moved from between her legs but kissed her on the mouth. She could taste her cream on his lips and then his tongue as he plunged it into her mouth. She reached up and grabbed hold of him, feeling so overwhelmed, but then he pulled back and Jeremy was there to take his place. Jeremy lifted her thighs over his shoulders as he sat in the chair in front of the table with her ass and pussy in his face.

  He closed his eyes and inhaled.

  “Fuck, you smell as sweet as honey.”

  He swiped his tongue over her pussy all the way to her anus. Back and forth, he licked her as he massaged her inner thighs. She reached down and held on to his head, tilted her head back, and enjoyed his tactics while moaning and panting for breath. A nip from his teeth then a suckle against a more sensitive spot had her wriggling on the table and moving her head side to side.

  When one finger entered her ass and another entered her pussy and began a series of strokes, she cried out another release, but Cooper and Cody were there to hold her arms above her head and then explore her breasts. She was restrained by three men while the fourth one stroked his cock, and he was so turned-on that she wanted to come. She wanted to let them fuck her. She never felt so wild and aroused in her life, and nothing had ever felt so right.

  Jeremy kissed along her thighs and then lowered her legs back down, easing his fingers from both holes. He eased his way over her body. Cooper and Cody still held her arms above her head, and her breasts were fully exposed. Jeremy licked along one breast and tugged, then licked along the other and tugged, holding her gaze with a dark, determined look.

  “You were made for us, Catalina. I believe that, but going slow just may not be an option tonight.” He covered her mouth and kissed her.

  Cody and Cooper kissed along her arms and then released them. She hugged Jeremy tight and wrapped her legs around his thighs, and he lifted her up and began to carry her out of the kitchen.

  When he set her feet down on the floor and placed his hands against the zipper of her dress as he stared into her eyes, she knew she wanted to be with them.

  “Stay with us tonight. Make love to us.”

  “This is so crazy. I hardly know you.”

  “You know enough. You know what we want, what we expect from this, and I think you want that, too.”

  “You aren’t even sure you know what you want to do with your lives. A long-distance relationship might not work.”

  “That may be true, but feeling you, being with you tonight, has made things clearer. It will take time to work things out, but I know I want you. My brothers do, too, and that’s something we’ve always dreamed about. We waited for you, Catalina, and the timing has to be right. It has to be,” Jeremy told her.

  He caressed her back, his large, firm hands over her skin arousing her senses. She felt so in tune to each of these men. She wanted to be loved, cared for, and to have a real relationship with honest, good men. Was it the right time to take this chance?

  He pressed closer and began to play with the zipper on the back of her dress. Cooper moved in behind her and kissed her shoulder.

  “We won’t hurt you.”

  “I must be out of my mind,” she whispered and then pressed her hands against Jeremy’s chest and ran them up along his shirt to his shoulders. As he leaned down to meet her lips with his, she felt the zipper go down on her dress, and it fell to the floor.

  “Sweet mercy, woman, you have one hell of an ass,” Cody told her, and Don chuckled.

  “One hell of a body, bro,” Don said as Jeremy continued to kiss her.

  She had to admit that, despite her hard workouts and being so health-conscious, she worried about how her body might look to them. She had been
alone for so long, not ever trusting any men, never mind four, enough to be intimate and have sex with them. She was fully exposing herself to these four men in every way. Her body, her heart, and her soul were all on the table. Would she get hurt? God, she prayed not. How could this be wrong and feel so good, so right as each of them touched her.

  Jeremy moved his lips from hers to her jaw and to her neck. Behind her, Cooper lowered, and she felt his fingers spread her ass cheeks as his tongue located her slit.

  “I’m going to need some serious creative tactics here, guys,” Don said as he sat on the edge of the bed completely naked, his leg all bandaged up as he stroked his cock.

  Jeremy cupped her breast as he lowered his mouth to her nipple and tugged.

  Cody joined in on the other side, taking her breast into his mouth and licking her areola before suckling the tiny, hard bud between his teeth. Sensations traveled through a string of nerves from her nipples to her pussy, making her moan and come a little.

  “Let me,” she said as Jeremy and Cody released her breasts.

