The Spell of Four

by Casey Morgan

  Or would she go one at a time? That sounded like it would take a bit. I hoped I had a good game on my phone to pass the time. I was sure Aiden wouldn’t last a minute, but Killian – well, I’d probably have to go before him.

  I supposed that whatever happened, it would be up to the woman. And Mila seemed to want all of us. I began to resign myself to the thought that what Mila wanted, Mila would get – and that that was just as it should be.

  Chapter 18

  Mila

  For a moment, I was overwhelmed. This was the time that everything had been leading up to and I started to get butterflies in my stomach.

  Suddenly, all the sensible advice Shanna had given to me seemed far away and hard to remember.

  This was supposed to be easy, right?

  So why is it so hard?

  It was nothing compared to the curse of grief I’d been under. I was proud of myself for breaking the curse of loneliness but I still wasn’t sure how to enact the spell that would break the curse of grief. I had a feeling that moving further along with the elves would help me do that. I had to continue, even though it felt very hard.

  “Do you not want any of us?” asked Aiden. “Is that what you’re going to say?”

  That would be a solution, right? If I didn’t take all of them, I could dismiss them all and know that I changed nothing. They would all still be friends and I could go back home knowing that I didn’t upset the balance or break anyone’s heart more than the others.

  But what would I think on my deathbed?

  I’d always wonder, “What if?”

  In this life, you had to take chances.

  Maybe this wouldn’t work out. Maybe it was a dumb mistake. Maybe a group relationship is a horrible idea that strips individuals of their identity and creates toxic group dynamics. But when I looked at Brody, Ryan and Shanna, all I saw was love.

  No, I wouldn’t die on my deathbed with regrets. I had nothing to lose. I had to go forward. I had to take risks.

  “All,” I said. “Just as I said. I want all three of you. I still do.”

  “How’s that gonna work?” asked Donovan, sounding unsure. “Like, we switch nights and schedule it or…”

  “No, we’re a team,” I explained. “The four of us, in a relationship, together. What do you say?”

  “All right, I’m in,” said Killian. “We can go on some more dates and get to know one another better, I’m sure.”

  “Not exactly what I want,” she said. “While yes, I would love that, I’m only in town for a few weeks. I don’t want to waste a lot of time dating. Let’s jump right into this.”

  “What do you mean?” asked Aiden.

  “Take me. Now,” I said, surprising myself with my brazenness. “I want you. I want all three of you in bed, right now.”

  “Well, that’s a clear message,” laughed Donovan. “I like your boldness, lass.”

  “I suppose that makes sense,” said Killian. “I’m game.”

  “Whoa, really?” said Aiden, a little overwhelmed. “Well, I – Yeah. Okay.”

  We walked back to Donovan’s car in silence. It was a little awkward.

  “Are you guys okay?” I asked, suspiciously.

  “Aw, yeah, why?” asked Donovan.

  “Well, you all got so quiet,” I said.

  “Well, it’s just, ye know…” said Donovan, trailing off.

  “What?” I asked.

  “When a man gets a woman to agree to have sex with him, it’s best to keep his mouth shut lest he say something to break the mood,” explained Killian. “At least until we’re naked and such.”

  “Oh,” I said. “Guess that makes sense. Probably experienced that before, just noticed it more with three of you keeping quiet.”

  “Yeah,” agreed Aiden quietly.

  Donovan drove us to the Odells’ orchard and we walked into the quaint farm house.

  “Guys, I don’t want to give you the wrong impression,” I said. “I know I made a bold move and everything, talking you into this, but I really do adore you all. And I’m not easy or anything. This is something that’s very new to me.”

  “Yeah, yeah, okay,” said Donovan, opening the door.

  “Don’t think we’re not nervous, too,” admitted Aiden.

  “Speak for yourself,” said Donovan.

  He was trying to project a brave front, but I could tell he was nervous, too.

  “Whether we’re nervous or not, it’s fine,” I tried to assure everyone, including myself. I was very nervous. “This is new to us, but it’ll be alright.”

  “Good point,” Killian said.

  “I knew you would see it my way,” I joked.

