Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality

by Eliezer Yudkowsky

  So complex, interdependent machinery, the powerful sophisticated protein machines that drove life, was always universal within a sexually reproducing species - except for a small handful of non-interdependent variants that were being selected on at any given time, as further complexity was slowly laid down. It was why all human beings had the same underlying brain design, the same emotions, the same facial expressions wired up to those emotions; those adaptations were complex, so they had to be universal.

  If magic had been like that, a big complex adaptation with lots of necessary genes, then a wizard mating with a Muggle would have resulted in a child with only half those parts and half the machine wouldn't do much. And so there would have been no Muggleborns, ever. Even if all the pieces had individually gotten into the Muggle gene pool, they'd never reassemble all in one place to form a wizard.

  There hadn't been some genetically isolated valley of humans that had stumbled onto an evolutionary pathway leading to sophisticated magical sections of the brain. That complex genetic machinery, if wizards interbred with Muggles, would never have reassembled into Muggleborns.

  So however your genes made you a wizard, it wasn't by containing the blueprints for complicated machinery.

  That was the other reason Harry had guessed the Mendelian pattern would be there. If magical genes weren't complicated, why would there be more than one?

  And yet magic itself seemed pretty complicated. A door-locking spell would prevent the door from opening and prevent you from Transfiguring the hinges and resist Finite Incantatem and Alohomora. Many elements all pointing in the same direction: you could call that goal-orientation, or in simpler language, purposefulness.

  There were only two known causes of purposeful complexity. Natural selection, which produced things like butterflies. And intelligent engineering, which produced things like cars.

  Magic didn't seem like something that had self-replicated into existence. Spells were purposefully complicated, but not, like a butterfly, complicated for the purpose of making copies of themselves. Spells were complicated for the purpose of serving their user, like a car.

  Some intelligent engineer, then, had created the Source of Magic, and told it to pay attention to a particular DNA marker.

  The obvious next thought was that this had something to do with "Atlantis".

  Harry had asked Hermione about that earlier - on the train to Hogwarts, after hearing Draco say it - and so far as she knew, nothing more was known than the word itself.

  It might have been pure legend. But it was also plausible enough that a civilization of magic-users, especially one from before the Interdict of Merlin, would have managed to blow itself up.

  The line of reasoning continued: Atlantis had been an isolated civilization that had somehow brought into being the Source of Magic, and told it to serve only people with the Atlantean genetic marker, the blood of Atlantis.

  And by similar logic: The words a wizard spoke, the wand movements, those weren't complicated enough of themselves to build up the spell effects from scratch - not the way that the three billion base pairs of human DNA actually were complicated enough to build a human body from scratch, not the way that computer programs took up thousands of bytes of data.

  So the words and wand movements were just triggers, levers pulled on some hidden and more complex machine. Buttons, not blueprints.

  And just like a computer program wouldn't compile if you made a single spelling error, the Source of Magic wouldn't respond to you unless you cast your spells in exactly the right way.

  The chain of logic was inexorable.

  And it led inevitably toward a single final conclusion.

  The ancient forebears of the wizards, thousands of years earlier, had told the Source of Magic to only levitate things if you said...

  'Wingardium Leviosa.'

  Harry slumped over at the breakfast table, resting his forehead wearily on his right hand.

  There was a story from the dawn days of Artificial Intelligence - back when they were just starting out and no one had yet realized the problem would be difficult - about a professor who had delegated one of his grad students to solve the problem of computer vision.

  Harry was beginning to understand how that grad student must have felt.

  This could take a while.

  Why did it take more effort to cast the Alohomora spell, if it was just like pressing a button?

  Who'd been silly enough to build in a spell for Avada Kedavra that could only be cast using hatred?

  Why did wordless Transfiguration require you to make a complete mental separation between the concept of form and concept of material?

