The Sleep of Reason

by C. P. Snow

  “I suggest we are all ready to take a certain amount for granted.”

  “This is a complicated structure, my lord.” Bosanquet spoke mildly, but he didn’t budge. “I require my pieces of bricks-and-mortar.”

  “Spare us anything you don’t require,” said the judge, with a nod which was resigned but courteous.

  The garage manager’s mystification: she (Cora Ross) could have put it right in ten minutes. She was a first-class mechanic herself.

  Next witness, Detective-Constable Hallam. He was raw-boned, quite young, and as he stood in the box his head was bent down towards his hands. His pertinacity about the car. “I was not satisfied,” he said, for once raising his head. His manner was stern but guilty-seeming, he hesitated over answering matter-of-fact questions. Gradually Bosanquet’s junior, young Archibald Rose, dug the story out of him. How he hadn’t been satisfied. How at the garage he thought something was strange. How he made enquiries all along the half-mile between Eric’s home and the recreation ground, asking if a green Morris had ever been seen. When had the car first patrolled that route? (That couldn’t be answered, but it might have been as much as a month before September 20.)

  The young constable, who had been a halting, unhappy witness, was given a special word of approval. Without him, it might have taken much longer to look in the direction of Rose Cottage.

  Statements from persons who had noticed a green Morris, read in a strong voice by the Clerk of Assize. “I saw this car when I was getting home from work, but did not take its number…”

  A detective-sergeant in the box, the first search of the cottage. The piece of Meccano. Exhibit. A plain-clothes policeman, standing by the clerk, with a stiff robot-like movement held up his hand. From where I sat, just a glint of metal. Then he exposed it on his palm. The gesture was as mechanical as the plaything. An ordinary object, prosaic and innocent: yet it did not seem quite real, or else had its own aura. An object like Davidson’s capsule.

  “Was this the piece of Meccano you discovered in Rose Cottage…?”

  “It was.”

  Another detective-sergeant (the cottage and garden had been crowded with them). The Meccano box. Exhibited. The plain-clothes policeman went through his drill.

  “Was this the box you discovered in the garden of Rose Cottage…?”

  “It was.”

  The shop assistant at the Midland Educational Company. The bill for a Number One Meccano Set.

  “Is this bill dated September 18?”

  “Yes, sir.”

  “Do you remember selling this set?”

  “Yes, I do.”

  “To whom did you sell it?”

  “To the one sitting there–” She glanced at Cora and away again.

  “That was on Wednesday, September 18?”

  “Yes, sir.”

  Bosanquet asked her to make sure of the date. “I’m sorry to press this, my lord, but you will see what I am establishing–” The judge turned to the jury. “Bricks-and-mortar,” he said. He sounded affable and half-sardonic: but he was being fair to Bosanquet, underlining that this was evidence of intent. Following him, Benskin tried to shake the identification, but the girl was both gentle and strong-willed, and he got nowhere.

  Witnesses, names, occupations, addresses, came, went, were forgotten, a random slice of the town. One stood out, a Mrs Ramsden, who testified about seeing a boy being driven in the car. She was plump, with a sharp nose poking out of the flesh: as a girl she must have had a cheerful, impertinent prettiness. As soon as she gave evidence, she gave the impression (much more so than any of the policemen) of being a natural witness. She was one of those people, and there were very few, who seemed to be abnormally observant and at the same time scrupulous. Yes, she had seen a brown Austin driving out of the city on the evening of September 20. What time? She could be fairly exact: she was hurrying home for a television programme: about 5.45. Where was this? Not far from the recreation ground? A few hundred yards away. What did she notice? A small boy sitting between two people in the front seat. She didn’t know Eric: from the photographs, it could have been him, it looked very like him, she couldn’t be more positive than that. A woman was driving the car. The other person in the front seat? Might have been a man or woman. Fair-haired, wearing dark glasses. What was the boy doing? He seemed to be waving. He might have been struggling? He might have been, but she didn’t think of it at the time. She thought that he was laughing. The person with dark glasses had an arm round him? Yes, round his neck. Like this? Bosanquet beckoned one of the plain-clothes policemen, who, sheepish and red-faced, had his neck encircled by counsel’s arm. There was a titter, tight and guilty, the first that afternoon. Both defence counsel cross-examined. Kitty’s, a young silk called Wilson, his actor’s face hard, masculine, frowning, was trying to demonstrate that the boy had gone willingly. Benskin, that the kidnapping might have taken place much later. To most people in the court, none of this could matter, it only dragged out the strain. All those who were used to courts of law would have known by now, though, that they were struggling with their instructions, though I for one couldn’t be certain what any of them were hoping for.