  We walked inside and made our way to the bedroom. Donovan grabbed a bottle of apple whiskey and a bunch of glasses. We got inside the room and he poured everyone a shot.

  “Should we drink before sex?” asked Aiden.

  “Yes. You especially, lad,” said Donovan. “You should have some liquid courage.”

  We clinked glasses and did a shot. Donovan quickly did a second shot as he set the bottle aside.

  Killian took my jacket and bag and hung them on a closet door knob. This master bedroom had an old, four poster bed.

  Killian had the body language of an elf who knew what he was doing. He grabbed me by the waist and kissed me deeply. It was a long sensual kiss and a good start to tonight’s antics.

  “Nice,” I said, smiling at him.

  Now I went to the other end of the spectrum: Aiden. He was sweating a little. He wasn’t sure what to do and his hands were shaking. I thought it was cute.

  I took him by the hand and calmed him down with a smile. Then I gently kissed him.

  He stood up and took hold of me and then kissed me back, deeply. It was a little hard and a little sloppy, but that was okay. It was passionate, and it felt good. He moved to kiss me more, but I put a finger on his lips as to gesture for him to wait.

  Donovan was on his third shot and was beginning to smell like apple whiskey. When he saw me turning toward him, he suddenly got up, knocking over his empty shot glass and grabbing me.

  It was like being gently mauled by a loveable bear. He was so big, and strong. I could feel the roughness of his three day old beard and he smelled like a man who’d been working in an apple orchard all day.

  Throwing me onto the bed, Donovan started to take off his clothes. Aiden, not knowing what else to do, also started to get naked.

  Killian walked over to the side of the bed, kissed me again, then kissed me down my cleavage. He unbuttoned a few shirt buttons and then unbuckled my jeans. He pulled them down and then slid off my shoes.

  Donovan remembered something and moved over to a nightstand. He opened the drawer.

  “Lads, the condoms are in here,” he announced. “And luckily there are plenty of them.”

  He tossed one to Aiden, who looked grateful. Donovan offered Killian one.

  “Yes, yes,” said Killian, mildly annoyed. “I know what they are.”

  Donovan shrugged, then climbed up onto the bed. He was completely naked now.

  He unbuttoned my shirt the rest of the way and then took off my bra. He kissed me again, and this his tongue trailed down my neck and tickled my left nipple.

  Killian pulled my panties off and started kissing the inside of my thighs. He was really making me wait for it. I enjoyed having all three elves pay attention to me. I wanted all of them to make me feel good at once.

  I made eye contact with Aiden and waved him over. He awkwardly climbed onto the bed. I grabbed him by the back of the head and kissed him.

  Killian was now sticking a finger in and out of my pussy, which was starting to become very wet. He licked around my labia and teased the hood of my clit with his tongue.

  I was moaning into Aiden’s mouth with pleasure and enjoying Donovan as he played with my breast. Finally, I came up for air with Aiden.

  “Up on your knees,” I told him.

  He did as I’d commanded, which made
me feel a rush of power. Just as I had expected, he was rock hard.

  I grabbed him by the cock and pulled him over to me. I started sucking his dick, which was quite big.

  “Oh, my God,” he said in surprise. “Oh, my fucking God.”

  He came into my mouth, which I’d expected. He tried to pull away, but I kept my mouth locked onto it as he continued to jizz onto my tongue and down the back of my throat.

  There was something about his cum that tasted different. Maybe it was because he was an elf, but the taste was bold and strong and interesting.

  He slammed his hand on the back of the headboard, steadying himself as he shook and I drained every last drop out of his balls. I let him go and he collapsed on the bed, panting heavily.

  “Oh, my God,” he said again. “That was incredible. No wonder everyone wants to do this.”

  “Why did he get to go first?” complained Donovan.

  “Give it up, Donovan,” said Killian. “It’s the boy’s first time. Let him have his fun.”

  “Well, I’m ready to have mine, then,” he proclaimed.

  “Bring yourself over here,” I commanded.

  Donovan straddled my torso, so I pushed my tits together around his dick so he could titty fuck me. My boobs were already wet from his saliva.

