Their Colorado Nights [Spirit, Colorado 2] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Alicia White

  She really didn’t want to outline what she wanted in the middle of the gun show. She placed the rifle back down on the table and started walking toward the exit. Both of the men followed closely behind her. She pulled her jacket closed and zipped it up tight as she walked outside. The wind hit her, but it didn’t bother her in the least. She actually felt hot.

  “How about this. After I win, I’ll tell you both exactly what I want,” she teased. They looked at each other, shrugged, and nodded. “When and where?”

  “Right now. We’ve got a rifle back at the B and B. Let’s drive out past the city limits and we can set up some targets.” Sam wrapped an arm around her waist and ushered her down the street. She could tell he was excited, and she wondered if he actually might lose on purpose. The question was…did she want to win?

  * * * *

  Loading up his rifle in the back of the truck, Andrew held open the door, letting Selena climb in first. He watched her crawl across the seat, getting a great view of her ass in the process. The jeans she was wearing hugged and outlined her plump ass and he couldn’t wait to sink his teeth into her. Climbing into the truck, he moved close to her, letting their thighs touch.

  The windows were rolled up, and her sweet scent filled the cab. She smelled like a combination of strawberries and sugar, and he wished that he could taste her. He could tell that she was excited by their close contact. Her breathing had changed from calm to erratic. The pulse in her neck beat rapidly, and Andrew felt the same. His cock hardened, and he shifted, hoping that she didn’t notice.

  It was obvious that her fantasy was having two men at one time. He wasn’t sure this was what he wanted, though. They had enough women that wanted to fuck, and although he loved sex, he didn’t want to add more one-night stands or short affairs.

  Driving out of town, they headed off-road, toward one of their secret spots. It was far enough from Spirit that nobody complained when they went shooting. The road became harsher with large boulders everywhere, and he bounced in the seat. Selena grabbed his thigh, holding on, and he wanted to thank Sam for taking this particular road. He felt the heat of her hand burn through his jeans, and his cock strained, begging for release.

  The truck came to a stop after only a couple minutes, and she moved her hand, and instantly he was disappointed. Taking a deep calming breath, he climbed out of the truck, going to retrieve his rifle case. Selena and Sam followed closely behind him, as he walked out to the open field. The question still remained. Should he let her win? Should he really try his hardest?

  “I’ll set up the targets. Then, we can get this little competition started.” Sam walked quickly, hanging up the targets on the hay bales.

  “Who goes first?” Selena asked him, cocking her head to the side.

  “It’s up to you.” He really was looking forward to seeing her in action. She seemed to know her way around a weapon, so he was pretty sure she was a good shot.

  “Okay. Sam, me, and then you? Let’s alternate shots, thoracic cavity of the target gets three points, and a head shot is five. How many shots each?” He was impressed. She knew more than he gave her credit for.

  “I like it. I was hoping to be last anyway. Each person gets five shots and their own target.” He held out his hand and she took it, giving him a nice, firm handshake.

  “Perfect. Let’s do this.” They walked toward the targets and Sam, who was waiting for them in front of the first target.

  Handing the rifle off to Sam, he watched as his brother took aim and fired one shot. “Five points, Sam, good job.”

  Aiming the rifle down range, Sam turned slightly. “What’s the point system?”

  “Five points for every head shot and three for the thoracic cavity.” Not that Sam cared. He would benefit if they won or lost. They would all benefit.

  Pretending to watch Sam shoot, Andrew thought about winning and losing. He was a fantastic shot, always had been. If they let her win, they might end up in bed tonight. He wanted her, no doubt about it, but he also wanted a more meaningful relationship. This had potential.

  “Seventeen points. Not bad, Sam.” Selena’s sweet voice pulled him from his thoughts, and he smiled, looking at the target. He knew that Sam could’ve done better, and he shook his head.

  Sam handed the rifle off to Selena and she pointed it, aiming at the target. She took a few deep breaths, relaxing her body and he knew that she had skills. The first shot was a perfect head shot, five points. From his viewpoint he could see her smile, lean back in, and take a second shot. Five points. Shit, she was a tough competitor.

