The Scarecrow: A Supernatural Thriller (Solom)

by Scott Nicholson

  Some old bits of hardware hung from pegs on the wall: a length of chain, stinky brown rope, a hackamore, rusty branch clippers, and a backpack spray tank that looked like a leftover prop from a Fifties big-bug sci-fi movie.

  She eased up the stairs. The second tread creaked like an arthritic toad. She paused, letting her weight settle. No sound from above.

  At the top of the stairs stood a rough door, sagging, the boards wired together. She thought she heard a soft thumping in the loft. She slipped out her phone and checked the signal. Barely a blip. She’d have to go all the way up.

  Sounds like the kind of last idea that dumb girls in horror movies get.

  The interior of the barn had grown darker, and no doubt the sun was just beginning its slide down Three Hump Mountain in the west. She used the light from phone’s screen to illuminate the top of the stairs. The loft was going to be dark and creepy. Maybe she should have just used the landline and dealt with it.

  Dad’s probably wasted anyway. He won’t even remember we talked.

  But she would. That was the point.

  A snort.

  From below. She looked down.

  Abraham stood on the barn floor, head lifted. Looking right at her. Jett could swear the animal was grinning, teeth glimmering wetly in the half-light, as if he could read her mind and knew all about the misery of a girl’s broken home.

  “Go away,” she mouthed. Goats were renowned eating machines, reducing forests to wastelands, eating the very fences that tried to hem them in. Maybe Abraham had a little bit of brains, since he didn’t seem to be in the middle of eating something at the moment.

  Abraham stared at her with those boxy pupils.

  Jett looked around, found a dry corn cob, and raised herself up to toss it. She flipped her arm forward and the cob spun end-over-end, striking Abraham just between the horns. He blinked and dipped his neck, grabbed the cob with his lips, and ground it between his teeth. The sound was like that of an alphabet block dropped into a whirring blender.

  “Shh,” she said. She looked about for something else to throw, maybe something with a little heft.

  The hinges rasped behind her. She turned toward the door, lost her balance, and grabbed for the rail. She almost dropped her phone. The door yawned, shadows pouring out to match those that had risen from the floor.

  The thing loomed, seven feet tall, a lantern in one gloved hand that cast flickering shadows up into a face she couldn’t see because of the straw hat pulled low. Its other hand held a darkly gleaming scythe.

  CHAPTER THREE

  Cabbage.

  Katy hated the stuff. When cooked, it stank almost as much as swordfish. But Gordon had grown it in the garden, and therefore it achieved all the sacred status of a sacrificial lamb. She could cop out and make slaw, a little mayo, celery seed, and paprika and she’d be done. But she wanted Gordon to know she had broken a sweat, and she might accidentally cut her thumb in the bargain and prove herself a worthy mountain farm wife.

  She lifted the heavy knife and was about to snick a fat green-white wedge when the scream pierced the air.

  Jett.

  Not from upstairs, so it couldn’t be Jett.

  Outside.

  Maybe the cat had gotten a baby rabbit. Katy had been startled by the first bunny scream she’d ever heard, on a Sunday morning several weeks back. It was the keening of a raped woman, the grunt of a gutted man, and the mournful wail of an abandoned child all rolled into one. Gordon had chuckled at her leap from the bed. “City girl,” he’d admonished.

  But Gordon wasn’t here and this was no laughing matter.

  The scream came again, and this time it did sound like Jett, and it came from the barn, muffled by the chestnut walls.

  Time for Supermom without a cape, her uniform stained blue jeans and beige sleeveless blouse instead of blue-and- red tights with a yellow S stretched across her boobs.

  She burst onto the porch, raising the knife as if she meant business.

  Katy made a direct line toward the barn, kicking away the dormant lilies that had grown around the Smith house for decades. She plowed through the garden, her flip-flops throwing up brown bits of dirt and dead vegetation. The gate was at the end of the driveway, but it was thirty yards out of the way. The fence was right in front of her, sparkling silver in the sunset, but seemed as ephemeral as a spider web. Her heart beat monkey rhythms.

  Where was Jett?

