Their Colorado Nights [Spirit, Colorado 2] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Alicia White

  “Damn. Wyatt was right, this place makes women strip.” She looked up at Andrew and watched him take his clothes off as well. It made sense that this place belonged to both Wyatt and Austin. They were very good-looking men, so of course they would have a little love shack in the mountain. They weren’t anything like her Sam and Andrew. Her men made her weak in the knees.

  “It’s hot in here. That fireplace is unbelievable.” She wiped her moist skin and stood naked in front of them.

  “We’re waiting for you, Sam,” she said. Sam was standing by the bed, still wearing his jeans, and she wondered what he had planned.

  “Come to the bed, Selena, we’re going to try something a little different.” Excited, she went to him. The first thing she noticed was that the bed wasn’t as innocent as it looked from far away. It was a black, steel four-poster bed with restraint hoops on all the corners. It wasn’t a huge leap to realize that Wyatt and Austin had been here earlier, getting the place ready for them.

  “Don’t be nervous.” Sam wiped his finger tip down the side of her face, and Selena felt her heart beat faster. She wasn’t scared. She was overwhelmed and excited. Sam took her hand and led her closer to the bed, letting her see all the ropes that lay waiting for her. She trusted them completely and knew that they both were only thinking of her pleasure.

  “I’m not.” She licked her lips.

  “Are you sure?” He stared at her, and she knew that he was waiting for her to tell him no.

  “Yes.”

  “I’m going to tie you to the bed, spread eagle. From this moment on, both Andrew and I are in charge of your pleasure. Do you understand?” She started to nod, but he stopped her. “We don’t need to do this. I don’t want you saying yes because you think that’s what Andrew and I want to hear.”

  “I want to,” she said firmly, and Sam nodded his head slowly.

  “Okay, I want you on your back in the middle of the bed. Andrew, come over here and tie her legs, please.”

  Pulling herself up onto the bed, Selena scooted over until she was directly in the center. She had always been fascinated by BDSM, so having this experience was yet another fantasy come true. Spreading her arms and legs, Selena held her breath as both Andrew and Sam worked together, tying her down on the bed. Once she was tied down, she tested the binds by pulling on her arms and legs.

  “You’re so beautiful,” Sam whispered, pushing his fingers through her hair, and Selena lifted her head, nuzzling his hand.

  “Just one more thing…” Sam turned, and Selena watched him take something from Andrew. He pulled out a silky black piece of material, and she shifted, knowing what was coming.

  “I want you to focus on feeling, so I’m going to take away your sight.”

  “I want to see you, though. You’re so sexy.” She pouted, and Andrew laughed, stealing her attention away from Sam. Andrew stood naked, arms crossed, next to the bed, and she licked her lips. Damn, he’s gorgeous. Sam covered her eyes, and Selena lay back down, relaxing against the sheets.

  “I thought we could play a game. For every right answer, you get pleasure. Every wrong answer, we get pleasure,” Sam announced.

  “So, it’s a win-win for me either way. Sounds good.” She laughed. These men were so exciting. They always thought of new ways to play with her.

  She felt something touch her lips, and Selena opened her mouth, first licking and then biting into a sweet piece of fruit. “Yum, strawberry, my favorite. This is so easy.” She felt a mouth at each ear, and they nibbled and kissed down the sides of her neck to her shoulders. Selena moaned deep in her throat.

  The lips moved back up to her ears and a whispered, “Correct,” made her glad that they decided to play this game. Goose bumps broke out over her skin, and Selena shifted, wanting more attention, but they stopped.

  She waited for the next taste of food. Something soft brushed over her skin, and Selena closed her eyes tight behind the blindfold and tried to focus on what it could be.

  “It’s soft. Dang, this is a hard one. I don’t know.” The object was lightly rubbed all over her body, and Selena tried to think of something, but she had no idea. Shaking her head, she waited for her punishment.

  “Wrong answer, it was a feather duster.” A large, callused hand cupped each breast and her nipples were rolled gently at first and then pinched hard. She arched her back and let the small burst of pain rush through her body, morphing into pleasure.