  When Mrs Ramsden had left, the judge coughed, and said in an amiably testy fashion: “I see the clock has stopped.” Heads turned to the back of the court. “I make it,” said the judge, “very nearly half past four. I don’t want to go much beyond the half-hour, Mr Bosanquet. I hope you can be brief with the next witness. After all, no one challenges the fact that the boy was taken by car to Rose Cottage. That is so, Mr Benskin, Mr Wilson?”

  For the first time, Bosanquet conceded the point. He left the witness – who swore to sighting the car near Rose Cottage on the Friday evening – to his junior, and within minutes the judge was bowing himself out of court.

  It had been difficult to feel, since the end of Bosanquet’s speech, how much people in the courtroom had been anaesthetised by the sheer mechanics of the trial. We soon knew. As we walked with George through the entrance hall, there was an air of hostility which, like a blast of freezing wind, tightened the skin. Then came, not loud, but menacing and sustained, the sound of hissing. George threw his head erect, jamming his hat further back so that his forehead was exposed. The hisses went on. They were not directed at him as a person (at the time I didn’t think of it: all I wanted was to lead him through the angry crowd). He wasn’t well enough known in the town for that. But he was connected with those two, and this was enough.

  We got him into the street. There were no taxis anywhere near, and we had to walk half-a-mile, people following us, women shouting at him, before we found one. On the way to the station, where Margaret had to catch a train back to London, none of us spoke. When we came in sight of the station building, the red brick glared like a discord in the spring sunshine.

  While I paid off the taxi, George stood mute by Margaret’s side. Then he said: “Well, I’d better leave you now.”

  No, we each told him, he must wait and see her off.

  “I’d better leave you now,” George repeated.

  We looked into his face. It was wild, his eyes gazing past us: and yet, how was it different from lunchtime, what did his expression mean?

  “I don’t want you to, you know,” said Margaret.

  “I think I’d better. I’ve got some things to do.”

  Without even glancing at each other, we thought we couldn’t press him any further. “I’ll see you tomorrow, then?” he said to me. “Of course,” I replied. He said to Margaret: “It was very nice of you to come,” and kissed her.

  When we were alone in the booking hall – the smell of damp wood and train smoke so familiar to me, but that evening bringing back neither homesickness nor meaning – Margaret said: “That must be the worst of it over, mustn’t it?”

  Her eyes were sharp with pain. All I could say was that I didn’t know.

  Down in the refreshment room, gazing at me across the marble table, she was saying that she was glad I was stay
ing with the Gearys. That had happened because Vicky and her father had by this time left the Residence. Margaret had spent the previous night with me at the Gearys’ house; she had liked them and trusted them more than she did usually at first sight. She wasn’t being entirely protective; she would have welcomed their good nature for herself as well as for me; she had been appalled by that day in the court. Before she went through it, she had imagined what it would be like. She had believed that she would be stronger than I was. Now she didn’t want (and this was true of the reporters and police officers, more used to the horrors of fact than the rest of us) to be alone.

  We were sitting there fidgeting with the glasses on the table, as we might have been in a love affair that was going wrong, articulateness deserting us, pauses between the words.

  She said: “Could we have taken it?”

