Dare to Trust [The Dare Series 1] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Dixie Lynn Dwyer

  “Oh Jesus, baby, that’s the scar on your hip?” Jack asked, kneeling down next to her and caressing her hip. She nodded her head.

  “The detectives and arson investigators couldn’t prove arson?” Mike asked.

  “They proved the cause was arson and there was an investigation, but Peter had an alibi once again. A woman. The one he cheated on me with.”

  “I don’t understand it. The arson investigators, the detectives would have pushed passed some bogus alibi to get the truth.” Mike raised his voice.

  Marlena stood up. “You think I’m lying? You think I’m making this up? This up?” she repeated and pushed down her shorts, raised her top, and revealed the scar from the burn she had gotten. Tears rolled down her cheeks.

  “Get out! All of you, now,” she yelled. She was so angry she was shaking. But the three men didn’t move.

  “I said get out!” she yelled again as tears rolled down her cheeks.

  “No, Marlena. We’re not getting out. You’re not pushing us away. We care about you,” Danny told her and stepped forward and pulled her into his arms. She felt the hands on her back rubbing her.

  “We asked for the truth and you told us. We’re not going to lie to you. We’re pissed off, we’re concerned, and things are going to change around here whether you like it or not,” Jack said.

  She pulled back, looking at Danny, who held her, reached up, and caressed the tears from her eyes.

  Then she looked at Jack. “What do you mean?” she asked.

  Mike stepped closer but didn’t touch her. She felt sick. He didn’t want her because of what Peter did to her. What she allowed him to take from her.

  “He means that you’re our woman. We’re claiming you officially with the sheriff, tonight. We’re going to protect you, be with you, and provide for you. No more holding back. No lies. No keeping things from us out of fear that we’ll be angry or that we could get hurt or some other nonsense bullshit. You understand me?” Mike asked her.

  She sniffled and could hardly hold his gaze, her eyes were tearing so much.

  “You don’t hate me?” she asked him.

  Mike uncrossed his arms and Danny and Jack released her to him.

  “Goddamn, baby, no fucking way do I hate you. I’m practically in love with you if you would let the damn wall down now and let us in. You need us. You’re ours, and there are no more arguments about it anymore. Got it?” he asked, pulling her hard up against his chest.

  She nodded her head and wrapped her arms around his shoulders.

  “Are you sure, Mike?” she whispered.

  “As sure as anything.” He leaned down and kissed her deeply. She let herself go. She gave her all in that kiss and then felt Mike lift her up and lay her down on the bed. He eased up slightly, his one thigh between her legs as he stared down into her eyes.

  “You’re not going anywhere. You belong with my brothers and me. And when you’re not working, you’ll be with one of us. Making love, letting us possess every part of you in every way. You got it?” he asked. She felt her heart racing and her belly quiver with excitement and love.

  She looked at all three of them as they gathered around her on the bed. Jack was unbuttoning his shirt while Danny was pulling his up and over his head.

  “What are you doing?” she whispered, even though she knew what they were doing and what she wanted. Them.

  Naked and making love to her for the rest of the night. Forever.

  “Getting ready to possess you in every way. To care for you, to make love to you, and to have your heart and your soul like you already have ours,” Jack said.

  She smiled then bit her lower lip.

  “I’ve never been with three men before. Uhm…will it hurt?” she asked shyly.

  Danny smiled and the clapped his hands together and rubbed them.

  “Only a little when I slap that ass while I’m fucking it.”

  “Danny,” Mike and Jack scolded.

  Marlena gulped. “Oh God. I don’t know about this,” she said.

  “Nice and slow, Marlena. We’ve got all the time in the world. Forever in fact,” Jack said then leaned over and began to lift up her tank top. Mike slid off the bed and discarded his clothing. Jack pushed her shorts and panties down, and Danny moved in to take a taste. His head was between her legs in no time and she was naked, holding his head, and feeling already ready to explode.

  She rocked her hips and titled her head back until she caught sight of Jack and Mike naked. Her mouth watered and she reached out to touch them. But they had different ideas and so did Danny.

