Bewitched by Three (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Kalissa Alexander

  “She’s sleeping now, still wearing your shirt. I was thinking that we should have kept her longer, not let her sleep, but our kind rarely succumb to brain injuries. But, just to be on the safe side, I’ll check on her in the morning.”

  “Don’t you think her grandmother might start asking questions?” Markus asked.

  “I’m not going to knock on the front door, and I’ll go before sunrise.”

  “That’s a good idea,” Parker said, nodding his head. “I’m sure you won’t mind if I go with you.”

  “You should go with me. What about you, Markus?”

  “I have an appointment to visit the Mayfair’s first thing in the morning. Their entire heard of goats need to receive their CDT vaccination. It’s a long-standing appointment.”

  “No. Don’t cancel,” Parker said, turning to his brother. “That wouldn’t be right.”

  “I agree,” Nathaniel said. “So, it looks like it will be just you and me, brother.”

  Markus stood up. “I’m going to bed. Almost scaring someone to death is exhausting work, but I think it was just meant to be, you know, that she met you tonight.”

  “Night, Markus,” both brothers said at the same time.

  “So, you think this girl is special?” Parker said after Markus had left the room.

  Nathaniel looked over at his brother. No one who met them for the first time would ever think they were brothers. He and Markus at least resembled one another. Parker, on the other hand, had reddish brown hair that complemented his light complexion that was sprinkled with freckles. He was shorter than he and Markus by about three inches, and he was husky, where they were more slender. Most women found him adorable. He had never lacked for girlfriends when they were in college. Even when they were with the same woman, he had a way about him that had them begging for more.

  “Yeah, she’s a beautiful woman. Breasts that are large but firm and nipples that you want to suck until the cows come home. Small waist, flared hips, long legs, and long blonde hair. But it’s what I saw when I looked into her eyes that took me back. It was like she was looking right into my very soul, twisting and turning it into something only she could make whole.”

  Parker was silent for a moment before he sat back in his chair and stretched his legs. “The physical description is making my mouth water, but seeing through you into your soul—that’s a bit unnerving. You’ve never let a woman see past your cock before.”

  Nathaniel laughed. “You’re right. But we have a problem.”

  “I know,” Parker said, his eyes serious. “She’s Mardi’s cousin and not exactly our kind of normal in the sense she wasn’t brought up here. She might be damaged and never reach her full potential.”

  “You think her mother repressed her spirit to the point she can’t recover?”

  “We won’t know that for a while. Of course, Markus is ready to make her ours right now, but I don’t want to repeat the same mistake we made with Mardi.”

  “Absolutely not,” Nathaniel said, shaking his head in agreement. You can judge for yourself tomorrow, that is if you’re awake. You’ve had a rough night.

  “Don’t worry, I’ll be up. I can’t wait to meet her.”

  * * * *

  Parker took a quick shower before he hopped into bed. He knew he needed to sleep, but thoughts of Amber and his brothers’ reaction to her were keeping him awake.

  He was anxious to meet her, but what if he didn’t bond with her? Would that mean that he was destined not to bond with the same woman as his brothers? He had never thought that was possible, but he had also never seen Nathaniel or Markus quite like this before.

  He turned and tried to put such thoughts from his mind. He was just about to dose off when he heard a noise. Instantly alert, he sat upright.

  “Parker? You awake?”

  “What’s wrong, Markus?”

  “I just wanted to talk to you for a minute,” his brother said, walking toward him and sitting down at the end of the bed.

  “Sure.”

  “I just want you to know that the way I feel about Amber is real and I’m not letting my body rule my mind like I have in the past. This is different. She’s different.”

  “I pretty much gathered that when Nathaniel admitted he felt it, too. Besides, after Mardi, you’ve grown up a lot. And there’s no way you would want to be with her cousin of all people unless there were a lot more to this than infatuation.”

  “Thanks,” Markus said, lowering his head.

