Crisis? What Crisis?

by Alwyn Turner

  Sight & Sound in Concert, ref 1

  Silk Cut, ref 1

  Sir, You Bastard (G.F. Newman), ref 1

  Silver Jubilee, ref 1

  Skinhead (Richard Allen), ref 1

  skinheads, ref 1

  Skinner, David, ref 1

  Skinner, Dennis, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4

  Slik, ref 1

  Small, Millie, ref 1

  Small Is Beautiful (E.F. Schumacher), ref 1

  Smethwick, ref 1

  Smith, Cyril, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4

  Smith, Guy N., ref 1

  Smith, Nicholas, ref 1

  Smith, Patti, ref 1

  smoking, ref 1

  Snowden, Philip, ref 1

  Social Democratic Party (SDP), ref 1, ref 2

  Social Trends, ref 1, ref 2

  Socialist Challenge, ref 1

  Socialist Strategy for London, A, ref 1

  Socialist Worker, ref 1

  Socialist Workers Party, ref 1

  Solti, Sir Georg, ref 1

  Sotheby’s, ref 1

  South Africa, ref 1, ref 2

  South Bank, ref 1, ref 2

  South Bank Show, ref 1, ref 2

  Soviet Union, ref 1, ref 2

  soya, ref 1

  ‘Space Oddity’ (David Bowie), ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Spain, ref 1

  Sparks, ref 1

  Spear, The (James Herbert), ref 1

  Special Branch, ref 1

  Special Branch, ref 1

  Spedding, Chris, ref 1

  Speed, Doris, ref 1

  Speer, Albert, ref 1

  Spider and the Fly, The (Graham Lord), ref 1, ref 2

  Spiders From Mars, ref 1

  Spiegel, Der, ref 1

  Spinners, ref 1

  Split Scene (Frederic Mullaly), ref 1

  Spong, Reverend Terry, ref 1

  Sportsnight with Coleman, ref 1

  St Jorre, John de, ref 1

  Star Trek, ref 1

  State of Denmark, A (Robin Cook), ref 1, ref 2

  Steadman, Ralph, ref 1

  Steel, David, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4

  Stein, Jock, ref 1

  Stewart, Ed, ref 1

  Stewart, Rod, ref 1, ref 2

  Stirling, Colonel David, ref 1

  Stockhausen Serves Imperialism (Cornelius Cardew), ref 1

  Stockwood, Mervyn, ref 1

  Stone Tape, The (Nigel Kneale), ref 1

  Stonehouse, John, ref 1, ref 2

  Story of O, The (Pauline Réage), ref 1

  Straker, Peter, ref 1

  ‘Strange Movies’ (The Troggs), ref 1

  Stranglers, ref 1

  Strauli, Christopher, ref 1

  Straw Dogs (Sam Peckinpah), ref 1

  Strawbs, ref 1

  strikes, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5

  Strong, Roy, ref 1, ref 2

  Stubbs, Una, ref 1

  Sugden, Mollie, ref 1

  Sullivan, David, ref 1

  Sullivan, John, ref 1

  Summers, John, ref 1

  Sun

  age of consent, ref 1

  Benn, ref 1

  ‘Crisis? What Crisis?’, ref 1

  Day of the Mad Dogs, ref 1

  Europe, ref 1

  leadership of Labour Party, ref 1

  Paisley, ref 1

  Powell, ref 1

  rise of, ref 1

  smoking beagles, ref 1

  trades unions, ref 1

  unofficial history of, ref 1

  ‘winter of discontent’, ref 1

  Sunday, Bloody Sunday (John Schlesinger), ref 1

  Sunday Mirror, ref 1

  Sunday Telegraph, ref 1

  Sunday Times, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5

  Sunningdale Agreement, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Surrey County Council, ref 1

  Surtees, John, ref 1

  Survivors, ref 1

  Sutch, Screaming Lord, ref 1

  Sweden, ref 1

  Sweeney, The, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5, ref 6

  Swizzlewick, ref 1

  Symons, Julian, ref 1

  Syria, ref 1

  Tafler, Sydney, ref 1

  Tate Gallery, ref 1

  Taverne, Dick, ref 1, ref 2

  Taxi Driver (Martin Scorsese), ref 1, ref 2

  Teachers Against Racism, ref 1

  Tebbit, Norman, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5, ref 6

  Teeth ’n’ Smiles (David Hare), ref 1

  Temple, Shirley, ref 1

  Terry-Thomas, ref 1

  Thames Barrier, ref 1

  Thames, River, ref 1

  That Was the Week That Was, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Thatcher, Margaret

  becomes Conservative leader, ref 1

  Benn and, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Christian values and the state, ref 1

