Dare to Trust [The Dare Series 1] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Dixie Lynn Dwyer

  She lowered her eyes. “I don’t want to talk about it. I’m not ready to.”

  “But this guy hurt you? He was an alcoholic?” Danny asked.

  She nodded her head.

  Jack stood up and walked closer. He rubbed her back trying to soothe her.

  “I won’t drink around you ever if it reminds you of him.”

  He was serious and she felt the tears in her eyes. He would do that for her? They can’t be real. When were the real men, the manipulative assholes going to show their ugly faces?

  “You don’t have to do that. I just wanted to be sure that drinking wasn’t something you do a lot or that you get drunk a lot. I mean you guys own and operate a bar. I don’t expect you to not drink. I wouldn’t ask you to not drink because of my stupid fears.”

  “Hey, your fears aren’t stupid. We would do that for you. We want you to feel safe and cared for,” Mike told her and he cupped her cheeks, leaned forward, and kissed her.

  She wrapped her arms around his shoulders and hugged him tight when he released her lips. He ran his hands along her lower back and then to her ass. He massaged it as he suckled against the skin on her neck.

  She kissed his neck in return and then things got a little wild.

  * * * *

  Danny lifted up Marlena’s shirt and began to massage her shoulders and her lower back. She eased back up and Mike caressed under her shirt and used his hands to lift her top and cup her breasts. Jack placed his fingers against her cheek, turned her to the right, and kissed her deeply. They were all touching her together and Danny felt so possessive and turned on. She had a sexy body, with a firm, round ass that filled her jeans to capacity, and large breasts that were too big to cup with one hand. And they all had big hands.

  Danny wanted to explore her body. He wanted to bring her pleasure and make her feel completely comfortable with him and his brothers touching her. Jack was kissing her deeply and she was moaning softly against his mouth. When Mike unclipped her bra, she tightened up, but Jack wouldn’t release her lips and Mike was fast to soothe her concerns.

  “Just getting to know this sexy body of yours, Marlena. We’ll only go as far as you want us to. Relax and just feel. Let us make you feel good,” he said then lowered his mouth to her breast.

  Behind her Danny watched his brother’s mouth latch onto a pink nipple as he massaged her full breast. Danny kissed her shoulder as he watched his brother explore and bring Marlena pleasure. He maneuvered his own hands around her waist to clasp on her jeans and then carefully unclipped them and pressed down the zipper. He suckled against her neck as Jack explored her mouth. She began to rock her hips and he knew she was aroused. He wanted to make her come. Right here in this kitchen. Right where they bonded and talked and shared their first kiss.

  He maneuvered his fingers down into her pants and under her panties. She felt so hot and smooth.

  “Fuck, baby, you are really warm down here. Are you wet, too? Are you liking three men loving this body together?” he asked then felt for her clit, pressed downward, and stroked a finger up into her cunt.

  She pulled from Jack’s mouth and gasped.

  “Oh God. Oh, Danny, please. We need to slow down. I shouldn’t be feeling this way.”

  “Yes, you should. You deserve to be cared for, catered to, and loved,” Jack told her and then reached for her cheeks and kissed her deeply again.

  Danny pressed her pants down lower and past her knees. He maneuvered closer behind her and rocked his hips against the crack of her ass so she could feel how hard his erection was. He stroked his fingers deeper and faster then pulled them out.

  Mike shoved the chair out from under him and lowered to his one knee. He was working on her breasts.

  Jack pulled from her mouth.

  “Hold on to Mike’s shoulders,” he told her, and she did as she panted and rocked her hips.

  Danny couldn’t see what Mike was doing. He focused on his own plan as he spread her thighs and pulled one of her legs from confinement as he stroked her cunt from behind. She moaned again.

  “Oh God please. Please.” She begged for more.

  Jack caressed her hair from her face.

  “Let go, Marlena. Let us have that sweet cream. Come for us. Orgasm for your three men.”

  She shook her head and Jack continued to push her.