  Harry might not be done with this problem by the time he graduated Hogwarts. He could still be working on this problem when he was thirty years old. Hermione had been right, Harry hadn't realized that on a gut level before. He'd just given an inspiring speech about determination.

  Harry's mind briefly considered whether to get on a gut level that he might never solve the problem at all, then decided that would be taking things much too far.

  Besides, so long as he could get as far as immortality in the first few decades, he'd be fine.

  What method had the Dark Lord used? Come to think, the fact that the Dark Lord had somehow managed to survive the death of his first body was almost infinitely more important than the fact that he'd tried to take over magical Britain -

  "Excuse me," said an expected voice from behind him in very unexpected tones. "At your convenience, Mr. Malfoy requests the favor of a conversation."

  Harry did not choke on his breakfast cereal. Instead he turned around and beheld Mr. Crabbe.

  "Excuse me," said Harry. "Don't you mean 'Da boss wants ta talk wid youse?'"

  Mr. Crabbe didn't look happy. "Mr. Malfoy instructed me to speak properly."

  "I can't hear you," Harry said. "You're not speaking properly." He turned back to his bowl of tiny blue crystal snowflakes and deliberately ate another spoonful.

  "Da boss wants to talk with youse," came a threatening voice from behind him. "Ya'd better come see him if ya know what's good for ya."

  There. Now everything was going according to plan.

  Act 1:

  "A reason?" said the old wizard. He restrained the fury from his face. The boy before him had been the victim, and certainly did not need to be frightened any further. "There is nothing that can excuse -"

  "What I did to him was worse."

  The old wizard stiffened in sudden horror. "Harry, what have you done?"

  "I tricked Draco into believing that I'd tricked him into participating in a ritual that sacrificed his belief in blood purism. And that meant he couldn't be a Death Eater when he grew up. He'd lost everything, Headmaster."

  There was a long quiet in the office, broken only by the tiny puffs and whistles of the fiddly things, which after enough time had come to seem like silence.

  "Dear me," said the old wizard, "I do feel silly. And here I was expecting you might try to redeem the heir of Malfoy by, say, showing him true friendship and kindness."

  "Ha! Yeah, like that would have worked."

  The old wizard sighed. This was taking it too far. "Tell me, Harry. Did it even occur to you that there was something incongruous about setting out to redeem someone through lies and trickery?"

  "I did it without telling any direct lies, and since we're talking about Draco Malfoy here, I think the word you're looking for is congruous." The boy looked rather smug.

  The old wizard shook his head in despair. "And this is the hero. We're all doomed."

  Act 5:

  The long, narrow tunnel of rough stone, unlit except by a child's wand, seemed to stretch on for miles.

  The reason for this was simple: It did stretch on for miles.

  The time was three in the morning, and Fred and George were starting the long way down the secret passage that led from a statue of a one-eyed witch in Hogwarts, to the cellar of the Honeydukes candyshop in Hogsmeade.


  "How's it doing?" said Fred in a low voice.

  (Not that there'd be anyone listening, but there was something odd about talking in a normal voice when you were going through a secret passage.)

  "Still on the fritz," said George.

  "Both, or -"

  "Intermittent one fixed itself again. Other one's same as ever."

  The Map was an extraordinarily powerful artifact, capable of tracking every sentient being on the school grounds, in real time, by name. Almost certainly, it had been created during the original raising of Hogwarts. It was not good that errors were starting to pop up. Chances were that no one except Dumbledore could fix it if it was broken.

  And the Weasley twins weren't about to turn the Map over to Dumbledore. It would have been an unforgivable insult to the Marauders - the four unknowns who'd managed to steal part of the Hogwarts security system, something probably forged by Salazar Slytherin himself, and twist it into a tool for student pranking.

  Some might have considered it disrespectful.

  Some might have considered it criminal.

  The Weasley twins firmly believed that if Godric Gryffindor had been around to see it, he would have approved.