  “Now go back to bed. You’ve got an early morning.”

  “There is one more thing.”

  Parker shoved his pillow behind his back and relaxed. Markus had always needed a lot of reassurance as a child, and as an adult he was still seeking approval.

  “What is it?” he asked Markus.

  “I’m worried about Mother. She was Amber’s mother’s friend. I know she was hurt by her when she left Justine Falls without a word to her. I’m not sure Mother’s going to be happy about our bonding with her so called friend’s daughter.”

  “Honestly, I hadn’t thought about that until now and I’m not sure Nathaniel has either. But one thing I do know, Mother would never try to stand in the way of our happiness.”

  “You’re right,” Markus said, his voice sounding slightly less stressed.

  “I know I am. Now go to bed and stop worrying.”

  Markus lifted himself from the bed and walked toward the bedroom door. He stopped and looked back. “Thanks, Parker.”

  “Good night, Markus.”

  Once Markus was gone, he lay awake thinking about what he had said about their mother’s relationship with Bess Linden’s daughter. The incident with Mardi had stirred up old memories that their mother had shared with them. She had wanted them to understand, especially Markus, how much the Linden family had been through already and why they were more sensitive than most to a bonding that didn’t go as planned. The aftermath that not only affected those directly involved but family and friends. His mother had been hurt that her friend had left without a word to never see her again. From what she said, they had been close and she still suffered from that hurt.

  Parker punched his pillow in frustration. Markus was right. Mother wasn’t going to be pleased about Amber.

  Chapter Five

  The following morning, as promised, Parker was ready and dressed in plenty of time to go check on Amber before her grandmother was up and about. It was still dark outside when the brothers took off. Nathaniel flew silently through her open window and into her room with Parker not far behind. She was still lying on top of the covers. Markus’s shirt remained unbuttoned, leaving her ample breasts exposed. Nathaniel gazed down at the sleeping woman, admiring her curves before he gently pulled the shirt together to cover her breasts.

  Very softly, he said, “Amber,” repeating her name a few times before her eyes fluttered open.

  “Nathaniel?”

  “I’m here to check on you. Since you wanted to keep your grandmother from worrying, I used the window.”

  She smiled, her eyes lighting up. She really was beautiful in an innocent, unpretentious way that made him want her even more than he already did.

  “Thanks. But I feel okay. I’m not sure this is necessary.”

  He pulled out his flashlight and looked in her eyes. Everything looked good. He could hardly even feel the bump on the side of her head. She appeared to be back to normal.

  Lifting herself, she looked over his shoulder He saw her eyes go to where Parker was standing.

  “Hello, Amber. I was sorry to hear about your fall. That was scary.”

  “A little,” she breathed, seemingly unaware of her state of undress until she looked down and blushed.

  “That’s my brother, Parker. He’s a vet, too.”

  “Nice to meet you, Parker,” she said somewhat shyly.

  Nathaniel gently pushed her back against the bed.

  “Be still, Amber.”

  He continued his examination an
d then smiled. “You seem to be fine. No lasting effects from the fall last night.”

  “I should get dressed. I need to give Markus back his shirt.”

  Parker, who stood at the end of the bed, stuck out his hand. “I’ll take it.”

  “Parker,” Nathaniel warned.

  He watched, mesmerized, as she shrugged it from her shoulders and shifted as she crawled past him, her body bathed in a light film of perspiration. She handed Parker the shirt before she swung her long legs off the bed and walked half-naked across the room to her closet where she pulled out a thin jersey that she slipped slowly down over her breasts. She might as well have not bothered to cover herself. The material hugged her plush mounds and protruding hard nipples, continuing to make his mouth water.

  Was she deliberately being seductive, playing the temptress, or was she so out of tune with her body that she was unaware of how she was affecting them? Somehow he doubted the latter was true as he watched her slowly turn to his brother.

  “Is there anything else you need…besides your brother’s shirt?” she asked, keeping her eyes glued to Parker’s, who for once didn’t seem to know what to say.

