Heretics of Dune

by Frank Herbert

"The Ixians are in this somewhere," Odrade said.

  Tuek agreed. That much shigawire... "Where have you taken the child?" he asked.

  "We are protecting her," Odrade said. "Be still." She tipped her head, listening.

  A robed woman sped back around the curve of the hallway and whispered something in Odrade's ear. Odrade produced a tight smile.

  "It is over," Odrade said. "We will go to Sheeana."

  Sheeana occupied a softly cushioned blue chair in the main room of her quarters. Black-robed women stood in a protective arc behind her. The child appeared to Tuek quite recovered from the shock of the attack and escape but her eyes glittered with excitement and unasked questions. Sheeana's attention was directed at something off to Tuek's right. He stopped and looked there, gasping at what he saw.

  A naked male body lay against the wall in an oddly crumpled position, the head twisted until the chin lay back over the left shoulder. Open eyes stared out with the emptiness of death.

  Stiros!

  The shredded rags of Stiros' robe, obviously torn from him violently, lay in an untidy heap near the body's feet.

  Tuek looked at Odrade.

  "He was in on it," she said. "There were Face Dancers with the Ixians."

  Tuek tried to swallow in a dry throat.

  Cania shuffled past him toward the body. Tuek could not see her face but Cania's presence reminded him that there had been something between Stiros and Cania in their younger days. Tuek moved instinctively to place himself between Cania and the seated child.

  Cania stopped at the body and nudged it with a foot. She turned a gloating expression on Tuek. "I had to make sure he was really dead," she said.

  Odrade glanced at a companion. "Get rid of the body." She looked at Sheeana. It was Odrade's first chance for a more careful study of the child since leading the assault force here to deal with the attack on the temple complex.

  Tuek spoke behind Odrade. "Reverend Mother, could you explain please what--"

  Odrade interrupted without turning. "Later."

  Sheeana's expression quickened at Tuek's words. "I thought you were a Reverend Mother!"

  Odrade merely nodded. What a fascinating child. Odrade experienced the sensations she felt while standing in front of the ancient painting in Taraza's quarters. Some of the fire that had gone into the work of art inspired Odrade now. Wild inspiration ! That was the message from the mad Van Gogh. Chaos brought into magnificent order. Was that not part of the Sisterhood's coda?

  This child is my canvas, Odrade thought. She felt her hand tingle to the feeling of that ancient brush. Her nostrils flared to the smells of oils and pigments.

  "Leave me alone with Sheeana," Odrade ordered. "Everybody out."

  Tuek started to protest but stopped when one of Odrade's robed companions gripped his arm. Odrade glared at him.

  "The Bene Gesserit have served you before," she said. "This time, we saved your life."

  The woman holding Tuek's arm tugged at him.

  "Answer his questions," Odrade said. "But do it somewhere else."

  Cania took a step toward Sheeana. "That child is my--"

  "Leave!" Odrade barked, all the powers of Voice in the command.

  Cania froze.

  "You almost lost her to a bumbling lot of conspirators!" Odrade said, glaring at Cania. "We will consider whether you get any further opportunity to associate with Sheeana."

  Tears started in Cania's eyes but Odrade's condemnation could not be denied. Turning, Cania fled with the others.

  Odrade returned her attention to the watchful child.

  "We've been a long time waiting for you," Odrade said. "We will not give those fools another opportunity to lose you."

  Law always chooses sides on the basis of enforcement power. Morality and legal niceties have little to do with it when the real question is: Who has the clout?

  --Bene Gesserit Council Proceedings: Archives #X0X232

  Immediately after Taraza and her party left Gammu, Teg threw himself into his work. New in-Keep procedures had to be laid out, holding Schwangyu at arm's length from the ghola. Taraza's orders.

  "She can observe all she wants. She can't touch."

  In spite of the work pressures, Teg found himself staring into space at odd moments, prey to free-floating anxiety. The experience of rescuing Taraza's party from the Guildship and Odrade's odd revelations did not fit into any data classification he constructed.

  Dependencies ... key logs ...

