18th Abduction

by Patterson, James

  “Oh, man. Too bad, Linds.”

  I filled Joe in on the details, including the shocker that she’d checked into the motel alone, and that according to the manager, she’d done it before.

  “He said she was a prostitute.”

  “No kidding. The schoolteacher?”

  “So said the manager. Right now I have nothing to support that. But, Joe, if Carly was a party girl, anyone could have killed her.”

  Joe commiserated, encouraged me to keep talking.

  I said, “The manager says he may have seen her date, but only from the back. He says Carly had a pimp named Danny or Denny, he doesn’t know. Our night shift is showing Carly’s picture around, talking to their CIs about her and this possible Danny or Denny. And here’s a surprise. None of the hotel guests heard or saw anything suspicious while Carly was at the Big Four.

  “These three women were having good lives by nearly any standard. What am I missing?”

  Joe said, “Maybe it wasn’t them. It was him. What kind of person would have done this?” His anger was right there, just below the surface. Was he thinking about Petrović and Anna? What kind of man had committed this shocking crime?

  I said, “I think her killer was careful. Organized. This wasn’t an amateur job. My guess is he’s killed before.”

  “I couldn’t agree more.”

  I pictured the three women leaving the Bridge feeling happy, maybe a little tired, tipsy … what had happened?

  “Joe, there’s no sign of a struggle in the parking lot outside the Bridge. Assuming the women were offered a lift back to the school after dinner. Say the driver saw an opportunity. Why did these women get into that car?”

  “Was it raining?”

  “Nope.”

  “Maybe they trusted him.”

  I smiled at him, squeezed his hand.

  “Or one of them did.”

  He said, “You’re in the early stages of the investigation. You need more information, Linds. Want to go to bed and sleep on it?”

  Sounded good to me. I cleaned up while Joe stacked the dishes in the dishwasher. A few minutes later I met the man I loved in the bedroom. We got under the covers, and Martha climbed in between us.

  We all slept.

  CHAPTER 29

  My eyes flashed open at some dark hour.

  I couldn’t remember the whole of my dream, but the fragment that remained was a picture of Carly, Adele, and Susan climbing into a vehicle outside the Bridge.

  Now my conscious mind kicked in.

  If the three women had gotten into a car with a killer, how was it that twenty-four hours later, Carly had checked into the Big Four Motel alone?

  Big question: Where had she been during that time?

  If Carly had been tricking, any smart and careful psychopath could have killed her in room 212.

  I was scared.

  I was afraid that this case could be an endless ball of string that would be unsolved for the next twenty years. Or it could go cold forever.

  Next unrelenting question: Where were Adele and Susan?

  Joe said, “You can’t sleep, either?”

  “Oh, damn. I didn’t mean to wake you up.”

  “I was awake. I can’t turn off my brain.”

  Martha rolled onto her back and I mindlessly rubbed her belly.

  “I’ve got unsolved murders running through my head,” I said.

  “And I’ve got voices talking to me,” said Joe.

  He rolled toward me. “The voices are saying, ‘Get it together, you dumb shit.’”

  “That’s just mean of your voices.”

  Joe sighed and reached for me.

  Martha jumped off the bed and I went into Joe’s arms.

  We comforted each other, and then we made love, and fell asleep again until the sun came through the bedroom window.

  It was Friday morning. I was primary on a sickening case, and I still had no clues. I had to go to work.

  CHAPTER 30

  By eight thirty that morning Conklin and I were at our facing desks trying to get a lead on Nancy Koebel, the housekeeper who’d come upon the gruesome scene in room 212.

  Then she’d vanished.

  Her phone number came up as a prepaid phone, a burner. I called Tuohy, and he told me once again that it was the only number he had for her.

  “She’s only been here for a coupla months.”

  “Thanks,” I barked at him. This guy really pissed me off.

  I went back to my computer.

