There is No Alternative

Home > Other > There is No Alternative > Page 36
There is No Alternative Page 36

by Claire Berlinski


  Powell, Colin

  Prices inflation and in Soviet Union. See also Retail price index

  Privatization Graham on of mining Thatcherism and in United States

  QE2. See Queen Elizabeth 2

  Queen Elizabeth 2 (QE2)

  Quintus Fabius Maximus

  Railway workers

  Reagan, Ronald on armament on Cold War election of “Evil Empire” speech by Falklands War response of Faulds on funeral of Gates on Gorbachev, M., and Hoskyns, J., on Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty signing by Kinnock and on Korean airliner downing Kremlin and Labour party and Lawson on Powell, Charles, on at Reykjavik summit SDI and on Socialism on Soviet Union Soviet Union economy effect of Thatcher., M., and

  Recession

  Referendum: on EEC on European Constitution

  Regeneration schemes

  Rentschler, James

  Resolution

  Retail price index

  Reykjavik summit

  Riley, Andrew

  Rimington, Stella

  Riots: at Orgreave in Turkey unemployment-related Whitelaw on

  The Road to Wigan Pier (Orwell)

  Romney, Mitt

  Rotary Club, of Grantham

  Rousseau, Jean-Jacques

  Royal, Ségolène

  Rumsfeld, Donald

  Russia. See Soviet Union

  Safety, in mining

  Sakharov, Andrei

  Saltley coke depot

  Sandinistas

  Sarbanes-Oxley Act

  Sarkozy, Nicolas

  Satan missile

  Saudi Arabia

  Scargill, Arthur “King Arthur,” on capitalism economics of on flying pickets funding of on Gorbachev, M. government blame by Harry on Heath and history of Hoskyns, J., on Ingham on Johnny on Kinnock on on Korean Airlines Flight 007 Lawson on Lewis on loss without limit declaration by Marxism of miners’ loyalty to NUM rise of at Orgreave on pit closures at Saltley coke depot Sheridan on on Soviet Union Soviet Union tours of spying on as Stalinist stockpiling and strike insistence of on Trade unions Walker on. See also “Arthur Scargill Walks on Water”; Sheridan, Linda; “There’s only one Arthur Scargill”

  Schmidt, Helmut

  Scotland

  Scowcroft, Brent

  Seattle

  Second Cold War

  Shakespeare, William

  Shame

  Sheffield

  Sheridan, Linda on Kinnock on Scargill on strike on Thatcher, M.

  Shrew

  Shultz, George

  Silver Fox

  Single European Act

  Sixties

  Socialist Labour Party

  Solidarity movement election of Gorbachev, M., on political support of

  “Some Suggestions for Strategic Themes” (Howarth)

  South Africa

  South Georgia

  South Korea. See Korean Airlines Flight (KAL) 007

  South Yorkshire. See Orgreave, South Yorkshire

  Soviet Union: Afghanistan invasion of Afghanistan withdrawal of armament of Berlin Wall and Britain and Central Intelligence Agency on coal strike support by collapse of Eastern Europe and economy of Howe on KAL attack response by Kuril Islands and Labour Party and Lawson on Lewis on nuclear arms in nuclear scare in oil in plane attack by Powell, Charles, on prices in Reagan and Scargill and SDI effect on Thatcher, M., meeting in Thatcher, M., meeting about Thatcher, M., on Thatcher, M., visit to Trade unions and United States and Walker on. See also Chernenko, Konstantin; Gorbachev, Mikhail

  Sovietologists

  Spain

  SS-18 missile

  SS-20 missiles

  Stagflation

  Stalin, Joseph

  Stalin Society

  State of the Union speech

  Statecraft (Thatcher, M.)

