Beyond Greed and Fear

Home > Other > Beyond Greed and Fear > Page 46
Beyond Greed and Fear Page 46

by Hersh Shefrin


  as forecasting variable, 282–283

  and 1987 market crash, 280–282, 283–284

  and overreaction, 285–286

  See also volatility, market

  incubator fund game, 171

  index funds, versus active money management, 220–221

  index options, and market swings, 283–284

  individual investing

  appeal of covered-call writing, 273–276

  heuristic-driven bias in, 131–133

  regret in, 128–131

  See also mutual funds

  portfolio selection, individual

  retirement saving

  inefficient markets, 5

  and conservatism, 35–37

  defined, 33–34

  and departure from fundamental value, 38–41

  and frame dependence, 37–38

  and overconfidence, 41–42

  and post-recommendation drift, 74

  and representativeness, 34–35

  traditional finance reaction to, 9–10

  See also market efficiency inflation

  expectations, and yield curve, 209–211

  impact on market prediction, 57–58

  and money illusion, 31–32

  initial public offerings (IPOs)

  Boston Chicken case study, 240–243

  connection with closed-end funds, 184–185

  evidence for “hot markets,” 251–255

  initial underpricing phenomena in, 247–250

  and long-run underperformance, 250–251

  Netscape Communications case study, 243–247

  initial underpricing, 239

  of Boston Chicken stocks, 243

  general phenomena of, 247–250

  and Netscape’s IPO, 244

  Institutional Investor, 264

  institutional money management. See money management industry

  Intel Corp., 74, 109, 231, 266, 267, 268

  interest rate forecasts

  behavioral themes impacting, 197–205

  and expectations hypothesis, 205–209

  and inflation expectations, 209–211

  and Orange County bankruptcy, 194–196

  Internal Revenue Service, using for retirement savings, 145

  Internet

  firms, IPOs of, 246

  mean variance analysis on, 126–127

  trading on, 133–134

  Internet Fund, 133

  Investment Company Institute, 170, 171

  investor overreaction hypothesis, 81. See also overreaction

  Investor’s Business Daily, 161, 173, 205

  Investors Intelligence, 60, 62, 63, 65, 68

  Ip, Greg, 47, 60–61

  IPO. See initial public offerings

  IPO Financial Network, 246

  Ippolito, Richard, 167

  Jackwerth, Jens, 280, 281

  Jegadeesh, Narasimhan, 77

  Jensen, Michael, 167, 168, 235

  Jobs, Steve, 25

  John R. Nuveen and Company, 176

  Johnson, Eric, 27, 28–29, 38, 218

  Johnson, Hugh A., 246

  Journal of Applied Psychology, 8

  Journal of Derivatives, 204–205

  Journal of Economic Perspectives, 198

  Journal of Finance, 8, 185

  Journal of Financial Economics, 8

  Kahneman, Daniel, 3, 7, 8, 14, 18, 24, 108, 129, 133, 151, 170, 217, 277

  Kan, Raymond, 185

  Kandel, Shmuel, 37

  Kaplan, Steven, 235

  Katz, Deena, 123

  Kavner, Robert, 229, 232

  Keon, Edward J., 257, 258, 259, 263, 265

  Kerschner, Edward, 40, 41, 46, 54, 79

  Kim, Dong-Soon, 189

  Kim, E. Han, 235

  Kinetics Asset Management, 133

  King, Mervyn, 135

  Kinnel, Russ, 173–174

  Klahr, Melvin, 108, 109, 116

  Klibanoff, Peter, 187, 188

  Knight, Ann, 79

  Kraus, Steven, 100

  Krugman, Paul, 302–303

  Kurlak, Tom, 74

  laddered portfolio, 147

  Lakonishok, Josef, 85, 87, 219, 220

  Lamont, Owen, 187, 188

  Landis, Kevin, 174

  Lang, Mark, 277

  Lau, Lawrence, 302

  “law of large numbers,” 18

  Leape, Jonathan, 135

  Lee, Charles, 40, 179, 180, 181, 184, 185, 187, 189

  Leeson, Nicholas, 24

  leverage, in closed-end funds, 190

  Levin, Laurence, 154–155

  Levitt, Arthur, 134, 171, 173

  Lewis, Salim (Cy), 107–108, 109

  Lim, Terence, 102

  Lipper Analytical Services, 108, 172

  Livingston, Joseph, 46, 209

  Longitudinal Retirement History Survey, 154

  Long Term Capital Management (LTCM), 6–7, 10, 21, 33, 34

  and investor overconfidence, 41–42

  long-term underperformance, 239

  as general phenomena, 250–251

  of Netscape’s stock, 244–245

  Lopes, Lola, 3, 120, 121, 122, 123, 125, 127, 133

  Los Angeles Times, 185, 195, 200, 203

  loss aversion

  in corporate takeover strategies, 229, 233, 236

  described, 24–25

  examples of, 107–110, 114–115

  as general phenomena, 108–109, 115–117

  myopic, in retirement saving, 145–148

  in Orange County bankruptcy, 201–203

  and time diversification, 146–147

  toward stocks, 37–38

  Loughran, Tim, 250, 254, 255

  Lowenstein, George, 123