  “Twenty-one!” Sam yelled. Hearing the excitement in his voice brought a smile to Andrew’s face.

  Selena passed the rifle off to him. Pulling the butt of the rifle up to his shoulder, Andrew stood steady, put his finger on the trigger and squeezed. Taking his time, he focused on the front sight and aimed for the head, every single time. He needed more than twenty-one points. He wanted Selena’s fantasy to come true, but he also wanted his own dreams as well. If she was the one for them, then things should happen at a slower pace. Grabbing the rifle by the stock, he stood staring at his target.

  “Twenty-five. You’re a fantastic shot, Andrew.” Selena’s voice sounded sincere, and he was grateful that she wasn’t upset that he had done a little better.

  “Thank you.” Turning around, he looked at both Sam and Selena. His brother looked confused, and Andrew shrugged. He knew exactly what he was thinking. Why didn’t you let her win?

  He wondered that himself as they walked back toward the truck. All three of them could be getting into a nice cozy bed. Instead, they would be heading for the Jacuzzi. He wanted to kick himself, but he wasn’t sorry for the decision he made.

  Chapter 9

  Heading back toward the truck, Selena wasn’t sure what to think. They were all good shots. Their performances today proved that. She felt that Sam had lost on purpose, and she knew why. He wanted her just as much as she craved him. She hadn’t expected Andrew to be such a great shot and get a perfect score.

  Questions kept running through her mind. Does he want to make my fantasy come true? Is he really interested in me? Yeah, he seemed to be. She had noticed his cock pushing against his zipper while they drove. She had wanted to touch him as her fingers itched to wrap around his cock. Even now, they walked to the truck and she wanted to touch him, kiss him.

  “What do you both think about a late lunch, early dinner thing? I’m really looking forward to that Jacuzzi,” Andrew said as he placed the rifle case in the back of Sam’s truck. The excitement in his voice made her smile, and Selena nodded, crawling into the truck.

  Selena was settled securely between Sam and Andrew as they headed back toward Spirit. With both of them being so broad shouldered, they crowded her. Instead of feeling cramped and uncomfortable, she felt petite and protected. She let the sensation soak into her bones, wanting to remember how warm they both felt when she was back at home, lying in bed alone.

  She loved this feeling and had been fantasizing about it for years. Now that she was sitting between them, she realized that she had really wanted to win. Disappointment weighed heavily on her shoulders. The three of them could’ve been headed toward the bedroom. She wasn’t upset that she would be spending the evening in the Jacuzzi, though, as seeing them half naked was worth the loss.

  Looking over at Sam, she felt her nipples harden. He kept glancing at her as he drove, the sparkle in his eyes unmistakable. She pushed her thighs together tightly, feeling moisture flow from her pussy. Both of these men affected her, and she hoped that she wouldn’t have to wait too long before their hands were on her body.

  “Thank you for playing along with this little competition. I had a great time watching you shoot.” Sam moved his hand to the outside of her thigh. He used his finger tips to draw little figure eights. When she didn’t object or pull away, he became bolder, letting his fingers trail over the inside of her thigh, grazing her jeans over her pussy.

  Lean
ing her head back, Selena closed her eyes and concentrated on every move his fingers made. “Did you have fun?” His voice was deeper, and she knew that he was affected.

  Inhaling deeply, she whispered, “Yes.” God, his fingers felt so amazing rubbing against her pussy. He kept teasing her, though, only letting his thumb swipe the crotch of her jeans briefly, or a finger here and there. Silently begging for more, she shifted her hips. She felt another hand touch her, and she turned her head to the side, opening her eyes. Panting, she made eye contact with Andrew and stared at him as he ran his hand along her thigh.

  “Don’t think that because I won I don’t want you. I do.” Leaning forward, she brushed her lips against his. She wasn’t sure why she decided to be so bold, but she knew that if she didn’t have this experience, she would regret it.

  Wanting more attention, Selena climbed onto Andrew’s lap. He wrapped his arms around her and pulled her tight against his chest. With that, she began to kiss him, her tongue sweeping into his mouth. He tasted delicious, and she moaned, rolling her tongue against his, playing with him. It didn’t take long for him to take possession of the kiss. She held on to him tighter, digging her nails into his shoulders. Strong hands moved up her T-shirt on her naked back, and Selena arched, needing him to touch her more.

