Fourth Rite: A Reverse Harem Tale (Lovin' the Coven Book 4)

by Jacquelyn Faye

  Shea lifted his eyes, but not his head, flashing me another of those shy smiles that made me question my sexuality at that moment. He was way too beautiful to be a guy. I kind of wanted to see what he looked like in a dress. Maybe some of Dot's leggings. Or a bikini. My cock went from stiffening to rigid with that smile and looked over at Dot. She stabbed herself in the mouth with her fork.

  "You okay?"

  "Yes?" She asked innocently. Too innocently.

  I narrowed my eyes, trying to read her. She was avoiding looking at Shea. She had noticed my discomfort and was completely mesmerized by it. "You missed your mouth." I gave her the opening for the innuendo bus to pull out of the garage.

  "Boy, if I had a dime for every time someone told me that…"

  She took it. She was turned on. If she hadn't, she would have gone for the innocent reply.

  Shea choked on a noodle. At least he had caught it.

  "What's the matter, Sheamus? Something get stuck in your throat?" I wanted to judge his reaction, too. The night might have just gotten infinitely more interesting. My cock throbbed in my pants.

  I might have dreamed of Shea. But I'd never wanted to do anything with another guy. A few times, in my younger days, I'd been involved in a couple of threesomes… Mostly with multiple women. One time, Dennis and I had fooled around with a girl from high school at the same time. She wasn't up for the old double penetration, but that didn't stop us from each taking opposite ends. One time, the opportunity did present itself. Jared, another fireman, had invited me to his house for dinner. It had ended up a drink fest and he shared his wife with me. She rode me and I had gotten the surprise of my life when he slipped inside her ass, standing over me. It had been one of the most erotic experiences of my life. The thought of sharing Dot with Shea…

  Shea set his wine down after washing away the noodle. "It is dangerous to eat around you both," he rasped.

  "Yep. Dot's appetites can quickly shift from the food to those around her."

  She swatted me in the arm and blushed.

  "But to be devoured by her…" Shea closed his eyes and a small smile spread across his face.

  "Yeah. It's wonderful," I told him.

  He lowered his head, but was still staring at her under his long lashes.

  "Is it getting hot in here, or is it just me?" Dot even fanned herself.

  "That is the effect of the wine. It is made to warm you on the coldest of days, igniting your internal fires."

  "You brought…aphrodisiac wine?" She looked almost afraid.

  "No. It is made for travelling."

  "Oh."

  "I thought it an auspicious start to our journey."

  "Oh." She was repeating herself. Things were about to get more interesting.

  "Why? Are you feeling…" I almost laughed as he looked at her expectantly. He delivered the death stroke. Best wingman in history!

  "No. Maybe. My fires are definitely kindled." She shifted in her seat. The sure sign that she was getting turned on. I could almost picture the wet spot on the front of her leggings. Lady, I love this woman!

  I chuckled softly, leaning back to watch the show, and put my hands behind my head. "Maybe it's not the wine, but the company."

  "Maybe," she answered, taking another bite and looking everywhere but at us.

  "Maybe you should lie down? Or step outside to cool off?" Shea offered her a means of escape. The fool.

  "Yeah. Maybe," Dot answered, taking her wine and heading for the bedroom.

  I wanted her hot, but not drunk. "Maybe you shouldn't finish that," I said worriedly, reaching for it.

  "I'm okay. Just a little…"

  "Okay." I stood up, just to make sure she didn't fall, and helped her to the bedroom.

  "Thanks," she gave me a smile.

  "I'll go clean up the kitchen."

  "You don't have to."

  "Don't worry. I'll send Shea in to keep an eye on you."

  Her eyes narrowed. She saw through me in an instant. She was the only woman who ever had or could and it made me love her that much more. Because she knew and still agreed.

  "Don't trust me?" I flashed her a grin to let her know I knew I'd been caught.

  "Would you trust you?"

  I reached down and slid my hand up under her shirt, letting the heat of my hand ignite her skin as I made lazy circles over her stomach. "With you? Yes."

  "That was the best answer, ever." She smiled.

  "You want him. Take him."

