Undocumented : How Immigration Became Illegal (9780807001684)

Home > Other > Undocumented : How Immigration Became Illegal (9780807001684) > Page 27
Undocumented : How Immigration Became Illegal (9780807001684) Page 27

by Chomsky, Aviva


  Ellis Island, 42

  El Norte (film), 112

  El Salvador. See Salvadoran immigrants

  employers: exploitation of immigrant workers, 54–55, 57, 62, 74–75, 116, 121–22, 191; reliance on Farm Labor Contractors, 123–24; sanctions for hiring undocumented workers, 12–13, 62, 115–16, 132, 189–91

  enforcement of immigration laws: abandoning enforcement policies, 204–5; as component of comprehensive reform, 188, 189–90, 195–96, 200, 202; effects on agriculture and industry, 125–26; during Great Depression, 53; in interior of US, 100, 105, 107; under Obama administration, 117; workplace raids, 116–17, 135–40, 150. See also border enforcement policies

  England, ideas about religion/race in, 31

  entry without inspection, 43, 45, 53–54, 71–73, 203–4

  Equal Protection Clause, 163

  European countries, 24–29, 31, 72

  European immigrants, 10, 33–35, 44, 45–46

  E-Verify program, 93, 117, 140–41, 202–3

  excludable classes of immigrants and citizens, 16–17, 31, 33–37, 42, 45

  exploitation of immigrant workers, 54–55, 57, 62, 116, 121–22, 191. See also kidnapping of migrants

  families: children’s loss of deported parents, 158–62; deportation effects upon, 5–6; family preferences in immigration law, 12, 165, 185; mixed immigration status in, 21, 91; undocumented parents as guilty of bringing children to US, 175–76; youth advocacy for, 177. See also children

  Farm Labor Contractors (FLCs), 123–24

  Farm Labor Organizing Committee (FLOC), 75–76

  farmworkers. See agriculture; migrant workers and US agricultural system

  farmworkers movement, 12–13, 60, 124–25, 188

  felony immigration violations. See civil vs. criminal immigration violations

  financial aid (higher education), 167–68

  Flores v. Meese (1997), 154–55

  focus groups on immigration, 198–203

  foreign-born population (US), 48–49

  Fourteenth Amendment (US Constitution), 10, 35, 163

  Foxen, Patricia, 67–69

  Framingham, Massachusetts, 98

  France, Anatole, 24

  fraudulent documents, 61–62, 63–64, 69–70, 74–76, 93–94, 95–96, 164–65

  “free citizenship” concept, 34

  freedom to travel, 26–29, 33–34, 36–37, 40–41, 206

  Gabaccia, Donna, 46–47

  Gadsden Purchase (1853), 49, 182

  GEO Group, 109

  Georges, Eugenia, 78

  Georgia, 97, 112, 126–27

  “global apartheid,” 36–37, 41

  globalization, 2, 186

  González, Gilbert, 55

  Gonzalez, Roberto, 165

  Grapes of Wrath (Steinbeck), 124

  Great Depression, 53, 55, 59, 124

  green cards. See legal permanent residents

  Guatemala-Mexico border, 79

  Guatemalan immigrants: case histories, 160–61; exclusion from Temporary Protected Status, 89; labor recruitment in, 76, 123–24; migration traditions, 64–67; misunderstanding of their own immigration status, 67–70; in Postville raid, 137; statistics, 48

  guest workers: agricultural demand for, 127; Bracero Program, 11, 55–59, 63, 121–22, 135; H-2 Program, 60, 73

  Guthrie, Woody, 113, 128

  Haitian immigrants, 90

  harboring undocumented immigrants, 114–15

  health care, 85, 92, 137, 178

  higher education, 41, 167–68, 179, 207

  Hing, Julianne, 180

  Hispanics. See Latinos

  Hondagneu-Sotelo, Pierrette, 144–45

  Honduran immigrants, 48

  housing bubble, 131

  human trafficking, 80, 156

  Hurricane Katrina, 132

  I-94 forms, 72, 96

  identity theft, 93–94, 136, 138

  Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act (IIRIRA, 1996), 140, 167

  illegality: under 1891 Immigration Act, 42; under 1924 Immigration Act, 45; under 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act, 60; anti-“illegal” rhetoric, 17–18, 46–47, 192–94, 206–8; challenges to the concept of, 22, 169, 174, 206–7; and inequality, 14; as a legal/social construction, 1–2, 20, 23–24, 208; as means of exploiting workers, 19, 39, 177; prison industry as benefitting from, 101; as scapegoat for social problems, 102, 125; “transition to illegality,” 165–66. See also undocumented immigrants

