The Kills

by Linda Fairstein

  "Unfamiliar number. I'll call it now," Mercer said.

  "You sure that was Robelon behind the wheel on Wednesday?"

  I rolled my eyes at Mike. "Please don't start second-guessing me. If you two don't believe in me, who will? I had a pretty good look at the guy and yes, it was Peter Robelon."

  "This is Mercer Wallace. Did you call me?" He was leaning against Mike's car and talking into his cell phone. He stood straight and gave us a thumbs-up. "Sure, I've got time to help you, Mrs. Gatts. No, no, I don't blame you for not wanting to talk to that homicide detective. Yeah, I can. Sure."

  "What kind of stroke job is he getting now from that tub of lard?" Mike asked.

  "The numbers joint on One Hundred and Eighteenth and Pleasant? You stay put in your house. I'm on it."

  "What's she got?"

  "Bessemer's back," Wallace said, pounding his fist on the hood of the car. "C'mon, unlock your batmobile and run me over to One Hundred and Eighteenth. Kevin Bessemer just showed up, high as a kite and looking to score. Drugs and the daily number. Sooner or later they all come back round."

  "You, blondie. Backseat. Buckle up and keep your yap shut. Maybe Kevin'll tell you who the real moneybags is behind the whole operation. Find who paid to hire Helena Lisi for Tiffany."

  Mike reached under his seat and lifted the red bubble dome to the dashboard. He tested the whelper to make sure it was working and wheeled out of his parking space, headed back to the northbound FDR Drive.

  Mercer was on the phone, calling the precinct to talk to the squad lieutenant. "Get your men over to Limpy's place. Kevin Bessemer, the snitch who-"

  The lieutenant didn't need a scorecard. He knew the players. Especially the one who'd taken himself out of the lineup.

  "Don't you want to grab him yourselves?" I asked.

  "And take the chance we knew where he was and let him get away again?" Mike said. "They'll hold him there for us and then we'll get to eyeball him."

  Mercer dialed again. "Limpy? Wallace here. That scumbag you got hanging out? Yeah, that's the one. The cavalry's coming. No, no, not to worry. They're not there to break your balls-they just want Bessemer. Don't let him outta your sight, okay?"

  "Why'd you give him a heads-up?"

  "Good guy, Alex. He's worked with us for a long time. Runs a pretty clean operation. Does numbers on the side. Just didn't want him to panic when the men in blue burst in. Limpy's bigger than I am, so Bessemer won't be going anywhere."

  "How's he going to hold down an out-of-control junkie, high on crack? He limps, no?" I asked.

  "Not his leg," Mike said. "Limp dick. That's how he got his name. Ex-wife gave it to him and it stuck."

  We were almost there when Mercer's cell rang.

  "Be there in two minutes," Mercer said. He repeated the rest of the conversation to us. "Bessemer's acting like a wild man. Limpy has him pinned in a chair in the basement with the cops at the top of the stairs."

  We pulled up to the building that housed the newsstand that was the front for the illegal numbers business. Mike and Mercer got out and went inside. I stepped onto the curb and explained to the two uniformed cops posted beside the open door that I was just waiting for the detectives to bring the prisoner out.

  I could hear Kevin Bessemer screaming at the top of his lungs. There was a sound like furniture crashing around the room, and Wallace's deep voice telling him, "Stop kicking, man. Stop breaking up the place. Calm down."

  They were on the staircase now and the scuffling noises continued, getting closer. Bessemer was kicking the walls and cursing.

  One of the cops felt it necessary to apologize to me for the perp's foul language. "That's the crack talking, ma'am. Sorry you have to hear it."

  Mike backed out of the store before the two detectives holding the cuffed prisoner. "You're the Kentucky Fried Chicken man, no? Two breasts and some wings-to go. Right out the fire escape with Tiffany. You ought to watch the Food Network more often, Kev," Mike said, faking a punch in his direction. " Bam!Take it down a notch, Kev."

  Mercer came out behind the prisoner. "Let's get him over to Met to sleep off his high. Psycho him before we think about going to court."

  Metropolitan Hospital was only a five-minute drive. The psych ward there had seen far worse than Kevin Bessemer.