  She wanted to move, but she couldn’t nor did she want to stop the kiss. His lips were soft yet demanding. She moved her legs, placing his large thigh against her pussy, and shifted, rubbing her clit. Sparks of pleasure ran through her body and she panted.

  “Damn. That’s hot,” she heard Sam say as Andrew continued to explore her body. She broke the kiss and pulled her jacket and T-shirt over the top of her head. She felt him unclip her bra and Selena leaned back, letting him take it off her, revealing her breasts. Running his hands over her breasts, Andrew spoke to Sam, “Lean over here and feel how soft she is.”

  Andrew continued to explore her while Sam reached over to touch her. “She’s perfect.” Sam held her breast in his large, callused hand, weighing it. Leaning back, Selena got comfortable against the dashboard. “She fits inside my hand.” He tweaked a nipple and then pinched it lightly between his thumb and forefinger.

  Selena arched her back, encouraging them to continue pinching and pulling her nipples. They knew exactly what she liked. “Oh, God,” she moaned, shifting her hips. She could feel her pussy dripping and knew that all it would take was one of these men to rub her clit and she would come.

  “I’m pulling over. Make her come,” Sam ordered. Unzipping her jeans, Andrew pushed his hand under her panties.

  “Fuck. She’s hot and wet. Oh, baby. Fuck my hand. Pretend it’s my cock.” Slipping two fingers in her needy pussy, Andrew fucked her. Selena threw her head back, the pressure inside her building once more. Knowing that they were watching her turned her on, and she rode his fingers, fantasizing that it was his cock. Her climax built, deep inside her, and Selena arched and came. She screamed Andrew’s name and then whimpered as he changed his speed, slowly bringing her back to reality.

  Panting hard, Selena opened her eyes and watched as Andrew pulled his hand from her pants. Moving his hand to his mouth, she stared at him as he licked each finger clean. “Yummy. Next time, my mouth is going to be on that hot little pussy when you come.” It sounded more like a threat than a promise, and she shivered.

  * * * *

  Grabbing her clothes off the floor board, Sam moved from the driver’s seat to help Selena get dressed. Her skin was still a beautiful rosy pink, and her eyes were glossy. The climax seemed to have zapped all of her energy. She leaned against Andrew’s chest, and Sam watched as his brother gently rubbed her back.

  He had planned on keeping his hands to himself, at least until they were all in the Jacuzzi, relaxing. But once she was sitting next to him in the truck and her thigh pressed tight against his, the plan changed. When he touched her, she seemed to want more. Watching her climb onto Andrew’s lap and demand her pleasure had been the biggest turn-on of his life. He couldn’t imagine anything better than his woman taking what she wanted.

  He knew it was too soon to classify her as his woman, but he couldn’t seem to help himself. As far as he was concerned, she was theirs. Watching her come had been mind-blowing, and he was surprised that he hadn’t come in his pants, just from her little show. He pushed his cock down, knowing that he would have to wait his turn.

  “Wow. That was amazing, baby. You’re so beautiful when you come.” Sam slipped the bra straps on to her shoulders, skimming his fingers along her too-soft skin. Selena turned, and he clipped it back in place, hiding her perfect breasts from his view. Sam and Andrew worked together, putting her shirt back on and then her jacket. Once she was sitting between them, Sam took a deep breath. Her sweet, tangy scent hung in the air, and he knew that he wouldn’t be washing his truck anytime soon.

  Sam leaned toward Selena and pulled her into his arms. He had wanted to kiss her ever since seeing her. He wasn’t going to waste this moment. Their lips touched, and Sam took his time, sipping from her lips, tasting her. Gently, he pushed his tongue into her mouth, swirling his tongue with hers. After swiping his lips against hers once more, Sam leaned back and let her go.

  Putting the truck in drive, Sam drove toward town. He moved his hand, clasping hers, and their fingers intertwined. “Dinner and then Jacuzzi?”