  After a gap, I said: “I’ve told you, sometimes I am afraid that one can take anything.”

  “I wasn’t thinking only of the little boy.”

  I nodded.

  “I was thinking of the parents. If it had been ours–”

  I didn’t need to reply.

  In time, she went on: “And I was thinking of the parents of the others. The ones who did it. If they had been ours–”

  Slowly I said: “Perhaps there, life’s a bit more merciful. Somehow one might cover it up or make excuses–”

  “Do you really believe that?”

  When the London train drew in, she clung to me on the platform until the whistle shrilled.

  The Gearys’ house was right on the outskirts of the town, in a district which had been open fields when I was a boy. Small gardens lay in front of the neat semi-detached pairs on both sides of the road: junior managers lived there, as well as modest professional men like Denis Geary. He and his wife were waiting for me in their sitting-room, bright, well-kept, reproductions of Vermeer and Van Gogh on the walls, on the mantelpiece photographs of their children, groups of the family on holidays abroad.

  A copy of the local evening paper under the bookshelf. Headlines about the trial. As he stood up, handsome, grizzled, Denis pointed to it.

  “Now,” he said, “you’ve got to forget all about it.”

  He was years younger than I was. But he was talking benevolently, as though I were a junior teacher on his staff, coming to him with some domestic trouble.

  I said that it wasn’t so easy.

  “Lewis, you’ve got to forget about it.” He went on, it might have happened anywhere, it had absolutely nothing to do with the normal run of things, we just had to wipe it out of our minds.

  I wasn’t used to being spoken to paternally. Not many men had ever tried to father me. But Denis was one of this world’s fathers, and I didn’t resent it.

  “He’s right, you know,” said Alison Geary.

  “I promise you,” said Denis, “that we’ll look after anything practical when it’s all over. We’ll look after old George as far as we can.”

  Yes, they would visit the Patemans and the two young women, wherever they were sent. It was all in the line of duty. They had visited criminals before now, they took it as naturally as talking to me.

  Denis said: “Now forget it and have a drink.”

  They had observed, at those dinners at the Shaws’, that I enjoyed drinking. They had laid in more liquor than would be expected in a headmaster’s house and more, I couldn’t help thinking, than they could comfortably afford. But I wasn’t saving their pockets when I told them that, in times of trouble, I drank very little. It was true. They were so kind that I was confiding in them.

  “I think I can understand that,” said Denis. He said it with fellow-feeling, as though he had gone through dark nights. Just for an instant, I wondered if he were more complex than he seemed. Heartily he came back: “Still, you must have a little.”

  They set to work to distract me both then and through dinner, which, as on the night before, was a delectable English meal. The Vice-Chancellorship – Denis guessed that I might still be made interested in jobs. They hadn’t yet found a successor to Arnold Shaw. They had offered the post to Walter Luke, but he had turned it down. Why? Denis replied, straight-faced: “He said that he didn’t want to become a stuffed shirt.” I couldn’t resist a grin: that sounded like the authentic Walter. Someone asked him if there were other reasons. Denis said, still straight-faced: “He said he couldn’t improve on the one he had already given.”

  Comprehensive education – they were both campaigning for it, it meant that our old school, Denis’ and mine, would cease to be a grammar school. “But it’s the only answer,” said Alison eagerly. “It really is.” She was as devoted a radical as her husband; she brought out all the arguments of the day. The lives we were wasting: we three had been lucky in our education, though we hadn’t thought so, we had been lucky, compared with the neighbours round us. This was the only answer. It was also good politics; the public wanted it, whatever the Tories said, and that was nothing against it; but the point was, it was right.

  Although she had been talking to distract me, she was committed. Her bright sepia eyes were shining: it was easy to imagine her, quick-stepping, full-bodied, tapping at the voters’ doors.

  She couldn’t raise an argument. She spoke about their children. The daughter had been married that winter. Did they like the man? He’s a very good chap, said Denis, we think they’re very happy. Where were they living? He was a schoolteacher in the town, said Alison.