  "So, Kev, tell the nice lady who your lawyer is. Your real lawyer."

  "I got the best money can buy," Bessemer screamed, twisting against his captors and kicking at the car tires on the RMP. "I got Clarence Friggin' Darrow. I got Johnnie Friggin' Cochran. I got Clarence Friggin' Thomas working for me. They gonna 'peal my case up to the Supreme Court."

  One of the cops grabbed the crown of his head and pushed it down, trying to get Bessemer off the street and into the patrol car as a small crowd began to gather.

  "What about Tiffany?" Mike asked. "Tell me who to talk to so Tiffany isn't left out there to swing in the breeze."

  "Fuck Tiffany," Bessemer shouted, lying back on the rear seat of the car and hurling his feet against the door as the cop tried to close it. "Tell that Spike Logan I'm coming back for a piece of what he got."

  37

  "I'll catch up with you two later in the day. Let me go on down to the hospital and sit by his bedside. Maybe when Bessemer sobers up, he'll be willing to talk to me," Mercer said.

  I got into the passenger seat and while Mike drove downtown toward my office, I tried to page the child welfare lawyers-Irizzary and Taggart-to learn what had happened at the meeting with Andrew and Dulles Tripping.

  The phone was ringing as I walked in. It was Peter Robelon. "You've got news?" I asked him.

  He was still angry about this morning. "Can we strike a deal? I act like a gent and you keep your goons away from me when you want to talk."

  "Depends on whatever deals you've worked out with Jack Kliger."

  Robelon was silent. It was obvious he had thought I didn't know that he was the target of an investigation in our office. "That's below the belt."

  "So is everything that's happened to this poor kid for his entire life. Don't use Dulles as a pawn, Peter. Why are you fighting to keep Andrew Tripping out of jail?"

  Why hadn't I played hardball earlier in the day? He seemed to be loosening up.

  "Look, Alex, the boy's meeting with Andrew didn't go as well as expected. Mr. Irizzary told me Dulles was-well-was kind of freaked out by his father."

  "And that surprises you? Your client's a very weird guy. So what's next?"

  Robelon was squirming. "The lawyers are considering another possibility."

  "Giving the Hoyts temporary custody?"

  "Yeah. They're taking him over to the Chelsea Piers where Hoyt's docked. Play some ball, shoot some hoops, let him go out on the river for the weekend."

  "Don't you think that's good for Dulles?"

  He was silent again.

  "Put aside your personal feelings for Graham Hoyt," I said. "Do you think he and his wife are sincere about wanting to adopt the boy?"

  "Actually, I do. Hoyt's a pretentious bastard, but he adores Jenna, and she's devastated about being childless. She'd be a great mother, and they both have a lot to give to Dulles-between Jenna's warmth and Graham's, well, material blessings."

  "Look, Andrew's your client, so I'm not asking you to say anything about him. But he's the last guy I'd want to see playing Mr. Mom."

  "Doesn't mean he killed anyone, Alex. Doesn't even mean he raped anyone."

  "We're just going around in circles. Thanks for letting me know the conversation is over," I said, ready to end it.

  "That's only part of the reason I called."

  "What's the rest?"

  "Any chance I could meet with you alone, just to talk over some ideas I had about Paige Vallis's murder? Just the two of us-no cops?"

  Not a prayer. "We're alone right now, Peter. Why don't you tell me what's on your mind?"

  "I'd prefer not to do it on the phone."

  "That's all I have time for at the moment."

&nbs
p; He didn't pause for very long. "Andrew has a theory."

  "I was almost ready to go along with you," I said. "His theories don't really interest me all that much, Peter."

  "Hear me out, Alex. The reason Paige Vallis left her apartment and went downstairs the night she was killed? It's about you."

  I sat up and started writing notes as he spoke. "That's ridiculous, Peter. If you're trying to make me feel worse about her death than I already do, then just keep on talking full-speed ahead."

  "It's true. We're sure of it."

  "'We' being you and that terribly unhinged psycho you represent?"

  "Listen for a minute. Andrew thinks he can prove that the reason Paige went downstairs from her apartment last Friday night was to mail a letter to you, to send something she needed you to know, to have."

