Falling for the Other Brother

by Stacey Lynn Rhodes

  Colin smiled against her neck then gave her a gentle kiss on the same spot before straightening up and walking down the hall carrying Erica. She gave Trevor a smile and cheeky wave goodbye before he disappeared from view.

  “Boo,” he called after them. “Spoilsports!”

  Colin carried her into her bedroom and kicked the door mostly closed behind him.

  “Are you ever going to put me down?” she asked against his mouth.

  “You’re such a tiny thing,” he murmured into her neck as he let her slide down his front, keeping full contact with her body as her breasts rubbed down his chest. He cupped her buttocks as he lowered her, grinding against her as her pussy glided across his hardened shaft. “I could hold you up like this for hours.”

  Oh my God. The visual that comment prompted of him nailing her to the wall—sans clothes this time—had her grabbing his neck and wildly seeking his mouth again. He smiled with delight dancing in his eyes and gave her another soul-searing kiss before firmly moving her away from him.

  “Let’s get undressed. I’ve been dying to get you naked again.”

  The thought of doing a striptease crossed her mind for a moment, then fled. She shed her clothing with alacrity and efficiency as Colin did the same. He finished first and stepped towards the bed, never once taking his admiring eyes from her. She undid her bra last and shrugged it from her shoulders. Her nipples perked immediately upon contact with the cool air and Colin’s gaze. Erica walked over and sat on the edge of the bed, crooking her finger to coyly beckon him closer.

  He stepped up, seemingly content to let her set the pace now. She stroked his rigid shaft, looking in wonder at its perfection contrasted against the scarring below, before bending to tentatively kiss the old injury. His intake of breath gave her even more incentive to make sure he was confident in her love for him. She wrapped her hand around the base of his cock as she licked him slowly around and across the head, feeling the slit with her tongue and tasting his tangy essence.

  Growing impatient, she took him into her mouth partway, wrapping her lips over her teeth to bite down gently, testing his firmness, then loosening her jaw and using her tongue to soothe. She suckled strongly and he groaned, grasping her head and gently directing her in taking and releasing him as he fucked her mouth with shallow thrusts.

  Erica felt so in tune with Colin. When she had made the difficult decision to turn his love away, she never could have dreamt she would have him back with her, on such a positive track to the future. She had wanted more than just a lasting connection, a relationship—she’d wanted a family, a man to be with, to share her love and life with.

  Erica pushed Colin back a step so she could slide to her knees on the floor before him. She smiled wryly as he responded to the different angle with an increase in the pressure of the fingers tangled in her hair. She trailed her fingertips down the deep, muscular V arrowing from the bottom of his abdominals to the base of his cock. Her pussy ached with the void she increasingly felt, needing him to fill her, but she was so enjoying the feel of his cock on her tongue and stretching her lips.

  Choices, choices.

  She added a hand to his shaft, squeezing and pumping lightly in time with her suction, then cradling his sac, learning the weight and feel of his remaining ball, giving it gentle attention.

  Colin couldn’t believe the erotic yet caring quality to her exploration. He could feel his ball drawing up against his body as he approached his pinnacle of pleasure and gritted his teeth trying to stem the tide. He didn’t want it to end so soon.

  Finally, he could take no more. “Condom?”

  She gave him a slight frown. “I don’t think we need it, do we? I’ve only been with Trev for close to a year and we always used one. And I’ve had a clean bill of health in the meantime.”

  “Me too, and you know you’re the only one I’ve been with in over a year, so…”

  “I vote no.”

  God, the thought of being in her bare was combustible. Colin sat on the bed, pulled her towards him and kissed her lingeringly, shifting her with his hands around her waist until she straddled his lap.

  Colin stroked her and found her already slick with need. He smiled against her mouth. “You’re one sexy woman.”

  “Mmm…”

  He slowly entered her while deepening their kiss. He paused a few times to allow her adjust to his cock, letting her channel flow and flex around him until he was seated to the hilt. Then he held still, firmly pressed into her, and kissed her thoroughly as he cupped her breasts and tweaked her pale, responsive nipples into hard peaks that brushed against his chest. Finally able to worship her beautiful body, he wanted to bring her as high as he was.