  Koebel’s name was absent from the DMV, SFPD, NCIC, and other available criminal databases. Did she get payroll checks from the Big Four—or was she paid off the books? Did she pay taxes? I doubted it. I couldn’t find a trace of her.

  “She’s undocumented,” I said to Conklin. I was taking an educated guess.

  That’s when Clapper called.

  Maybe he’d found evidence on Carly Myers’s body.

  “Hold a sec,” I said, “I’m putting you on speaker.”

  I stabbed the button on my phone console.

  Hellos were exchanged, then Clapper said, “What do you want first? Bad news or good?”

  “Bad,” I said. “Don’t cushion it.”

  “Inventory of Carly’s handbag: two textbooks, American history, Western civ. Hefty makeup kit. Pair of sneakers and two white socks. Miscellaneous pads and pens. A strip of condoms. Phone and charger. Laptop and charger. We’ve run down the numbers and email; she shops and pays her bills online. Nothing pops.”

  “Shit.”

  Clapper kept going.

  “Meanwhile, here’s something to keep hope alive. We’ve impounded the ATM from the Stop ’n Go facing across Polk toward the back of the motel,” he said. “We’re taking it apart and should know shortly if the camera was working, the disk was usable, the lens was clean. If all that’s a go, we’ll see if it captured anything useful.”

  “Good,” I said, crossing my fingers.

  Clapper said, “I’m being paged, but we finished processing Carly Myers’s body down at the morgue last night. Claire has my detailed notes. Call me if you have questions.”

  I had questions. Lots of them.

  I shouted, “Charlie, wait.”

  “Can’t,” he said. “Boxer. Go to the morgue. Claire’s waiting for you. And keep the faith.”

  He hung up.

  I looked at my partner. “Ready?”

  “You go. Take notes. I’ll keep working on Koebel.”

  Fine.

  I jogged down the four flights of stairs to the lobby and out the back door, and then power walked three hundred yards to the ME’s office. I pulled open the heavy glass door.

  It was closing in on 9:00 a.m., and the waiting room was filled with several cops and civilians who were likely family members waiting for autopsy results.

  I opened my jacket, flashed my badge at the new receptionist, and told her that Dr. Washburn was waiting for me.

  The receptionist pressed the intercom button on her phone and said, “Doctor, Sergeant Boxer is here.” Then, to me, “Go ahead.”

  She buzzed open the inner door.

  Several people who were waiting their turn saw this exchange and gave me hard looks.

  Well. I was on the job.

  I headed back to the autopsy suite. It was still early in the investigation, but maybe Claire would give me one tidbit or even, God willing, a eureka that would lead us to a killer and maybe from there to the two still-missing women.

  Claire, San Francisco’s chief medical examiner and my best bud, was suited up in baby-blue gown, cap, and gloves. She said, “I’ve got you a set of clothes over there, Lindsay. See it?”

  There was a pile of blue cotton scrubs folded on a metal stool, necessary attire to prevent contamination of Carly Myers’s body.

  When I was properly dressed, I moved in.

  Claire and I bumped our gloved fists, what Claire’s little girl, Rosie, calls an elephant kiss. We grinned and then turned our attention to Carly M
yers. She was draped with a sheet from her knees to her armpits.

  Claire told me, “Obviously, I haven’t begun the internal autopsy yet, but I have a few useful notes and one thing that has me completely stumped.”

  “Start there,” I said.

  “What? You want to spoil all my fun?”

  “God forbid. Start where you like. It’s your party and I’m in your house.”

  CHAPTER 31

  Claire opened the victim’s mouth and shined her flashlight inside.

  She said, “Look here, Lindsay. Call this confirmation of what you suspected. In a death by hanging, you’ll usually find the tongue is cut from biting.”

  Carly’s tongue looked intact to me.

  I said, “So she was dead when she was hanged.”

  “Yes, that’s my opinion. I found petechial hemorrhaging in the eyes and bruising around the neck. The cricoid cartilage in the neck was fractured. This doesn’t happen with ligature strangulation.”

  “What then? Manual strangulation?”