  The brothers walked on and on and on, mostly in silence. The Weasley twins talked to each other when they were thinking through new pranks, or when one of them knew something the other didn't. Otherwise there wasn't much point. If they already knew the same information, they tended to think the same thoughts and make the same decisions.

  (Back in the old days, whenever magical identical twins were born, it had been the custom to kill one of them after birth.)

  In time, Fred and George clambered out into a dusty cellar, strewn with barrels and racks of strange ingredients.

  Fred and George waited. It wouldn't have been polite to do anything else.

  Before too long a thin old man in black pajamas clambered down the steps that led into the cellar, yawning. "Hello, boys," said Ambrosius Flume. "I wasn't expecting you tonight. Out of stock already?"

  Fred and George decided that Fred would speak.

  "Not exactly, Mr. Flume," said Fred. "We were hoping you could help us with something considerably more... interesting."

  "Now, boys," said Flume, sounding severe, "I hope you didn't wake me up just so I could tell you again that I'm not selling you any merchandise that could get you into real trouble. Not until you're sixteen, anyways -"

  George drew forth an item from his robes, and wordlessly passed it to Flume. "Have you seen this?" said Fred.

  Flume looked at yesterday's edition of the Daily Prophet and nodded, scowling. The headline on the paper read THE NEXT DARK LORD? and showed a young boy which some student's camera had managed to catch in an uncharacteristically cold and grim expression.

  "I can't believe that Malfoy," Flume snapped. "Going after the boy when he's only eleven! The man ought to be ground up and used to make chocolates!"

  Fred and George blinked in unison. Malfoy was behind Rita Skeeter? Harry Potter hadn't warned them about that... which surely meant that Harry didn't know. He never would have brought them in if he did...

  Fred and George exchanged glances. Well, Harry didn't need to know until after the job was done.

  "Mr. Flume," Fred said quietly, "the Boy-Who-Lived needs your help."

  Flume looked at them both.

  Then he let out his breath with a sigh.

  "All right," said Flume, "what do you want?"

  Act 6:

  When Rita Skeeter was intent on a tasty prey, she didn't tend to notice the scurrying ants who constituted the rest of the universe, which was how she almost bumped into the balding young man who'd stepped into her pathway.

  "Miss Skeeter," said the man, sounding rather severe and cold for someone whose face looked that young. "Fancy running into you here."

  "Out of my way, buster!" snapped Rita, and tried to step around him.

  The man in her pathway matched the movement so perfectly that it was like neither of them had moved at all, just stood still while the street shifted around them.

  Rita's eyes narrowed. "Who do you think you are?"

  "How very foolish," the man said dryly. "It would have been wise to memorize the face of the disguised Death Eater training Harry Potter to be the next Dark Lord. After all," a thin smile, "that certainly sounds like someone you wouldn't want to run into on the street, especially after doing a hatchet job on him in the newspaper."

  Rita took a moment to place the reference. This was Quirinus Quirrell? He looked too young and too old at the same time; his face, if it relaxed from its severe and condescending pose, would belong to someone in his late thirties. And his hair was already falling out? Couldn't he afford a healer?

  No, that wasn't important, she had a time and a place and a beetle to be. She'd just received an anonymous tip about Madam Bones making time with one of her younger assistants. That would be worth quite a bonus if she could manage to verify it, Bones was high on the hit list. The tipster had said that Bones and her young assistant were due to eat lunch in a special room at Mary's Place, a very popular room for certain purposes; a room which, she'd found, was secure against all listening devices, but not proof against a beautiful blue beetle nestled up against one wall...

  "Out of my way!" Rita said, and tried to push Quirrell from her path. Quirrell's arm brushed her own, deflecting, and Rita staggered as the thrust went into the thin air.

  Quirrell pulled up the sleeve of his left robe, showing his left arm. "Observe," said Quirrell, "no Dark Mark. I would like your paper to publish a retraction."

  Rita let out an incredulous laugh. Of course the man wasn't a real Death Eater. The paper wouldn't have published it if he was. "Forget it, buster. Now take a hike."