  Lucent Technologies, 233

  Lynch, Peter, 52, 159–161, 163, 166, 174

  One Up on Wall Street, 160

  Macaulay, Frederick, 193, 206

  McGee, Suzanne, 283–284

  McGough, Robert, 109

  MacKay, Elizabeth, 46

  Malatesta, Paul, 235

  market capitalization, of recommended stocks, 75, 76–77, 79–80

  market efficiency, 9–10

  beating the market and, 70, 71

  illusion of, 69, 70

  and IPO phenomena, 239–240

  rationale for, 70

  and risk, 75–77

  See also inefficient markets

  market feedback hypothesis, in IPOs, 248–249

  market prediction. See prediction, market

  market volatility. See implied volatility, of options

  volatility, market

  MarketWatch.com, 246

  Markowitz, Harry, 5, 24, 31, 119, 120, 136

  masking the risk game, 173

  Mauro, Martin, 198, 208

  mean-variance analysis, 124–125

  Internet access to, 126–127

  Mendenhall, Richard, 96

  Menlow, David, 246

  mental accounting

  and frame dependence, 26

  and hedonic

  editing, 27–29

  in institutional money management, 218

  in portfolio selection, 125–126

  in retirement saving, 143–145, 152, 155

  Meriwether, John, 6

  Merrill Lynch, 9, 16, 21, 46, 47, 74

  and Boston Chicken, 241, 243

  and Orange County bankruptcy, 194, 195, 199, 202, 204

  Merton, Robert, 5, 6, 9–10, 34, 40, 71

  Metrick, Andrew, 6, 64

  Meyers, Lawrence, 286

  Michaely, Roni, 261, 262

  Microsoft, 245, 265, 267, 268

  Miller, Merton, 5, 9, 11, 23, 29, 34, 185, 204–205

  Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, 94

  mispricing, 33–34, 91

  illusion of, 69, 70

  and momentum, 78

  See also inefficient markets

  Modigliani, Frank, 9, 23, 57

  momentum

  and mutual fund performance,
169

  and postearnings-announcement drift, 91, 101, 102

  of recommended stocks, 76, 77–78

  money illusion, and inflation, 31–32, 57

  Money magazine, 31, 175

  money management industry

  behavioral issues in, 216–219

  general findings in, 219–222

  role of regret and responsibility in, 222–223

  tax-exempt, study of, 219–220

  university endowment case study, 214–216

  Money Market Services, 208, 209, 305

  Moorlach, John, 200, 201

  Morgan Stanley, 16, 46, 51, 243, 244, 268

  Morningstar publications, 169, 170, 171

  Motorola, 94, 95, 101

  Mullins, David, 235

  mutual funds

  and adviser obfuscation games, 170–174

  evaluating, by past performance, 163–165

  investors, characteristics of, 170–171

  Peter Lynch’s success with, 160–161, 166

  ratings, 169–170

  representativeness in evaluating, 165–166

  and rules of chance, 161–163

  skill versus luck in performance of, 166–169

  Myers, James, 40

  myopic loss aversion, 38

  in retirement saving, 145–148

  naive diversification, 136

  Natale, Robert, 242, 244, 246

  Natenberg, Sheldon, 278, 285, 286

  National Association of Investment Clubs, 131

  National Association of Investors Corporations, 135

  NCR takeover, 227–233, 234

  Nesbitt Burns, 93

  net asset value, 175

  Netscape Communications, 243–246, 247, 248–249, 250

  New Israel Fund, 188

  newsletter advisors

  betting against prevailing views of, 59–60

  controversy over accuracy of, 60–68

  naive extrapolation and nervous bullishness of, 66–68

  New York Times, 187

  Nixon, President, 209

  Nocera, Joseph, 266

  noise traders, 295

  Nuveen Premium Income Municipal funds, 176–179, 181–182, 189

  obfuscation games, 170–174

  Odean, Terrance, 10, 41, 64, 116, 132, 134

  O’Neill, Barbara, How Real People Handle Their Money, 121, 132, 135

  online trading, 133–134. See also Internet

  opaque fees game, 171

  open-ended mutual funds. See mutual funds

  optimism

  analyst, and investment banking relationship, 258–262

  in corporate takeovers, 233, 236, 237

  in earnings forecasts, 263–265

  excessive, 22, 148, 237, 255

  of individual investors, 131, 132

  options

  covered-call writing, 273–277

  employee stock, 277

  and implied volatility, 278–286 (See also implied volatility)

  market overreaction in, 285–286

  measuring sentiment with, 286–287

  and 1987 market crash, 280–282, 283–284

  pricing theories, 5, 277–278

  Orange County bankruptcy, 9, 194–196

  behavioral themes impacting, 197–205

  and expectations hypothesis, 205–208

  making sense of, 211–212

  orange juice futures, 289–298

  O’shaughnessy, James, 93

  overconfidence

  and corporate takeovers, 277 (See also hubris hypothesis)