  There were a few selections in town, but he wanted to take her somewhere really nice. The nicest place in Spirit was the High Country Inn. He would’ve loved to take her to the Silver Lodge, but it was still under construction. He knew that his friends Josh and Rex were working hard, trying to make their dream come true. He planned to stop by and lend a hand sometime during the week.

  “That sounds good.” Selena leaned into him as he drove down High Country Boulevard toward the B and B.

  Driving past Miss Melanie’s Spirit Emporium, Sam arched a brow. He wondered briefly if he could sneak over and purchase a few items before their date. He knew that Selena’s fantasy was to have them both, and he planned to make all of her dreams come true. He also wanted to have a little chat with Andrew. He knew that his brother was interested, but instead of throwing the match, he won. Why didn’t he let Selena win? That question ran through his mind.

  Pulling into the small parking lot, Sam opened the door, helping Selena out. They held hands and walked inside. The house smelled amazing, and he inhaled deeply. He unzipped his jacket and then turned to help Selena remove hers. “Let’s meet down here in a couple hours. We’ll go to the High Country Inn together.” Pulling Selena in his arms, he felt her nod against his chest.

  “Andrew and I need to run some quick errands. We’ll see you soon.” Stepping back, Andrew took his place and hugged her.

  Walking out of the B and B, Sam turned right, going toward Miss Melanie’s Spirit Emporium. He really wanted to have a few things just in case their night turned from relaxing in the Jacuzzi into something a lot more intimate.

  “What errands do we need to run?” Andrew followed him closely.

  “I spotted a store down the street that I think we should visit.”

  “I like where your mind is at.” Laughing, Andrew walked faster.

  It didn’t take long to reach the high-class sex toy store. The door jingled as they walked in. Sam looked around, scanning the store, trying to figure out what he wanted to purchase. He walked around, trying to find something amazing for the night ahead. He wanted to surprise Selena. Each aisle held so many different sexual delights that he wondered what he should purchase.

  “Hi. Can I help you find something?” a young, cute girl asked, and Sam felt a moment of embarrassment. “Are you looking for anything special?” He really didn’t feel comfortable talking about sex with this girl. It just didn’t seem right. “Don’t be embarrassed.” She laughed. Looking over at Andrew, he could tell that he was enjoying this conversation. He leaned comfortably against the row of dildos like it was no big deal.

  “I’m not embarrassed. I’
m just looking.”

  “Okay. If you need anything, just let me know. I’m Casey, the new owner.” Walking away, Sam saw the smile spread across her face. He definitely didn’t want her to assist him in finding anything. In fact, he was planning to let Andrew pay. When she was finally out of earshot, he heard Andrew laugh.

  “Wow. That was uncomfortable to watch. It’s like you’ve never spoken to people before. Why does being here embarrass you? You’re the one that wanted to come here.”

  “I don’t think that she can help me.” He continued down the aisle.

  “What are you looking for?” Andrew asked, cocking his head to the side.

  “Some new toys to make Selena’s fantasy better.” They both knew that Selena wanted to have a ménage, and he was looking forward to making it happen. He wanted to make every night exciting so that this would be a great experience for them all.

  “Toys like handcuffs, paddles, and nipple clamps?” Andrew arched a brow. “Or flavored lube, anal plugs, and edible panties?” He stared at him, and Sam knew what he was asking. Were they going to introduce Selena to their lifestyle, or were they just going to have sex with her? Either way, he knew it would be fantastic.

  “We need everything. I wasn’t planning on meeting someone like Selena.” A slow smile spread across Andrew’s face, and Sam could tell that he was anticipating the night ahead.

  “Perfect. Now that I know what we’re looking for, let’s head to the bondage section.” Shaking his head, Sam followed Andrew toward the far wall.

  * * * *

  Selena watched them both go, and although she hated that they had errands to run, the view was spectacular. Tight asses encased in denim. Yummy.

  The sound of a throat clearing drew her attention and Selena turned and saw Ruth leaning against the registration desk, smiling. “Well, hello dear, how was the gun show?”

  “Oh, um, great. Thanks for asking. How has your day been so far?”