The Lincoln Lawyer Collection

by Connelly, Michael

  “But how can they bring her in here like that?”

  “Who, Mr. Roman?”

  Roman pointed out to the gallery and right at Reyes.

  “Her.”

  The judge looked at Reyes and then at Bosch sitting next to her. A look of deep suspicion crossed her face.

  “I’m going to ask the jury to step back into the jury room for a few moments. This should not take long.”

  The jurors filed back into the jury room. The moment the last one in closed the door, the judge zeroed in on Bosch.

  “Detective Bosch.”

  Harry stood up.

  “Who is the woman sitting to your left?”

  “Your Honor,” Haller said. “Can I answer that question?”

  “Please do.”

  “Detective Bosch is sitting with Sonia Reyes, who has agreed to help the prosecution as a witness consultant.”

  The judge looked from Haller to Reyes and back to Haller.

  “You want to run that by me again, Mr. Haller?”

  “Judge, Ms. Reyes is acquainted with the witness. Because the defense did not make Mr. Roman available to us prior to his testimony here, we have asked Ms. Reyes to give us advice on how to proceed with our cross-examination.”

  Haller’s explanation had done nothing to change the look of suspicion on Breitman’s face.

  “Are you paying her for this advice?”

  “We have agreed to help her get into a clinic.”

  “I should hope so.”

  “Your Honor,” Royce said. “May I be heard?”

  “Go ahead, Mr. Royce.”

  “I think it is quite obvious that the prosecution is attempting to intimidate Mr. Roman. This is a gangster move, Judge. Not something I would expect to see from the District Attorney’s Office.”

  “Well, I strongly object to that characterization,” Haller said. “It is perfectly acceptable within the canon of courtroom procedure and ethics to hire and use consultants. Mr. Royce employed a jury consultant last week and that was perfectly acceptable. But now that the prosecution has a consultant that he knows will help expose his witness as a liar and someone who preys on women, he objects. With all due respect, I would call that the gangster move.”

  “Okay, we’re not going to debate this now,” Breitman said. “I find that the prosecution is certainly within bounds in using Ms. Reyes as a consultant. Let’s bring the jury back.”

  “Thank you, Judge,” Haller said as he sat down.

  As the jurors filed back into the box, Haller turned and looked back at Bosch. He gave a slight nod and Bosch knew that he was happy. The exchange with the judge could not have worked better in delivering a message to Roman. The message being that we know your game, and come our turn to ask the questions, so will the jury. Roman now had a choice. He could stick with the defense or start playing for the prosecution.

  Testimony continued once the jury was back in place. Royce quickly established through Roman that he and Sarah Gleason had a relationship that lasted nearly a year and involved the sharing of personal stories as well as drugs. But when it came to revealing those personal stories, Roman did a cut and run, leaving Royce hanging in the wind.

  “Now, did there come a time when she spoke about her sister’s murder?”

  “A time? There were lots of times. She talked about it a lot, man.”

  “And did she ever tell you in detail what she called the ‘real story’?”

  “Yes, she did.”

  “Can you tell the court what she told you?”

  Roman hesitated and scratched his chin before answering. Bosch knew this was the moment that his work either paid off or went for naught.

  “She told me that they were playing hide-and-seek in the yard and a guy came and grabbed her sister and that she saw the whole thing.”

  Bosch’s eyes made a circuit of the room. First he checked the jurors and it seemed that even they had been expecting Roman to say something else. Then the prosecution table. He saw that McPherson had grabbed Haller by the back of his arm and was squeezing it. And lastly Royce, who was now the one hesitating. He stood at the lectern looking down at his notes, one armed cocked with his fist on his hip like a frustrated teacher who could not draw the correct answer from a student.

  “That is the story you heard Sarah Gleason tell in group counseling at the rehabilitation center, correct?” he finally asked.

  “That’s right.”

  “But isn’t it true that she told you a different version of events—what she called the ‘real story’—when you were in more private settings?”

  “Uh, no. She pretty much stuck to the same story all the time.”

  Bosch saw McPherson squeeze Haller’s arm again. This was the whole case right here.

  Royce was like a man left behind in the water by a dive boat. He was treading water but he was in the open sea and it was only a matter of time before he went down. He tried to do what he could.

  “Now, Mr. Roman, on March second of this year, did you not contact my office and offer your services as a witness for the defense?”

  “I don’t know about the date but I called there, yeah.”

  “And did you speak to my investigator, Karen Revelle?”

  “I spoke to a woman but I can’t remember her name.”

  “And didn’t you tell her a story that is quite different from the one you just recounted?”

  “But I wasn’t under oath or nothin’ then.”

  “That’s right, sir, but you did tell Karen a different story, true?”

  “I might’ve. I can’t remember.”

  “Didn’t you tell Karen at that time that Ms. Gleason had told you that her stepfather had killed her sister?”

  Haller was up with the objection, arguing that not only was Royce leading the witness but that there was no foundation for the question and that counsel was trying to get testimony to the jury that the witness was not willing to give. The judge sustained the objection.

  “Your Honor,” Royce said, “the defense would like to request a short break to confer with its witness.”

