Beast Brothers: A Stepbrother Sports Romance

by Stephanie Brother

  We need to talk, Cody texts me. I know you’re avoiding us, and I know you lied to us on Sunday. What’s wrong?

  I ignore the sharp jab in my stomach. Nothing, I tell him. I just have a lot on my mind.

  Brock is blunter: Did we hurt you?

  That feels even worse. I can’t bear for them to believe that. No, I answer. That was the most amazing experience of my life.

  Then what the fuck is going on? His frustration is almost a physical thing in the room with me, his words searing themselves on my heart.

  I just have a lot to think about. It’s a lame excuse and I know it, but it’s as close to the truth as I can come.

  He doesn’t answer, but I know that’s not the end of it, and I’m right. On Saturday, I get another text from Brock: Tomorrow, after the game, we’re talking. No excuses, no hiding. If you try to get out of it, we’ll find you.

  Behaving Like a Stepsister Should

  Megan

  From anyone else, those words would frighten me and then send me into a rage. They give me a shiver, all right, but not of fear. Because the hell of it is, he has the right to demand that of me. I know it. I thought the twins didn’t understand what happened that night in all its fulness, but maybe they were more aware of my emotional state than I realized.

  On Sunday, I’m filled with a mix of trepidation and reluctant excitement at seeing Brock and Cody again. But this particular Sunday brings with it an added discomfort: Jason.

  The Leopards are taking on the Mammoths today, and though I hope to, at most, only see Jason from across a crowded stadium, just knowing he’s in town has my nerves on edge.

  I ride in with Dad again. To my surprise, he didn’t lose it over the sudden appearance of a new car in his driveway. Whatever the twins told him, they must have finessed it really well. He can’t help but notice that I’m not actually driving the Mustang, but he’s preoccupied with the team’s upcoming schedule, so he doesn’t push it. I’m sure he’d prefer that I not accept anything from the Beast Brothers anyway.

  If he only knew.

  I take my seat in the stands early, and wait for Tara and Zoe to join me. They’re not huge football fans, and they probably won’t come to every home game, but I told them I needed their moral support and they promised to be here.

  As the stands are just starting to fill, I feel someone sit down beside me. Expecting to see one of my besties, I’m surprised to look up and find Vivian.

  “Hi, Megan. Mind if I join you?” Her voice is sweet, and I bristle inwardly, but of course I tell her she’s welcome, because what else can I say?

  “How are you settling in, dear?” she asks as she gets situated in her seat.

  “I’m not, really,” I say. “I’m still waiting for the insurance payment on my car, and I’ve been job hunting without much luck.” I’ve also had life-changing sex with your sons and have since been avoiding them, I think as I inwardly cringe.

  “I’m so glad you’ve moved back home,” she says.

  I stiffen, and any reply I might have gets stuck in my throat. Maybe she means she’s glad I moved back to town, but it sounds like she’s talking about the house I grew up in as if it’s her home too, and it’s not. But it soon will be, I remind myself. It’ll be hers more than mine.

  “I’m really looking forward to all of us being a family,” Vivian continues. “You and Brock and Cody seem to get along so well.”

  Oh god, if you only knew how well we get along.

  Though I’m not ashamed of what the three of us did, and I have zero regrets, I can’t help feeling uncomfortable talking to the twins’ mother after being so intimate with them. All the more reason why I can’t have that particular kind of fun again with my stepbrothers-to-be.

  Vivian keeps on talking and I’m grateful she’s not expecting much in the way of a response. “Your dad is so happy you’re back,” she says.

  Before I can stop myself, I snort. “You could have fooled me. You heard what he said about me leaving Jason.”

  She smiles at me sympathetically and briefly touches my knee. “He just worries about you. That’s what dads do. He loves you so much.”

  A rush of heat fills my chest. I know that’s true. I know he does. I don’t know why things seem so difficult right now.

  “You’ll understand someday. It’s not always easy being a parent. I had a lot of struggles with my sons.” Vivian laughs softly to herself. “I always wanted a daughter.” She looks at me and smiles. “I hope that you and I can be close, and have girl time together.”