  Steel industry

  “Stepping Stones” report (Hoskyns, J.) Socialism in

  Stockpiling, of coal: Hoskyns, J., on Kinnock on plans for Scargill and Walker and

  Strasbourg

  Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty

  Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI) Cold War and Reagan and Reykjavik summit proposal for Soviet effect of Thatcher, M., on

  Strategy and Tactics Committee

  Strikes: Britain end of history of pit closures and railway workers threat of regularity of scab death in supervisor’s threat of union votes on. See also Coal strike, 1984

  Subsidies

  Such, Such Were the Joys (Orwell)

  Suez

  Suicide

  Supply side

  Sweden

  Tax fixed-rate income lowering of poll subsidized mining as Value Added

  Thatcher, Denis

  Thatcher, Margaret: 2002 speech of accent of on armament assassination attempt on attractiveness of Bible references of as Boudicea on British identity Bruges speech of on Bush charisma of Chirac and on Churchill Clark on class challenges of on coal strike alternative coal strike and coal strike speech of on coal strike violence Cold War and on Common Market on communists Conservative Party conference speeches of Conservative Party resignation of courage of on Delors d’Estaing and on disarmament in diva role economic criticism of economics of on EEC membership as emasculating equality speech of on European Union on Falklands War father figure for female roles of on financial aid first years of as flirt on France on free-market economics Galtieri on Germany and Gorbachev, M., and Haig meeting of Heath on honesty of Hoskyns, J., on Hoskyns, M., on in housewife role Howe and humor of on Hussein on inflation Ingham on on Iranians Iraq and Islamic extremism awareness of ITV interview of on Kinnock Kinnock conflict with Kinnock on on Korean airplane attack Kremlin meeting of, Labour Party and on Lawson Lawson on leadership style of at Lockerbie marriage of on Marxism matron role of mentor of mining issue for Mitterand and monetarism and on nation-states negativity towards papers of pit closures under Polish visit of political start of popularity of Powell, Charles, on power loss by Reagan and re-election of resignation of second election of in Second World War Sheridan on as shrew Single European Act of on Socialism on Soviet Union Soviet Union interview for Soviet Union visit of Statecraft by temperament of third election of Trade unions and transformation of United Nations address of upbringing of Walker’s appointment by on Walters, A. Winter of Discontent speech of women as threat to as xenophobe Zamyatin on. See also Thatcherism

  Thatcher Revolution Falklands War and wiring diagram as start of

  “Thatcher the Milk-Snatcher,”

  Thatcherism: criticism of economics of free markets in Ingham on Lawson on monetarism in Socialism in

  “There’s only one Arthur Scargill,”

  Third Way

  Thompson, Fred

  “Thoughts on the Coming Battle” (Lawson)

  Tory Party. See Conservative Party

  Trade unions: 1982 Employment Act and government and Labour Party link with Powell, Charles, on Scargill on Soviet Union and Thatcher, M.. See also Coal strike, 1984; Electrician’s union; National Union of Mineworkers; Transport and General Workers Union; Union of Democratic Mineworkers

  Trades Union Conference

  Training

  Trains

  Transport and General Workers Union

  Travellers Club

  Treasury

  Turkey

  UB40

  Underclass

  Unemployment in Britain Friedman’s ideas about inflation and rioting due to in Sweden in Yorkshire

  Unemployment Benefits

  Union of Democratic Mineworkers

  United Nations: Falklands War response of Thatcher, M., address to

  United States: Afghanistan and armament of Britain and Central Intelligence Agency on in Cold War communism and economics of Falklands War response of Grenada invasion of Hoskyns, J., on hostages from mining in in North Vietnam nuclear power of privatization in Sarbanes-Oxley Act in Soviet Union and

  Vale of Belvoir

  Value Added Tax

  Venezuela

  �
��Vote Yes” campaign

  Wakefield. See Yorkshire

  Walden, Brian

  Walesa, Lech

  Walker, Peter: on Blair on Bush Ingham on on Iraq on Islamic extremism on miners on Scargill on Soviet Union stockpiling and strike alternative of Thatcher, M., appointment of

  Warsaw Pact

  “Wedgie” Benn. See Anthony Benn

  Weinberger, Caspar

  Welfare mining as

  Wellington Room

  West Germany

  Wham!

  Whitelaw, William Hoskyns, J., on on rioting

  “Who Governs Britain?”