  “Oooh, you like that?” he asked. “You’re such a naughty little witch. You like a bit of titty fuckin’, eh?”

  “Mmm, yeah,” I said, teasing the top of his cock with my tongue. “I love feeling your big elf dick on my titties. Fuck my titties.”

  At the same time that that was going on, Killian was sticking his tongue in and out of my pussy, while teasing my clit with his thumb. I was dripping my hot pussy juice directly into his mouth.

  It was hard to concentrate on which sensation I wanted to feel more, but the act of trying to feel both simultaneously was in and of itself an erotic moment. I was overloaded with sensation and attention from the boys.

  Killian stopped for a moment and then I felt him enter me with a condom on his dick. I was being titty fucked and pussy fucked at the same time. Aiden, who had been in a daze after his orgasm, finally recovered enough to look up.

  “Holy shit,” I heard him mutter.

  “Yes. Yes. Yes,” I said, with every thrust.

  I stopped Donovan and pulled him closer to me. I ran my tongue up from his balls to the base of his shaft, then up the shaft to the head.

  “Fuck me,” he gasped.

  His smell made me so hot. He smelled like outdoors: like hazelnut, apples, beer and earth. I put one of each of his balls in my mouth.

  “Oh, God. I’m about to cum,” he moaned.

  I had just enough time to get the top of his cock back in my mouth. He exploded against my cheek, firing his jism into my lips and mouth. It filled up one side of my cheek and I was sucking and swallowing the hot load as fast as I could.

  “Ahhh. Ahhh,” moaned Donovan. “Sweet Jesus. That’s hot.”

  Moaning on his cock, I could still feel Killian fucking me. The length of his cock penetrated me deeply.

  It was wonderful, feeling him against my walls. I was cumming on his shaft and I could feel the condom fill up with his seed. The warm sensation sent me over the top and I was vibrating inside.

  “Oh, God. Yes,” said Killian, cumming. “Oh, God. Oh, God.”

  We stayed there a moment, panting and enjoying the post-orgasm quakes.

  “That was fun,” said Aiden. “Is anyone else thirsty?”

  “You think that’s it?” I said. “Oh, we’re not finished, boyo.”

  “We’re not?” he smiled.

  “Oh, no,” I laughed. “Not by a long shot.”

  Donovan had gotten off of me and retrieved the bottle. He started to pour again.

  “Speaking of shots,” he laughed.

  Killian rushed off to the bathroom to dispose of his condom.

  “Would it be okay if we did it together?” asked Aiden. “You know, just me and you, once?”

  “The lad’s got stamina,” laughed Donovan. “I’ll drink to that.”

  “Sure, babe,” I smiled. “Come here.”

  Aiden and I kissed and hugged. It was his moment. He felt my tits and I could feel his hard cock against my leg. He fumbled with the condom, but got it on and then prepared to enter me.

  “Slowly,” I advised.

  He did as I asked. Aiden’s cock was a really nice size and I moaned as he pushed in.

  “Are you okay?” he asked.

  “Yeah,” I gasped. “In and out, that’s it. Your cock feels so good, Aiden.”

  That really got him going. I could feel him getting even harder inside me. I spread my legs as far as I could, and he went balls deep inside me, again and again.

  “Grab me by the back of the knees. That’s it,” I encouraged.

  He did as I asked. I started gushing onto his cock. I loved to have my legs held into the air as a guy fucked me.

  Aiden had that energy. He had either hand on the bed on either side of me. His sweat dripped onto my body as he pumped and pumped.

  “That’s it, baby. That’s it,” I squealed.

  “Ooooh. Oh, God. Shit. Uhn.”

  He fell forward on top of me. Our sweat intermingled as he came inside the condom. Oh, God, the sensation was incredible.

  I couldn’t stop cumming. I just moaned and squirmed on the bed, which made it even hotter for both of us. He laid on top of me for a moment, breathing heavily.

  “That’s it,” I panted, patting him on the head. “Good job. Now, pull out nice and slow and try not to spill the condom.”

  Aiden did as I asked and the sensation going out was almost as good as the one coming in. I shivered in delight and he rushed off to the bathroom to clean up.