  I can’t help but look away. I pretend to find something extremely fascinating out on the field while she continues. I didn’t think Vivian was such a talker. She seems to have stored all this up and she can’t stop.

  “I’ve made a lot of mistakes in the past, and I feel so lucky that I found your dad. He’s been so wonderful to me, not like any other man I’ve known.”

  I risk a quick glance at Vivian and see that she looks sincere.

  When I give her a brief nod, she takes encouragement and continues. “I know he’ll always love your mom, and that’s how it should be. I don’t want to replace your mom. I just want to make him happy. I hope you and I can be friends too.”

  Tears sting my eyes, and it’s not just the pain of missing my mom. I’m also struck by the emotion in Vivian’s words.

  As I search for the right response and try not to cry, I see familiar faces coming up the aisle. I wave to them, grateful for the interruption. “Tara! Zoe! Over here!”

  As they approach, Vivian begins to stand. “I’ll leave you with your friends. Maybe I’ll see you at dinner tonight?”

  On impulse, I reach for her arm. “Don’t go. Sit with us. My friends really like you.” It’s a small gesture; I’m not prepared to respond to everything she’s just said to me. But the way her face brightens at my invitation, you’d think I was the one who asked her to marry me.

  The Leopards trounce the Mammoths. We were favored to win, but the final score is a complete embarrassment for Omaha.

  For most of the game, I forget that Jason is even out there. He doesn’t get any play until the fourth quarter, and just like anytime I’m in their presence, the Beast Brothers draw all my attention.

  I even decide it’s okay for me to cheer hard for them today. Vivian will just think I’m being supportive of her sons, and she cheers even louder than me anyway.

  It’s late in the fourth quarter when it happens. Cody’s covering Jason, and intercepts a pass meant for him. He runs it back a few yards before the Mammoths tackle him, and as he gets up Jason’s in his face, shoving him in the chest.

  Vivian and I rise simultaneously to better see what’s happening, but by then the referees have surrounded them. Jason is ejected from the game, and the Mammoths are penalized 15 yards for a personal foul. Cody appears to be unhurt, but the whole thing leaves a sour feeling in the pit of my stomach.

  When the men have separated and Cody walks away, Vivian leans in and yells above the roar of the crowd. “You may not realize it yet, but I think you dodged a bullet with Jason.”

  My jaw is still tight with tension but I somehow feel lighter when I yell back at her, “I think you’re right.”

  Dad and Vivian make dinner plans at Donohue’s, the fanciest steakhouse in town, for all of us after the game. It crosses my mind to come up with an excuse not to go, but it’s game day, we just won, and I can’t think of any plausible reason to miss the celebration. It also seems that sharing a meal with them after home games will become a tradition, so I may as well start getting used to seeing Brock and Cody and behaving like a stepsister should.

  Tara and Zoe give me a ride to Dad’s so I can change into something nicer than the jeans and jersey I wore to the game. “Ohmygod!” Zoe yells as soon as she spots the Mustang. “I thought you couldn’t afford a new car!”

  “I can’t,” I grumble. “The twins bought that.”

  My friends look from me to the car to each other, then back at me
.

  “I’m not accepting it,” I explain. When they exchange looks again, I add, “Let’s not talk about it.”

  They know I’ve decided that I can’t be with the twins again, and they’re supportive as always, but an odd silence seems to hang in the air as we go inside.

  I’m already in an off mood, and looking through my closet, seeing outfits that I bought when I was with Jason, dresses I wore on dates with him, just makes me feel worse.

  Though I tried my best not to think about him today, Jason being in town reminded me of how I wasn’t enough for him. I thought I was all he needed, but he demonstrated in the most graphic way possible that I wasn’t.

  What happens if I’m not enough for someone else? What if I make more bad decisions, like I did with him? And even though I’ll treasure my memories of the twins forever, getting together with them was arguably not the best decision I’ve ever made.

  My friends are sitting on my bed and they can’t help but notice my posture slumping as I stand looking at my clothing, not really seeing anything.