  Cooper followed her as she turned to the left and lowered to her knees in front of Don. She ran her hands up his thighs, being careful to avoid the bandage and the side of his leg where the stitches were. He ran his hands through her hair.

  “I’m going to beat the crap out of that fucking rookie first chance I fucking get.” He looked so angry and serious that she knew she needed to calm him down. They could do this. They could all make love tonight.

  She leaned forward and licked the tip of his cock. Don hissed.

  “Just relax and let me take care of you,” she told him as she looked up into his eyes

  “Goddamn,” Cooper whispered and stepped in behind her.

  He lowered to his knees and ran his hands along her legs from ankles to thighs and hips. Then he spread her thighs wider and pulled her hips back. She inhaled at the way Cooper parted her thighs and then placed a hand on her hip to squeeze her closer while he found her clit with his other finger and began to stimulate her cunt. Don gripped her hair and slowly stroked into her mouth, and that was it. She opened for him, wanting to please him, to make him come in her mouth since he might not be able to come inside of her body.

  The connection, the deep, instant need to please, to want to protect and care for him, for them, was overwhelming. So as Cooper maneuvered his fingers into her cunt from behind and started to stroke faster and faster, she thrust her hips back and relished his capabilities and this moment. Tomorrow would be a different story entirely.

  * * * *

  “You’re so giving, Catalina. You want to please us, don’t you, baby?” Jeremy asked, taking a seat on the bed.

  He was naked and his cock so hard and needy to be inside of Catalina. He caressed her shoulder and stroked a finger along her cheek as she sucked on Don’s cock. Don had his eyes closed, and behind Catalina, Cooper smiled. Jeremy watched Cooper press over her much-smaller frame as he stroked her pussy, making her thrust back against Cooper’s fingers. Jeremy felt his cock grow harder at the way Cooper licked her skin and then moved his hand over her waist to the front of her.

  “Open for me. Offer me this sweet pussy, baby.”

  “Oh hell, Coop,” Don complained, and his face contorted as he seemed to be trying to hold his ground and not come in Catalina’s mouth.

  Jeremy gripped her hair. “Cody, grab the lube and the condoms.”

  Catalina gasped but kept sucking on Don’s cock as Cooper switched hands and maneuvered the one in the front of her to stroke fingers up into her cunt. Cody appeared with the tube of lube and two boxes of condoms.

  “Feeling that sure of yourself?” Jeremy teased.

  “Fuck yeah. I want in every hole. I want to mark her as our woman and make her see that there’ll never be another man but the four of us,” Cody said and then tossed the condoms on the bed.

  “Oh, damn. Damn, Coop, what are you doing to her?” Don asked and started panting then thrusting his hips faster.

  Catalina was sucking and moving her head up and down. One look over her shoulder and Jeremy could see Cooper’s other fingers pressing the lube in her ass, spreading her and getting her ready for their cocks.

  “I need you, baby. Say you want us,” Cooper said, pulling his fingers from her body. She nodded, and he smoothed his hands along her ass, squeezing her ass cheeks.

  “Cody?” Cooper said, and Cody handed him a condom. A moment later, Cooper was gripping Catalina’s hips.

  “Here I come, baby. Time to make you all ours.”

  Jeremy caressed her back just as Cooper stroked his cock into her pussy from behind. When Catalina began to push back, Jeremy knew that this was going to be a wild night. She wanted them. They wanted her, and nothing had ever come even remotely close to this sensation.

  “Fuck, I’m there. I can’t hold back. Fuck,” Don yelled out and then shot his load into Catalina’s mouth. She sucked and caressed him, and then he pulled from her mouth and she kissed his inner thighs.

  “Catalina?” Jeremy whispered to her and caressed her cheek. She looked at him, her lips wet, parted, and her cheeks rosy pink. She was gasping and moaning as Cooper thrust into her pussy harder, faster.

  “Oh God. Oh, Cooper,” she moaned.

  Jeremy was shocked when Catalina pushed back and then moved in between Jeremy’s legs to cup his cock and balls. She ran her hands along his inner thighs and stroked his muscle.