  A cold, flat object got her attention, and Selena racked her brain trying to figure out what it could be. This game was getting tougher, and she wasn’t feeling as confident that she would win. “Crap. I don’t know. It’s cold and I’m assuming metal or plastic.”

  “Half right, but I’m sorry you didn’t guess it exactly, so it’s a wrong answer. Metal spoon.” She felt the bed dip and waited for her punishment. A warm body touched hers and then a cock was rubbing against her lips.

  “Open up, baby,” Andrew whispered, and she complied, opening her mouth wide. He fucked her mouth in slow, steady strokes. Selena curled her tongue around the head of his cock, enjoying the flavor. He pulled his cock out of her mouth too soon, and Selena curled her lip, making a sad face.

  “You can taste me later, baby.” Andrew kissed her cheeks and moved away from her and off the bed.

  “Okay, let’s see if you can get this right. It’s easy.” Sam told her before something freezing cold touched her skin. She tried to pull back as the small item was pulled up her leg to her stomach and then her neck. It left a trail of moisture behind on her skin and Selena immediately knew what it was.

  “Ice. Damn, that’s cold.”

  “Correct. Good job, baby.” The bed dipped once more, and she felt warm air touch her inner thigh and then her pussy. She knew right away what her prize was and relaxed. A hot tongue licked her pussy, and Selena fisted her hands, wishing she could touch one of her men. It was torture being tied down. She thought he might go slowly, but he didn’t. The mouth sucked her clit hard, and he pushed two fingers inside her pussy, fucking her. Thrashing her head, Selena focused on the mouth and the climax that was looming.

  “Andrew,” Sam warned, and the mouth pulled back, stopping. One gentle kiss to her clit, and the bed dipped once more. Andrew stepped away.

  “No, no, no. I was so close. Please let me come,” she begged.

  “One more thing, and then the game is over. You just need to get this one right to be the winner,” Sam informed her, and Selena nodded even though she was irritated.

  She felt them both at her hands, untying her. They rubbed her wrists gently and laid her arms down on the bed. Next, they went to her ankles and did the same.

  “Open your hands, palms up. This is a touching test.” She could hear the humor in Sam’s voice, almost as if he thought this was a silly joke.

  Waiting patiently, Selena soon felt two hard, flesh cocks in her hands. She stroked them both and made faces, pretending she had no idea what they were. She laughed silently to herself when Sam growled. They obviously wanted her to win.

  “Gosh, I just don’t know.” Applying more pressure, she stroked harder, loving the different sounds that they made.

  “You’re a little faker, you know.” Sam pulled the blindfold off her, and Selena laughed, looked back and forth between her two naked men. They were so delicious.

  Sam pulled her hand off his cock and grabbed a condom, quickly rolling it onto his hard shaft. He climbed onto the bed with her and pulled her into his arms. He kissed her gently, pushing his tongue inside her mouth. With their bodies close together, he rolled, moving her underneath him. It felt good to have his body on top of hers, their mouths meshed together. Shifting his hips, she spread her legs, feeling his cock hard and ready at the opening of her pussy.

  With a gentle push of his hips, he slowly entered her, and Selena moaned into his mouth, loving the way his cock felt. He pulled out until just the tip remained inside of her and then pushed back in until he was once more buried deep. His pace built
, and he moved faster, driving his cock into her deep and fast. Lifting his head, he stared into her eyes as he thrust into her, not holding anything back, moving fast and hard.

  Her legs hooked over his ass, her arms tightly wound around his neck. Their bodies moved together perfectly as he pounded, hitting every nerve ending. He held himself up, getting a better angle as he drove deeper, adjusting his cock to hit that spot inside her that made her cry out his name. Pleasure crashed through her as Sam moved.

  “Sam!” She yelled, digging her nails into his shoulders, needing him to slow down as her pussy twitched and convulsed around his hard cock.

  “Oh, God, baby, I’m coming!” he shouted, throwing his head back. She watched his face, mouth open, eyes shut tight. His muscles flexed, and his body jerked.