  She moaned and moved on his cock and that was the end of his control. He finally obliged, grasping her hips and beginning a rocking motion that had his cock moving more within her than actually withdrawing and entering. He made slight circles as he thrust, and thrummed his fingers over her clit in time with his motions. Soon she was gasping with every pass.

  Erica clutched him close as her head fell back, then she was coming, her head snapping forward and teeth grazing his shoulder as she ground her pelvis against his. Her channel pulsed, milking his cock and he couldn’t hold back any longer. A handful of hard thrusts and his cum jetted into her as he groaned his completion, each pulsing movement made more intense by the stillness of the rest of their bodies.

  Colin tried to catch his breath, swamped by the love he felt for Erica. Resting his cheek against her hair as they recovered, he felt a sense of rightness being there with her. Thank God Trevor had straightened things out and had got everything out in the open.

  He picked her up and, still connected, began walking towards the bathroom. They had almost made it before he slipped out.

  “Damn.”

  Erica giggled. “We’ll just have to do it again sometime.”

  He let her down slowly and she stood naked and confident before him. “I love you,” he whispered in the still of the room.

  “I love you too.” Erica stroked her hand across his cheek. “Thank you for not giving up on me when I was being stupid and short-sighted.”

  “How could I? You’re the perfect woman for me. My forever woman.” Tears filled Erica’s eyes and alarm spiked through him. “What’s wrong?”

  She shook her head, eyes glistening. “Happy tears,” she explained, fanning her face with one hand.

  He caught her hand and kissed each of her eyelids in turn. “So that’s what happiness tastes like. Salty.”

  They laughed and Colin reflected as he started the shower that happiness did seem to be a tangible thing now, because the sound of their mingled laughter had an almost palpable, wonderful feel to it.

  Chapter Twelve

  They hadn’t poked their heads out of Erica’s room until late that night. Trevor’s bedroom door had been closed when they’d tiptoed out to the kitchen to warm up leftover Chinese, which was about the best thing Erica had ever tasted. Maybe she was just biased, since she was the happiest she’d ever been.

  The next day her alarm had seemed to go off extremely early, and she’d heartily wished that she didn’t have to go to work. Having Colin in bed with her was a temptation to snuggle and play hooky if she’d ever known one. He’d helped her out by getting up with her and encouraging her on her way out of the door.

  The only consolation she’d had was that she had a lighter schedule at the moment story-wise, unless something major happened—fingers and toes crossed against that. And it had worked. She’d been able to leave work at an entirely reasonable time in the early evening.

  Now the three of them were sitting around the living room after a nice dinner that Colin had made. She and Colin were nestled together on the couch, and Trevor was lounging in an arm chair while they planned his move back to the condo.

  “If I didn’t know better, I’d feel very unwanted and unloved right now.” Trevor pouted.

  Erica smirked. “Oh, you know y
ou’ll be happy to get back to the man cave.”

  “No, really. I’d rather stay here. You never know when a live sex show is going to break out and the food is awesome.”

  “Speaking of sex…” Erica stopped talking when both of the guys burst into laughter. “What?”

  “Nice segue,” Colin teased.

  “Best ever,” Trevor agreed. “Keep talking. I want to see where this is going.”

  Erica fought a smile. The recent events seemed to have settled things between them and all of them, herself included, were crazy happy and content. It was a vast improvement on the past month or so when the future had been impenetrable.

  “We need to talk about the having kids thing.” God, here she was about two minutes into a relationship and already angling for kids. “I’m… Well, I’m not getting any younger.”

  “I know,” Colin agreed, and laughed as she smacked his arm. “I don’t mind starting trying right away.”

  Relief suffused her and she looked at Trevor, who was watching from his chair with a naughty grin. “I think your brother is willing to do the honors, although I’m not sure what changed his mind. He seemed very adamant about not being a donor anymore.”