  and earnings predictions, 35

  in foreign exchange market, 300–301

  as heuristic-driven bias, 18–19

  of individual investors, 131, 132–133

  of investment strategists, 48–51

  and mispricing exploitation, 41–42

  and Orange County bankruptcy, 197–200

  and post-earnings-announcement drift, 100

  overreaction, 8, 10

  and implied volatility, 285

  misinterpreting

  evidence about, 86–88

  and post-earnings-announcement

  drift, 101–102

  and winner-loser effect, 81, 84, 85

  PaineWebber, 40, 46, 48, 54, 78, 79, 80

  Panel Study of Income Dynamics and Consumer Expenditure Survey, 153

  Paradyne Corp., 230

  Patel, Jayendu, 167, 268, 269

  Peles, Nadav, 130, 170

  pension plans

  managing, 219–220

  performance of, 223 See also retirement saving

  Perolt, Andre, 7

  Personal Money Guide, 275

  pessimism, inducing, in earnings forecasts, 265–267

  Philadelphia Inquirer, 209

  Phillips, Don, 170, 171

  pick-a-number game, 5–6

  Plexus Corporation, 92–96, 97, 98, 99, 100

  Pollo Tropical Inc., 242

  Pontiff, Jeffrey, 189

  Pope, Robin, 122, 123

  Porter, Michael, 186

  portfolio selection, individual

  balancing goals and risk tolerance in, 121–125

  and emotional time line, 120–121

  frame dependence in, 125–126

  and heuristic driven bias, 131–133

  impact of Internet on, 133–134

  importance of diversification in, 134–136

  layered pyramid structure for, 121–123

  mean-variance analysis versus emotional response in, 126–127

  optimism and overconfidence in, 132–133

  regret and hindsight bias in, 128–131

  security versus potential in, 125–126, 127–128

  use of “ladders” in, 147See also retirement saving

  post-earnings-announcement drift, 20, 91, 96–98

  behavioral biases in, 100–101

  and momentum and overreaction, 77, 101–102See also earnings announcements

  Poterba, James, 136, 141, 142

  Pound, John, 38, 152–153

  prediction, market

  and asset allocation, 47

  betting on trends in, 51–52

  gambler’s fallacy in, 45–46

  general findings on, 46–47

  heuristic diversity in, 52

  and heuristic-driven bias, 16–18

  and illusions about randomness, 55–57

  impact of inflation on, 57–58

  impact of overconfident strategists on, 48–51

  role of sentiment in, 53–55

  technical analysis versus fundamental analysis in, 53–55

  price efficiency. See market efficiency

  price-to-book ratios, of recommended stocks, 75–76, 78

  price-to-earnings ratios (P/E), 8, 39–40

  of recommended stocks, 76

  and value investing, 81

  Principal Guaranteed Strategy, 127–128

  prospect theory, 24, 108

  “Pros versus Darts” contest, 70, 77

  Prudential Securities, 53, 54, 79

  Psychology Today, 129

  Putnam Equity Income Fund, 171

  Putnam Investment Management, 243

  Putnam Strategic Income Trust, 171

  Putnam Strategic Investments Trust, 276–277

  pyramids, in portfolios, 121–123