  immigrant rights: and comprehensive immigration reform, 196, 201–3; framing as racial discrimination, 115–16; as human rights, 22; organizations supporting, 190, 202; protests for, 171, 196–98; undocumented youth advocacy for, 41, 168–73, 177

  immigrants. See immigration status; migrant workers; undocumented immigrants

  immigrants, defined, 43

  immigrants vs. workers distinction, 10

  Immigrant Workers Freedom Ride, 197–98

  Immigration Act (1891), 42

  Immigration Act (1903), 42

  Immigration Act (1924), 10, 34–35, 44, 45, 54

  Immigration Act (IMMACT; 1990), 89

  Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE): budget growth, 102; deportation cases and DACA, 178; deportation guidelines, 159–61; detention of children and youth, 155–57; fraudulent marriages, 94–95; inspection of immigrants, 71; interior enforcement of immigration law, 100–101; prosecutorial discretion of, 159, 173, 203–4; quotas for removals, 106–7; Secure Communities program, 97–98, 107, 202–3; workplace raids and audits, 116–17. See also earlier Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS)

  Immigration and Nationality Act (1965), 59–60, 184–85

  Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS): application backlogs, 89; detention of children and youth, 154–55; Operation Vanguard, 134; refugee and asylum policies, 189; workplace raids, 134–40. See also later Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)

  immigration court system, 6–8, 99, 102–3, 107, 138–39, 161–62

  immigration “crisis,” 194

  immigration documents. See fraudulent documents; specific types of documents (e.g., visas)

  immigration law and policy: Arizona S.B. 1070, 110–12; children and youth, 156; comprehensive immigration legislation, 196; as criminalizing people of color and African Americans, 15–18, 109; criminal vs. civil violations, 98–100; elimination of “illegality” from, 22, 204–5; exceptions for Mexican workers, 10–11; family preferences, 12, 165, 185; illegality in post-1965 laws, 1–2; on immigration from the Philippines, 164–65; inequality as enshrined in, 24–25, 85–86; as legitimizing abuses against migrants, 82; as prohibiting regularization of immigration status, 41; race and, 33, 107. See also enforcement of immigration laws; specific laws

  immigration raids. See workplace raids

  Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA; 1986): employer sanctions in, 13; failures of, 189–92; legalization provisions, 61–62, 88; path to citizenship in, 43; prohibition on hiring undocumented workers, 114; provisions for agricultural labor, 122–23

  immigration reform proposals (present day), 21–22, 195–96, 204–5. See also comprehensive immigration reform

  immigration status: and access to social services, 91–93; as an internal border within US, 176–77; of children and youth, 153, 174–79; methods of attaining legal permanent residence, 46; and registry for noncitizens, 43; temporary statuses, 88–89; undocumented immigrants’ confusion about, 68–69; US laws prohibiting regularization of, 41. See also legalization of immigration status; legal permanent residents; undocumented immigrants

  incarceration, 15–18, 104–5. See also detention for immigration violations; prison system

  independent contractors, 131–32, 147–48

  indigenous people, 7, 30, 48, 63, 64–70, 123, 188

  Individual Taxpayer ID Numbers (ITINs), 91

  inequality: global, 2, 36–37; “illegal” immigration as perpetuating, 14, 19, 151, 206; as root of immigration to US, 187; a
s structural to agricultural system, 120–21; in United States, 145

  in-sourcing of jobs, 13–14, 118–19, 152

  “intending citizenship” concept, 33–34

  “internal border,” 176–77

  Internal Revenue Service (IRS), 94

  Ireland, 31

  Irwin (GA) Detention Center, 112

  Jalisco, Mexico, 52–54, 56, 62–63

  Jews in Spain, 29–30

  Jim Crow system, 2, 14–18, 27, 38. See also slavery

  jobs: types of jobs undesirable to Americans, 121, 124–25, 127, 143; of undocumented workers, 117–20

  Kansas, 126

  Kanstroom, Daniel, 57, 58

  Kerik, Bernard, 144

  kidnapping of migrants, 79–82

  labor markets: dual labor market, 9–12, 38–39, 55; effects of reducing undocumented immigration upon, 125; impact of INS/ICE raids upon, 134–36, 140; labor shortages, 55, 126–27, 143

  labor recruitment and contracting: for authorized workers, 136, 139; Bracero Program, 11, 55–59, 63, 121–22, 135; forced recruitment of Guatemalan Mayans, 64–66, 68; in H-2 program, 74–76; under IRCA, 123–24; in Mexico, 52–53

  labor unions: AFL-CIO, 13, 15, 191, 197–98; Farm Labor Organizing Committee, 75–76; in-sourcing and avoidance of, 133–34; stance on immigration policies, 12–13, 197–98; United Farm Workers, 12–13, 124–25, 188