  I was sweeping aside documents and law journals and case reports that had stacked up on my desk while I was out of town. Laura had sorted the mail from the past two days but I had buried it under the papers I had carried in this morning, so I looked for return addresses or unmarked envelopes that might possibly be from Paige Vallis.

  "Like what?" I was making more of a mess, agitated by Peter's suggestion.

  "I'm not sure, Alex. But Andrew-well, when I see you-"

  "I'll call you back later. Let me look around." There was also three days of mail at home that I had not even touched, other than to pay some of the bills.

  Mike had followed me in. "What'd that loser want?"

  "To see me alone. Without you-or my goons, as he so politely implied. He says Tripping thinks Paige Vallis ran into her killer on her way from sending some midnight missive to me. Does that make sense to you?"

  "That I'm a goon?" Mike was lifting papers and shuffling through things on my desktop. "Nah."

  "I mean the letter to me."

  "Like a suicide note? Like she sent you an apology for causing you such a hard time at the trial and then choked herself to death in her hallway? I don't think so."

  "I don't either. Wouldn't she have called to tell me what she wanted to say, or if she was frightened, left me a message that she was mailing me something?"

  "He's a whackjob, the Tripping guy. A complete paranoid. Next thing Robelon's going to tell you is that she sent you a letter recanting her allegations, saying she made up the whole story about the rape. That's what he and Tripping want you to believe. That and the fact that the mailman lost the letter."

  "You're probably right."

  "Sure I am. This way, you don't just dismiss the indictment against him in a couple of weeks, you get to exonerate him completely, with Vallis permanently out of the way."

  I looked up at Mike. "Good thinking."

  "Yeah, that one goes in the dead-letter department. What's next?"

  "I thought we'd take a ride over to Chelsea Piers. Try to catch up with the happy campers before the child welfare agency lawyers cut out. See what went wrong at this morning's meeting between Dulles and his dad, and what the thinking is about the Hoyts as prospective parents," I said, and filled him in on what Robelon had told me.

  "Nice day for an outing. Saturday afternoon on the river. Sure you didn't have enough water this week?"

  "The sun's out now, it's a crisp fall day. I'll spring for hot dogs. If we get lucky, Hoyt's chef'll cook you a meal."

  It was a little after one o'clock when we left the office and drove across Canal Street to get to the West Side Highway. "Don't ever tell my mother I took you to the Chelsea Piers. You know her and her superstitions. All bad things come in threes," Mike said.

  "So what were the first two?"

  "That's where the Titanic was supposed to dock on its maiden voyage, before that ice cube got in its way. And the Lusitania? She sailed from Chelsea on her regular run to London when the U-boat got her."

  "You look at the place now and it's hard to believe it was the world's premier passenger ship terminal once." We drove north to Twenty-third Street, crossing onto the Hudson River Boulevard and parking in one of the large lots.

  The Chelsea Piers, opened in 1910 to house the Atlantic's luxury liners, were a stunning urban design complex by the same firm that built Grand Central Terminal. The elegant row of gray buildings, edged with pink granite facades, took the place of a mess of crumbling, old waterfront structures of the nineteenth century.

  In both world wars, the piers became the embarkation point for soldiers heading off to battle. By the 1960s, when air travel had made most ocean crossings obsolete, the decaying buildings were converted to cargo facilities. And when that part of the business relocated to the ports of New Jersey a decade later, the once-grand piers were demoted to use as warehouses, car pounds, and sanitation-truck repair stations.

  By 1995, after a few years' work based on a proposal by three smart developers, the four surviving Chelsea Piers-numbered 59 through 62-were transformed through a $100 million project into a spectacular center for public recreation right on Manhattan's waterfront. Golf driving ranges, batting cages, roller rinks, bowling, an equestrian center, and a marina that could handle yachts like Graham Hoyt's were only some of the amusements available on the Piers.

  "What's your guess?"

  "Let's start at the boat. At least the crew is bound to be there, someone who should know where Hoyt and the kid are," I said.

  We took the promenade south of what they called the golf club and walked along yachts in the marina, looking for the Pirate. There was a warm breeze coming off the water, and although it seemed a bit choppy, it was deep blue and clean. A maze of small boats crisscrossed the river, and the commuter ferries worked the waves in both directions.