  Trevor’s grin softened into a smile, but his eyes dropped. “I made that decision after the accident.” He looked up at Colin then back at Erica. “With him wanting to have kids but not able to produce sperm anymore, I knew my only donations from that time on would be to his future wife. Although”—the wicked glint returned—“I didn’t count on being so lucky as to have the option to donate in person. Or as Rhonnie called it, hand-deliver.” Trevor winked and Erica felt her cheeks go warm. “Much more enjoyable prospect than the old magazine and cup routine.”

  “Yeah, well, we’ll just keep your enjoyment to the necessary minimum,” Colin grumbled, though his contented tone belied the implied jealousy.

  “Another thing. We’ve always used condoms, and—”

  Trevor was already nodding. “No worries. I got tested last week—had a feeling this might come up. Or maybe I should say I hoped it would. No diseases so we’re good to go.”

  Erica blinked at his preparedness. Really, between assuredness of the two brothers, she felt like she was constantly catching up. “Okay, well that’s good.”

  Something else suddenly occurred to her. “Along those lines, I know at some point you’re probably going to date someone else, but if we’re going bare…”

  How did you ask a young single guy to remain monogamous to you when you weren’t even dating him?

  “I get it, and I’m willing to put off sex with another partner until I’ve done what I’ve come here to do.” He waggled his eyebrows at the pun and Colin and Erica groaned. “Best case scenario for all of us is to knock you up ASAP.”

  Feeling like the luckiest woman in the world, Erica thought about her future now with a sense of wonderment and expectation. In love with one brother, and loving them both, together they’d grow a family.

  She eyed the hallway to the bedroom then sent what she hoped to be an inviting look to both of her men. “No time like the present.”

  Colin rose from the couch and met Trevor’s inquiring look with a shrug. He honestly wasn’t sure how he’d react when the time came, but he was going to try his damnedest to keep any jealousy at bay so he could give her this.

  He pulled Erica to her feet and led the way, repeatedly kissing her on the way to the bedroom, putting all the love he had for her in every touch of his lips. As his arousal grew, the light kisses were no longer enough. He cupped the back of her head, pulling her in for a deep kiss, thrusting his tongue in to duel with her, needing the passionate response she was always willing to give him.

  In the bedroom, Erica reached down and helped Colin unfasten then slide his jeans to his ankles, smoothing her hand down his backside and thighs with a touch that left him breathless. She tugged him down on the bed then knelt down in front of him to remove his boots and slip the pants off. Colin impatiently tore his T-shirt over his head and sat naked, his growing erection jutting out. A soft warmth enclosed his cock and he groaned as Erica slid her mouth down over the head then pulled off.

  “Sit up against the headboard,” she instructed then turned to Trevor while she quickly stripped. He watched her with a slight smile and Colin knew he should probably feel jealous, but thankfully he was so far avoiding that emotion.

  “And where do you want me, boss lady?”

  “Hmm, well, you undressing would be a good start and then we’ll see,” she answered then crawled up the bed towards Colin, pressing his legs apart until they were spread wide. A sensuous grin crossed her lips as she looked up at Colin from under her dark lashes and cupped Colin’s sac in her small hands. She stroked his scar and rolled his ball in a manner that was fast becoming a regular part of their bed play, and went a long way towards assuaging the last of Colin’s negative feelings about his body.

  “Is this all right?” she teased, and he groaned.

  “Erica, baby, if it were any more right, I’d be tossing you down and fucking you, and to hell with Trevor trying to get you pregnant.”

  She ran her fingers along the sensitive crease above his thighs then loosely held his cock. Erica looked fascinated as clear liquid welled from his slit, and she slid her hand up to touch it, rubbing it over the head of his cock in a super light, teasing touch that was driving him insane. When she lifted her finger to her mouth for a taste, Trevor and Colin groaned in unison.

  Trevor was now as naked as they were and he joined them on the bed. “Sorry, Colin, I had no idea she was that much of a tease. I think turnabout is fair play, don’t you?”