  Teg found himself seated in his own workroom, an assignment schedule projected in front of him with shift changes to approve and, for a moment, he had no idea of the time or even the date. It took a moment to relocate himself.

  Midmorning. Taraza and her party had been gone two days. He was alone. Yes, Patrin had taken over this day's training schedule with Duncan, freeing Teg for the command decisions.

  The workroom around Teg felt alien. Yet, when he looked at each element in it, he found each thing familiar. Here was his own personal data console. His uniform jacket had been draped neatly across a chair-back beside him. He tried to fall into Mentat mode and found his own mind resisting. He had not encountered that phenomenon since training days.

  Training days.

  Taraza and Odrade between them had thrown him back into some form of training.

  Self-training.

  In a detached way, he felt his memory offering up a long-ago conversation with Taraza. How familiar it was. He was right there, caught in the moments of his own memory-snare.

  Both he and Taraza had been quite tired after making the decisions and taking the actions to prevent a bloody confrontation--the Barandiko incident. Nothing but a hiccough in history now but at the time it had demanded all of their combined energies.

  Taraza invited him into the small parlor of her quarters on her no-ship after the agreement was signed. She spoke casually, admiring his sagacity, the way he had seen through to the weaknesses that would force a compromise.

  They had been awake and active for almost thirty hours and Teg was glad for the opportunity to sit while Taraza dialed her foodrink installation. It dutifully produced two tall glasses of creamy brown liquid.

  Teg recognized the smell as she handed him his glass. It was a quick source of energy, a pick-me-up that the Bene Gesserit seldom shared with outsiders. But Taraza no longer considered him an outsider.

  His head tipped back, Teg took a long swallow of the drink, his gaze on the ornate ceiling of Taraza's small parlor. This no-ship was an old-fashioned model, built in the days when more care had been taken with decoration--heavily incised cornices, baroque figures carved in every surface.

  The taste of the drink pushed his memory back into childhood, the heavy infusion of melange ...

  "My mother made this for me whenever I was overly strenuous," he said, looking at the glass in his hand. He already could feel the calming energy flow through his body.

  Taraza took her own drink to a chairdog opposite him, a fluffy white bit of animate furniture that fitted itself to her with the ease of long familiarity. For Teg, she had provided a traditional green upholstered chair, but she saw his glance flick across the chairdog and grinned at him.

  "Tastes differ, Miles." She sipped her drink and sighed. "My, that was strenuous but it was good work. There were moments when it was right on the edge of getting very nasty."

  Teg found himself touched by her relaxation. No pose, no ready-made mask to set them apart and define their separate roles in the Bene Gesserit hierarchy. She was being obviously friendly and not even a hint of seductiveness. So this was just what it seemed to be--as much as that could be said about any encounter with a Reverend Mother.

  With quick elation, Teg realized that he had become quite adept at reading Alma Mavis Taraza, even when she adopted one of her masks.

  "Your mother taught you more than she was told to teach you," Taraza said. "A wise woman but another heretic. That's all we seem to be breeding nowadays."

  "Heretic?"
He was caught by resentment.

  "That's a private joke in the Sisterhood," Taraza said. "We're supposed to follow a Mother Superior's orders with absolute devotion. And we do, except when we disagree."

  Teg smiled and took a deep draught of his drink.

  "It's odd," Taraza said, "but while we were in that tight little confrontation I found myself reacting to you as I would to one of my Sisters."

  Teg felt the drink warming his stomach. It left a tingling in his nostrils. He placed the empty glass on a side table and spoke while looking at it. "My eldest daughter ... "

  "That would be Dimela. You should have let us have her, Miles."

  "It was not my decision."

  "But one word from you ... " Taraza shrugged. "Well, that's past. What about Dimela?"

  "She thinks I'm often too much like one of you."

  "Too much?"

  "She is fiercely loyal to me, Mother Superior. She doesn't really understand our relationship and--"

  "What is our relationship?"

  "You command and I obey."