  “You can trust us to care for you and to catch you when you fall.”

  Danny thrust two fingers into her cunt faster and faster. She was dripping with cream and he wanted to taste her. It would be difficult in this position, but he could do it. He needed to get her wetter and send her over the edge.

  She was panting and moaning and as he stroked she spread her legs wider.

  He pulled out his fingers and stroked her anus.

  “Oh God,” she gasped. Jack leaned down and caressed her as cheeks.

  “You have a perfect ass, Marlena. Perfect.” He ran his hand along the cheeks and pinched her ass cheek. She jerked and more cream dripped from her pussy.

  “I think she likes that, Jack,” Danny said.

  “Just wait until she takes a cock in her mouth, her pussy, and her ass at the same time. She’ll love that,” Jack said and then pressed his finger over her puckered hole and pushed against it.

  She shook and Danny lowered to his knees, pulled his fingers from her pussy, and suckled her cunt with his mouth. She bent forward more and Mike held her so that Danny could get better access to her pussy.

  “Give him your sweet cream, Marlena,” Mike ordered her.

  “Oh God, this is so naughty. So bad,” she cried out and then shivered. Danny felt her pussy explode and he licked and suckled until her clit was swollen and then Mike was lifting her up into his arms.

  Danny leaned back on his heels and smiled at Jack.

  “Delicious,” he said, and Jack headed toward the couch where Mike held Marlena on his lap.

  * * * *

  Mike caressed her hair from her cheeks and held her tight.

  “Are you okay, Marlena?”

  She nodded her head.

  Jack knelt on the floor next to her and Mike.

  He reached out and caressed her thigh.

  “I want to taste you, too. Will you let me?” Jack asked her.

  She pulled her bottom lip between her teeth and then looked at Mike. Mike cupped her cheek.

  “We all want a taste of what’s ours.”

  Her cheeks turned a nice shade of red and then she nodded.

  Mike smiled at her then kissed her nose.

  “I want to taste you, too,” she said, and Jack felt his heart begin to pound inside of his chest. He couldn’t talk. He could hope that she meant what she just said.

  Mike held her gaze. “You don’t have to if you’re not ready.”

  “I want to,” she said and then she turned in Mike’s arms and straddled his waist. She kissed him deeply and then she lowered down his body until her knees were on the rug and she began to unzip his jeans.

  Behind her Jack caressed her smooth, round ass.

  “I love this ass. I love the little sounds you make when you’re coming.” He stroked his finger up into her cunt as he spread her thighs wider. She gasped but then Jack heard Mike moan. Jack peeked to the side and saw Mike’s cock disappearing into Marlena’s mouth. His own dick hardened.

  “Fuck, that’s hot Marlena. You’re so giving,” Danny told her as he caressed her hair.

  “Damn, Marlena, that mouth. Oh God, baby, that feels so good. So fucking good,” Mike said, holding her head and thrusting upward lightly.

  Behind her Jack stroked a finger from her pussy then over her anus. Every time he swiped her anus, it contracted.

  He leaned forward and licked along each ass cheek as he thrust his fingers into her cunt. He was stroking quickly, turned on by the sight of her cream, her sexy body, and how giving she was.

  He licked along her crevice.

  She moaned louder and pressed her ass back.

  Jack pulled
one finger from her ass and maneuvered it against her puckered hole. He slowly pushed into the tight rings and entered her. In and out he stroked both her anus and her pussy. She rocked her hips faster. Her head bobbed up and down faster on Mike’s cock and Mike moaned his release.

  Marlena followed and Jack pulled his fingers from her body, lifted her hips, and suckled her cream as it poured from her pussy.

  “My turn,” Danny said and Jack moved out of the way. Danny lifted her up into his arms. She straddled his waist and he kissed her.

  Jack looked at Mike, who was smiling and moving off the couch.

  Jack looked at the gauze on her hip and the scarring that hit along her hip bone and upper thigh. It was definitely a burn of some sort.