  "I don't have to. He's already mine. Just like you."

  "Forever and a day," I told her, meaning every word.

  She reached up and grabbed my neck, pulling me in for a kiss. I knew if I let her, she would have pulled me down on top of her and the fun would have started prematurely. I forcibly kept it slow, soft and delicate, just to build her frustration. That was the key of getting her over her inhibitions. She shouldn’t have them. Not her.

  I just needed to stoke her fires a little more. I slid my hand up higher, lightly grazing her nipple.

  "Why are you teasing me?" Her voice cracked. She was ready.

  "Because I am leaving the room. I want you to devour him and really make him yours."

  "But I want you, too," she practically whimpered.

  "Oh, don't worry. I'll be back." I meant it. Every word. I pinched her nipple. "Shea, Dot wants you," I called over my shoulder. "Have fun," I whispered to my Dot, letting my tongue flick over her lips.

  I handed her the rest of her wine. The heat inside her had burned away the effects of what she already had and she might need a little bit more courage. She gulped it down, stared at it for a fraction of a second. "Jimmy?"

  "Yes?"

  "Hurry."

  "Yes, ma'am," I answered with a little chuckle, heading for the kitchen.

  I gently touched Shea's shoulder in passing, giving him a bit of fair warning.

  I abhorred doing dishes, but with the dessert that I was about to feast upon, I did them in record time. Dar reaped the benefits of the uneaten portions of our dinner and he gazed at me lovingly. "You're welcome, Dar."

  Walking over to the table, I sat and slowly sipped the rest of my wine, trying to judge the atmosphere and the sounds coming from the bedroom to time my return. It wasn't anything but my inability to stay away a moment longer that finally drove me to the door.

  Shea was sitting on Dot's chest, completely naked, hair freely flowing down to his waist. I was shocked to literally see him covered in tattoos. My second shock was that, completely naked, he could never be mistaken for a woman. His shoulders were too broad, his hips too narrow. I may have even been expecting to see tiny breasts and almost sighed in disappointment as I caught a glimpse of his chest as he bent over to kiss her. As he threw his head back, I knew she had his cock in her mouth. It was so hot, I couldn't stop myself, I took off my shirt, pulled my cock out of the front of my pants, and began lazily stroking it.

  "Where do you want to come, Shea?" She asked him. "Do you want to explode in my mouth? Or do you want to come inside of me, Shea? Do you want to plunge this inside me and fill me?"

  He groaned, unable to form the words.

  I answered for him. "Why not both?"

  Dot leaned over and saw me stroking myself in her doorway. "That's a damn good idea, Jimmy." She looked up at him. "Do you think you can do that? Can you come for me twice, Shea?"

  "I could come a thousand times if you keep looking at me like that."

  "That's a damn good answer."

  "It is the truth."

  "Is it all right if Jimmy joins us? He was practically begging earlier," she said to tease me.

  "I do not mind."

  My cock surged and I had to stop myself from coming, not before a little leaked out of the tip and fell to the floor. I kept myself there, at the edge as he knelt over her and fed his cock into her mouth. I was almost jealous…of her.

  I almost yelled, "No," when he pulled himself from her mouth and used the tip to tease her nipples. Invo
luntarily, her hips began lifting off the bed as he continued to tease her.

  It was time for me to join in. I crossed the empty space between us and reached down, grabbing the waist of her leggings and pulling them down over her legs, nearly groaning as her pussy became exposed to my eyes. I had never told her, but her patch of red hair drove me absolutely insane with desire.

  As I lowered myself to her, I don't know what came over me, but my lips found Shea's spine and planted three gentle kisses on my way down. That shocked me more than anything, and I had to fight the urge to let my tongue drift over his skin. I needed a distraction and found it between Dot's wet lips as I plunged my tongue inside her, drinking in her wetness.

  Her hips began bucking against my mouth as she pleasured Shea with hers. He looked over his shoulder at me pleasing our Lady. "As it should be."

  "It should?" I heard Dot's quivering voice.

  "Yes. You are our Lady. You should have multiple men surrounding you, pleasuring you in every way possible."

  She shuddered. "Brilliant and sexy," she said to him.