  “Holy hell, woman. God, those hands feel so good, but I’m going to be inside of you when I come. You hear me, baby? Inside of that sexy ass.”

  He stroked her hair, and Cooper slowed his pace behind her. Jeremy locked gazes with him.

  Cooper’s expression was so intense and filled with such emotion. Jeremy glanced at Cody, who moved closer.

  “Together. Let’s take her together and make this official.”

  Cooper eased his cock from her pussy, and Catalina released Jeremy’s cock.

  She was breathing erratically, her chest all patchy with red marks, her breasts full and perfect.

  “We want you together. We’ll go slow, baby. We all need to take you tonight.”

  Cooper gave her hips a tap. He then lay down on the bed with his legs hanging off the bed as Jeremy stood up. Cooper curled his finger at her, indicating for her climb up on top of him.

  Jeremy helped her up, feeling her sexy body and how light and feminine she was. He suddenly had such a possessive feeling come over him. He felt protective of her, and he knew that protectiveness would get stronger.

  She slid down over Cooper’s cock, taking it up into her cunt slowly as she eased up and down. She ran her hands along his chest as Jeremy took the lube from Cody and squirted some to her ass as he pressed a finger against her puckered hole.

  “Oh God. It burns, Jeremy. It feels so odd.”

  “Just relax those muscles. Let us in, Catalina,” Cody whispered to her and leaned forward to kiss her shoulder, and then down her upper arm to her exposed breast.

  He suckled and feasted on her as Cooper gripped her hips and pressed upward while Jeremy maneuvered his fingers faster, deeper into her ass. He scissored his fingers, stretching her inner muscles, preparing her for his cock. He felt the pre-cum drip from the tip of his cock and prayed he would last more than a few strokes, but she was incredibly aroused, and she was absolutely perfect in every way. She was their woman. There was no doubt in his mind.

  “I’m coming in next, baby. Get ready for Cody, too, now,” Jeremy instructed. Being in charge, leading this lovemaking session and taking care of his family was his job, his calling. The fact that he immediately thought of Catalina as family struck his heart as he thrust his fingers a little faster. Catalina moaned and thrust back against his digits. She was super wet when Cody tilted her head toward his cock and then pressed it between her lips. She explored Cody’s cock with her mouth and tongue and then accepted his strokes, tilting her head back and accommodating his thick, hard cock.

  “Here I come.
”

  Jeremy eased his fingers from her ass and replaced them with the tip of his cock.

  “Goddamn, this is fucking wild and sexy as damn hell,” Don said from the bed. He was sitting up watching, stroking his cock again.

  Jeremy chuckled, but then he clenched his teeth as he eased his cock into the very tight muscles. “Relax and let me in. It will feel so fucking good, baby. You’ll be filled in every hole by your men.”

  He eased deeper and deeper until he felt the “plop” sensation, and then was fully seated in her ass. The three of them exhaled as Catalina moaned against Cody’s cock.

  In and out, they moved in sync, rocking the bed, thrusting into Catalina’s body.

  “Here I come, baby. Here I come,” Cody said and then thrust and came in her mouth. She licked him clean, and he moved off the bed.

  “Too fucking tight. Holy hell, baby, this ass of yours is fucking gripping my cock so tight. I’m coming,” Jeremy said and began to move faster and faster.

  “Oh God!”

  She screamed her release, and Jeremy came pumping into her ass three more times. Then, holding himself inside of her as he pressed his body against hers and cupped her breasts, he tweaked the nipples then kissed her everywhere his mouth could reach.

  He eased out of her ass, and Cooper continued to thrust up into her. Then Don stood up.

  “What do you think you’re doing?” Jeremy asked as Don rolled a condom onto his cock.

  “I’m making love to our woman tonight, too.”

  He eased around her and grabbed the tube of lube, then pressed some into her ass. A moment later, he was massaging her back and whispering to her.

  “I need inside of you, baby. Tonight you become all of ours.”

  “Be careful, Don. Please, the stitches,” she said with concern, but then she gasped as Don eased his cock into her ass and thrust all the way in.

  “Holy fuck,” Don said, gripping her hips and tilting his head back.