  She was unaware of leaping the fence, though one foot had probably reached the top strand of hog wire, but she stumbled on the other side, the knife flying from her hand as she fell to her knees. The barn rose before her, a haunted vault of straw and cow manure, as ancient as the family that had erected it. Her daughter, her life, her soul was in there.

  She scrambled to her feet and found the knife. Her breath was a sick series of dry heaves in her chest. As she entered the barn, she raised the blade like a talisman.

  “Jett?”

  No answer, only the wooden echo of her pulse.

  The inside of the barn had gone to a bruised shade of purple with sunset.

  Creeeeeek.

  The loft.

  She squinted and found the stairs and was halfway to them when a blur of motion came from her left.

  “Jett?”

  Katy’s gasp tasted of dust. She stepped back as the body fell from above, its arms flailing in the half-light, the waist bent at an obscene angle. She cringed, waiting for it to fall in a splintering heap of bones on the crooked steps. Instead, the body bounced and sprawled on the dirt floor at her feet. She jumped away, slamming her back into a locust support beam.

  The body was too large to be Jett’s. It was face down, the limbs askew. Katy waited for breathing or a wheeze of pain to come from the twisted figure. After a few moments of silence, she eased forward and nudged the body with her toe. It moved with a rodent rustle, too light to be flesh and bone.

  Katy knelt and touched the flannel of the shirt, then lifted the head. Straw and cotton spilled from a split seam in the clothing. It was a scarecrow, mildewed and ragged. Her ascent up the stairs must have dislodged it from its seasonal slumber dangling from a rusty nail. A length of braided hemp rope was tied in a noose around its neck, the top end frayed. The head was a burlap sack stuffed with wads of gray cotton, with two burned holes for eyes and a ragged stitch of a smile. Its straw planter’s hat had rolled away, a jagged crescent torn in the brim as if some animal had taken a big bite.

  Maybe Jett had seen the scarecrow and thought it was a person and freaked out, just as Katy had done. After all, Gordon had told her the legend, too, and Jett’s face had gone pale while listening, making her black eye shadow even more dramatic.

  But there were worse things than legends. Like drugs. What if Jett had scored some molly or crystal meth, something that turned reality into a rocket ride down a nightmare chute to hell?

  “Jett?”

  Footsteps drummed on the loft floor above. Boots, too heavy to be Jett’s ankle-high black leather things.

  Katy mounted the steps, glancing at the four chicken-wired windows on the lower floor, wishing more of the fading sunlight would pour through and burn her fear away. But she had little room for fear, because worry took over. At the top of the stairs, she eased up the little metal hasp that kept the door fastened. She gathered chickens and sometimes fed the livestock, but she’d rarely visited the loft.

  Too bad she wasn’t Supermom for real. X-ray vision would come in handy right now. The light was a little better up here, thanks to the large triangles cut into each end of the barn. Uneven squares of dirty blonde hay were stacked around like an autistic giant’s alphabet blocks. Stalks of tobacco dangled upside down at the far end of the barn, speared on poles, the drying leaves like the wings of reddish-brown bats.

  Could Jett be playing some bizarre game of hide-and-seek? She wasn’t the type to scream. If Jett wanted to get attention, she usually came up with some mind-blowing observation or another. But Katy had been neglec
ting Jett in favor of Gordon lately, even though Jett’s world had been shaken more than anyone’s by the move to Solom.

  “Okay, Jett,” she said. “Fun’s over. Come on out.”

  She heard a giggle, or maybe it was only a breeze rifling the parched tobacco.

  “Dinner’s probably burning,” Katy said. “If you thought the swordfish was bad, wait until you smell scorched cabbage.”

  Katy felt silly holding the knife, so she tucked it behind her back as she headed between the rows of hay. The air was as thick as snuff, motes spinning in the shafts of dying sunlight. A few loose piles of hay were scattered here and there, near the black square holes in the floor through which silage was thrown down to the animals. Katy expected Jett to jump from behind a stack at any moment, or burst up from one of the hay piles in a sneeze-inducing spray of gold. Good prank, except that would spoil dinner. She wanted Gordon in a good mood, so maybe they could finally finish consummating their marriage.