  LaBotz, Dan, 76

  La Mesilla Purchase (1853), 49, 182

  landscaping industry, 141–45

  Latin America, US policies in, 186–87

  Latinos: and criminalization of immigration violations, 105; increase in population of, 47–48; mass incarceration of, 15–18; as Secure Communities detainees, 107; undocumented as percentage of, 153; views of employer sanctions, 15–16; as voting bloc, 153, 174, 198, 202. See also Central American immigrants; Mexican immigrants and immigration

  “Latino threat narrative,” 101–2

  law enforcement. See local law enforcement

  “lawfully present” immigrants, 91, 179

  Leadership Council on Civil Rights, 115–16

  legalization of immigration status: DACA, 90; economic impact of, 149–50; Immigration and Nationality Act (1965), 59–60; industry calls for, 143; IRCA, 61–62, 88, 122–23, 189–92; NACARA, 89; and upward mobility, 127; via reentry through Canada, 46; vs. citizenship, 173. See also fraudulent documents; specific immigration statuses

  legal permanent residents: deportation of, 18, 60, 105, 185; entry through Canada, 46; exclusion from services, 91; fraudulent green cards, 164; origin of status, 59

  literacy requirements, 43, 53

  local law enforcement, 84, 97–98, 110, 195

  Los Angeles, California, 144–46

  Lovell, George, 65, 68

  LULAC (League of United Latin American Citizens), 188, 195

  Lutz, Christopher, 65, 68

  Management and Training Corporation (MTC), 109

  Manifest Destiny, 27

  marches for immigrant rights, 171, 196–98

  Margolis, Maxine, 78

  marrying for documents, 94–95

  Martin, Philip, 62, 123, 127

  Martínez, Alma, 188–89

  Martínez, Oscar, 60

  Martínez, Samuel, 78

  Massachusetts, 179

  massacres of migrants, 81

  Massey, Douglas, 48, 61

  Mayan immigrants. See Guatemalan immigrants

  McCarran-Walter Act (1952), 114

  meatpacking industry, 118–19, 133–40, 152

  Menchu, Rigoberta, 65–66

  Menendez, Robert, 176

  Meng, Grace, 175

  Menjívar, Cecilia, 89–90, 153

  Mexican American rights organizations, 188–89

  Mexican immigrants and immigration: Bracero Program, 55–59; criminalization of, 15–18, 82; defined as non-white, 34–35; discrimination against, 36; pre-1919 ease of entry, 43; employer sanctions and, 191–92; exemptions from immigration laws, 9–10, 53; importance in American labor market, 113–14, 125; increase in number of, 47–48, 184–85; “Mexican wages,” 54–55, 57, 183; migration patterns, 42, 48–52, 56, 62–63, 123–24, 184; railroads and, 50–52; restrictions on citizenship of, 34; sending communities in Mexico, 52–54; tourist visas, 71–72; US economic crisis and decrease in, 77; and visa quota system, 44, 184; voluntary removal of, 99; as “workers” vs. “immigrants,” 11–12, 50, 183

  Mexican Migration Project, 49

  Mexican National Institute of Migration (INAMI), 79, 82

  Mexico: children deported to, 154–56; company towns in, 54–55; dangers of migration through, 77–82; indigenous people, 7, 48, 63, 123, 188; limits on migration from, 60–61; northern border, 82–83; railroads and migration in, 50–52; southern border control, 78–79

  Michigan, 179

  middle-class American lifestyle, 144–45, 146, 148–51

  Migrant Farmworker Justice Project, 118

  migrants to US, risks faced by, 3–6, 8, 79–82, 158

  migrant workers: culture of migration, 56; ineligibility for DACA, 175; as returning to home country, 49–50; seasonal patterns of migration, 11–12, 42, 118, 120–22, 184–85. See also undocumented immigrants

  migration patterns: European/American domination over, 26–29, 33; of Guatemalan Mayans, 64–67; IRCA disruption of Mexican, 62–63, 123–24; from Philippines, 164–65; poverty and crossing through Mexico, 78; and railroads in Mexico, 50–53; as seasonal and circular, 11–12, 56, 60–61, 184–85; of undocumented immigrants, 20. See also labor recruitment and contracting