  Leaning his face down, he kissed her neck and held her tight. Her heart beat frantically and she held him, taking his weight. It felt good to be this close to him and she shut her eyes, knowing that she would miss him the minute he drove out of Spirit.

  They laid there together in silence, and Selena opened her eyes, wanting to find Andrew. He hadn’t joined them, and she looked to her right and saw him sitting in a chair, smiling. He winked, and she knew that he had given her and Sam this time alone to say good-bye. Her heart hurt, and Selena closed her eyes and took deep breaths, memorizing the smell, feel, and taste of Sam.

  Chapter 17

  The Next Morning

  Selena lay in her bed, staring at the ceiling. She had to go to the bathroom, but she didn’t want to move for fear that she would wake both Andrew and Sam and they would leave. Turning her head to the side, she stared at Sam’s beautiful face. Memories from the day before came to the forefront of her mind, and she remembered each and every detail of their time together at the cabin.

  After they made love, the three of them ate a delicious meal that Sam cooked in the kitchen. They spent most of the day and early evening together naked. When they left the cabin, she felt like Sam had said his good-bye. They had all mounted their horses and headed back to the ranch. When they reached the barn, Wyatt and Austin were standing there waiting for them.

  The drive home was relatively silent, and she held both their hands, fingers entwined. At that moment, she knew their happy threesome was over, at least temporarily. Her heart still hurt, though, realizing that Sam and Andrew were leaving.

  The bed moved, and Selena turned her head and watched Andrew’s naked ass as he walked to the bathroom. Waiting a couple of minutes, she rolled out, trying not to wake Sam. Tiptoeing to the bathroom, Selena watched Andrew get into the shower, and she hurried to the toilet to go relieve herself before she joined Andrew in the shower.

  “Good morning, beautiful,” he whispered, pulling her into his arms for a hug. The water rained down on them, and Selena felt herself waking up.

  “Morning.” Her words were muffled by his chest.

  The sound of the shower stall door opening got her attention, and she jerked her head, watching as a smiling Sam joined them. This would be their last morning together. She knew that it might not be forever, but still, having Sam come into town for sex on his vacation was less than what she knew she deserved.

  It was so weird to think about having one without the other, but she was glad to have Andrew coming back to Spirit. They stood in silence under the huge showerhead, and Selena felt like she could hear a ticking clock, counting down their time together. The three of them showered together. She washed them, and they spent time worshipping her body. The sound of her alarm clock shrieking made her jump, and Selena left the shower.

  Soaking wet, she ran to her alarm and shut it off. A towel was wrapped around her, and Selena snuggled into the thick, warm cotton. Turning her around, Sam leaned down and claimed her lips, kissing her, and she felt her eyes fill with tears. They kissed and touched, rubbing their bodies against one another.

  The sound of Ruth’s sputtering car pulled Selena out of her sexual high. She stopped, ran to her dresser and pulled out clothes. She knew that it was another workday, but she wasn’t expecting Ruth this early.

  “Shit. I’m sorry. I wasn’t expecting my mom to be here this early. She probably wants to say good-bye.” Sam looked sad, and Selena could only shake her head. It was now obvious that the three of them wouldn’t be able to make love one last time.

  “It’s okay. I’m sure you both have to pack anyway. I’ll go unlock the back door. See you in the kitchen.” Selena hurried. She got dressed in record time, kissed them both, and left her room.

  Selena skipped her normal routine of lighting incense and meditating. She rushed through the kitchen, opening the back door just as Ruth walked up the back stairs.

  “Good morning, Ruth,” Selena said, breathing heavily.

  “Good morning, dear. I know it’s early, but I really wanted to make breakfast for Sam and Andrew, and I wanted to say good-bye again.” Selena nodded. She understood that Ruth wanted to see her sons off. Ruth walked into the kitchen, set her bag down and starting rummaging through the cupboards.

  “What are you going to make them?”

  “Bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches. They usually don’t like stopping on the way home, and I want to make sure that they have a good meal on the road.” Selena went to the dryer and pulled out the cloth napkins. She went to the large counter and sat down on the barstool. Folding the clothes, she tried not to focus on the thought that her men were leaving. She wasn’t going to have the final good-bye she wanted, but she was glad that they had spent the whole day together yesterday.