  Taraza looked at him over the lip of her glass. When she put down the glass, she said: "Yes, you've never really been a heretic, Miles. Perhaps ... someday... "

  He spoke quickly, wanting to divert Taraza from such ideas. "Dimela thinks the long use of melange makes many people become like you."

  "Is that so? Isn't it odd, Miles, that a geriatric potion should have so many side effects?"

  "I don't find that odd."

  "No, of course you wouldn't." She drained her glass and put it aside. "I was addressing the way a significant life extension has produced in some people, you especially, a profound knowledge of human nature."

  "We live longer and observe more," he said.

  "I don't think it's quite that simple. Some people never observe anything. Life just happens to them. They get by on little more than a kind of dumb persistence, and they resist with anger and resentment anything that might lift them out of that false serenity."

  "I've never been able to strike an acceptable balance sheet for the spice," he said, referring to a common Mentat process of data sorting.

  Taraza nodded. Obviously, she found the same difficulty. "We of the Sisterhood tend to be more single-track than Mentats," she said. "We have routines to shake ourselves out of it but the condition persists."

  "Our ancestors have had this problem for a long time," he said.

  "It was different before the spice," she said.

  "But they lived such short lives."

  "Fifty, one hundred years; that doesn't seem very long to us, but still... "

  "Did they compress more into the available time?"

  "Oh, they were frenetic at times."

  She was giving him observations from her Other Memories, he realized. Not the first time he had shared in such ancient lore. His mother had produced such memories on occasion, but always as a lesson. Was Taraza doing that now? Teaching him something?

  "Melange is a many-handed monster," she said.

  "Do you sometimes wish we had never found it?"

  "The Bene Gesserit would not exist without it."

  "Nor the Guild."

  "But there would have been no Tyrant, no Maud'dib. The spice gives with one hand and takes with all of its others."

  "Which hand contains that which we desire?" he asked. "Isn't that always the question?"

  "You're an oddity, you know that, Miles? Mentats so seldom dip into philosophy. I think it's one of your strengths. You are supremely able to doubt."

  He shrugged. This turn in the conversation disturbed him.

  "You are not amused," she said. "But cling to your doubts anyway. Doubt is necessary to a philosopher."

  "So the Zensunni assure us."

  "All mystics agree on it, Miles. Never underestimate the power of doubts. Very persuasive. S'tori holds up doubt and surety in a single hand."

  Really quite surprised, he asked: "Do Reverend Mothers practice Zensunni rituals?" He had never even suspected this before.

  "Just once," she said. "We achieve an exalted form of s'tori, total. It involves every cell."

  "The spice agony," he said.

  "I was sure your mother told you. Obviously, she never explained the affinity with the Zensunni."

  Teg swallowed past a lump in his throat. Fascinating! She gave him a new insight into the Bene Gesserit. This changed his entire concept, including his image of his own mother. They were removed from him into an unattainable place where he could never follow. They might think of him as a comrade on occasion but he could never enter the intimate circle. He could simulate, no more. He would never be like Maud'dib or the Tyrant.

  "Prescience," Taraza said.

  The word shifted his attention. She had changed the subject but not changed it.

  "I was thinking about Maud'dib," he said.

  "You think he predicted the future," she said.

  "That is the Mentat teaching."

  "I hear the doubt in your voice, Miles. Did he predict or did he create? Prescience can be deadly. The people who demand that the oracle predict for them really want to know next year's price on whalefur or something equally mundane. None of them wants an instant-by-instant prediction of his personal life."

  "No surprises," Teg said.

  "Exactly. If you possessed such fore-knowledge, your life would become an unutterable bore."

  "You think Maud'dib's life was a bore?"

  "And the Tyrant's, too. We think their entire lives were devoted to trying to break out of chains they themselves created."

  "But they believed... "

  "Remember your philosopher's doubts, Miles. Beware! The mind of the believer stagnates. It fails to grow outward into an unlimited, infinite universe."

  Teg sat silently for a moment. He sensed the fatigue that had been driven beyond his immediate awareness by the drink, sensed also the way his thoughts were roiled by the intrusion of new concepts. These were things that he had been taught would weaken a Mentat, yet he felt strengthened by them.

