Perfect Match [Ménage.com 2] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Peyton Elizabeth

“You,” Elise whispered, wanting nothing more than to have one of them inside of her. She didn’t care anymore that they didn’t know she was a virgin. In the back of her mind, she knew that by the time they figured it out, it would be too late. It didn’t matter to her. She wanted them.

  “Then you’ll have us, sweetheart.”

  Both men released their hold on her body so that they could stand up and shed their clothes. Seeing their naked forms in the sunlight was like one of her cover arts come to life. They were beautiful. They were sensual. They were hers. Their golden skin glowed in the sunlight, while the sweat that ran down their chests glistened in the heat.

  Dakota must have pulled a condom from his jeans, because he was tearing a packet open with his teeth. She watched as he placed the rubber to his tip, pinching the end with his fingers and then rolling it down his shaft. His cock was long, so the latex stopped shy of his base by a couple inches. She would have loved to have found out what he tasted like. Knowing now that she wasn’t going to get that taste, she switched her sights to Chad. His cock was just as impressive, although instead of length, it was his width that was massive.

  “I need to have one quick taste before I take you,” Dakota informed her, sinking to his knees in between her spread legs. “Chad got to lick the dew from your pussy first, but I’ll be the one to feel what it’s like to sink my cock into your moist heat.”

  Dakota leaned down, swiping his tongue from her anus all the way to her clit. His actions were so quick that she hadn’t realized his intention until he had already done it. She had never felt a tongue in that forbidden area before, but the wetness against her anus was simply so naughty, it had her right on the edge of where Chad had left her moments before.

  Dakota brought his lean body over hers and placed his tip at her entrance. She looked up into his blue eyes and, for a brief second, thought she saw their future. Elise knew that she was in danger of losing her heart, but she tried to brush those warning signals far from her brain. Looking past him to where Chad was still standing, she saw that the sun was situated directly behind him and knew she had failed at her task. His skin seemed to glow, making him look like an angel sent down from the heavens. Was this where she was supposed to be?

  “Look at me,” Dakota ordered, his voice tender. “I want to see your eyes as I take you.”

  Dakota pushed past her moist folds, his cock sliding right in from the aid of her wetness. The fullness he created wasn’t enough. She couldn’t believe how greedy she’d become in just two days, when yesterday morning, one tiny vibrator had been enough. She lifted her hips to accept more of him but knew the exact moment he realized he’d encountered a barrier. His blue eyes widened in shock, and his mouth opened and closed a few times. She was so afraid he’d stop, that she wrapped her legs around his waist and locked them at her ankles.

  “Please don’t stop,” Elise begged. “It’s okay. It’s no big deal.”

  “No big deal?” Dakota said hoarsely. “Elise, you’re a virgin!”

  “What?” Chad sank to his knees on the blanket. “Dakota, pull out. This isn’t the time or place for her first time.”

  “No, this is perfect. I want this.” She reached out and with one hand, grabbed onto Chad’s leg. With her other, she latched onto Dakota’s shoulder. “This is exactly how it should be. And it’s only a thin piece of tissue. Please don’t place any importance on it.”

  Dakota went to pull out again, but Elise held fast. Digging her fingers into his muscles, she leaned up and captured his lips before he could pull away. What could she say that would make them continue?

  “Importance?” Dakota asked as he ended their kiss.

  “Do you understand the significance of the gift you are giving us?” Chad asked, laying down beside her and causing her fingers to break contact with his leg. He made up for it when he leaned down and kissed her, stroking her hair away from her face. The loving act was so tender that for a second, she contemplated what she was doing.

  “This doesn’t change anything, though,” Elise whispered, hoping that what she was about to say wouldn’t change their minds. “I still need to leave.”

  “This changes everything.” Dakota shifted above her on his arms, causing his muscles to flex. It also caused his dick to pull out a half inch, making her clamp her legs tighter around him. “If you want us to continue, then you have to agree to give us a chance. We can’t let you walk away from us, especially after a gift this special.”