  “I’ve got to admit,” said Donovan, who was sitting nearby with another erection. “Watching that was pretty hot. I think I definitely could get used to this.”

  “You ready for a little back door play?” asked Killian, hopefully.

  “First, I have to loosen things up,” I said. “Hand me my purse.”

  He did and I routed around and pulled out my butt plug. It was just one of the many toys I had brought on the trip. If I didn’t meet anyone, I had to get myself off so I could go to sleep. I had quite the sex drive, probably more so than that of a man.

  “What’s that?” asked Aiden.

  “Butt plug,” I explained. “Gets you ready for butt stuff.”

  I pulled out the lube and lubed it up.

  “Who would like to do the honors?” I asked.

  “Give it here,” said Killian. “Nice and slow, eh?”

  Killian started to push on it. I could feel my asshole expanding. It felt good.

  “Mmm, that’s it. Push it all the way in,” I instructed.

  He did so and now it was completely in my butt.

  “Okay, now get over here and fuck me,” I instructed.

  Donovan did another shot. I had lost count of how many he had had, but he still had a raging hard on.

  He slid a condom on with one hand and grabbed me from behind. He started to tease my pussy with his cock. I could feel the reservoir tip tickling my hole. Killian ran around to the other side of the bed and presented his growing penis to me.

  “Mmm, who is this?” I said hungrily.

  “Mr. Johnson,” he said playfully. “He would like a word with you, young lady.”

  I stroked him as Donovan continued to play with my pussy. Then I teased Killian with my tongue and licked my lips. I kissed and played with his cock, watching it get harder.

  I was also moaning because Donovan was driving me crazy with his teasing. I wanted his fat cock inside me, but he was making me wait. The anticipation was a bit maddening.

  Finally, just as I started to suck Killian’s dick, Donovan penetrated my waiting hole.

  His whole body pushed against the butt plug, adding an additional sensation. His cock was definitely the fattest and I could feel my walls stretching. I
moaned on Killian’s shaft and he could feel the vibrations of my mouth and tongue on him.

  “Jesus-Mary-and-Joseph,” exclaimed Killian. “That’s wonderful, Mila.”

  Killian grabbed the sides of my head and I suppressed my gag reflex. The boys were now fucking me simultaneously in both of my holes. It was incredible.

  It was everything Shanna had said it was and more. I was in a constant state of cumming at this point. Water was pouring out of my pussy like a waterfall and running down Donovan’s legs.

  Donovan grabbed my buttocks with his big, knobly, elf hands and pulled me into him with every thrust.

  “Yeah. You like that? Aw, yeah. Fuck,” he said. “I love your pussy. It’s like manna from Heaven. I could fuck it all night long. Aw, yeah.”

  The slap of his body against my ass pushed the butt plug deeper into me. I could feel it making my gaping ass just a little bigger.

  I couldn’t wait to replace it with a cock. Killian was now reaching climax, as I kept my mouth open.

  I was slobbering everywhere, letting the saliva run all over his dick and down my chin. He finally erupted.

  “Oh. Oooooh,” he moaned.

  Hot gobs of his cum filled my throat and I gagged a little. Some of it ran down the corners of my mouth as I tried to swallow it all.

  Donovan’s constant ravaging of my pussy with his fat cock was making it impossible for me not to get a good grip on it. Killian’s dick slid out of my mouth and his cum squirted on my boob and left shoulder.

  “Uhn. Uhn. Uhn,” were Donovan’s only words now – if you could call them “words”.

  He was nearing the end. I could feel it welling up inside his cock as the blood pumped and the veins expanded.

  The bumps on the side of his shaft made every penetration a new sensation. Killian’s cum ran down my face as I tried to swallow it, but I could only moan in pleasure with my mouth open.

  “Yes. Yes. Fuck me, Donovan. Cum deep inside meeeeeee.”

  I was so overcome, I was almost crying. My insides were vibrating like every cell in my body had been super energized.

  At that moment, I never felt so alive. I could feel Donovan’s condom fill with his hot load and the feeling made my eyes roll back in my head.