  He watched as Danny laid her on the couch, spread her thighs wide, and then feasted on her cunt.

  Marlena sat there holding his head, panting and wearing only her T-shirt, her bra still undone and her breasts bobbing and swaying. Then Danny placed her thighs over his shoulders and he suckled and fingered her cunt until Marlena was screaming Danny’s name and holding him to her chest.

  Danny leaned up and kissed her deeply then held her in his arms as she wrapped her legs around his midsection and caught her breath.

  She was amazing. She was their woman, and he wanted to know who hurt her, who scared her so much and possibly caused those physical scars. Whoever they were, he and his brothers would make sure that person never got near her again. Never.

  * * * *

  Marlena was shocked when Jack appeared with a warm washcloth to wash her up. She reached for the cloth. “I can do that.”

  He shook his head and pulled it from her grasp. He held her gaze. “That’s our job. To take care of you, and cater to your every need.”

  She swallowed hard and when he was done, he leaned down and kissed the top of her pussy. She shivered, pulling her bottom lip between her teeth as Mike scooped her up, and placed her onto his lap. Danny placed a blanket over her.

  They joined her on the couch and she wanted to ask them more about this relationship and how they felt it could work. She loved every minute with them. She loved what they just shared. She’d never felt so many emotions and such a connection before. It was wild.

  “Why do you want to share me? What is it the three of you are looking for in a ménage relationship?” she asked.

  Mike looked at Jack and Danny.

  “I think the three of us want a woman we can all relate to, connect with on most levels, and to share our lives knowing that woman, you, would always be cared for,” Danny told her.

  “I think in some ways we feel like everything we have to give is even more, and a deeper connection and strength than if just one of us loves a woman and makes her ours,” Jack added.

  “I think it’s all of that, and the simple fact that my brothers and I are close. We grew up with parents who love us and support us and who engage in a ménage relationship and are very happy. I like knowing that when I’m at work, or have to leave for a training or something, that my brothers are with you, protecting you,” Mike said.

  “You’ll never be alone, I mean unless you want some alone time. It’s not like we’d become your shadow. It’s more like your protectors, your guardians, the ones that ensure you live a happy, loving life, and that you’ll want to love each of us as well.”

  She thought about what they said and she played with her fingernails.

  “It sounds so nice, so perfect. But I don’t know if I can do this. I’m scared for a whole lot of reasons.”

  “But when we’re with you, are you scared?” Danny asked her.

  “No.”

  “When we shared what we did, when each of us were touching you, arousing you, and making you come, were you scared?” Jack asked.

  “Sort of,” she replied.

  Mike cupped her chin.

  “What do you mean sort of?”

  “I never felt anything like it before. I wanted to please the three of you, but I was also getting pleasure from the three of you. It wasn’t one-sided. It was equal.”

  “Exactly. And that’s the way this relationship works. We’re equal. One doesn’t love the other more, we love together,” Danny said to her.

  “God, it’s so much to take in and accept. I want to be with each of you. I want to feel more of what you made me feel. It’s wild.”

  “It’s real, not fake or forced,” Jack said to her. He took her hand, brought it to his lips, and kissed her knuckles.

  “Can you see yourself being with us? Living with us? Making love to us and giving us all of you as we give all of ourselves in return?” Jack asked.

  She knew immediately that she could. Hell, she would ask them to stay the night right now if they had already been dating a while. They could think she was easy or desperate. Hell, did she have to tell them about Peter and what he did to her and how he could come looking for her?

  “Yes. I can.”

  “Good, because in a few minutes I want another taste of that sweet cream,” Danny told her and ran his hand between her legs, and she wiggled from his touch and maneuvered off of Mike.

  She stood up, wrapped the blanket around her waist, and held their gazes.

  “I don’t think that’s a good idea,” she said.

  “Why the hell not?” Jack asked, standing up in front of her.

  She held his gaze. “Because then I’ll ask you to stay the night, and make love to me.”

  They all stood up. Danny pulled her closer and cupped her cheek.