  Wilson, Harold: EEC referendum of election of Graham and mining under resignation of

  Winter of Discontent

  Wiring diagram

  Women: Conservative Party and Kinnock and Thatcher, M., and

  Woodward, John

  World Economics Forum

  World Trade Organization (WTO)

  World War II

  Wreford-Brown, Chris

  WTO. See World Trade Organization

  Xenophobia

  Yorkshire: miner interviews in miners in unemployment in. See also Orgreave, South Yorkshire

  Yorkshire Miner

  Young Communist League

  Zamyatin, Leonid

  Zeebrugge harbor, Belgium

  Zulu

  1 John William Middendorf II, U.S. diplomat, telephone conversation, March 9, 2007.

  2 One could argue for quite some time about these definitions, and many do. Karl Marx did not classify communism as a species of socialism; socialism, as he defined it, was the stage between the inevitable proletarian revolution and the emergence of communism. These doctrinal debates are interesting, if you like that sort of thing, but they are not my point. My point concerns the locus of property rights: If they tend to reside with the state, I define the system as socialist. So did Thatcher.

  3 “I’m a Conviction Politician Like Maggie, Brown Taunts Cameron,” Evening Standard, September 5, 2007.

  4 Speech to Grantham Conservatives, March 4, 1977, Guildhall, Grantham. Thatcher MSS (digital collection), doc. 103329. All documents from this collection may be consulted at www.margaretthatcher.org.

  5 E. J. Hobsbawm, Industry and Empire: The Making of Modern English Society, 1750 to the Present Day (Pantheon, 1968), p. 1.

  6 January 8, 1975, Ford Library (NSC NSA Memcons Box 8).

  7 January 16, 1979, Hansard HC [960/1524–61].

  8 The OECD, or Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, is a club for rich countries.

  9 “Come on, there weren’t that many corpses,” Thatcher’s detractors tend to respond when this point is raised. Readers may decide for themselves how many corpses would need to be piled on their streets before the situation struck them as a legitimate cause for concern. My own view is that even one would be a corpse too many—unless it belonged to one of my enemies, obviously—but perhaps I’m excessively fastidious.

  10 PBS interview with Cecil Parkinson, trade minister in Thatcher’s first government, for Commanding Heights: www.pbs.org/wgbh/commandingheights/shared/pdf/int_cecilparkinson.pdf.

  11 Margaret Thatcher, The Downing Street Years, 1979–1990 (HarperCollins, 1993), p. 20.

  12 Peter Rawlinson, A Price Too High: An Autobiography (Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1989), pp. 246–247.

  13 Keith Joseph speech at Upminster, June 22, 1974, Thatcher MSS (digital collection), doc. 110604.

  14 Speech at St. Lawrence Jewry, City of London, March 31, 1978. Oxford University Press CD-ROM of Margaret Thatcher’s Complete Public Statements, 78/039.

  15 Speech to the Church of Scotland General Assembly, May 21, 1988, Thatcher MSS (digital collection), doc. 107246.

  16 Speech to Conservative rally at Cardiff, April 16, 1979, Thatcher MSS (digital collection), doc. 104011.

  17 Conservative Party Manifesto, April 1979, Conservative Central Office, THCR 2–7–1–23 (4). All documents prefaced by “THCR” may be consulted among the papers of Baroness Thatcher at the Churchill Archives Centre, Cambridge.

  18 There are many versions of this story; it seems reasonable to conclude that if these are not precisely the words he used, they are close enough and certainly convey the mood of the encounter.

  19 The Labour politician Healey was at the time favored to win his party’s leadership election.

  20 U.S. Embassy in London to State Department, “Margaret Thatcher: Some First Impressions,” U.S. State Department Archives, February 16, 1975. www.margaretthatcher.org/document/E85DA4E0A8144A278F350BCF08F7F80A.pdf.

  21 Speech at Kensington Town Hall, “Britain, Awake,” Chelsea, January 19, 1976, Thatcher MSS (digital collection), doc. 102939.

  22 Sir Nicholas Henderson, “Britain’s Decline: Its Causes and Consequences,” March 31, 1979, Diplomatic Report No. 129/79, Thatcher MSS (digital collection), doc. 110961. Almost all of this document was published in the Economist on June 2, 1979.

  23 Speech to Conservative Party Conference, October 10, 1980, Brighton, Thatcher MSS (digital collection), doc. 104431.

  24 When you see the words “council houses,” think “housing projects.”

  25 Interview with Baron Charles Powell, June 15, 2007, London.

  26 1979 Conservative Manifesto, p. 6.