  Colin was moving before the last few words were out of Trevor’s mouth. He arranged Erica into an almost identical position as he’d been in against the headboard, only lying flat, then ran his whisker-rough cheek over the inside of her thigh. She gasped in response, and he inhaled her sweet scent as he laved the scratched area with his tongue, licking in tight circles closer and closer to the trimmed, red curls of her pussy.

  He sucked at her smooth outer folds then used his thumbs to spread her labia apart, stroking the sleekness he uncovered with his tongue and his thumbs in turn. She squirmed restively and he stilled her with an iron grip on her hips then ran his tongue up to her clit, teasing it until it was swollen and taut.

  Meanwhile, Trevor had moved to Erica’s side and was tonguing and nipping across one pale breast. He watched as Trevor stroked the other with his hand, plucking the nipple to a tight stand. Colin turned his attention to Erica, who was watching both men with desire-hazed eyes.

  Colin lapped lower at the new burst of moisture that was his for the taking then took the entire area around her swollen bud in his mouth and suckled and tongued it mercilessly until she was crying out and heaving helplessly against him as she came.

  He barely allowed her to come down before slowly entering her with both thumbs, stretching her sensitive entrance and again flicking her nub with his tongue, keeping her off balance before withdrawing his touch completely and watching in satisfaction as her pussy attempted to grasp his retreating fingers.

  “Nice,” Trevor praised. Trevor dipped in to lick her clit once, and Colin heard Erica catch her breath. Then both men moved their attention upwards, suckling and lapping at her breasts, paying extra attention to her sensitive nipples.

  Trevor moved between her thighs and cupped Erica’s curvy ass with one hand as he used the other to place his shaft at the entrance of her pussy.

  Colin rested his cheek against hers as he draped himself atop her while Trevor pressed deep inside her with a slow, steady motion. She linked her arms around his neck.

  “Okay?” he asked, pulling back to look down at her, and she nodded. He braced himself on his elbows above her and gave her a tender kiss. He reached down between Trevor and Erica to get a thumb on her clit, riding it there, letting it stroke on each thrust.

  Her eyes locked on his as she moaned and came with
head thrown back and back arched. Her climax seemed to trip Trevor’s orgasm, and he and Erica strained together, gasping their fulfilment.

  Soon afterward, they shifted positions until Trevor was spooned behind Erica with Colin in front, kissing her full mouth periodically as they relaxed, sated. Colin was relieved that the experiment with sharing Erica’s attentions had gone well and without any unexpected negative reactions. He supposed that the love between them all, though it varied in intensity and type on each side of the triangle, kept things from becoming too difficult.

  This just might work out after all.

  Epilogue

  “Is Trevor home from LA yet? I haven’t heard from him at all today.” Erica dodged other pedestrians as she walked along the sidewalk towards Rhonnie’s restaurant.

  “No, I don’t think he’ll be back until tonight sometime. And it’s a good thing I’m not a jealous man with how concerned you are about my brother’s whereabouts.” Colin’s voice held a teasing grin.

  “Not concerned, just curious, and you know I talk to you way more than I ever did to him.” So much so that she’d had to set herself a strong rule to not reach out to Colin while she was at work or she’d never get anything done. It was tempting since he worked from the home office he’d set up in her former guest room, and he had never yet turned a call away because he was too busy to talk. That didn’t stop her from having him on speed dial the moment she stepped out of the building for lunch or at the end of the day.

  “So you’re meeting Rhon for lunch?” he asked.

  “Yes. Wish you could join us.”

  “Hmm. I’d love to see you too, but I’m heading out in about an hour to give a proposal presentation to that new client, and I need to wrap things up.”

  “Okay, okay, I’ll let you go.” She had just reached the restaurant anyway. “Love you.”

  “Love you too, babe.”

  “Knock ’em dead.” She grinned at his laugh in reply and they said their goodbyes. She tucked her phone back into the slot of her purse and reached for the door. It flew open and she stepped back.