  “What’s wrong, Meg?” Tara comes over and puts a comforting hand on my shoulder.

  “I don’t know,” I say. It’s all too much to put into words.

  “Rough day? she says. Though none of us mentioned Jason’s name all day, his presence hung in the air.

  “It’s time for a fresh start,” Zoe says, joining us at the closet. She starts flipping through outfits, and finds the purple dress she bought for me last week.

  “That? Tonight?” I say, remembering how unexpectedly sexy it looks on me.

  “Why not?”

  When we shopped for the dress, my friends pictured me wearing it for Brock and Cody, but tonight I’d be wearing it for myself. I admit that I could use the ego boost the dress will bring. Maybe the bold color will also help me to be strong in the presence of the Beast Brothers.

  If they flirt with me, I need to resist. I have to tell them we can’t be together again. And when they move on, I’ll need to pretend I don’t care. I’m not sure which will be harder.

  Right to the Bone

  Megan

  An hour later, the three of us are riding the elevator up to the restaurant in the tallest building downtown. My friends look fabulous — Tara in a little black dress and Zoe in a green one that brings out her eyes.

  They helped me style my hair. My curls are pulled up on the sides, and the rest falls to my shoulders and frames all the cleavage that the dress exposes. “We could go out after, to a club?” I say.

  “I have to be at work early tomorrow, but I can manage a few hours,” Tara says.

  “We all look too good to keep it to ourselves,” Zoe agrees.

  Even though my besties didn’t argue with my decision to break things off with the twins, I have the impression Zoe doesn’t completely agree. Still, she’ll probably be trying to fix me up with someone new before the night is over.

  I’m not ready for that, but I could definitely use a night out dancing with my friends.

  I see a few other Leopards players as the maître d’ shows us to our table. The restaurant is the best in town, and apparently a popular spot for post-game dinners. I also see a few other guys I vaguely recognize from the Mammoths, and I hope like hell that Jason isn’t here.

  My nerves pick up as we approach our table. Dad and Vivian are already there, and so are Brock and Cody. Damn! They look so good. They always look good, and it was painful watching them play today, but now I’m just a few feet away from them and they’re all cleaned up, carefully groomed, and wearing dark suits and ties that only emphasize the fact that they’re the best-looking men I’ve ever seen.

  Zoe is in front of me and Tara behind me, but Brock and Cody’s eyes are only on me. One look at them, and I know I’m facing an uphill job. Their eyes are full of heat — and steely determination.

  Maybe this dress wasn’t the best idea. I don’t want to tease them. I don’t want them to think I’m dressing up for them, and then refusing to be with them.

  Reality check. Who am I kidding? They could have a line of women at their door anytime they want. Maybe the dress is cutting off circulation to my brain.

  My dad and my stepbrothers-to-be all rise as we approach the table. Cody steps forward, gives brief hugs to Tara and Zoe, and then turns to me, that lustful gleam still in his eyes. His embrace is brief, nothing to attract suspicion, but he voices two small words in a husky whisper at my ear. “That dress.”

  Two little words, and I instantly have a vision of him peeling this dress off of me, of my breasts spilling out for him, of his mouth … oh god, this dinner is going to be so much harder than I imagined.

  Brock manages to deliver a subtle yet inappropriate squeeze when he greets me. “Bootylicious,” he whispers in my ear, and all my inner muscles tighten.

  He’s right that we need to talk, but it isn’t going to go the way they expect. I need to tell them we can’t be together, and I need them to stop tormenting me. Thanks to our parents, we’ll have to be around each other for years to come, and that won’t be possible if they don’t behave.

  As if being near them isn’t hard enough, I somehow end up seated right between Brock and Cody. My besties try to intervene, but the twins aren’t having it.

  From where I sit, I can smell their clean, deliciously manly scents. Their suit jacket sleeves brush against my arms every time they move, and I can feel the heat radiating from their bodies. And though they keep their hands above the table, their feet tangle with mine, pulling my legs apart. I’m getting wet for them, despite my best efforts to remain unaffected.