  “Cute, honey. We can have a good laugh over the dinner table.”

  No answer. The time Jett had taken acid in Charlotte—after lying to Katy about spending the night at a friend’s house—she’d stayed out alone until morning, hiding in a storm sewage pipe, showing up late for school the next day, dirty, wild-eyed, and ravaged by insects. Katy, who was called to the school, had picked her up, taken her to the doctor, and let the school psychologist give the lecture. The divorce was to blame, of course. Katy was to blame. Something in Jett had changed after that, a drifting look in her eyes, a secretive smile that spoke of more journeys to come. Hopefully this wasn’t one of them.

  Katy made her way through the maze of bales to the far end of the barn. She looked through the triangle to the wooded hills above. A few goats dotted the slopes, browsing in the brush at the edge of the forest. In the adjacent meadow, separated by a stitch of fencing, cows worked the grass, their heads swiveling, ears twitching against the insects.

  “Jett, seriously. Don’t make me get mad.” She tapped the knife against a post. “The scarecrow trick was a good one. Spooked the living daylights out of me. I bet you can’t wait to tell Gordon.”

  No answer. Maybe Jett had already slipped down the stairs and was waiting at the dinner table, or in her room, cheeks swollen with the laughter she was storing up. At any rate, Jett was fourteen and could find her way to the house with no trouble, even in the dark.

  But that scream—

  It hadn’t sounded like a joke.

  If there had even been a scream. Maybe, like the perfume in the kitchen or the footsteps that had no legs, the scream had been nothing more than invisible smoke. The farm wasn’t haunted. Despite the way Gordon’s first wife had died.

  This is silly. Katy decided she would check on dinner, and if she didn’t see Jett in the house, she would grab a flashlight and return. Without the knife.

  “Okay, Jett,” she yelled, annoyed at herself, her words stifled by the hay. “I’m going back to the house. And I’m never going to let you out of my sight for the rest of your life. Plus you’re grounded until you’re a hundred and twelve.”

  The lower floor of the barn was darker as she descended the stairs. The air was as cool as a cellar. A soft, moist sighing arose from the packed floor. She swallowed hard and took another step, nearly slipping to fall alongside the prone scarecrow. Something large and pale moved in the shadows, and Katy tightened her grip on the knife.

  Damn Gordon and his mountain legends. The one about the haunted scarecrow, in particular. About how it only walked at late harvest, when the corn was turning hard and brown and the first frosts settled on the land. According to legend, the scarecrow climbed down from the stake where it had hung all growing season like a neglected Christ on the cross. Then it dragged itself into the barn, where it feasted on one of the animals, filling its dry throat with fresh blood. Sustained until winter, the scarecrow then returned to its stake, though on moonlit nights you might see rusty red spots on its sackcloth head. Gordon’s eyes glistened as he’d told the story, and Katy had given the uneasy laugh he expected in response.

  This was the right time of year. And the scarecrow that had fallen at her feet looked just like the one that leaned broken and sad in the cornfield at the end of the vegetable garden.

  No. That was just a mountain folk tale. Not a wives’ tale, because no wife would be so stupid as to pass along a story like that. Katy could come up with a rational explanation. Holder of a business degree from Queen’s College, assistant to the board of directors at the Wells Fargo branch, she was made of stern stuff. Almost boring but ultimately practical.

  So THINK.

  Surely a big farm like this one had several scarecrows. Gordon’s family had probably saved them, the same way frugal farm families had always hoarded things that could be used again. Besides, it was just a sack of straw. Flannel and old denim and scraps. No matter the legends.

  The dim outline of the scarecrow made a lesser darkness on the floor, the gray socks of the feet poking out of the jeans, gloves at the end of each sleeve. The left sock, the one closest to her, twitched.

  The wind, had to be. Except the air was as still as sundown.

  Katy put out her own foot, meaning to kick the sock in case a frantic mouse was inside and upset that its nest had been disturbed. The straw toes flexed and curled, then the foot kicked back at her.