  Before Haller could object the judge denied the request.

  “By this witness’s own testimony this morning, you have had since March second to prepare for this moment. We go to lunch in thirty-five minutes. You can confer with him then, Mr. Royce. Ask your next question.”

  “Thank you, Your Honor.”

  Royce looked down at his legal pad. From Bosch’s angle he could tell he was looking at a blank page.

  “Mr. Royce?” the judge prompted.

  “Yes, Your Honor, just rechecking a date. Mr. Roman, why did you call my office on March second?”

  “Well, I seen something about the case on the TV. In fact, it was you. I seen you talking about it. And I knew something about it from knowing Sarah like I did. So I called up to see if I was needed.”

  “And then you came to my offices, correct?”

  “Yeah, that’s right. You sent that lady to pick me up.”

  “And when you came to my office, you told me a different story than you are telling the jury now, isn’t that right?”

  “Like I said, I don’t remember exactly what I said then. I’m a drug addict, sir. I say a lot of things I don’t remember and don’t really mean. All I remember is that the woman who came said she’d put me up in a nicer hotel and I had no money for a place at that time. So I sort of said what she told me to say.”

  Bosch made a fist and bounced it once on his thigh. This was an unmitigated disaster for the defense. He looked over at Jessup to see if he realized how bad things had just turned for him. And Jessup seemed to sense it. He turned and looked back at Bosch, his eyes dark with growing anger and realization. Bosch leaned forward and slowly raised a finger. He dragged it across his throat.

  Jessup turned away.

  Thirty-nine

  Thursday, April 8, 11:30 A.M.

  I have had many good moments in court. I’ve stood next to men at the moment th
ey knew that they were going free because of my good work. I have stood in the well in front of a jury and felt the tingle of truth and righteousness roll down my spine. And I have destroyed liars without mercy on the witness stand. These are the moments I live for in my professional life. But few of them measured up to the moment I watched Jason Jessup’s defense unravel with the testimony of Edward Roman.

  As Roman crashed and burned on the stand, my ex-wife and prosecution partner squeezed my arm to the point of pain. She couldn’t help it. She knew it, too. This was not something Royce was going to recover from. A key part of what was already going to be a fragile defense was crumbling before his eyes. It wasn’t so much that his witness had pulled a one-eighty on him. It was the jury seeing a defense that was now obviously built upon a liar. The jury would not forgive this. It was over and I believed everyone in the courtroom—from the judge to the gadflies in the back row of the gallery—knew it. Jessup was going down.

  I turned and looked back to share the moment with Bosch. After all, the silent witness maneuver had been his idea. And I caught him giving Jessup the throat slash—the internationally recognized sign that it was over.

  I looked back to the front of the court.

  “Mr. Royce,” the judge said. “Are you continuing with this witness?”

  “A moment, Your Honor,” Royce said.

  It was a valid question. Royce had few ways with which to go with Roman at this point. He could cut his losses and simply end the questioning. Or he could ask the judge to declare Roman to be a hostile witness—a move that was always professionally embarrassing when the hostile witness is one you called to the stand. But it was a move that would allow Royce more latitude in asking leading questions that explored what Roman had initially said to the defense investigator and why he was dissembling now. But this was fraught with danger, especially since this initial interview had not been recorded or documented in an effort to hide Roman during the discovery process.

  “Mr. Royce!” the judge barked. “I consider the court’s time quite valuable. Please ask your next question or I will turn the witness over to Mr. Haller for cross-examination.”

  Royce nodded to himself as he came to a decision.

  “I’m sorry, Your Honor. But no further questions at this time.”

  Royce walked dejectedly back to his seat and a waiting client who was visibly upset with the turnabout. I stood up and started moving to the lectern even before the judge turned the witness over to me.

  “Mr. Roman,” I said, “your testimony has been somewhat confusing to me. So let me get this straight. Are you telling this jury that Sarah Ann Gleason did or did not tell you that her stepfather murdered her sister?”

  “She didn’t. That’s just what they wanted me to say.”

  “Who is ‘they,’ sir?”

  “The defense. The lady investigator and Royce.”

  “Besides a hotel room, were you to receive anything else if you testified to such a story today?”

  “They just said they’d take care of me. That a lot of money was at—”

  “Objection!” Royce yelled.

  He jumped to his feet.

  “Your Honor, the witness is clearly hostile and acting out a vindictive fantasy.”

  “He’s your witness, Mr. Royce. He can answer the question. Go ahead, sir.”

  “They said there was a lot of money at stake and they would take care of me,” Roman said.

  It just kept getting better for me and worse for Jessup. But I had to make sure I didn’t come off to the jury as gleeful or vindictive myself. I recalibrated and focused on what was important.

  “What was the story that Sarah told you all those years ago, Mr. Roman?”

  “Like I said, that she was in the yard and she was hiding and she saw the guy who grabbed her sister.”

  “Did she ever tell you she identified the wrong man?”

  “No.”

  “Did she ever tell you that the police told her who to identify?”

  “No.”

  “Did she ever once tell you that the wrong man was charged with her sister’s murder?”

  “No.”

  “No further questions.”

