Appaloosa / Resolution / Brimstone / Blue-Eyed Devil

by Robert B. Parker

“Okay, Mr. Stroud,” Virgil said. “We’ll take a look.”

  “I liked that horse,” Stroud said.

  “See what we can do,” Virgil said. “Everett, try to find Pony.”

  I took the eight-gauge and headed for Pike’s Palace.

  An hour later the three of us were sitting on our horses, looking at Stroud’s dead horse. Pony climbed down and picked up the arrow that lay on the ground near the horse. He looked at it for a moment and handed it to Virgil.

  “Same thing,” Virgil said, and handed it to me.

  “No arrowhead,” I said.

  Pony circled the dead horse in steadily widening circles. Twenty feet from the horse, he stopped and sat on his heels and studied the ground.

  Then he pointed south, along the river.

  “Gone this way,” Pony said. “Come this way same.”

  “Okay,” Virgil said.

  We rode south along the river. The hoofprints were plain enough. I could have followed them, too.

  “Going fast,” Pony said after a while.

  I could see that the prints were deeper and farther apart, with a little rim of dirt pushed up in back of each print.

  “Why you suppose he didn’t kill that fella?” Virgil said.

  “Stroud?” I said. “I’m guessing he wanted us to hear about it quick.”

  “So we’d come out looking for him quick,” Virgil said.

  “Maybe,” I said. “Why would he be in a hurry?”

  “Mighta been a day, maybe longer, ’fore someone found the dead man and told us,” Virgil said.

  We rode in silence, following Pony as he tracked.

  “Probably took Stroud an hour to walk in from where his horse got shot,” Virgil said. “And it took us maybe another hour to find Pony and saddle up and get out here and look around.”

  “So, say he’s got two hours on us,” I said.

  “And he’s pushing his horse,” Virgil said.

  “Can’t push him forever,” I said.

  “Unless he got more than one,” Virgil said. “And even if he don’t, he can widen the gap between us.”

  “So he isn’t trying to walk us into an ambush,” I said.

  “Don’t seem so,” Virgil said. “He was doing that, he’d want us to catch up.”

  “He wants us out of town,” I said.

  “Seems so,” Virgil said.

  “We could head back to town now,” I said.

  “Yep.”

  “But if we’re wrong,” I said, “we lose the chance to catch him.”

  “Yep.”

  Pony turned to the riverbank, which was probably twenty feet high at this point.

  “Jefe,” Pony said.

  Virgil and I moved up beside him. Pony pointed at the horse tracks.

  “Into the river,” Pony said.

  “From here?” I said.

  Pony pointed again.

  “Horse go down,” he said.

  We looked at the gouges and drag marks in the riverbank. “Why not wait for the ford,” I said, “downriver?”

  “It’s what he’s hoping we’ll do,” Virgil said.

  Pony patted his horse’s neck.

  “We go down,” Pony said, and kicked the horse toward the bank. The horse balked. Pony kicked him again, leaning over the horse’s neck. He was speaking to him in Apache, too fast and soft for me to make any of it out. The horse went over the edge, front legs stiff out ahead of him, back legs bunched, and began to slide and scramble down the near-vertical slope, with Pony crouched up over his neck. Pony let the reins drape over the saddle horn and held on to the horse’s mane, still talking to him in Apache.

  And then they were down and into the river. It was deep here, so the horse had to swim. Pony slid out of the saddle as they went in and they swam together, with Pony’s hand on the saddle horn to the other side. When they reached the other side, I saw why the Indian had gone in here. There was a short strip of dry land at the foot of the far bank, and a narrow arroyo, cut by spring rains, that Pony was able to lead his horse into. We lost sight of them for a little while, and then they appeared at the top of the bank on the other side.

  “That would have been the place for the ambush,” I said.

  Virgil nodded.

  Holding his horse’s reins, Pony crouched again and looked at the sign. Then he swung up into his wet saddle and pointed north, back the way we’d come, and began to follow the tracks.

  I looked at the riverbank.

  “Nothing says we have to go across here,” I said.

