Sins of the Immortal

by Jamie McGuire

  SINS OF THE IMMORTAL

  A NOVELLA

  Jamie McGuire

  Providence Trilogy

  Jamie McGuire

  Sins of the Immortal

  Copyright © 2021 by Jamie McGuire

  This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents are either the product of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously, and any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, business establishments, events or locales is entirely coincidental.

  All rights reserved. This e-book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. This e-book may not be re-sold or given away to other people. If you would like to share this book with another person, please purchase an additional copy for each recipient. If you’re reading this book and did not purchase it, or it was not purchased for your use only, then please return and purchase your own copy. Thank you for respecting the hard work of this author.

  Edited by Silla Webb, Masque of the Red Pen Publishing

  Formatted by Silla Webb, Masque of the Red Pen Publishing

  Cover Design by Hang Le

  First edition.

  TABLE OF CONTENTS

  Also by Jamie McGuire

  Chapter One

  Chapter Two

  Chapter Three

  Chapter Four

  Chapter Five

  Chapter Six

  Chapter Seven

  Chapter Eight

  Chapter Nine

  Chapter Ten

  Chapter Eleven

  Chapter Twelve

  Chapter Thirteen

  Chapter Fourteen

  Chapter Fifteen

  Chapter Sixteen

  Chapter Seventeen

  Chapter Eighteen

  Chapter Nineteen

  Chapter Twenty

  Chapter Twenty-one

  Epilogue

  Also by Jamie McGuire

  Providence (Providence Trilogy Book One)

  Requiem (Book Two)

  Eden (Book Three)

  Sins of the Innocent (A Providence Trilogy Novella)

  Beautiful Disaster

  Walking Disaster

  A Beautiful Wedding (A Beautiful Disaster Novella)

  Something Beautiful: A Novella

  Beautiful Oblivion

  Beautiful Redemption

  Beautiful Sacrifice

  Beautiful Burn

  A Beautiful Funeral

  Red Hill

  Among Monsters (A Red Hill Novella)

  Happenstance: A Novella Series (Parts 1-3)

  Apolonia

  From Here to You

  The Edge of Us

  All the Little Lights

  Chapter One

  Bex

  I’d heard Nina cry before, but I’d never heard the sound she made in the moment we lost Eden. The wail that came from her throat gave rise to goose bumps on my skin; the hair on the back of my neck stood on end. The room was filled with her broken heart.

  “Come outside,” Jared said, gently moving Nina toward the door. “Claire?”

  “Yeah?” our sister said, still in shock.

  “Cynthia.” Jared pointed to the chair where Nina’s mother sat, holding a dainty handkerchief to her hairline just above her temple.

  Just as Claire began to walk over, Cynthia stood, holding up her hand. “I’m fine. If none of you mind, I believe I’ll retire to my room.”

  “I’d feel better if you stayed at the loft, Cynthia,” Jared said. “We should all go back there, actually. This place is still swarming.”

  Cynthia breathed out a laugh. “I’m staying for the same reason I persuaded you to bring Nina back here. This is the still the safest place for us.”

  “The safest?” Nina said, looking up at her mother. “Can you really say that with a straight face, Mother?”

  “You have a head wound, Mrs. Grey,” Ryan said, preventing Cynthia from responding. “Let us take you to get checked out, and then I’ll drive you wherever you want.”

  “I was the PTA president for seven years, Mr. Scott. I assure you, I’ve faced worse.”

  “With all due respect, Mrs. Grey. What made you think you could go toe-to-toe with Satan?” Claire asked. “Did you really think you could stop him because angels fell out of your family tree?”

  “She’s like Kim was,” I said, staring at Cynthia. She didn’t know I knew, but I always had. I could sense the darkness in her blood, just like I could sense the power magnet she held within her somehow. “Except she can turn it on and off. She wasn’t strong enough to take Lucifer’s power.”

  “I used to be,” Cynthia said, looking defeated.

  Nina looked at her mother, horrified. “You…”

  Cynthia looked caught. “We have a lot to discuss, I’m sure. Just … not now,” Cynthia said, struggling to stand. Her heels clicked slower than usual, and she touched every piece of furniture she passed for stability, but she made it to her room.

  Nina was reduced to tears again, only emanating a combination of moans and cries, her cheeks wet. She couldn’t fight her husband. Instead, she reached for the space where Eden had been, inches from where Levi sat on his knees, bent over until his forehead touched the ground. It was weird to appreciate that my niece’s body had been reduced to ashes before our eyes once Lucifer took her life and disappeared. Somehow, it seemed better than staring at her lifeless body on the floor, but the image of her sweet face and tiny body being grayed and then blowing away into nothing would be forever burned into my memory.

  “Darling,” Jared said, cradling his wife in his arms. “Come with me.”

  Nina’s knees collapsed next to Morgan’s limp body, her eyes glossed over and bulging. A vein in her forehead protruded as if every one of her senses were about to boil over. “She’s not gone. He took her somewhere. She’s not gone.” She clenched her eyes shut, pushing the tears out and down her cheeks.

  Jared tugged on her a few times. “Love,” he said, encouraging her.