  "The view is good from back here, too." I called out, not lying. Shea's ass… Dot's pussy. They were equally as beautiful.

  "Less talkie talkie, more lickey lickey." She bucked her hips impatiently.

  I sucked her clit into my mouth and let my tongue undulate against it. She began moaning and must have been pleasuring Shea with each moan. He began to roll his hips in tempo.

  "I cannot hold out any longer…" You could practically hear the orgasm coming from his voice.

  I doubled my efforts with my tongue, wanting her to come at the same time. And she did. Tenfold.

  "Jimmy…" Her voice became a throaty chuckle as I refused to relent until she was happy.

  Giving her a gentle kiss, I pulled away.

  "Lady, that was amazing."

  "Yes. Yes, it was."

  He groaned a little more and I knew she was teasing him. My cock had leaked all over the bed, and I was lying in a very wet spot, not caring in the least, and resting my head against her leg.

  "You…um. You taste good," she told Shea.

  "Thank you?" He slid off her, over the edge of the bed. I grinned at her, my mouth nearly touching her pussy.

  "Did you have fun?"

  I nodded in answer. Her face and neck were splattered with Shea's come. My grin washed away as curiosity took hold.

  "You want a kiss?" She cocked an eyebrow as she asked. Almost as if she knew.

  I nodded. It was all I could do. I wanted to taste his come on her lips.

  "Come here."

  I got up and crawled over her, mashing my lips against hers and letting my tongue taste him in her mouth. It was more erotic, sexy, and right than I'd imagined. Sighing happily, I pulled away. "It's all over you," I whispered. "You're covered in his come."

  "It doesn’t bother you at all, does it."

  "No. It's hot."

  "And sweet for some reason."

  I had only gotten a hint of flavor from our kiss. I found myself wanting more. There was a large glob of it on her chin and I flicked my tongue out, scooping it off her and kissing her again, letting his seed play between our tongues.

  While we shared that kiss, I lifted my hips, letting my cock align with her entrance and thrusting myself inside her. She enveloped me with more heat, more wetness than I had ever thought possible.

  My name became unintelligible syllables as I began thrusting in her, fucking her with a need that almost scared me. I wanted her, but more than that, I wanted to explode inside her.

  She pulled away from the kiss, eyes rolling in pleasure until she spotted Shea stroking himself beside her. She reached out and cupped his balls, rolling them gently between her fingers.

  "Goddess…"

  "Do you like that?" She asked him.

  "Yes."

  She used his soft flesh to pull him closer. His cock was barely inches from our faces. "That's hot, isn't it?" She was asking me, but never taking her eyes from him. Neither was I. All I could do was nod.

  "Do you want to touch it?"

  A million thoughts raced through my brain. The one that emerged victorious was, "Yes! Fuck yes." I gave a smaller nod, not wanting to seem too enthusiastic.

  "Shea, can Jimmy touch you?"

  "Please," he whimpered causing Dot to spasm around my cock.

  "Go ahead, Jimmy. He shouldn't be jerking himself off when there are two other people in the room."

  And just like that, she made up my mind for me. I'd have to thank her later. She'd have to settle for a kiss for now.

  I reached out, my hand practically trembling as it was about to wrap itself around another man's cock. There was no denying it. He was definitely a man. And his skin felt smoother in my hand than mine did. My hand practically glided over the velvety smoothness of it.

  "First time? Are you really sure about that, Jimmy?" Dot teased me, and it turned me on even more.

  "Um. I've done this a billion times…just never to anyone else. I swear. If I'd ever done this before, I would have told you about it a long time ago," I told her and meant it. It was hot.

  "Fair. I would have been fascinated by it, too. I probably would have come twenty time just from the story alone."

  "This turns you on that much?" I asked, but I already knew the answer. The hunger in her eyes, the wetness of her pussy, gave it all away.

  "You have no idea." She was practically quivering, watching me stroke Shea.

  "What about this, then?" I watched her face as I pulled Shea closer, not stopping to think about what I was about to do. Sparing Shea a glance, I wanted his permission, and he understood, giving me a small nod. Flicking my tongue out, I let my tongue catch the drops of moisture leaking from his tip and then pulled the tip of him into my mouth.