  Quirrell stared at her for a moment.

  Then he smiled.

  "Miss Skeeter," said Quirrell, "I had hoped to find some lever that would prove persuasive. Yet I find that I cannot deny myself the pleasure of simply crushing you."

  "It's been tried. Now get out of my way, buster, or I'll find some Aurors and have you arrested for obstruction of journalism."

  Quirrell swept her a small bow, and then walked past. "Goodbye, Rita Skeeter," said his voice from behind her.

  As Rita bulled on ahead, she noted in the back of her mind that the man was whistling a tune as he walked away.

  Like that would scare her.

  Act 4:

  "Sorry, count me out," said Lee Jordan. "I'm more the giant spider type."

  The Boy-Who-Lived had said that he had important work for the Order of Chaos, something serious and secret, more significant and difficult than their usual run of pranks.

  And then Harry Potter had launched into a speech that was inspiring, yet vague. A speech to the effect that Fred and George and Lee had tremendous potential if they could just learn to be weirder. To make people's lives surreal, instead of just surprising them with the equivalents of buckets of water propped above doors. (Fred and George had exchanged interested looks, they'd never thought of that one.) Harry Potter had invoked a picture of the prank they'd pulled on Neville - which, Harry had mentioned with some remorse, the Sorting Hat had chewed him out on - but which must have made Neville doubt his own sanity. For Neville it would have felt like being suddenly transported into an alternate universe. The same way everyone else had felt when they'd seen Snape apologize. That was the true power of pranking.

  Are you with me? Harry Potter had cried, and Lee Jordan had answered no.

  "Count us in," said Fred, or possibly George, for there was no doubt that Godric Gryffindor would have said yes.

  Lee Jordan gave a regretful grin, and stood up, and left the deserted and Quieted corridor where the four members of the Order of Chaos had met and sat down in a conspiratorial circle.

  The three members of the Order of Chaos got down to business.

  (It wasn't that sad. Fred and George would still work with Lee on giant spider pranks, same as ever. They'd
only started calling it the Order of Chaos in order to recruit Harry Potter, after Ron had told them about Harry being weird and evil, and Fred and George had decided to save Harry by showing him true friendship and kindness. Thankfully this no longer seemed necessary - although they weren't quite sure about that...)

  "So," said one of the twins, "what's this about?"

  "Rita Skeeter," said Harry. "Do you know who she is?"

  Fred and George nodded, frowning.

  "She's been asking questions about me."

  That wasn't good news.

  "Can you guess what I want you to do?"

  Fred and George looked at each other, a bit puzzled. "You want us to slip her some of our more interesting candies?"

  "No," said Harry. "No, no, no! That's giant-spider thinking! Come on, what would you do if you heard that Rita Skeeter was looking for rumors about you?"

  That made it obvious.

  Grins slowly started on the faces of Fred and George.

  "Start rumors about ourselves," they replied.

  "Exactly," said Harry, grinning widely. "But these can't be just any rumors. I want to teach people never to believe what the newspaper says about Harry Potter, any more than Muggles believe what the newspaper says about Elvis. At first I just thought about flooding Rita Skeeter with so many rumors that she wouldn't know what to believe, but then she'll just cherry-pick the ones that sound plausible and bad. So what I want you to do is create a fake story about me, and get Rita Skeeter to believe it somehow. But it has to be something that, afterward, everyone will know was fake. We want to fool Rita Skeeter and her editors, and afterward have the proof come out that it was false. And of course - given that those are the requirements - the story has to be as ridiculous as it can possibly be, and still get printed. Do you understand what I want you to do?"

  "Not exactly..." Fred or George said slowly. "You want us to invent the story?"

  "I want you to do all of it," Harry Potter said. "I'm sort of busy right now, plus I want to be able to say truthfully that I had no idea what was coming. Surprise me."

  For a moment there was a very evil grin on the faces of Fred and George.