  She is teaching me, he thought. There is a lesson here.

  As though projected into his mind and outlined there in fire, he found his entire Mentat-attention fixated on the Zensunni admonition that was taught to every beginning student in the Mentat School:

  By your belief in granular singularities, you deny all movement-evolutionary or devolutionary. Belief fixes a granular universe and causes that universe to persist. Nothing can be allowed to change because that way your non-moving universe vanishes. But it moves of itself when you do not move. It evolves beyond you and is no longer accessible to you.

  "The oddest thing of all," Taraza said, sinking into tune with this mood she had created, "is that the scientists of Ix cannot see how much their own beliefs dominate their universe."

  Teg stared at her, silent and receptive.

  "Ixian beliefs are perfectly submissive to the choices they make on how they will look at their universe," Taraza said. "Their universe does not act of itself but performs according to the kinds of experiments they choose."

  With a start, Teg came out of the memories and awoke to find himself in the Gammu Keep. He still sat in the familiar chair in his workroom. A glance around the room showed nothing moved from where he had put it. Only a few minutes had passed but the room and its contents no longer were alien. He dipped into and out of Mentat mode. Restored.

  The smell and taste of the drink Taraza had given him so long ago still tingled on his tongue and in his nostrils. A Mentat blink and he knew he could call up the scene entire once more--the low light of shaded glowglobes, the feeling of the chair beneath him, the sounds of their voices. It was all there for replay, frozen into a time-capsule of isolated memory.

  Calling up that old memory created a magical universe where his abilities were amplified beyond his wildest expectations. No atoms existed in that magical universe, only waves and awesome movements all around. He was forced there to discard all barriers built of belief an
d understanding. This universe was transparent. He could see through it without any interfering screens upon which to project its forms. The magical universe reduced him to a core of active imagination where his own image-making abilities were the only screen upon which any projection might be sensed.

  There, I am both the performer and the performed!

  The workroom around Teg wavered into and out of his sensory reality. He felt his awareness constricted to its tightest purpose and yet that purpose filled his universe. He was open to infinity.

  Taraza did this deliberately! he thought. She has amplified me!

  A feeling of awe threatened him. He recognized how his daughter, Odrade, had drawn upon such powers to create the Atreides Manifesto for Taraza. His own Mentat powers were submerged in that greater pattern.

  Taraza was demanding a fearful performance from him. The need for such a thing both challenged and terrified him. It could very well mean the end of the Sisterhood.

  The basic rule is this: Never support weakness; always support strength.

  --The Bene Gesserit Coda

  "How is it that you can order the priests around?" Sheeana asked. "This is their place."

  Odrade answered casually but picked her words to fit the knowledge she knew Sheeana already possessed: "The priests have Fremen roots. They've always had Reverend Mothers somewhere near. Besides, child, you order them around, too."

  "That's different."

  Odrade suppressed a smile.

  Little more than three hours had passed since her assault force had broken the attack on the temple complex. In that time, Odrade had set up a command center in Sheeana's quarters, carried on the necessary business of assessment and preliminary retaliation, all the while prompting and observing Sheeana.

  Simulflow.

  Odrade glanced around the room she had chosen as command center. A scrap of Stiros' ripped garments still lay near the wall in front of her. Casualties. The room was an oddly shaped place. No two walls parallel. She sniffed. Still a residual smell of ozone from the snoopers with which her people had assured the privacy of these quarters.

  Why the odd shape? The building was ancient, remodeled and added to many times, but that did not explain this room. A pleasantly rough texture of creamy stucco on walls and ceiling. Elaborate spice-fiber hangings flanked the two doors. It was early evening and sunlight filtered by lattice shades stippled the wall opposite the windows. Silver-yellow glowglobes hovered near the ceiling, all tuned to match the sunlight. Muted street sounds came through the ventilators beneath the windows. The soft pattern of orange rugs and gray tiles on the floor spoke of wealth and security but Odrade suddenly did not feel secure.