  The scarecrow would rise to its elbows and knees and haul itself off to eat a chicken or pig or maybe even a cow, ready to gnaw with those teeth—what would its teeth be?—kernels of giant, hardened corn, piercing flesh and grinding bone and—

  The boots sounded above her again.

  She hadn’t imagined them. Despite her hallucinations in the house, she wasn’t losing her mind. Scarecrows didn’t move by themselves and her new house wasn’t haunted.

  Crumbs of straw fell in a snow between the cracks in the flooring planks above. Someone was up there for real.

  The barn door beckoned. Twenty steps and Katy would be out of there, away from animated scarecrows and footfalls and demented goats.

  And away from Jett?

  Katy paused, heart like a horseshoe in her throat.

  She couldn’t leave Jett here, even if she was playing right into Jett’s little joke.

  The barn had grown darker, the sun settling behind the trees on the ridge line, fingers of deep red light reaching across the valley. The footsteps above had ceased. Katy’s palm was a wooden knot around the knife handle. What good would a knife do against an animated scarecrow? Even if she shredded the cloth, dug into the chest and found the ragball heart, would that even slow it down? Or would it keep crawling, rubbing against her, choking her with its chaff, that uneven grin never changing?

  A knock came from one of the stalls. It was soft but insistent, like the hammering of a dying rain.

  “Jett!”

  Katy hoped to God Jett was back in the house. Even if the house was haunted, it couldn’t be worse than this creepy hell-shack of a barn. Katy backed away from the scarecrow twitching before her. Hallucinations and fleeting visions were one thing, and maybe a transparent woman walked the Smith house, but now she was dealing with a stack of rags and silage that did everything but talk.

  Katy backed away, but the thumping in the stall was behind her. Whatever was making the sound couldn’t be worse than the scarecrow. It had stopped moving, but she was sure it was holding its breath, waiting for her to come closer, tensing its fibrous muscles and licking its corn-kernel teeth with a parched tongue.

  She turned and made for the stairs. Maybe if she reached the loft, she could signal Jett and tell her to go for help. Except what kind of help was there against a living scarecrow? Calling Ghostbusters and requesting a smarmy Bill Murray and his team to take the next flight down?

  Gordon would be home any minute. He would know some mountain saying or folk spell to cast on the scarecrow, a secret passed down through the generations. That was the way these things worked, wasn’t it? Evil countered by a g
ood and courageous heart?

  But if those were the weapons, what chance did Katy have? Her own heart was dormant, and besides her feelings for Jett, hadn’t been used much in the last few years. She loved Gordon, but was no longer sure what the “L”-word meant. She couldn’t really love God because of all the things He had visited upon her, but she was trying hard for Gordon’s sake. But if Gordon, or God, or even Bill Murray, could get her and Jett out of this barn, she would kiss his ring until the end of time.

  The stall door opened to her right, and Abraham the goat emerged from the inky depths, his eyes glittering. He ignored Katy and went straight toward the scarecrow. The wad of dead vegetation probably smelled like a gourmet feast to the goat. Katy climbed three steps, stopping on a warped tread to watch the encounter.

  The scarecrow regarded the goat with something approaching curiosity, as much as that expression could be suggested by the blank, stitched-up face. The eyeholes were filled with only darkness. Ascribing human characteristics to the face was nothing more than projection, but Katy couldn’t help it. She had seen its foot move. She’d heard the legends.

  Abraham’s nostrils flared, then he lowered his head and approached the scarecrow, the horns curled flat against his skull but still menacing nonetheless. Twenty feet separated the two creatures—a little voice inside Katy admitted she had already accepted the scarecrow as an organic part of this strange, ancient world of Solom—when the boots sounded upstairs again.

  “Jett?”

  Please, God, let her be safe in the house.

  Except why should God listen to Katy? He was probably enjoying this little show.

  Abraham reached the scarecrow, which lay still and prone like a willing sacrament. The billy goat sniffed at the stuffed sock, lowered its bearded chin, and nudged the toes. Katy expected the scarecrow to kick out, to sit up and dig its teeth into the furry neck. Instead, Abraham clamped his teeth onto the sock and tugged, lifting the sock free, showering straw across the ground.