  Chad shocked her when he slipped his hand between her and Dakota, his fingers finding her clit with amazing accuracy. She felt her juices slide out around Dakota’s cock, into her ass cheeks. Her pussy clamped down on his dick, begging for more. Would it be so bad to at least consider what they were offering?

  Elise tentatively nodded her head, not breaking eye contact with Dakota. His eyes deepened into the cobalt color she loved so much. Chad started to rub her clit in circles, his fingers sliding over the engorged button. Every time he made a complete circle, her pussy pulsated. Why wasn’t Dakota moving? His cock was just sitting inside of her, not moving forward or back. She tried to arch her hips to get him to thrust, but he maddeningly followed her every movement.

  “Why won’t you move?” Elise questioned, both hands now on Dakota’s shoulders. Her fingers sunk into his skin as far as they could go.

  “In time, honey,” Dakota assured her. “Right now, let Chad make you feel good.”

  “I couldn’t feel any better,” Elise said in a frustrated voice. “But you’re going to be hurting really soon if you don’t start to move.”

  Dakota let out a strained laugh. Chad was doing magical things with his fingers, but when he dipped his head to run light kisses up her neck, a shiver passed over her. What was it about these two men that she couldn’t get enough of? Instead of stopping at her shoulder, Chad continued down until he caught her nipple in between his teeth.

  “Ah!” Elise whimpered. “Chad, make him move!”

  Chad chuckled, while something like a groan passed Dakota’s lips. Rasping his tongue over the pebbled tip, Chad kept up the stimulation while increasing the pressure on her clit. Out of the clear blue sky, which is what she was staring at from slinging her head back, the orgasm hit her with the intensity of a tornado. Her body felt as if it were flying, as if it were sailing through the sparse clouds above her like an eagle gliding with its wings spread wide open. The freedom she found from her little red convertible was nothing compared to the freedom she found in their arms.

  Chapter Eight

  Dakota felt her pussy clamp down on his cock before Elise probably knew what was happening. He watched as her body arched into Chad’s hand, her head thrown back as her body had its release. Using the pulsations of her pussy to his advantage, Dakota thrust through her barrier and sunk deep into her sheath. Her heat surrounded him, stealing his breath away.

  He had to hold himself still so he didn’t embarrass himself by coming so soon. His sac drew up close to his body, and it took several deep breaths before he had himself under control. Damn, but she was beautiful in the throes of passion.

  Her muscles slowly relaxed, although Chad was still manipulating her clit. He knew she had to be extra sensitive on her bundle of nerves. Her fingers finally let up from his shoulders, not that he was complaining, and she brought her face back down to where he could see her expression. He couldn’t help but give a strained smile in return.

  “Wow,” Elise whispered. “That was nothing like in my books.”

  “That was nothing compared to what you’re going to feel next,” Dakota promised, slowly pulling out of her. Elise tried to use her legs to keep him where he was, but Dakota knew that if he waited any longer, she might lose her momentum. “Honey, let me move. The hard part is already done.”

  “What?” Elise gave him a confused look, but her face turned to wonder as he slid back home. “Oh!”

  “That’s right. You were enjoying your orgasm too much to feel the slight pain I caused,”
Dakota informed her, gritting his teeth. He wasn’t sure how many strokes he could get in before he shot his load, but he would do his best. He wanted her to remember this for the rest of their lives. Her gift to them was something they would never take for granted. He started a slow rhythm, wanting her to get used to the movement. “Feel how perfect we fit together. And when the time comes and we get to take you together, you’ll see just how perfect.”

  “Hmmm—why not now?” Elise whispered, still looking euphoric.

  “Because this is your first time and we want to take things slow. We need to get you used to our bodies.” Dakota saw that Chad leaned down to nibble on her beaded nipple. “Chad, help us out here.”