  Daily Mirror, ref 1, ref 2

  doctrinaire approach, ref 1

  Duke of Edinburgh’s speech, ref 1

  emergence of, ref 1, ref 2

  Falklands, ref 1

  first conference speech as leader, ref 1

  Foot on, ref 1

  Good Samaritan interpretation, ref 1

  image of, ref 1

  immigration, ref 1

  Keith Joseph and, ref 1, ref 2

  Liberal Party, ref 1

  Mary Whitehouse, ref 1, ref 2

  New Statesman, ref 1

  Peter Hall, ref 1

  Powell and, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5, ref 6

  quoted, ref 1

  Shore on, ref 1

  sitcoms and, ref 1

  Times on, ref 1

  trades unions, ref 1

  Thaw, John, ref 1

  There’ll Almost Always Be an England (Jack Rosenthal), ref 1

  These Foolish Things (Bryan Ferry), ref 1

  Thomas, Gareth, ref 1

  Thomas, Jimmy, ref 1

  Thorpe, Jeremy, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Throbbing Gristle, ref 1

  Till Death Do Us Part, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5, ref 6

  Times, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5

  Times Educational Supplement, ref 1

  Tina Transport, ref 1

  Tolpuddle Martyrs, ref 1

  Tom Robinson Band, ref 1

  Tomaszewski, Jan, ref 1, ref 2

  Tomlinson, Ricky, ref 1

  Tomorrow People, The, ref 1, ref 2

  Top of the Pops, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4

  Total Film, ref 1

  Tottenham Hotspur FC, ref 1

  Tower Hamlets, ref 1

  Townsend, Cyril, ref 1

  Townshend, Pete, ref 1

  trades unions, ref 1

  Benn, ref 1, ref 2

  Callaghan, ref 1

  cinema and television depictions, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Conservative party, ref 1

  dockers, ref 1

  fear of, ref 1

  Healey, ref 1

  Heath, ref 1

  Labour Party, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5, ref 6

  miners, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  music and, ref 1

  Northern Ireland, ref 1

  shop stewards, ref 1

  Transport & General Workers Union (TGWU), ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5, ref 6, ref 7

  Treaty of Rome, ref 1

  Trevelyan, John, ref 1

  Tribune, ref 1, ref 2

  Troggs, ref 1

  Trotskyism, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Trouble Shooters, The, ref 1

  TUC (Trades Union Congress), ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4- see also trades unions

  Tuzo, Lt. Gen. Sir Harry, ref 1

  Tynan, Kenneth, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5, ref 6

  UFOs, ref 1

  Uganda, ref 1, ref 2

  Ullerstam, Lars, ref 1

  Ulster Defence Association, ref 1

  Ulster Unionists, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Ulster Workers’ Council, ref 1

  Union of Musl
im Organisations, ref 1

  United Arab Emirates, ref 1

  United Ulster Unionist Council, ref 1

  Universal Herbal, The (Thomas Green), ref 1

  Unsuitable Job for a Woman, An (P.D. James), ref 1

  Upper Clyde Shipbuilders, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Upstairs Downstairs, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Usher, Shaun, ref 1

  Valentine, Anthony, ref 1

  Van Greenaway, Peter, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  VAT, ref 1, ref 2

  Venables, Terry, ref 1

  Victoria and Albert Museum, ref 1

  Vietnam, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5

  Villain (Michael Tuchner), ref 1, ref 2

  Virgil, ref 1

  Visconti, Tony, ref 1

  Voltaire, ref 1

  Wade, Virginia, ref 1

  Walden, Brian, ref 1

  Wales Act 1978, ref 1, ref 2

  ‘Walk on the Wild Side’ (Lou Reed), ref 1

  Walker, Alexander, ref 1

  Walker, Pete, ref 1, ref 2

  Walker, Peter, ref 1

  Walker, General Sir Walter, ref 1

  Walsh, Michael, ref 1

  Ward, George, ref 1

  Warrington, Don, ref 1

  Waterloo, Battle of, ref 1

  Waterman, Dennis, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Watership Down (Richard Adams), ref 1, ref 2