  security and potential in, 125–126, 200See also portfolio selection, individual

  Raabe, Matthew R., 201, 202–203

  randomness, illusions about, 55–57

  Raymond, James, 78, 79, 80

  real estate investment, 110

  recommendation game, 258–262

  recommended stocks

  impact of analyst changes in, 74, 262

  investment banking relationship with, 258–262

  momentum of, 77–78

  performance of, 71–74, 78–80

  postrecommendation drift of, 74, 77

  risk involved in, 74–77

  turnover rate of,
77–78

  Red Chip Review, 94

  reference point effect, 200, 201–202

  regression to the mean, 15, 16–17

  and market predictions, 46

  regret

  as frame dependence, 30–31, 88

  and hindsight bias, 88, 130

  and individual investors, 128–131

  in IPO investing, 242, 255

  in Orange County bankruptcy, 203–205

  role in money management industry, 222–223

  representativeness

  in evaluating mutual funds, 165–166

  as heuristic-driven bias, 14–18

  and perception of stocks, 81–83

  role in inefficient markets, 34–35

  Research Institute of America, 275

  responsibility

  and “blame game,” 203–204

  role in money management industry, 222–223

  retirement saving, 139–140

  case study for, 140–141

  dividends for, 151–153

  dollar-cost averaging in, 148–151

  and mental accounting, 143–145

  myopic loss aversion in, 145–148

  and self-control, 141–142

  retirement spending, 153–155

  Riepe, Mark, 133

  rights offerings, in closed-end funds, 190–191

  risk

  involved in recommended stocks, 74–77

  measures of, 75–77

  in options trading, 278, 279

  systematic, in threefactor model, 85–86

  risk premium, in foreign exchange, 307

  risk tolerance

  and frame dependence, 27–29

  mean-variance analysis versus emotional response to, 126–127

  and portfolio selection, 120, 121–125See also loss aversion

  Ritter, Jay, 85, 247, 249, 250, 254, 255

  RJF Asset Management, 21, 99, 218–219

  Robertson, Julian, Jr., 303

  Robert W. Baird & Co., 92, 94

  Roll, Richard, 227, 233–234, 289, 295

  Rolm, 229, 230

  Ross, David, 9, 204–205

  Royal Dutch Petroleum, 7, 41

  Rozeff, Michael, 149

  Ruback, Richard, 235

  Rubinstein, Mark, 280, 281, 288

  Rukeyser, Louis, 62–64, 65

  rules of thumb, 4, 13. See also heuristic-driven bias

  Russell, Richard, 57

  Russell, Thomas, 265

  Salomon Brothers Inc., 46, 246

  Saltmarsh, Bob, 166

  Samblis, Steven, 244

  Samuelson, Paul, 9–10

  San Francisco Chronicle, 245

  Santa Clara University endowment portfolio, 214–218

  Santos, Tano, 38

  Sarin, Atulya, 263, 264

  Scholes, Myron, 5, 6, 33, 34, 41, 42, 277–279, 280, 281, 282

  Science, 8

  Scott, R. A., 200

  Scoville, Jack, 297, 298

  Sculley, John, 25

  seasoned equity offerings, 254, 263–264

  Seguin, Paul, 180

  self-attribution bias, 101

  self-control

  and dividend payouts, 30

  and retirement saving, 141–143

  Senk, Marshall, 267

 

‹ Prev