  Danny lifted up and smiled. “Fucking delicious.” He gripped her hips, flipped her over then pulled her back.

  “Condoms?” he said aloud.

  “Right here,” Jack said, passing him one.

  She shivered and shook, she was so aroused. She couldn’t help but wonder if he would take her ass. She wanted them everywhere. She wanted to be their possession, their woman.

  She didn’t want anything between them as she looked over her shoulder to see Danny fumbling with the condom. Jack caressed her back and ass, and Mike watched her with sultry eyes. He leaned over and cupped her breasts.

  “You don’t need the condoms. I’m on the pill. I’m clean. I always used protection with Peter.” Danny threw the condom and gripped her hips, pulling them back and against him.

  He lay over her back softly and kissed her neck, and whispered into her ear.

  “Never say his name in our bed, when we’re making love. He’s gone. He doesn’t exist with us. We’re your lovers. Your only ones.”

  “Yes,” she said and closed her eyes.

  She felt her legs being spread wide and then Danny’s mouth on her cunt from behind. He pressed his tongue in and out as Jack touched her cheek and brought his cock to her mouth.

  She didn’t hesitate as she took it between her lips and began to suck his cock. Back and forth, she bobbed her head until she felt Danny lifting her higher. Mike slid underneath. They moved her around how they liked and easily with their big muscles and strong capabilities. It aroused her as she came just as Danny thrust fingers to her cunt.

  “Oh, she’s ready for us,” Danny said to them. She felt his tongue lick back and forth over her crevice. The she felt his fingers again thrust into her cunt then back over her puckered hole. A moment later she felt Mike’s cock as he gripped her hips and held her gaze.

  “You want us?” She nodded as she moaned, still sucking Jack’s cock as he held her hair and caressed her cheek. She took in all the sounds, the smells, and the sensations. Men’s cologne, soap, masculinity, and control. She wanted to please them, to give them every part of her and just let go. She wanted them in her life forever. She wanted their love, their touches, and their bodies. She moaned louder as cream dripped from her cunt.

  “Fuck, she’s coming like crazy. She’s so turned on,” Danny said.

  “Then she’s ready. She ready for all of us,” Mike said and then she felt his cock against her pussy. She moaned against Jack’s cock.

  “Get inside of her. I’m not going to last long,” he said, and then Mike pushed upward and she cried out from the fast penetration. She let him hold her hips and rock up into her as Jack held her head to steady her as he fucked her mouth. She was overwhelmed with emotions and need. Then she felt the finger press into her anus and she lost it. She shook and shivered but the three men had plans. She let go. She let them have complete control as the tears rolled down her face and happiness filled her heart. She felt Danny’s fingers pull from her ass and she thrust her ass backward in resistance to him leaving their position. But then she felt the thick, bulbous head of his cock and heard his calm, deep voice against her ear and neck. It sent shivers and vibrations through her body.

  “I’m coming in. We’re yours and you’re ours. Tonight is only the beginning, baby.” He slowly pushed into her and she couldn’t breathe. Jack kept pumping and Mike held her steady, his cock deep in her cunt. Then she felt Dann
y ease in and out until she felt the pop and he sunk all the way into her ass. They all moaned and took a moment to just feel the sensations of being inside of her.

  “Move. Fucking move. I’m there,” Jack complained. In and out, they thrust into her in sync.

  “Marlena, I’m coming, baby. Let me out if you don’t want to swallow,” Jack said. She was touched that he offered. Peter never had. He forced her to swallow him even when she didn’t even want to give him oral sex. He was a jerk. These men were different. They seemed to really care and want her.

  She held him steady as he grunted and came. She swallowed all of him until he pulled from her mouth and reprimanded her for torturing him.

  Then Mike and Danny took over. The bed rocked and moaned, the moans filling the room as their bodies slapped against one another. She loved them. She knew it, and after tonight there was no turning back.