  “Nope,” Virgil said. “But I’m thinking that one of the reasons he went across is if you went after him, you couldn’t get back.”

  “So you’d get back to town at least two hours after he did,” I said. “No shortcuts.”

  “Yep.”

  “But,” I said, “we ain’t over there, and if we head straight northeast, and don’t stay with the river, we can probably close that by an hour.”

  “And if we ain’t got it figured right,” Virgil said, “we’re leaving Pony to go up against this fella by himself.”

  “Pony ain’t no bank clerk,” I said. “ ’Sides, what would we do for him over here.”

  “You’re thinking ’bout the eight-gauge,” Virgil said. “With a Winchester I could hit a jackrabbit from here, never mind a big Indian in a black coat.”

  “So, which is it?” I said. “The town, or Pony?”

  “We get back to town quick as we can, we’re still an hour after him,” Virgil said.

  “And it don’t figure that whatever he’s doing, he’ll spend an hour doing it,” I said.

  Virgil nodded.

  “So, it’s Pony,” I said.

  “It is,” Virgil said.

  “Good,” I said.

  We rode north along the river, with Pony on the other side. At the ford near town, Pony stopped beside a riderless horse. The horse wore no saddle or bridle. Pony got down and looked at his hooves. Then he looked at the ground for a moment and got back up on his horse. He came across the river.

  “Other horse,” he said.

  “Hid him near the ford,” Virgil said.

  Pony was looking at the ground.

  “Ride him to town,” Pony said.

  “So he’s got a fresh mount,” I said.

  Virgil nodded.

  “Let’s see what he did,” Virgil said.

  And we rode into town, following the fresh tracks of the new horse straight down Arrow Street.

  39

  THERE WERE A LOT OF PEOPLE standing around on Arrow Street as we rode into town. There was a crowd in front of Pike’s Palace, looking at the shattered front windows in the swinging doors.

  Pike came out of the saloon and stood on the porch.

  “Pony,” he said. “Where the fuck were you?”

  Pony grinned and made a big circular motion with his hand.

  “Round and round,” he said.

  “And you fucking deputies,” Pike said. “Where the fuck you been?”

  With no expression on his face, Virgil looked at Pike for a long silent moment.

  Then he said, “Round and round.”

  “Fucking Indian rode in here, dozen people saw him, big as life,” Pike said. “Like he’s the fucking mayor or something. Rides right up Arrow Street. Hauls out a shotgun and unloads both barrels through my windows. You know how much those cocksuckers cost me? They come all the way from fucking Saint Louis, and that fucking red nigger blows them apart and rides out.”

  “Anybody hurt?” I said.

  “Couple of drunks got nicked,” Pike said. “They’ll live.”

  Virgil was looking at the street in front of the saloon.

  “Left him an arrow,” Virgil said.

  I nodded.

  “I don’t give a fuck what he left. What are you gonna do about it.”

  “We’ll probably chase him again,” Virgil said.

  “Don’t bother,” Pike said. “I sent Kirby and J.D. after him.”

  �
�Anybody else?” Virgil said.

  “J.D. and Kirby’s usually enough,” Pike said.

  Virgil nodded.

  “You know why this fella shot up your saloon,” he said.

  “ ’Cause he’s a fucking prairie coon, and he don’t know what else to do,” Pike said.

  Virgil nodded.

  “Figured there’d be a reason,” he said. “Pony, come on down to the office with us.”

  “I want Pony here,” Pike said.

  “None of us cares much what you want, at this here moment,” Virgil said. “Me and Everett are deputy sheriffs, and we’re planning to question Pony.”

  Pike looked at Virgil. Virgil looked back. The crowd began to open up a little. I stepped away from Virgil and rested the eight-gauge barrel up on my shoulder, and thumbed both hammers back. It was so quiet that I could hear the sound of cicadas singing.

  They sang for a while.

  Then Pike said, “Pony, when you’re through with the deputies, come on back here, if you would.”

  Pony nodded, and turned and walked down to the office with me and Virgil. Behind us, Pike went back into his saloon, and the crowd began to thin out.