  Chad must have listened and pressed harder on her clit, because Elise arched back up, causing his cock to slide deep. He started a slow thrusting, and Chad kept aiding them in adding that extra stimulus to make sure she was sent over the edge with him. Even through the stretched latex, her heat seamed to sear into his dick. Increasing his rhythm, Dakota felt his sac draw up tight against his body. It was her screaming out their names that sent him over the edge. With each rope of cum shooting into the latex, her pussy would clamp down and seem to draw another one out. When he thought he couldn’t come any more, her cunt closed tight around his cock, sucking out one last jet.

  “No,” Elise protested, as Dakota went to pull out of her. Her legs had wrapped around his waist and must have been crossed at the ankles, as he couldn’t lift off of her. “Stay inside of me.”

  “Then Chad wouldn’t get to experience the slice of heaven I just did.” Dakota leaned down and captured her lips. As her body relaxed against his, he slowly slid his cock from her pussy. “That’s right, just relax and let us take care of you.”

  * * * *

  Chad had never witnessed anything more beautiful in his life. Elise was wearing nothing but her sexy librarian glasses. Her blonde hair surrounded her beautiful face like a halo, while her body was pure sin. Her plump breasts were more than a handful, and her nipples were just the right size for suckling. The light, wet curls matched her hair in color and, since it was so light, made her pussy seem like it had a sheer material laying overtop just waiting to be taken off. Chad couldn’t wait to be the one to shave her cunt, knowing from experience how much more sensitive it made a woman.

  While Dakota was stroking Elise, bringing her down from such an intense release, Chad readied himself with a condom. His dick had never been so hard. It throbbed like the worst headache, only the pain was tortured pleasure. He gritted his teeth to keep himself in check, as he wanted her to experience another release. Her body would need time to recover after this, but knowing that he and Dakota had made her first time enjoyable made him the happiest man on earth.

  Dakota had rolled to his side, reaching down for the used condom. Chad saw the traces of blood outlining the latex. Looking down at her pussy, her dewy folds looked like a rose petal that had bloomed. He lowered his body on top of hers. Elise opened her baby-blue eyes, and Chad swore he saw his life within them. She was the key to their happiness. If they could just convince her to turn the key, that room contained their future.

  “Sweetheart, are you too sore?”

  For a moment, confusion swept over her face and then cleared. She smiled and reached for him. Having those tiny hands caress his chest and then come to rest upon his shoulders was like being tucked into a cozy bed at night. Chad leaned down and buried his face into her neck. The heat level was rising and they were covered in sweat, but the warmth enveloped them, adding to the intimacy.

  “No,” Elise murmured. “I want to feel you inside of me.”

  Chad wanted her to be the one in control, not wanting to hurt her. Her pussy was so wet that the tip of his cock was sucked right into her tight hole. Pushing in slowly, he heard her swift intake of air. No matter what she said, he knew that she was tender. He took a hold of her waist and flipped her. She gave a yelp and placed her palms onto his chest.

  Dakota was lying next to him. His brother reached up and took a nipple in between his fingers. He saw the little nub swelling under the pressure at the same time that her pussy clamped around his cock.

  “You lead this time, Elise. Take whatever pleasure you want.” Chad gritted his teeth as she started to rotate her hips, instead of using an up-and-down motion. “That’s right, sweetheart. Make yourself feel good.”

  While Dakota played with her nipple, Chad reached down and pressed a thumb against her clit. It needed no lubricant, as she was soaking wet. His thumb slipped across the engorged pearl, causing Elise to pick up momentum.

  “I need—” Elise’s voice broke off, as if she couldn’t take any more pleasure.

  “What do you need, sweetheart?”

  “I—don’t—know,” Elise answered, although her words came out punctuated. She had started to lift up on her knees but hadn’t found the steady pace Chad knew she needed. “More.”

  Chad helped her by bucking his hips up as she was coming back down. His cock slammed into her, making her cry out. She lifted farther up, this time crashing herself down upon him. It must have been what she needed, as she took over. Her left breast was bouncing, while her right lay in Dakota’s hand. He had yet to release her nipple and was now pulling on it.

  Releasing his right hand from her hips, but keeping his left thumb directly on her clit, Chad reached behind her. He was going to come the second she came down upon him. The pressure in his balls was sweet agony, but he needed to make sure she came with him. He and Dakota were alike in that aspect. Their woman’s pleasure came first.