  Marlena felt her body tighten up just as Danny roared his release and shoved balls-deep into her ass. He shook and shivered, then gave her ass a series of five smacks. She creamed some more. He pulled out slowly, kissing her spine and caressing her ass until Mike took over complete control. He rolled her to her back and thrust into her hard and fast. Their fingers clasped together as he raised them above her head and rocked into her. Their gazes locked.

  “Ours forever. Never anyone else.”

  “Never,” she said and then let go as her body convulsed one more time along with Mike. They came together then he held her in his arms, promising her protection, compassion, and ultimately more than anyone had ever offered her in her life.

  * * * *

  Mike held Marlena in his arms. Her breasts were pressed up against his chest as Jack pressed up behind her. Jack’s hand caressed her outer thigh and up to where the burn on her skin from the fire sat. It was the same side she had the blisters on from the cup of coffee Vicky pushed on her. It pissed him off. He hadn’t wanted Marlena to feel any pain. Never again. Not as long as he were alive.

  He inhaled her shampoo and the scent of their lovemaking in the air. Jack sat in a chair, half-dressed with his legs stretched out on the bottom of the bed. They were all around her. Their lovemaking so intense, so deep, he actually felt fearful.

  He swallowed hard as he stared at the discoloration on her skin, and thought about the fear she had to have had when she was caught in the horrible fire. A fire her boyfriend set to try and kill her. He needed to talk with Max. The sheriff and some of their other close friends who had experience and connections in law enforcement and the government would know what to do. He and his brothers would protect her forever.

  When he ran a finger gently along the raised skin, she flinched and nonchalantly moved onto her back so he couldn’t touch her there. It was obvious she was sensitive. She crossed her arms to try and cover her large breasts but she was unsuccessful.

  “Baby, don’t even try it. They’re way too beautiful to cover up,” Jack said as he reached over and cupped a breast. He lowered his mouth to her lips, kissed her, and then her breast.

  Mike turned onto his side and ran his hand along her belly. He played with the small delicate decoration, a diamond hoop. It was feminine and petite like her.

  She giggled and reached out to caress the top of his hand.

  “Jack,” she moaned as Jack suckled her breast and pulled on the nipple. Mike eased his hand between her legs and softly caressed her mound.

  The bed dipped.

  “Open for us. Offer us what’s ours, Marlena,” Danny told her.

  Danny was once again naked and between her legs, stroking a finger into her cunt, making her moan and thrust. She tried to push her legs together, but Mike and Jack pressed them wider with their palms. Mike leaned down and licked across her nipple.

  “Your body is amazing, Marlena. Every inch of you is gorgeous,” he said and then leaned up and kissed her.

  “Hold her for me. Put her hands above her head. I want to see her breasts bounce so sexy, and her eyes dilate while I make her come again and again,” Danny said and Mike and Jack massaged up each arm and then pressed them high above her head.

  “Oh God please, Danny. I’m shaking.”

  Danny sat up between her spread thighs that Mike and Jack held open with their other hand. Danny stroked his cock, letting the tip tap against Marlena’s pussy lips.

  “Oh,” she moaned.

  “That’s because you need cock. Our cocks inside of you. Isn’t that right?” he asked her then pressed the tip of his cock slightly into her pussy.

  “Yes. Yes, I do.”

  “That’s right.” He reached up and cupped both breasts, bringing them together and massaging them.

  “How do you want us, Marlena? One at a time or together, with a cock in every hole?” he asked.

  “Oh. My. God,” she said and shook as she came.

  “Eyes open. Look at us as you come,” Danny ordered. Her eyes popped open and Mike felt his own cock harden. He was totally turned on by this. By sharing Marlena with his brothers, his best friends.

  “I need her, too,” Mike said and then stroked along her pussy, being sure not to touch his brother’s cock.

  “Yes, Mike. Yes. However you want me. I don’t care just take me. All of you,” she said and Danny chuckled.

  “Oh, we plan on it. Again, and again, and again.”

  Jack lay down on the edge of the bed with his legs lying over the side. Danny lifted her up and placed her onto Jack, who pressed his cock immediately up into her wet cunt. They both moaned.