  40

  “WHADDYA THINK?” Virgil said to Pony as we sat out front of the sheriff’s office and looked at things.

  “J.D. and Kirby town men,” Pony said. “Good with guns, but . . .” He shook his head.

  “Not so good on the prairie?” Virgil said.

  “No,” Pony said.

  “Not as good as the Indian,” Virgil said.

  “No.”

  “You as good as the Indian?” Virgil said.

  Pony nodded.

  “Better,” he said.

  The stage from Barrow went past, heading for the St. Louis Hotel, the big draft horses walking easily. The driver held the reins loosely. They’d made the run so often that the horses knew when to slow down and where to go.

  “This whole thing was supposed to get someone to ride out after the Indian,” I said.

  “Seems so,” Virgil said.

  “He didn’t go to all this trouble to get us out of town so he could ride in and shoot out Pike’s windows,” I said.

  “Think he wanted J.D. and Kirby?” Virgil said.

  “I think he wanted Pike,” I said.

  “Makes more sense,” Virgil said. “Don’t it.”

  “Certainly gotta be some reason he’s hanging around here,” I said. “ ’Stead of someplace else.”

  “Same reason,” Pony said, “coyotes around dead buffalo.”

  “Just that?” I said. “ ’Cause the killing is easy?”

  Pony shrugged.

  “Maybe,” he said.

  “Any reason he might have for killing people round here?” Virgil said.

  “Indian people always have reason to kill white people,” Pony said.

  Virgil nodded.

  “Indian always happy to kill white,” Pony said. “So this Indian come here and he kill cow and not much happen. Except he get some beef. Then he kill a man and steal his horses. He get to do something he like, and he get to take horses, and he get to look at you.”

  “Us,” Virgil said.

  “Yes, he get to see what you are like.”

  “Same with the women?”

  Pony nodded.

  “Kill white man, take white women, have white women, sell white women, see what you do.”

  “And now this,” Virgil said.

  Pony nodded again.

  “You think it’s about Pike?” Virgil said.

  “Maybe,” Pony said. “Maybe about you.”

  Virgil was sitting with his chair tilted back. He let it slowly come forward until it was flat.

  “He’s thinking we’ll come after him,” Virgil said.

  “Maybe,” Pony said.

  “So maybe it ain’t about Pike,” Virgil said.

  “Maybe about all,” Pony said.

  “Pike and Everett and me.”

  “Might,” Pony said.

  “You been with Pike a long time,” Virgil said.

  “Scouted for him in Army,” Pony said.

  “He done anything,” Virgil said, “you know about, might rile this Indian?”

  “Pike killed a lot of Indians,” Pony said.

  “But you work for him,” I said.

  “Half Mexican,” Pony said.

  “And half Indian,” I said.

  “Half Chiricahua,” Pony said. “Pike didn’t kill no Chiricahua.”

  “Who’d he kill most?” Virgil said.

  “Comanche,” Pony said. “Hell, I kill Comanche, too.”

  “Think this Indian’s Comanche?” Virgil said.

  “Don’t know,” Pony said. “It’s Comanche land. Arrow could be Comanche.”

  “But you don’t know,” I said.

  “Indian make arrow out of what he can find,” Pony said. “ ’Specially toy arrow he going to leave behind.”

  “Name’s Buffalo Calf,” I said.

  Pony shrugged.

  “Speaks English good,” Virgil said.

  “Me too,” Pony said.

  “Sometimes,” I said, “some Indians’ camp would get wiped out and they’d take a couple kids that survived and send them to Indian school. Teach them to be good Americans.”

  Virgil nodded. He sat silently for a while, then tilted his chair back again and looked at the street.

  “So maybe he’s after Pike because Pike killed some Comanches when he was in the Army,” Virgil said.

  “Not in battle, though,” I said. “Comanches see death in battle as honorable. Part of how things are. No reason to revenge such a death.”

  “So it would be something else, then,” Virgil said.

  “Maybe women, children, something like that,” I said.

  “Pony?” Virgil said.