  “That is correct, my dear sergeant.”

  Claire showed me the bruises around Carly’s throat that had been covered by the collar of the white shirt.

  Claire said, “And look here. Abrasions on her knees, forearms, and here, the base of her palms. This might have happened if she tried to get away from her attacker and fell when he overpowered her.”

  Those abrasions had been hidden by shirttails and pink panties around her wrists when I saw Carly’s body in the shower. If she’d been attacked in the motel room, carpet fibers might be embedded in her scraped knees. If she’d been attacked outside, she should have traces of dirt from a lawn or a road or a parking lot, or even carpet from the inside of a vehicle.

  That kind of evidence could be a break for the good guys.

  I asked, “What kind of trace did CSI find in the wounds?”

  “Linds, I hate to tell you this, but Clapper himself swabbed those abrasions last night, and it’s his opinion that the body is squeaky clean.”

  I asked, “How squeaky? You’re not saying she was washed?”

  “Clapper thinks so. When the DNA tests come back, he’ll be able to say with certainty, but from the first pass, this is what he got. They combed out her hair and found no foreign particles. No trace under her nails. They swabbed the bite mark on her neck, and that swab has gone off to the lab. The shampoo bottle that was found in the bathroom was empty, and even with decomp, you can smell the soap on her. Chamomile.”

  “Nuts. Her killer really cleaned up after himself.”

  “He’s smart enough. If he had sex with her, he used a condom and left no trace on the bed—or anywhere.”

  “There were towels missing,” I said.

  “So he put them on the bed to protect the spread. Huh. Possible.”

  “What else?” I asked.

  Claire told me that she had sent out the sexual assault kit and the blood samples, that there was zero chance that results would come back until after the weekend—if then.

  “We’re looking at weeks for the DNA. I can only ring the fire alarm so many times,” she told me, “and I’ve rung it quite a lot recently.”

  I remembered the many times I’d stood in this room with Claire, using logic and forensic pathology to puzzle out what had happened to the person on the table who couldn’t tell us anything.

  Claire waggled her fingers in front of my face.

  “You still with me, Linds?”

  I snapped out of my thoughts and said, “Absolutely. We have to wait for the sexual assault kit to come back.”

  “Correct,” she said. “But I’m not done here. Not by far.”

  CHAPTER 32

  “Okay,” Claire said. “CSI found nothing at all on the shirt. It’s a common brand, all cotton, size 2XL, available for purchase in twenty thousand stores all over the country and online, priced between twelve and twenty bucks, made in China.”

  I sighed, long and loudly.

  Claire didn’t notice. She said, “The shirt hadn’t been worn until Carly’s dead body was dressed in it.”

  “Great,” I said sadly.

  If the doer had a new shirt handy, it pointed to a premeditated crime, either specific to Carly or in general if a choice opportunity arose.

  “And what about Carly’s own clothes that were left on the motel room floor?”

  “They were worn, but there was no blood or dirt or anything that would lead anywhere. I do have something for you, though.”

  “Please, Claire, make my day.”

  She smiled. She was enjoying herself. But hell, this was a rough job, and if someone had to oversee twelve hundred autopsies a year, best if it was someone who enjoyed her work.

  “I’ve taken photos of her injuries,” said Claire, “including these.”

  She pulled down the sheet, exposing Carly’s torso. She had large bruises on her body from chest to hips, and there was more: a half dozen discrete wounds in Carly’s flesh, three inches long, like knife wounds in a random pattern.

  Claire said, “She was beaten over a couple days’ time, but these wounds are fresh. She’s got similar wounds on her back and buttocks.”

  “What the hell are they?”

  Claire said, “I’m asking the same question. The incisions are shallow and were made by an unusual kind of blade. Check this out. There’s no collateral bruising at the point of entry.”

  “Meaning?”

  “The blade was beveled and double-edged and super sharp. I can’t yet identify the implement—that’s good. It wasn’t any kind of knife I’ve seen. So if you find the weapon, you may find the killer.”