  “I have her mouth this time. I want to feel those sexy lips on me. You get her sexy ass,” Danny said and gave her ass a slap as he got into position.

  Mike got into position behind her as he stood on the rug and caressed her ass.

  “Pull out a sec, bro, I need to get this ass ready for me,” Mike said and Jack lifted her up by the hips, pulling his cock from her pussy. Mike pressed fingers to her cunt from behind and stroked her over and over again, until she was panting and creaming everywhere. He stroked fingers over her anus then pressed one in. “We’re good,” he said as he used his other hand to massage her ass. Jack pulled her down for a kiss and thrust his cock up into her pussy, making her moan and thrust against him.

  She cried out when Jack released her lips and started thrusting hard and fast upward. Then Danny took her face between his hands and kissed her deeply as Mike fingered her ass, getting it ready. Mike couldn’t take it anymore. He wanted in. He wanted to claim her ass, claim every part of her, every inch, and mark her his woman. He would protect her and watch over her always.

  He pulled his fingers from her ass and replaced them with his cock. He slowly pushed through the tight rings and Marlena moaned and bucked on top of Jack.

  “I’ve got something for you, Marlena. Come on now and be a good girl,” Danny said and pressed his cock to her lips. She must have opened immediately because Danny moaned and then it was on. They worked their cocks into her together, making her moan and thrust. Mike slapped her ass, massaged the cheeks, then smacked her ass again. He could feel her cream drip and then heard Danny grunt as he came and Jack followed. Mike thrust harder, faster, wanting, needing to mark her so she knew she would never belong to anyone but them and then he heard her scream her orgasm and he couldn’t hold back. He grunted and called out her name as he came.

  “Marlena! Marlena!”

  He held himself within her and caught his breath. He stared at the marking on her hip and he caressed it, held her hips despite her shifting and trying to still pull away. He pulled her back as Jack and Danny released her and he hugged her back to his chest.

  “Don’t hold back and be afraid. He can’t hurt you anymore. We’ll protect you. Just trust us,” he said and kissed her shoulder. He felt her ease up and relax as he slowly pulled from her body. Jack was there with a washcloth for her, and as he caressed her skin, Jack kissed her. Mike locked gazes with Danny, and his brother didn’t have to say a word. Tomorrow they would start the hunt. Tomorrow they
would take the steps to ensure Marlena was safe in Chance and with them, forever.

  Chapter 8

  “I can’t be late for work,” Marlena said, stepping out of the shower and wrapping a towel around her body. Danny watched as he stood in the doorway with his arms crossed in front of his bare chest. His brothers had left for work earlier. Every day this week they stayed the night at Marlena’s place. But last night, after they all made love and as she slept, they awoke hearing her crying and moaning in her sleep. He wanted to ask her about it and wondered if it was a normal occurrence. Could she be having nightmares of the fire and not telling them?

  “Why are you looking at me like that?” she asked, pulling the towel from her body and wrapping her hair in it. She flipped her head over then used the towel to wrap around her head before placing it on top. He was always amazed about how women did that, but with Marlena he watched her every move. He wanted to memorize every detail, every marking on her body from the scar that made him long to hurt the man responsible, to every pretty, dainty freckle and beauty mark.

  She was stunning, and she was theirs.

  “I’m not allowed to look at you? To admire your sexy body, and think about the many ways I want to explore it with my brothers?” he teased. Her cheeks turned a nice shade of red and she quickly stepped into her tiny black thong and a crisp white bra she had to stuff her breast into.

  He licked his lips. He adored her body, her beauty, her everything.

  Marlena took the towel off her head, towel-dried her hair, then ran a brush through the long blond strands.

  She bent over to reach under the counter for the hair dryer, like she did every morning this week, and he uncrossed his arms, snagged her around the waist, and held her to him.

  “Danny,” she scolded, gripping onto his forearms. But he held her gaze in the reflection of the mirror and she smiled and leaned back against his chest.