  “Sí, jefe,” Pony said. “Comanche people, Chiricahua people, most Indian people, death between warriors honrosco.”

  “And maybe Buffalo Calf got scooped up and sent to school,” Virgil said. “And now he’s grown up and wants revenge?”

  Pony shrugged. I shrugged.

  “Could be,” I said.

  “So, if he’s after Pike, why all the rigmarole,” Virgil said.

  “Maybe he wants Pike to know it’s him,” I said. “And to think about it. Maybe it’s got some private meaning to him.”

  “And maybe we got it all wrong,” Virgil said.

  “And maybe we’ll never know, even when it’s over,” I said.

  “Sometimes you don’t,” Virgil said.

  “Even if you went to West Point?” I said.

  “Maybe even then,” Virgil said.

  “Disappointing,” I said.

  “Sometimes it’s just about shooting,” Virgil said.

  “Least we’re good at that,” I said.

  “And if it ain’t Pike?” Virgil said. “Why us?”

  “Power?” I said, and looked at Pony.

  Pony nodded.

  “He see you come look at first dead man,” Pony said. “He see you come take women back. See you have power. He kill you. He take your power.”

  “And Pike?” Virgil said.

  “He kills Pike,” I said, “we still have power.”

  Virgil nodded.

  “Complexicated,” he said.

  “Very,” I said.

  Virgil looked at Pony, who was looking at nothing and seeing everything, the way Virgil did.

  “Maybe J.D. and Kirby will get him,” Virgil said.

  Pony shook his head.

  “You with us on this?” Virgil said. “If they don’t?”

  “Yes,” Pony said.

  Virgil grinned at him.

  “You after his power?” Virgil said.

  Pony didn’t grin, but he looked like he might have.

  “Sí, jefe,” he said.

  41

  MARY BETH CAME INTO the sheriff’s office after lunchtime, mush-mouth drunk and weaving as she walked.

 
“Wanna report a man fuckin’ a child,” she mumbled.

  Virgil stood and went around his desk and eased her onto a chair. Then he sat on the edge of his desk right in front of her.

  “A man fucking a child,” Virgil said.

  “Used to fuck me, now he fuckin’ her.”

  Virgil nodded.

  “You thinking about what happened to you and Laurel, ’fore we found you?”

  “Naw,” Mary Beth said. “Brother Percival fucking us.”

  “You let him?” Virgil said.

  “I don’ . . .”

  Mary Beth slid suddenly off the chair. Quick as he was, Virgil got a hold of her as she went and broke her fall. He eased her the rest of the way down and she sat on the floor with her legs splayed.

  “Everett,” Virgil said. “Whyn’t you go see if you can find Allie.”

  I nodded and left.

  I found her in The Church of the Brotherhood, practicing on the organ. To me it sounded like a cow in labor, but I was never musical.

  “What’s wrong?” she said when she saw me.

  “Nothing bad,” I said. “Mary Beth Ostermueller is drunk and falling down in Virgil’s office.”

  Allie stood up.

  “Oh, God,” she said.

  As we walked down to the office, Allie said, “What is she doing there. What is she telling you?”

  “She was telling us that Brother Percival was fucking Laurel,” I said. “ ’Fore she fell off the chair and Virgil caught her.”

  “That’s ridiculous,” Allie said.

  “Said he’d been doing it to both of them,” I said.

  “Brother Percival is a man of God.”

  “I’ve heard even they do it, sometimes,” I said.

  “Not if they are holy men like Brother Percival,” Allie said.

  “He ever show any interest in you?” I said.

  “Of course he shows interest. He cares about my soul. He shows interest in everyone.”

  “Care about any of your other parts?” I said.

  “Everett!”

  When we were at the office, I opened the door and ushered her in. Virgil was at his desk, his feet up, his white shirt gleaming from the laundry.

  “Where’s Mary Beth?” Allie said.

  “Sleeping in a cell,” Virgil said.

  “What did she tell you?” Allie said.

  “Not much,” Virgil said.

  “Everett says she’s been accusing Brother Percival.”