  I checked the clock as I returned to my seat. We still had twenty minutes before the lunch break. Rather than break early, the judge asked Royce to call his next witness. He called his investigator, Karen Revelle. I knew what he was doing and I was going to be ready.

  Revelle was a mannish-looking woman who wore slacks and a sport jacket. She had ex-cop written all over her dour expression. After she was sworn in, Royce got right to the point, probably hoping to stem the flow of blood from his case before the jurors went to lunch.

  “What do you do for a living, Ms. Revelle?”

  “I am an investigator for the law firm of Royce and Associates.”

  “You work for me, correct?”

  “That is correct.”

  “On March second of this year, did you conduct a telephone interview with an individual named Edward Roman?”

  “I did.”

  “What did he tell you in that call?”

  I stood and objected. I asked the judge if I could discuss my objection at a sidebar conference.

  “Come on up,” she said.

  Maggie and I followed Royce to the side of the bench. The judge told me to state my objection.

  “My first objection is that anything this witness states about a conversation with Roman is clearly hearsay and not allowed. But the larger objection is to Mr. Royce trying to impeach his own witness. He’s going to use Revelle to impeach Roman, and you can’t do that, Judge. It’s damn near suborning perjury on Mr. Royce’s part, because one of these two people is lying under oath and he called them both!”

  “I strongly object to Mr. Haller’s last characterization,” Royce said, leaning over the sidebar and moving in closer to the judge. “Suborning perjury? I have been practicing law for more than—”

  “First of all, back up, Mr. Royce, you’re in my space,” Breitman said sternly. “And second, you can save your self-serving objection for some other time. Mr. Haller is correct on all counts. If I allow this witness to continue her testimony, you are not only going to go into hearsay but we will have a situation where one of your witnesses has lied under oath. You can’t have it both ways and you can’t put a liar on the stand. So this is what we’re going to do. You are going to get your investigator off the stand, Mr. Haller is going to make a motion to strike what little testimony she has already given and I will agree to that motion. Then we’re going to lunch. During that time, you and your client can get together and decide what to do next. But it’s looking to me like your options got really limited in the last half hour. That’s all.”

  She didn’t wait for any of us to respond. She simply rolled her chair away from the sidebar.

  Royce followed the judge’s advice and ended his questioning of Revelle. I moved to strike and that was that. A half hour later I was sitting with Maggie and Sarah Gleason at a table at the Water Grill, the place where the case had started for me. We had decided to go high-end because we were celebrating what appeared to be the beginning of the end for Jason Jessup’s case, and because the Water Grill was just across the street from Sarah’s hotel. The only one missing at the table was Bosch, and he was on his way after dropping our silent witness, Sonia Reyes, at the drug rehab facility at County-USC Medical Center.

  “Wow,” I said after the three of us were seated. “I don’t think I’ve ever seen anything like that before in a courtroom.”

  “Me, neither,” Maggie said.

  “Well, I’ve been in a few courtrooms but I don’t know enough to know what it all means,” said Gleason.

  “It means the end is near,” Maggie said.

  “It means the entire defense imploded,” I added. “See, the defense’s case was sort of simple. Stepfather killed the girl and the family concocted a cover-up. They came up with the story about hide-and-seek and the man on the la
wn to throw the authorities off of stepdad. Then sister—that’s you—made a false identification of Jessup. Just sort of randomly set him up for a murder he did not commit.”

  “But what about Melissa’s hair in the tow truck?” Gleason asked.

  “The defense claims it was planted,” I said. “Either in conspiracy or independent of the family’s cover-up. The police realized they didn’t have much of a case. They had a thirteen-year-old girl’s ID of a suspect and almost nothing else. So they took hair from the body or a hairbrush and planted it in the tow truck. After lunch—if Royce is foolish enough to continue this—he will present investigative chronology reports and time logs that will show Detective Kloster had enough access and time to make the plant in the tow truck before a search warrant was obtained and forensics opened the truck.”

  “But that’s crazy,” Gleason said.

  “Maybe so,” Maggie said, “but that was their case and Eddie Roman was the linchpin because he was supposed to testify that you told him your stepfather did it. He was supposed to plant the seed of doubt. That’s all it takes, Sarah. One little doubt. Only he took one look at who was in the audience—namely Sonia Reyes—and thought he was in trouble. You see Eddie did the same thing with Sonia as he did with you. Met her, got close and turned her out to keep him in meth. When he saw her in court, he knew he was in trouble. Because he knew if Sonia got on the stand and told the same story about him as you did, then the jury would know what he was—a liar and predator—and wouldn’t trust a single thing he said. He also had no idea what Sonia might have told us about crimes they committed together. So he decided up there that his best out was the truth. To screw the defense and make the prosecution happy. He changed his story.”

  Gleason nodded as she began to understand.

  “Do you think Mr. Royce really told him what to say and was going to pay him off for his lies?”

  “Of course,” Maggie said.

  “I don’t know,” I said quickly. “I’ve known Clive a long time. I don’t think that’s how he operates.”

  “What?” Maggie said. “You think Eddie Roman just made it all up on his own?”

  “No, but he spoke to the investigator before he ever got to Clive.”