  “What do you think you’re doing, Amber?” Nathaniel asked sharply. Amber’s head snapped toward him.

  “I,” she stammered, “don’t know.” She turned around, reaching for her robe on the closet door, and pulled it around her, tightening the sash. “I mean…” She seemed at a loss for the words, keeping her back to them.

  When she finally turned around to face them, she said, “I don’t know what possessed me to act like that. I really don’t. I’ve never even been with a man before.” She closed her hand over her mouth.

  Nathaniel felt the heat of her embarrassment. But more than that, he felt her honesty and confusion.

  Now he understood. Without proper training, she was at the mercy of her sexual needs that for the first time in her life were not being stifled into submission. The Witch in her was becoming more powerful, and that meant she could no longer just ignore what her body was telling her. She had little if no control over her urges that could overwhelm her at any time, and especially when she was around others whose feelings she could easily feed off. She was a wild card, and that could be dangerous for all of them. It was also making her even more desirable.

  He wanted her, and he could tell by Parker’s hooded eyes and jagged breathing that he felt the same way. Possibly it was their desire that had triggered her actions. She was so new to their lifestyle, so unguarded and open. She didn’t know how to defend herself from their lustful thoughts or her own reaction.

  “Don’t be embarrassed,” he said softly, trying to calm her nerves. “It wasn’t your fault. I think we both wanted to see you naked so badly that we inadvertently sent you messages that you couldn’t resist. We took advantage of your inexperience. I’m sorry.”

  “I’m sorry too,” Parker said, “that we’ve pushed our feelings on you. But I’d be lying if I said you aren’t the most beautiful woman I’ve ever seen. Your breasts are gorgeous, along with the rest of you.”

  Her eyelashes fluttered. “I was taught to be ashamed of them,” she said, looking away from Parker as she tightened her robe around her. “I used to have to wrap them so that they would appear smaller.”

  “What a horrible thing to do to a young girl. You have to know that your parents weren’t in their right minds. No one would do such a thing if they were,” Nathaniel said. His anger at her parents made him feel physically ill for what she had been made to endure.

  What else did they do to you?” Parker asked, his voice low and threatening.

  Nathaniel watched her eyes become cloudy with pain. “You don’t have to tell us now, Amber. We didn’t come here to upset you.”

  Parker sighed. “I’m sorry.”

  “I should have been a better daughter. I tried. I really did.”

  “You don’t really believe that, do you? Nathaniel asked. “You have to know that none of what happened to you was your fault.”

  Amber raised her eyes to Nathaniel’s. “But the way I just flaunted my body makes me think that maybe they were right. I’m out of control.”

  “Don’t ever think that,” Parker said. “It’s not true. You’re a Witch, and these feelings are normal. You just haven’t had a chance to learn how to deal with them yet.”

  “Really? Even now when you’re both being so kind, I’m still feeling the need to”—she hesitated—“to show myself to you again, and I’m fighting that urge. What’s wrong with me? I’ve never felt like this before. I’m so ashamed,” she cried.

  Nathaniel felt her confusion and pain as it ripped through him. Without thinking, he pulled her into his arms. With a groan, Parker moved closer to hug her from behind, sandwiching her between them.

  “If you’re out of control, it’s only because we are out of control. We want you, Amber. We want you so badly that we can’t stop thinking about what it would be like to have you in our bed,” Parker groaned into her neck. “But we’ll try and go slow. We want you to want us without guilt or feeling you are doing something wrong.”

  “Right now”—Nathaniel held her tighter—“you are reflecting our feelings, making them your own. That’s why you want to be naked in front of us, because that’s what we want.”

  “You have to stop,” she said without conviction, trying to remove herself from their embrace while at the same time rubbing her body against theirs.

  She was sending them mixed signals, and it was making them a little bit crazy. Nathaniel knew they had to be strong for her sake. She didn’t know it, but she had power over them already. He had never believed in bonding with a woman so quickly. It had always been pure lust. With Amber, it was so much more.