  27 Why Cambridge? After all, Oxford was her alma mater. But Oxford failed to award her an honorary degree, a deliberate snub to protest her parsimonious funding of higher education. Every previous prime minister educated at Oxford had been given one. She was neither the sort to forgive this kind of insult nor fail to return it; many years later, delivering a memorial to Keith Joseph, she was still furious enough to take a nice swipe at “those raging, spitting Trotskyite crowds at our great liberal centers of learning.” So Cambridge got her papers. Churchill College was the obvious choice; Churchill, after all, was the figure with whom she most wished to be associated.

  28 John Hoskyns, “Stepping Stones,” draft, undated (circa 1977), THCR 2–6–1–247 (6) and (7), p. 46–47.

  29 Memorandum from John Hoskyns to Thatcher, October 3, 1977, THCR 2–6–1–247 (410), p. 1.

  30 THCR 2–6–1–247 (411), p. 2.

  31 John Hoskyns, “Stepping Stones Review,” November 8, 1978, THCR 2–6–1–247 (442), p. 2.

  32 David Cameron is the current leader of the Conservative Party. PPE, short for Politics, Philosophy, and Economics, is a famous degree course at Oxford.

  33 John Hoskyns, Just in Time: Inside the Thatcher Revolution (Aurum Press, 2000), p. 8.

  34 Ibid., p. 11.

  35 John Hoskyns, “Stepping Stones Review,” November 8, 1978, THCR 2–6–1–247 (447), p. 7.

  36 “Stepping Stones,” November 14, 1977, THCR 2–6–1–248 (237), p. 55.

  37 THCR 2–6–1–248 (32), p. 18.

  38 THCR 2–6–1–248 (254), p. 29.

  39 “Stepping Stones” draft, THCR 2–6–1–247 (6) and (7), pp. 46–47.

  40 “Stepping Stones,” November 14, 1977, THCR 2–6–1–248 (257), p. 37.

  41 Chris Patten, “Implementing Our Strategy,” December 11, 1977, THCR 2–6–1–246 (13), p. 2.

  42 Note from Nigel Lawson to Thatcher, “Thoughts on ‘Implementing Our Strategy,’” January 15, 1978, THCR 2–6–1–246 (27), p. 1. Lawson is now even more famous for having fathered Nigella Lawson, the voluptuous television chef.

  43 Memorandum from Nigel Lawson to Sir Michael Fraser, “Thoughts on the Coming Battle,” October 15, 1973, THCR 2–6–1–246 (34), p. 1 and (35), p. 2.

  44 Memorandum from Alan Howarth to Thatcher, December 16, 1977, THCR 2–6–1–250 (16) and (17), pp. 2–3.

  45 Memorandum from Alan Howarth to Thatcher, January 4, 1978, THCR 2–6–1–250 (26).

  46 Alan Howarth, “Some Suggestions for Strategic Themes,” January 4, 1978, THCR 2–6–1–250 (32), p. 4. The end of this section of the document is mildly puzzling. Howarth concludes by calling for “an end to the depressing politics of guilt”—words
rather at odds with all the words preceding them. But the word “politics” has been altered, by hand, to read “policies.” Whose hand did the altering? I don’t know. Is it significant? I don’t know. Archives are like that, sometimes.

  47 Speech to Conservative Party Conference, October 8, 1976, Brighton, Thatcher MSS (digital collection), doc. 103105.

  48 John Campbell, Margaret Thatcher, vol. 2: The Iron Lady (Jonathan Cape, 2003), p. 258.

  49 George Bush and Brent Scowcroft, A World Transformed (Knopf, 1998), p.31.

  50 Alan Clark, Diaries: In Power, 1983–1992 (Phoenix, 2001), p. 319.

  51 Nigel Lawson, The View from No. 11: Memoirs of a Tory Radical (Corgi, 1993), p. 680.

  52 The two Helmuts—Helmut Schmidt, then chancellor of West Germany, and Helmut Kohl, then chairman of Germany’s Christian Democratic Union.

  53 Chequers is the prime minister’s country residence.

  54 www.youtube.com/watch?v=1aZdAyHVjzQ.

  55 Diana Gould was a British housewife who on BBC TV in 1983 attacked the prime minister’s decision to sink the Belgrano. This exchange too may be viewed on YouTube: www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWOy23MLY1I.

 

‹ Prev