  Seeking out what he wanted, Chad used his middle finger to tease her dark hole. Elise gasped, but didn’t make a move to stop him. Taking that as a sign that she was okay with anal play, Chad used her juices to ease the tip of his finger past her tight muscle. The second he breached her anus, Elise came slamming down on top of him. Her upper body went still while her lower half trembled. The muscles in her legs quivered as her body found the pleasure it was seeking.

  Chad let his body have his release, his cock exploding into the condom with such a force, he was afraid it would break. They both rode the wave of ecstasy, letting it carry them away. Ever so slowly, Elise lowered herself down until she was lying flush with his body. He slipped his finger out of her, although his cock remained enclosed inside her pussy. They were both breathing hard, their skin sticking together because of the sweat that now coated their bodies.

  “Wow,” Elise whispered against his neck.

  “I second that,” Dakota murmured. Chad glanced at him, and he saw his brother had his forearm draped over his eyes. The sun was beating down on them, and if they didn’t get Elise out of it soon, she was going to be red in places that had never seen color. “When we get our strength back, you better be ready to give an explanation.”

  “Yes,” Chad agreed, stroking her back, “that was quite a shock, sweetheart. Not that we are complaining. A gift like that…” Chad let his words trail off.

  “It’s not—”

  “If you say it’s not a big deal, your ass will be red, and it won’t be from the sun,” Dakota warned.

  Chad grinned, knowing Dakota would indeed spank her ass. Dakota had an edge that Elise hadn’t seen yet, and Chad mentally rubbed his hands together at the two of them butting heads. Dakota was a planner, as he had shown by this morning’s get-together with their parents. And when things didn’t go as planned, Dakota usually resorted to things that got the job done. Chad liked to place actions in motion, knowing a few schemes never hurt anyone as long as the results were positive and everyone was happy.

  “Fine, I won’t say that,” Elise said. “But I will say that it still doesn’t change the fact that I need to leave soon.”

  Chad mentally started to count to five, knowing Dakota wouldn’t take that long to explode. He got to three.

  “Excuse me?” Dakota sat straight up, looking down at them. Chad knew better then to interrupt Dakota when he was about to get o
n a roll. His brother really needed to learn to be a little more laid back, but now wasn’t the time to tell him that. “You aren’t going anywhere, honey, especially after someone attacked you.”

  “I have a life, and the fact that we had sex doesn’t change anything.”

  Elise pushed herself off of Chad’s chest, groaning when his dick slipped from her pussy. He could see from where he was laying that her labia was swollen and well used. He liked that look on her. Dakota’s raised voice brought his focus back to the conversation at hand.

  “If I remember correctly, you agreed to give us a chance,” Dakota yelled, standing up. He must have taken off his condom at some point, because the latex was missing. His brother picked up his jeans and shoved his legs inside, bringing the denim up. Chad figured now wasn’t the time to mention he hadn’t put his briefs on. “And if you think you can renege on that decision, think again!”

  “I will give you guys a chance, but that doesn’t include me staying in town,” Elise argued, scrambling to a standing position. Chad put his arms behind his head, looking up at both of them under hooded eyes. Life with them was going to be very interesting. “You can e-mail me and call me.”

  “Woman, you are one word away from getting your ass spanked. E-mail or phone? Are you crazy?” Dakota reached down and grabbed his shirt. He shook the shirt at her, as if that would stress his point a little farther. “You will stay with us, just like you did last night, until this guy is caught. Whatever hang-up you have on relationships will have to change, because down here in Triple, we take a woman’s innocence to heart.”

  “What is this, the nineteenth century?” Elise grabbed her clothes and started to shove her limbs inside. “And don’t think for a second I don’t know why you brought me to your parents’ house this morning. But just because you’ve shown me one marriage that has succeeded, don’t think that changes my mind. A hang-up? Seriously?”

  “You’re lucky we don’t run your ass over to the church right now!” Dakota thrust his shirt over his head.