  Ruth finished cooking their breakfast, wrapped both sandwiches in a cloth napkin along with some other snacks and put everything into a picnic basket on the counter. Selena folded faster, taking her irritation out on folding. She was really sad and knew that the minute they left she would probably call Lana. She needed some girl time. Staring at the pile of napkins, Selena sat in silence as Ruth worked on making breakfast for the guests.

  “Do you want to help me make breakfast?” Ruth asked, and Selena jerked her head up, wondering if she had heard her correctly.

  “What? You never let me help,” she exclaimed.

  “I know, but you look like you might need a distraction,” she said sympathetically, and Selena stood up, ready to help. Ruth held her arms open, and Selena hugged her.

  “It’s going to be okay. They’re both going to move here. I know that Andrew will be home first, but trust me, Sam will be following behind him in no time.” Ruth winked. Maybe she knew something that Selena didn’t. Either way, it was hard to believe.

  “I don’t think so. They both have a business there in Santa Fe. I know Andrew’s coming back, but I don’t think Sam will. He likes it there. He’s got a life there.” She tried not to sound too depressed, but she couldn’t keep the sadness out of her voice.

  “Come on. Let’s make breakfast.” Ruth led her to the counter next to the stove and handed off her knife. For the next twenty minutes, Selena cut up vegetables and fruit, grated cheese, and cracked eggs into a large bowl for Ruth.

  The kitchen door swung open, and Andrew and Sam walked into the kitchen. They both looked sad, and Selena forced a smile. She wouldn’t let them see how she really felt. She didn’t want them to be depressed on the long drive home.

  “I made you boys breakfast.” Ruth hugged both of them, and they said their good-byes.

  “Mom, don’t be upset. I’ll be back here next week for good, and you know Sam comes to town a few times a year, but eventually he’ll move here, too.” Andrew comforted her.

  “I know. I just want my family to all be together.” Ruth wiped her face.

  “You’ll have Andrew and Selena, Mom. It’s okay.” Sam hugged her tight and Ruth sniffled.

  “All right, you boys say your good-byes to Selena now. I’ll finish making breakfast.” Ruth went back to work and Selena went to them both and took their hands. The three of them walked out to the front, and she noticed their luggage was already packed, sitting at
the front door.

  Her heart beat a little faster and her eyes filled with tears, but she refused to let them fall. She had no idea what she was going to do. Her life had been so routine and boring. They came into town and changed everything. Sam pulled her into his arms and held her tight. She felt the tears she was holding in slip and fall down her cheeks, landing on his shirt. She inhaled his scent, trying to memorize him and this moment. She knew that she would see him again, but she just couldn’t seem to control her heart breaking.

  “I love you, baby. I’ll be back in July for a week and then November for two weeks. It’s only going to be four months.”

  “I know,” she sniffled. “I’m just gonna miss you.”

  Pulling her back, he wiped the tears off her cheeks and kissed her gently. Throwing her arms around his neck, she took over the kiss, pushing her tongue into his mouth, needing one more taste. He moaned, grabbing her ass and rubbing his erection against her stomach. She wished that they had more time and the privacy of a room, but they didn’t. Giving him one last kiss, she let him go and went to Andrew, hugging and kissing him good-bye as well.

  “I’ll be back in a week. Keep the bed warm for me.” He kissed her once more and then picked up his luggage. Sam did the same, and she watched them turn and leave. Walking outside, they went to Sam’s truck, loaded their things, and jumped in. She couldn’t take her eyes off them until they were down the street and out of sight. Swallowing the lump in her throat, Selena went to her room. She needed a few minutes alone. As soon as the bedroom door closed, she collapsed to the floor and started crying.

  * * * *

  One Week Later

  Sitting in the kitchen, Selena bit her nails, wondering when Andrew would show up. It had been a whole week without either of her men, and she felt lonely. It was amazing how having them around relaxed her and made her so happy. She knew that she was in love before they left and went back to Santa Fe, but it was drilled in when the truck hit the main street and drove away.