  Tara and Zoe give me looks from across the table. I can’t quite read their expressions — Sympathy? Support? Maybe with a little friendly jealousy mixed in from Zoe?

  Then I see Tara’s eyes widen at the same time I hear a familiar voice behind me. “Megan, I need to talk to you.”

  The voice of my asshole ex cuts right to the bone.

  I turn in my seat and see him. He’s alone, just a few steps away and coming closer.

  “Why haven’t you been answering my calls?” he says. He doesn’t sound as bad as he did during his drunken phone calls, but neither does he sound completely sober.

  Speechless, I look Jason over and realize I don’t feel one bit of sadness or regret. Only anger and dread.

  He reaches me and puts a hand on my shoulder, but Brock knocks it away before I even have a chance to register what’s happening.

  Braver than I’d have given him credit for — or maybe just stupider — Jason ignores Brock and tries again to reach for me. “Megan, I need to talk to you. In private.”

  “I’m not interested, Jason. Go away,” I tell him. I try to turn in my chair to face him, but I don’t have much room to move.

  “No, you’re going to talk to me,” Jason persists. He yanks at my arm, and Brock and Cody are both up and in his face in an instant.

  Get Me Out of Here

  Megan

  Vivian gasps, and I notice that my dad is on his feet too, but Brock and Cody have effectively formed a wall between Jason and the rest of us. I can’t see him at all; I can only hear his voice, which grates on me and fills me with disgust.

  “Are you with these two now, Megan? Is that why you left?” Jason says loudly.

  I can’t see beyond the twins, but from what I can see, everyone in the restaurant is looking at us. At first I’m completely startled that Jason seems to know that I’ve been with Brock and Cody — I’m at a family dinner, not eating with just the two of them. Why would he jump to that conclusion? How would he know?

  And then I remember the late night phone call. The one that Brock answered and then crudely told Jason that he was fucking me. Oh god. It seemed so funny at the time, such beautiful payback, and now it’s come back to haunt me.

  It also startles me that Jason is including both of the brothers in his accusations. He’s probably heard stories, though. Not about me, but about other wild exploits Brock and Cody h
ave had.

  “Did you leave me for these guys!?” he persists.

  I see movement and hear struggle, and then Brock and Cody start to move away from the table, each of them holding one of Jason’s arms. He’s so outmatched, it isn’t even funny. Each of the twins could restrain Jason with just one of their arms.

  I jump up to follow them. I feel responsible, and I’m afraid of what Brock and Cody might do to Jason. I also need to get away from the table. I can’t even chance looking in my dad’s direction.

  The guys are moving quickly, and I’m wobbling a bit on my heels, so I don’t catch up until they’ve moved out of the dining area, through the lobby, and down a vacant side hall that leads to restrooms and who knows what else.

  The twins still have ahold of Jason; he’s struggling to no avail. When he sees me, he tries to pull free. “Megan! Call these creeps off of me!”

  “Guys, stop!” I say. “He’s not worth it.”

  Jason’s voice is tortured and full of hate when he continues. “You fucking the Beast Brothers, Megan? Is that why you left me?”

  At that, my anger erupts. “I’m not the one who cheated, you asshole!” I yell.

  Cody turns to me, his eyes dark, his entire posture threatening. “Megan, you don’t need to see any more of this loser. We’ll deal with him.”

  As he’s talking to me, Jason kicks him, striking out in the only way he can, and Brock responds by twisting Jason’s arm up behind him, making Jason wince.

  “You weren’t even gone twenty-four hours and you were already fucking someone else,” Jason says with a sneer. “Wearing a slutty little dress and fucking players from another team!”

  “That’s enough, asshole.” Brock twists Jason’s arm up further, causing him to cry out.

  “That’s enough, all of you.” My dad’s voice is sharp and stern and cuts through me like a knife. I didn’t even realize he’d followed us.

  He glares at Brock and Cody until he’s satisfied that they’ve stopped hurting Jason, and then he looks at me. “Is it true, Megan?”