  military service, 168, 174

  minimum wage, 125, 132

  Mitchell, Don, 120, 121–22

  mobility restrictions, 24–30

  Molina, Sandra, 160

  Morton, John, 159, 173, 203

  Motomura, Hiroshi, 33–34

  Muslims in Spain, 29–30

  NAACP, 13, 115–16

  nannies, 144–47

  national security, 95, 101–2, 158, 203

  Native Americans, 27–28, 30, 31, 34, 181

  Navarrette, Ruben, 207

  Nebraska, 134–35

  neoliberal policies, 186–87

  Nevada, 131

  Nevins, Joseph, 194

  New Imperialism, 27

  New Orleans, 132

  newspaper delivery system, 146–48

  Ngai, Mae, 45

  Nicaraguan Adjustment and Central America Relief Act (NACARA; 1997), 89

  9500 Liberty (film), 150

  No More Deaths (organization), 3

  North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), 63

  Obama, Barack: on comprehensive immigration reform, 200–204; DACA program, 90, 153, 174–79; on DREAM Act, 172–74; E-Verify system expansion, 140, 202–3; removal and deportation under, 100, 107, 158–61, 177; on undocumented children, 162; on workplace raids, 117

  Operation Hold the Line, 82–83

  Operation Streamline, 6–8, 104–6

  Operation Wetback, 58

  Orantes-Hernandez v. Meese, 189

  organized crime, 80–81, 204–5

  out-migration, 42

  outsourcing, 13, 130, 142

  Pacheco, Gaby, 170–71, 172

  Palauan immigrants, 139

  parental rights, 153–54, 159–62

  parents. See families

  Passel, Jeffrey, 191

  passports, 40–41, 43, 44, 73, 95, 159, 165

  paths to citizenship, 43, 168, 174, 177, 200–201, 205

  Patrick, Deval, 98

  payroll fraud, 131

  Pearce, Russell, 110–11

  Perez-Funes v. District Director, 189

  Perry, Rick, 167, 194–95

  Philippines, 163–65

  Plan Sur, 78

  plea bargains, 105, 138

  Plyer v. Doe (1982), 163

  political consulting firms, 198–203

  politicians: attracting Latino votes, 173–74; campaign donations to, 111; as employers of und
ocumented workers, 144; immigration as rallying point for, 101–2, 192–93, 199–203; lobbying by prison system, 108–11

  Postville (IA) raid, 69, 136–40

  Praeli, Lorella, 177

  Pratt, Travis, 108

  Pren, Karen, 48

  prices of consumer goods, 51, 101, 125

  prison system, 15–18, 38, 104, 108–12, 158

  probationers as agricultural labor, 127

  Proposition 187 (CA), 192–93

  prosecutorial discretion, 103, 159, 173, 203–4

  protests for immigrant rights, 171, 196–98

  Proyecto Kino, 4–5

  public benefits eligibility, 91–93, 163, 167, 178–79

  public defenders, 103, 105, 106, 138–39

  public housing, 92

  Puerto Rican birth certificates, 93–94

  quota system (visas), 12, 33, 44, 46, 60, 184

  race and racism: in anti-immigrant movement, 198–99, 206–7; and citizenship, 32–37; in criminalization of immigration violations, 105; employer sanctions and racial profiling, 115–16; in ideologies justifying colonialism, 26–29; and immigration laws, 2, 10, 15–18; linkage to religion, 29–32; against Mexicans, 182–83; racial profiling in workplace raids, 135–36; and welfare reform, 193

  raids, 116–17, 134–40, 150

  railroads and migration patterns, 50–52, 79–80

  REAL ID Act (2005), 95–96

  reentry after removal, 45–46, 104, 106–7, 160, 203

  refugees, 136, 155–56, 189

  registry for noncitizens, 43, 45

  Reid, Harry, 172, 173, 176

  religion, 26, 29–32

  remittances, 56, 67

  removal from the US: under Operation Streamline, 104–5; reentry after removal, 45–46, 104, 106–7, 160, 203; voluntary departure and removal, 99–100, 104. See also deportation

  Republican Party, 97, 172–73, 188, 193–95, 198

  Reyes, Silvestre, 83

  rights: as conferred through citizenship, 32–34, 36, 115–16; of deported parents, 161–62; under immigration court system, 102–3, 138; protests for immigrant rights, 171, 196–98; race and, 30; of undocumented children, 153; voting rights, 16, 34, 35; work as obligation vs. privilege, 37–39. See also immigrant rights

  Rodino, Peter, 115

  Rogers, Chip, 97

  Romney, Mitt, 144, 178, 198

  Rubashkin family, 136–37

  Rubio, Marco, 173–74

  Ruskola, Teemu, 28

  Russian immigrants, 44–45

  Salvadoran immigrants, 48, 89–90, 143, 189

  sanctions against employers, 12–13, 62, 115–16, 132, 189–91

 

‹ Prev