  Graham Hoyt saw us before we spotted him. He was behind us, coming from one of the other parking lots. "You have any jurisdiction on the high seas, Detective?"

  "Aye, aye, Cap-what do you need?"

  "Left here twenty minutes ago to take Ms. Taggart back to her car and answer some questions for her. Could have sworn I had ninety-eight feet of a fine-looking boat sitting right at the end of that dock," he said, pointing. "Grand larceny, I think."

  The small tender, the Rebecca, was tied up, but the slip for the larger vessel was empty.

  "Are you serious?" I asked.

  "Either that or my crew has mutinied, Alex. Maybe I worked them too hard on the way down from the islands."

  He was laughing, so it was clear that no one had made off with the boat.

  "Where's the boy, Mr. Hoyt?" Mike asked.

  "Jenna took him over to one of those buildings in the sports complex. Todd, our first mate, was going to hit some balls with him, just play and hang out. Let him be a kid for a change. Guess the captain decided to go for a ride in the meantime. Want to go have a look for Dulles and my wife?"

  "Sure."

  We retraced our steps at Mike's suggestion. "The batting cages are in the field house, up between the first two piers. Eighty thousand square feet of pure heaven for a kid. This was a good idea of yours. They've got hoops there as well as baseball and gymnastics equipment. You ever been here before?"

  Hoyt shook his head. "Only the marina."

  Mike was leading the tour. "That's the building where they film all the TV shows, you know, like-"

  "Graham!"

  A woman was screaming Hoyt's name at the top of her lungs. The first two times we each heard it and looked around, unable to find her among the hordes of adolescents who had taken over the Piers' activity centers on the busy weekend.

  "Jenna-what is it?"

  I turned and saw a diminutive woman running toward Hoyt. She was dressed in a T-shirt, cotton slacks, and sneakers. Her face was contorted into an expression suggesting she was in pain, and she was weeping as she came at us.

  "What's the matter?" he said, grabbing both arms and trying to calm her down. "Is it Dulles? Where is he?"

  She caught her breath and tried to speak. "He's okay. But it was frightening, it was terribly frightening."

  The more she tried to talk, the harder she cried.<
br />
  "Tell me what it is," Hoyt said, sternly now, enunciating each word between clenched teeth, ordering her to explain whatever had happened.

  "Mrs. Hoyt," I said, trying a softer approach by putting my arm around her shoulder and taking her hand in mine. "Please tell-"

  She ignored me and talked to her husband. "It was Andrew. That meeting he had with Dulles this morning, before Nancy Taggart brought him here? Andrew was angry that it broke up so abruptly."

  She stopped again to take some deep breaths.

  "Damn it," said Graham. "He just can't let go of the boy."

  "Andrew actually followed them here. That Taggart woman must be an idiot," Mrs. Hoyt said, her tears replaced by anger. "She led him right to us."

  "Did Andrew do anything? Did he go anywhere near Dulles?"

  "No, not that close. But-"

  "Where the hell were you? What was going on? Where's Dulles?"

  "I was sitting in the stands on the side, watching him play. I didn't even see Andrew." She was beginning to whine now, seeing that Graham was getting frantic over something that she had not been able to control. "Next thing I know Dulles looks up and just freaks out. He saw his father standing twenty feet away, just staring at him, holding on to the wire cage."

  Hoyt was looking all around now. "Where are they?"

  "It's okay, Graham. Todd scooped Dulles up and started running. Right to the boat. I-I couldn't keep up. I decided to try to block Andrew, to get in his way so he wouldn't be able to catch them."

  She pointed down at her torn slacks. She must have fallen and scraped her knee. There was still fresh blood. Hoyt didn't seem interested in her bruise.

  "Todd and the boy?"

  "I saw them get on the Pirate. I saw the captain pull out into the river."

  "Which way?"

  "North."

  "You sure?"

  She was pointing now, and the magnificent steel bones of the George Washington Bridge stood in the distant background as if they were painted against the sky.

  Mike and I were more worried about the fact that Andrew Tripping had begun to stalk his own child.