  “And what would be so bad about that?” he asked.

  “We haven’t even gone out on a date yet. What would you think of me, jumping into bed with three men who haven’t even asked me on a real date?” she teased, feeling her cheeks warm.

  “The woman’s right. We’re going about this ass backwards,” Danny said, taking her hands into his.

  Jack moved in behind her and grabbed her hips and rocked his cock against her ass. “With an ass as perfect as hers, ass backwards is fine with me.” He kissed and suckled her neck, making her giggle then smack at his shoulder.

  “Let’s make it official. Dinner tomorrow night?”

  “But we have to finish this kitchen,” she said.

  “Well, I’m fine with dinner here tonight being our first date, if you are,” Danny said, teasing her.

  God was she tempted, but she wanted to do this right.

  “No can do. A real date, so I don’t feel so easy,” she said.

  “Not easy. We’ve been hinting at liking you, wanting you for over six months. Definitely not easy,” Mike told her.

  “So the lunches and breakfasts don’t count either?” Danny asked as he pushed the blanket down and off of her, wrapped his arm around her waist, and cupped her bare pussy.

  “Danny!” she scolded, and Jack and Mike chuckled.

  “Dessert again it is,” Mike said, and Danny carried her to the couch, lifted her so her back was against his front, and spread her thighs over his open thighs. She faced Mike and Jack.

  “Brothers, look what I got for you,” he said and he cupped her breasts, and Mike fell to his knees and stroked her pussy.

  “Get ready, baby, we’re going to break you down and get you used to this triple action,” Mike said then began to feast on her pussy. His brothers cheered.

  “Oh yeah, triple action strikes again,” Jack said and Marlena moaned her first release and wondered if she would have the willpower or the strength to make them go home tonight when really all she wanted was for them to stay.

  Chapter 6

  “Okay spill the beans now, woman,” Mercedes said as Marlena stood by the table with Adele and Alicia. She’d called for this meeting and Mercedes knew that her project with Danny and his brothers had progressed further and faster.

  As she explained what went down, they were smiling wide.

  “Oh God this is great. They’re perfect for you. Why the hell didn’t you just sleep with them last night?” Mercedes asked.<
br />
  “Duh! You know why,” Marlena said and looked around the diner. It was slow now. The rush would be in soon.

  Adele touched Marlena’s hand. “Honey, you like them a lot. They obviously care about you and the chemistry is there. You should take the chance and see where this goes.”

  “And if they turn out to be using me, then what? Besides, I don’t think I can let it go that far. Not yet, anyway,” Marlena said, lowering her eyes and worrying her bottom lip.

  “Marlena, I’m the last one to give advice to anyone about men. I lost more than I can explain because of my poor decisions. But, time heals everything. Moving here to Chance, the four of us finding one another was fate. We support you no matter what decision you make. But know this, don’t let that man from your past dictate your future. There’s differences between him and the Spencer men. You know it. You feel it,” Alicia told her.

  “I know that. I do. In my head, at least.”

  “No, in your heart and in your body, from what you described took place in your little cottage last night,” Mercedes teased. They all chuckled and Marlena’s cheeks reddened. She looked around the diner and made sure no one was listening. They were in the corner away from anyone and whispering low.

  “I’m scared. For more reasons than I shared with the three of you.”

  Mercedes looked at the others. What had Marlena left out about the man from Connecticut who was alcoholic and abusive?

  “What I didn’t tell you is that Peter, well, he could be looking for me.”

  “What?” Adele and Alicia asked at the same time. Mercedes took Marlena’s hand.

  “Honey, shit, why didn’t you tell us?”

  Marlena wiped the tear from her eye before it escaped.

  “I’m embarrassed by it. I don’t want to face the fact that I could have to hightail it out here one day with no notice, no explanation, and just disappear.”

  “No, honey. No, you can’t live your life like this. What did he do to you? I mean like being verbally and physically abusive is one thing, but what else that he could come after you?” Adele asked her this time.