  “Well, you did the same,” said Denis, with an uxorious grin.

  “He’s an extremely nice man,” said Alison. “He’ll make her a good husband.” Then, as though she couldn’t help it, her face changed. It began to wear an expression I had not seen in her before – was it wistful or shamefaced?

  “But I always used to think she’d do something different, after all.”

  “She’s going to be happy,” Denis told her, like one repeating himself.

  “Yes. She’s a pretty girl,” Alison turned to me, “though I am her mother.”

  From the photographs, that I could believe.

  “She’s got a lot of imagination too. She always used to be reaching after something wonderful. I used to think that she’d finish up by marrying – well, someone like André Malraux.”

  It seemed a curious dream: even though Alison, determined to be practical, explained that she meant, naturally, a younger version of M. Malraux. The Gearys’ marriage was one of the happier ones: but what Alison dreamed for her daughter, she must, of course, once have dreamed for herself.

  They didn’t stop working to snag my interest until, very early, I went up to my room. Through the open window came faint scents of the spring. Clouds rushed across the sky, unveiling stars. At the bottom of the garden there were no houses in sight, only a range of trees. The moon, rising above one level branch, was just turning from silver to gold. In some moods that sight would be a comfort or a cheat, telling one that there was an existence more desirable than ours.

  I might have remembered, though I didn’t, someone who refused to take false comfort. We did not exist outside out of time. Those were only words which drugged us, which made us blind to our condition. He said to me, on just such a night as this, that he hated the stars.

  I stayed at the window, looking out at the night sky.

  27: An Impermissible Term

  THE next morning, I arrived early in the entrance hall. Through a side door I could see the courtroom, already nearly full. There was not such a queue outside as on the first day. Lawyers hustled by, swinging their briefcases, on the way to robe. Then, as I stood about, George Passant, also early, joined me. After his loud greeting, which hadn’t varied in all the years, his first remark was: “I’ve been thinking, I don’t think I shall fag to come in today.”

  I was so surprised that I hardly noticed the old-fashioned slang.

  “You won’t?”

  “I don’t see any point in it today.”

  His manner was bold, defiant, diffid
ent, like a young man’s. As I looked at him, I didn’t understand. Other people in the hall were looking at him, but there was no demonstration. One might have thought he was frightened of another crowd like that of the night before, but I knew that wasn’t true. His courage was absolute, as it had always been. He was saying that tomorrow or next day, they might be getting somewhere. Then I believed I had it. He had been working out the progress of the trial. This morning or afternoon, which he wanted to escape, the medical evidence would come into court. That, though he couldn’t tell me and was brazening it out, he wasn’t able to endure.

  “I think that I shall stay,” I said.

  “Well then,” said George with relief, “I’ll see you later on.”

  After I had watched him leave, I asked a policeman to take a message to the Deputy Sheriff enquiring whether he could still find me a place. Before the answer came back, I saw, and this was another surprise, for at that time I hadn’t been told of the telephoning between him and Margaret, my brother Martin. He wasn’t smiling, but he said: “I thought you mightn’t mind a bit of company.”

  I recognised the clerk from the morning before, polite and welcoming. Yes, of course there were two seats. Yes, of course the Deputy Sheriff would be delighted to invite Dr Eliot. The clerk led us down a corridor behind the court, narrow and white-painted, past the judge’s room, out to the official box.

  From there our line of sight was only just above the level of the lawyers’ wigs. We had to look up to see the crowd in the rake of the court, heads lit up by the long windows behind them. The row of barristers, the next row of solicitors – suddenly they reminded me of ministers on the front bench in the Commons, their PPS’s whispering to them: I might have been watching them, as I had done often enough from the civil servants’ box, but the angle was different, for it was like being on the wrong side of the Speaker’s chair.

  Somehow we were in an enclosure with the professionals, part of the machine. An official sitting beside us gave us piles of typescript, records of the police court hearing, depositions.