  Levi’s hand scooted a few inches away, resting on Nina’s outstretched fingers. “I’ll find her.”

  Nina sniffed, wiping her nose, her wide eyes staring at Levi. “Can you … can you do that?”

  “I can. And I will,” he said, standing.

  “Levi,” I said. “Given the situation, maybe you should take a minute to form a plan. You can’t bring her back, and even if you could, it’s not without permission.”

  “I don’t ask permission,” Levi said, staring at something I couldn’t see.

  “Jared?” Nina said, looking to him for answers. “Tell me he’s right.”

  “I … I don’t know. I hope so.” Jared was lost when our father died, and again when Nina left him almost twenty years before. This was something different; deeper. The almost silent grunting noises he made trying to hold his breath to avoid releasing his anguish made me wish I had Nina and Ryan’s human hearing.

  “But … you don’t believe him,” Nina said, broken.

  “Come with me,” Jared said, lifting her in his arms, tears filling his eyes and tumbling down his face.

  Claire kept her eyes on the floor, but when Ryan cupped the back of her neck, her expression crumbled. “I’ll be the one to say it. She isn’t coming back, Nina.”

  Nina leaned over again, the pain too much to bear, too much to stay upright. “What could we do?” she asked, wiping her cheek with the underside of her wrist. “It was what she wanted.”

  “There was nothing we could do,” Ryan said, his voice cracking. “She was stronger than all of us. And she believed saving Morgan was what she was meant to do.”

  “You don’t?” Nina said, her eyes swelling and red, her upper lip wet.


  “There’s always more we can do,” I said.

  “Bex,” Jared scolded.

  “I still feel her,” I said, closing my eyes.

  Nina closed hers, waiting. “I told you, Jared. I told you. She’s not gone.”

  Morgan coughed and turned on his side. His clothes were bloody, but at least Lucifer had repaired the bones he’d fractured while trying to bait Eden before he’d left her friend’s body for good.

  I kneeled next to him, checking his pulse. “He’s alive. I don’t know for how long. He needs medical attention.”

  “We’ll take him,” Ryan said. He lifted Morgan in his arms, and even then, the boy only whimpered.

  “How are you going to explain that to hospital staff?” Levi asked.

  “We’ve been doing this for a while,” Ryan said. “We’ll think of something.”

  “You,” Claire said, nodding to Levi. “You can’t just jump into Hell and start a fight. Your Bex’s Taleh. If you get killed, Bex does, too, and I’ll be damned if I’m losing anyone else today.”

  Ryan carried Morgan out, followed closely by Claire. His heavy steps were contrasted by his wife’s. She barely made a sound.

  Jared guided Nina out, and I watched Levi, wary.

  “Come with me,” he said, finally meeting my gaze. “We’ll burn it all down.”

  The temptation was overwhelming. I thought about losing control, destroying everything between my niece and me, but that wasn’t my path.

  “I have to stay here,” I said, staring at the place where I last saw her. “I don’t know why. It should be the opposite. I should stay close with you. But I’m supposed to stay here.”

  “Then you should,” Levi said.

  It was a moment of mutual respect, him validating my answer without judgment, and I at least didn’t think of him as the enemy.

  “I should’ve…” he began, but just like me, every instance he could point out could’ve been countered by the fact that it was what Eden wanted, and we all knew there was no changing her mind. He shook his head. “Is it just me? Do you feel her, too?”

  “I don’t know what I feel,” I said, wiping my nose with the back of my wrist. “I don’t know if I can feel anything right now. I’m just … numb.”

  “I’m not. I’m furious, and I’m going to take it out on every demon that crosses my path until I see her again.”

  “Do you know what it means if she’s really gone?” I asked, leaning against the wall.

  “I couldn’t imagine,” he said, his eyes losing focus. “Honestly? I’d probably nuke the world, Bex. Then those selfish sons of bitches won’t have anything to fight over.”

  I remembered what it was like to lose Nina’s friend Kim. We’d spent a lot of time together before she'd died. We spoke for hours in the underbelly of Jerusalem, uncoupled, the odd men out. She was quirky and a little weird, but in the end, she felt like family. I was sad when she died, but what I felt for Eden’s loss superseded sadness. I was curious how I would react when the time came that I processed it. Curious, and maybe even afraid.

  Levi’s suggestion might have set off alarms, and I probably should have tried to talk him out of it, but they’d taken it too far. Hell, erasing her for more power, and Heaven, creating her just to die. Not to save millions, the world, or even a city full of women and children. Her story, her life, her purpose, all ended for just one boy.

  “I’m going,” Levi said. “Don’t worry. I won’t get us killed.”

  I nodded to him once, knowing my life was in his hands. He waved goodbye before closing the door behind him, and I sat on the bottom step, barely able to dial my phone. When the voice on the other end answered, I rubbed the back of my neck, trying to hold back tears.

  “Bex? Is that you, son? I can’t hear you,” Mom said.

  “I’m here,” I said, my voice breaking.

  She hesitated. “Is everything all right?”

  “It’s Eden, Mom. She’s…”

  Mom sucked in a breath. After several moments, she finally spoke. “How?”