  “Were the cuts made premortem or post?”

  “She was alive,” Claire told me. “And that also supports Clapper’s opinion that this body was washed. Even though these cuts were shallow, Carly had to have bled. But there’s no sign of blood.

  “That said, keep in mind that these wounds didn’t kill her, Lindsay. She was strangled. That’s a man’s crime.”

  “So, unofficially …” I said, prompting her.

  “Unofficially, manner of death: homicide. Cause of death: asphyxiation by manual strangulation. I’ll call you,” she said. “Right after I do the internal post.”

  CHAPTER 33

  Claire’s receptionist elbowed the door open and said, “Sergeant, Inspector Conklin called. He’s waiting upstairs for you.”

  I told Claire, “Thanks. Talk to you later,” and left the ME’s office, taking the breezeway to the back entrance of the Hall’s garnet-colored, marble-lined lobby. An elevator was waiting, and I rode it to four and then walked the short, brightly lit corridor to the homicide squad.

  Conklin was sitting behind his desk—and Cindy sat behind mine. Even at that time, before they’d gotten together, there was chemistry between my friend and my partner, known by women in and around the Hall as Inspector Hottie. I’d liked seeing it.

  Cindy said, “What can you tell me?”

  It was quite bold of Cindy—coming to our house, taking my chair, making demands. She’s infuriating and funny, often at the same time.

  I smiled and said, “This is absolutely all I can tell you, Cindy. You can say that the deceased is, in fact, Carly Myers and that the authorities are looking for anyone who may have seen her or her killer.”

  “Cause of death?”

  “Still undetermined. Claire is doing the post now.”

  “So, a positive ID of Carly Myers, deceased. What about the other two women? By my calculations, they’re still missing on day four.”

  “We’re working on it. All of us.” I waved my hand to encompass the squad room, which was largely empty.

  “Okay. I’ll do another blog post about the missing women.”

  “Good. Thanks. And here’s something we haven’t released,” I said. “Nancy Koebel was a housekeeper at the Big Four. She disappeared. Can you say on your blog that the SFPD needs to get in touch with her? She may have seen or heard something regarding this c
rime.”

  I spelled Koebel’s name, hoping that going public with that wouldn’t drive her further underground.

  Cindy closed her tablet and gathered her possessions, saying, “I’ve got some work to do. I’ll speak to you later. That means both of you.”

  She waved in our direction and headed out.

  Conklin followed her with his eyes.

  “Back to work, Tiger,” I said to him.

  I filled him in on what I’d learned from Claire and Clapper.

  “First and worst, Richie. No trace evidence has been found on Carly’s body. Clapper thinks and Claire agrees that the body was washed to destroy evidence. There’s also nothing of interest on Carly’s phone or laptop as far as Clapper can tell. Blood and DNA swabs are out for analysis.”

  “Shit. The killer rolled up his trail,” said Rich. “He threw her in the shower before he strung her up.”

  “Yep. And washed her down with the freebie shampoo. The shirt she was wearing is a generic men’s cotton shirt that could have been purchased anywhere. Claire is positive—unofficially—that Carly was strangled manually. The electric cord wasn’t the murder weapon.”

  “It was window dressing?” Conklin asked.

  “Exactly,” I said. “A distraction. A feint. An artistic touch.”

  I told my partner the Claire-stumping news that Carly had been cut in a dozen places front and back with a sharp unidentified blade that left an unusually shaped slit. I showed him the photo. “Narrow on both ends and broader in the center.”

  “What does Claire make of these … injuries?”

  “She says that Carly was alive when she was cut. Some of the incisions were made like this.”

  I used a letter opener to demonstrate a slice to my forearm.

  “Others were at an angle. One of the cuts just grazed her shoulder, opening a flap of skin.”

  “If the wounds weren’t lethal, what was the point?” Conklin asked.

  “I think he wanted to scare her, Rich. Or force compliance. Either way, Carly was tortured.”