  Watkinson, Lord, ref 1

  Watson, David, ref 1

  Watts, Los Angeles, ref 1

  Waugh, Auberon, ref 1

  Webster, Martin, ref 1

  Weekend World, ref 1

  Weimar, ref 1

  Welch, Raquel, ref 1

  Wellington, Duke of, ref 1

  Wells, Dee, ref 1

  Wells, John, ref 1

  West Lothian Question, ref 1

  Wesker, Arnold, ref 1

  West Bromwich Albion FC, ref 1

  West Germany, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5, ref 6, ref 7

  Westwood, Vivienne, ref 1

  Whatever Happened to the Likely Lads, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5

  Wheatley, Dennis, ref 1

  Wheeltappers and Shunters Social Club, The, ref 1

  When the Kissing Had to Stop (Constantine Fitzgibbon), ref 1

  Which?, ref 1

  White, Jos, ref 1

  Whitehouse, Mary, ref 1, ref 2

  Callaghan and, ref 1

  child pornography, ref 1

  Longford and, ref 1

  nostalgia and, ref 1

  petitions, ref 1

  Whitelaw, William, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Who Killed Enoch Powell? (Arthur Wise), ref 1, ref 2

  Who Needs Men? (Edmund Cooper), ref 1

  Why Is Britain Becoming Harder to Govern?, ref 1

  Why You Should Vote Yes, ref 1

  Wicker Man, The (Robin Hardy), ref 1, ref 2

  Wilberforce, Lord, ref 1

  Wilde, Oscar, ref 1

  William Hill, ref 1

  Williams, Charlie, ref 1, ref 2

  Williams, Gordon, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Williams, Kenneth, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5

  Williams, Rt, Revd Ralph, Bishop of Leicester, ref 1

  Williams, Raymond, ref 1

  Williams, Shirley, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4

  Williams-Ellis, Clough, ref 1

  Williams-Ellis, Susan, ref 1

  Willis, Ted, ref 1

  Wills cigarettes, ref 1

  Wilson, Brian, ref 1

  Wilson, Colin, ref 1, ref 2-2

  Wilson, Harold

  battle to succeed, ref 1

  Benn and, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4, ref 5, ref 6

  Callaghan and, ref 1

  EEC, ref 1, ref 2

  football and, ref 1

  foreign countries and, ref 1

  Heath and, ref 1, ref 2

  keeping party together, ref 1

  leadership challenge, ref 1

  1967, ref 1

  1970 election, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4

  1974 return, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Northern Ireland, ref 1

  Powell, ref 1

  resigns as PM, ref 1

  security services and, ref 1

  Selsdon Man, ref 1

  ‘social contract’, ref 1

  Wimbledon (tennis), ref 1, ref 2

  Wimpy cafes, ref 1

  Winn, Arthur, ref 1

  Winner, Michael, ref 1

  Wise, Arthur, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Wistrich, Enid, ref 1

  Wodehouse, P.G., ref 1

  Wogan, Terry, ref 1

  Wolverhampton, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Wombles, The, ref 1

  Wood, David, ref 1

  Woodward, Edward, ref 1, ref 2

  Woolley Colliery, ref 1

  Woolwich, Bishop of, ref 1

  Workers Revolutionary Party, ref 1, ref 2

  World Cup, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  World in Action, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3

  Wrestling, ref 1

  Wright, Bill, ref 1

  Wurmbrand, Pastor Richard, ref 1

  Wyman, Bill, ref 1

  Wymark, Patrick, ref 1

  Wyngarde, Peter, ref 1

  Yamani, Sheikh, ref 1

  Yarwood, Mike, ref 1, ref 2, ref 3, ref 4

  Yom Kippur War, ref 1, ref 2

  ‘You to Me Are Everything’ (Real Thing), ref 1

  Youens, Bernard, ref 1

  Young, Barbara, ref 1

  Young Communist League, ref 1

  Young Conservatives, ref 1- see also Conservative Party

  Young Liberals, ref 1- see also Liberal Party

  Yuill, P.B., ref 1

  Z-Cars, ref 1

  A Classless Society

  Foreword

  When I first began working on Crisis? What Crisis? Britain in the 1970s it was the autumn of 2005. Tony Blair had recently won his third election victory, the economy had been growing for thirteen consecutive years, and England had just been beaten 1–0 by Northern Ireland in a World Cup qualifying match. Now, as I come towards the end of A Classless Society, the third – and last – book in this series, Britain has its first coalition government since the Second World War, the talk is of a triple-dip recession, and England have been held to a 1–1 draw by the mighty Macedonia. It would be hard to see all these things as steps forward.