  “It’s new for us to want someone so quickly and without thinking through the consequences. It’s usually Markus that goes around acting half-cocked.”

  “You’re right,” Parker said, lifting his lips from Amber’s shoulder to look at his brother. “There’s nothing I want more than to spread her legs and taste her before we fuck her in every way possible. I can’t get enough of her scent, the touch of her skin.”

  Amber began to shiver in their arms. He knew her need matched theirs. Her whole body was on fire, and the warmth between her legs radiated outward and into him, filling him with a wanton desire that was obliterating whatever common sense he was trying to hold on to. But there was also a trace of fear laced with her lust—a heady combination.

  “We won’t hurt you.” Nathaniel didn’t want her to fear them, although their dominance sometimes triggered that in women who weren’t experienced in their desires.

  “I want you, and I’m not even sure what it is exactly that I want, but I want to taste you. I can’t seem to think about anything else,” she answered.

  “We understand,” Parker said huskily, nuzzling her neck. “But you need time, and we have to give that to you. But I warn you, we aren’t patient men.”

  “I feel like I’m on fire,” she moaned softly. “My nipples are so sensitive that just the texture of my robe rubbing against them is making my private place so wet that my thighs are wet, too.”

  “Dear God, Amber, do you really have no idea what you are doing to us?” Nathaniel groaned into her hair.

  “Nathaniel, we have to stop,” Parker said without conviction.

  “No, please,” Amber moaned.

  Nathaniel watched as she dropped to her knees, her fingers going to the button on his jeans and then his zipper. He knew he should stop her, but he was paralyzed with his need.

  She pushed his pants down along with his underwear as his hard cock sprung outward. He heard her sigh as her tongue licked the pre-cum forming at the tip of cock. Where was Parker? Why wasn’t he stopping this?

  He looked up and Parker was staring at them with his cock in his hand. Their eyes connected in unspoken agreement. Neither of them could stop what all three of them wanted, but for her sake, they had to try one last time. />
  Cursing himself for trying to do the right thing, he pushed her head away from his cock.

  “What did I do wrong?” Tearfully, she looked from one brother to the other.

  “You did nothing wrong,” Parker said softly from where he now stood beside his brother.

  “It’s us,” Nathaniel said, his voice full of regret. “We’re taking advantage of your inexperience. We want this, but we’re here in your grandmother’s house and you have so much to learn about who you are. It wouldn’t be right.”

  “But I want to taste both you. I know I’ve never done this before, but I know it’s what I want. Please let me do this. I need it. I can’t explain why, but if I don’t, I know I’ll regret it. Believe me when I tell you that there’s nothing I want more.”

  “I can only take so much,” Nathaniel said, his resolve weakening.

  Parker gathered Amber in his arms and took her to the bed. “It will be easier this way,” he said softly.

  Nathaniel followed and sat down while Amber kneeled between them. She undid the sash on her robe and let it fall around her.

  “You’re so beautiful,” Parker said in awe.

  “You make me feel beautiful,” she said as she lowered her head and wrapped her lips around his cock.

  Nathaniel watched as his brother closed his eyes in absolute bliss. Reaching out, he played with her nipples. He could feel her reaction. She was everything he could have ever wanted and more.

  When her mouth left Parker’s cock to lock onto his own, he knew it wouldn’t be long before he came. His whole body was shaking with his need. He was weak for her and he didn’t care. She was all he could think about. She was unbelievable going between the two of them with an urgency that mirrored their own need.

  When he knew he could no longer stop himself, he watched as Amber opened her mouth and took his cum down her throat. She had no qualms about swallowing what he was giving her.

  Smiling with lips covered in his cum, she gave her mouth to Parker, whose cock exploded in her throat. She seemed insatiable as she swallowed every drop of his cum and then began to lick them both until they were clean.