  Dot went absolutely wild, spasming beneath me. I'd have to admit, I did too. Between having a cock in my mouth and Dot's pussy squeezing my own, I erupted into her as I sucked Shea into my mouth as far as I could. I let my orgasm flow through me as his cock twitched in my mouth.

  When I finished emptying myself inside her, Shea reached down and ran his fingers through my hair in thanks. I was just sad he hadn't come with us, but I let him go. I had better plans.

  I kissed Dot, reached under her, and rolled us over. "You want in on this?" I grinned up at my new partner in crime.

  "I do not understand."

  "I want you to fuck her while I hold her," I told him.

  "But… Aren't you still inside her?"

  "Yep."

  "Jimmy?"

  "It's up to Shea. Not me. I was asking him if he wanted to."

  "I've never had anything in my ass before." She sounded almost worried.

  "Who said anything about your ass?"

  "Wait." She stopped to think about it. "You want him to stick his dick inside me with yours already in there?"

  "Yeah."

  "Okay." She didn't bat an eyelash, seaming almost eager. "I'm game if Shea is."

  "Lady?"

  She nodded and gave him a sultry look. My cock, still inside her, hadn't really gone soft but surged back to attention. Looking back up at Shea, I nearly laughed at the smile on his face. "Only if you want to," she said one last time.

  "Oh, I do and do not need to be asked again."

  I spread my legs, and Dot did the same, giving Shea a place to kneel between them. "I love you," I told her as she stared at me lovingly.

  "You sucked a cock for me. I love you more."

  I couldn't, wouldn’t lie to her. "Might have sucked it a little bit for me, too. Kinda always wondered," I said, finally admitting the truth. Even to myself.

  "Did you like it?"

  "Wait a minute. I sucked a cock for you. I get to love you more."

  "I might have said yes, but you said you liked it, so it doesn't count. I love you more."

  And then we were both rendered unable to speak as we both felt Shea's cock nudge Dot's entrance, just above my cock.

&nb
sp; "Go slow. I don't know if you're both going to fit in there."

  Luckily, I had exploded inside her. The abundance of lubrication made it almost easy for him to slide inside, his cock rubbing against mine until his balls touched mine. He displaced my semen and it practically poured out of her, landing on me and it kind of turned me on more. If that was even possible.

  Dot had noticed. "Now you know how I feel."

  "Happy?"

  She nodded, smiling. "Full."

  "Feels good, doesn't it?" I asked her.

  "Yes. How are you still hard?"

  "Um… This is like the fucking hottest thing ever? I'm probably going to have an erection that lasts more than four hours. I'll probably have to consult a physician."

  "Or I could just continue to take care of them for you."

  I groaned as I pushed myself even further inside of her. When I did, Shea pulled out. He knew what he was doing, and the thought surprised me. He was far from innocent. How far, I would have to determine later. When I could think clearly. Between her pussy and his cock, this wasn't going to last much longer.

  "Oh, my Lady. Holy fuck." Dot was grunting as we seesawed inside her.

  "Not going to last long."

  "What? You literally just came."

  "His cock…it's sliding against mine. The undersides… It feels too good."

  She turned around to look at Shea. As soon as she did, the orgasm hit her like a truck. She started panting, unable to even make sounds as she lowered her head next to mine, breathed into my neck, and lost consciousness for a moment. Shea slowed his movements.

  "Welcome back," I told her as she looked up at me dreamily. She clenched around me, almost triggering my orgasm. "Stop that. You're going to make me come."

  "Stop what?" She asked with a grin, purposely clenching her insides around us.

  "That!"

  "You mean this?" Clench.

  "Shea! Damn the torpedoes, full steam ahead!"

  "Aye, Cap'n."

  And we pounded her into submission, his in to my out as we pummeled her with our cocks. She came again. Another time after that, until she lowered her head to my shoulder and just rode the pleasure. Shea called out and I felt him splash over me, just increasing the wetness flowing from her all over me. It was that wet heat that enveloped us that sent me over the edge into blackness…