  This was never intended as a trilogy. It started as an attempt to reclaim the memory of the 1970s, the decade in which I spent most of my teenage years and which was not then as well chronicled as it has been since. The project has been extended, into Rejoice! Rejoice! Britain in the 1980s and then into the present volume, because the story refused to reach a satisfactory conclusion. The crises that racked this country during the 1970s remained unresolved. By the time some episodes had been wrapped up – with the defeat of the trade union movement in 1984, for example – others were already under way.

  To some extent, of course, this is simply because the division of history by dates is a necessarily arbitrary affair. Decades and centuries are artificial, crude concepts that seldom fit the objective facts. They do, however, have an impact on the subjective experience of time, the turning of the years affecting how people see the evolution of their societies. And the current book approaches its conclusion with the biggest of all such markers: the end of the second Christian millennium. Except that even that isn’t quite the right place to stop. It was not until the re-election of the Labour Party in 2001, and the second decisive defeat of the Conservatives, that things seem to have been settled in Britain.

  And there is, I think, a settlement to be recorded. The social upheavals of the 1960s, when a cultural revolution began to challenge the legitimacy of the established order, were followed by the economic and industrial travails of the 1970s. Between them, they destroyed the post-war consensus, which had always been a typically British muddled compromise of a mixed economy and a shared Christian heritage, held together by the fantasy of growing pros
perity. That came to an end in September 1976, with James Callaghan’s speech to the Labour Party conference. ‘The cosy world we were told would go on for ever, where full employment would be guaranteed by a stroke of the chancellor’s pen,’ he said; ‘that cosy world is gone.’

  The story of these three volumes is essentially the tale of the building of a new consensus. It’s not as cosy. A sizeable minority of the population has been effectively excluded from mainstream society, historically terrifying levels of unemployment – however the figures are disguised – have become entrenched, and the concept of a job for life has long since vanished. On the other hand, sizeable minorities who were previously excluded are now welcomed. The economic fantasy remains, this time built on a massive increase in personal debt.

  The new consensus may not be sustainable. All things change, and this may not last as long as the previous settlement – at the time of writing, it is still unclear what impact the financial crisis that began in 2008 will have. But it is at least the end of a cycle that began with the right-wing backlash against the 1960s and culminated with the victory of liberalism, in all its economic, social and cultural forms.

  Alwyn W. Turner

  May 2013

  Intro

  Nineties

  ‘From despair to where’

  Margaret Thatcher cast a long shadow. Her enforced departure from office in November 1990, deposed as prime minister by her own colleagues in the Parliamentary Conservative Party, was the biggest political earthquake that Westminster had experienced since the defeat of Winston Churchill in the election of 1945. The key difference, of course, was that Churchill had been removed by the will of the people in a vote that had been delayed due to hostilities; ten years and a world war had passed since the last time the British electorate had been consulted about the future of the nation. Thatcher’s exit, on the other hand, came after a hat-trick of election victories, and was brought about by the actions of the 152 Tory MPs who cast their vote against her in a leadership challenge.

  The consequences of that contest were to colour Conservative politics well into the next century, many in the party believing that there was still unfinished business, that the Thatcherite revolution had yet to be completed. More widely, though, the new decade was to find it hard to escape the influence and impact of her political philosophy. Even in her heyday, she had never carried the whole country with her, but so powerful and all-pervasive was her presence that she had become the dominant symbol of Britain, whether one supported or opposed her.

  In particular she bequeathed the culture a single phrase that echoed through the 1990s. ‘There’s no such thing as society,’ quoted a character in an episode of the television drama Our Friends in the North. ‘Remember that?’ Much of what was to come in the political and cultural developments of the following years was an attempt to overturn that perception, to insist that there was indeed such a thing as society.