  “Lucifer took her. He shelled her friend Morgan, used him to… She turned to ash.” I cleared my throat, trying not to squeak, but if anyone didn’t care about that, it was my mom. “She faded into ashes and blew away. There’s nothing left of her.

  It took her a few moments to speak. “And where is Morgan?”

  “Claire and Ryan took him to the hospital.”

  “Where are Jared and Nina?”

  “They left.”

  She cleared her throat. Like always, she was staying strong for us. “Ashes?”

  “Yeah,” I said, staring at the door. My upper lip and cheeks were wet. I could feel Levi’s growing anger and his excitement to unleash his wrath and find my niece. He fully believed he could. “Yeah. Levi went to find her.”

  “Find her?” Her tone changed. A hint of hope whispered in her words.

  “In another plane. He’s convinced he can jump over there and get her back.”

  “Can he?”

  I sighed. “I hope so. He’s the son of Lucifer, and he’s pissed off. And…” My chest concaved as I tried to hold in the pain. “I miss my best friend.”

  “Listen to me, Bex. Levi will find her. He’ll bring her home,” Mom said.

  I nodded, even though she couldn’t hear me.

  “I love you, son.”

  “Love you, Mom.”

  I hung up, letting the phone dangle from my thumb and index finger. Levi was still driving, and the farther he was away, the more my need to protect him fought with whatever silent voice commanded that I stay put.

  I dialed another number I knew by heart, and listened to the ring, hoping for voicemail so I could just listen and hang up.

  “Bex?” Allison answered, curiosity and anxiousness in her voice. “Hello?”

  “I’m sorry. I’m so sorry for calling you. I know I said I wouldn’t.”

  “Are you okay?” she asked.

  “I don’t mean to bother you, but…” I hesitated. If Levi did bring Eden back, and I told Allison she was dead, that would be one more thing I’d have to explain away. Allison was the love of my life, and I’d had to lie to her over and over. She was a law student when we first met and questioned everything. It wasn’t like my father’s relationship with my mom. Allison wouldn’t accept my vague answers and half-truths, so I had to choose.

  “You’re never a bother to me, Bex,” she said, her sweet voice making my heart ache more.

  “I … I just miss you.”

  “I miss you, too,” she said without hesitation. “Having a rough night?”

  “One of the roughest of my life.”

  “Your mom is okay?”

  “Yes.”

  “Eden?”

  I paused. Of course, that would be the second person she’d name. Allison knew how much Eden meant to me.

  “Bex? Did something happen to Eden?”

  “Yeah.”

  “But you can’t tell me,” she said, trying to keep the accusatory tone from her voice.

  “No.”

  Her face made a muffled noise against the phone as she nodded. “It’s okay. We can still talk. Tell me about everything else.”

  “Tell me about you. I just need to hear your voice.”

  “Well, I passed the bar six months ago, and I was hired by Tigges & Fowel five weeks after. I had my choice, and they seemed like the best fit. Tilly and I just got a new place. She’s still nosy, but I would honestly die without her cooking…”

  I leaned back against the wall, listening to the only voice besides my mother’s that would even begin to remind me that I didn’t want to die, too. Allison was my anchor to being human, and so I listened to her stories of her roommate, moving mishaps, and getting settled into her new job as a junior prosecuting attorney in Albany, New York.

  It was easier to focus on her than Eden’s ashes or Levi driving 100 miles per hour to Hell,
so I envisioned myself in every story, immersing myself in the images she described.

  “I still love you, you know,” she whispered into the phone. “Tilly says I should get out there; start dating again, but I just … I just can’t.”

  I closed my eyes. “I just want you to be happy, Allie.”

  “That’s you. You’re my happy.” After a few beats she continued, “But, I know… I know that you can’t. So I just wanted you to know. Because I know that you still love me.”

  “And I always will.”

  “Want me to keep talking?”

  “Yes, please.”

  She hesitated as she thought of more to say. “I just moved into this apartment a few months ago. It’s the same price as the one in Providence, but it’s smaller. It’s within walking distance to the office, though, and there’s a cute little coffee shop on the hill just up the street…”

  Chapter Two

  Jared

  Nina’s sobs had quieted down in the last hour, reduced to intermittent whimpering between silence. As she lay on my lap, hugging my thigh, I ran my fingers through her hair, saying prayers in the language of Heaven. That had always seemed to calm her most.

  I’d regretted my choice to reveal myself to her more times than I could count, but those feelings of guilt were always overshadowed by my love for her, the precious moments we shared, and the life and family we’d built together.

  Not this time.

  My choice had hurt Nina—physically and emotionally. She’d been afraid for her life, for our daughter’s, and had already lost too much before she watched our daughter’s murder. Nina was even tortured in her dreams. But this… I didn’t deserve to look her in the eyes after this.

  “I know what you’re thinking,” she said, caressing my arm with her fingertips. “Do you know what I’m thinking?”

  “I’m afraid to ask,” I said, sincere.

  She turned for a moment to kiss the underside of my forearm, but didn’t look me in the eye. “Of the bench.”