El Alamein
Page 40
35. Quoted in Paul B. Baker, Yeoman Yeoman: The Warwickshire Yeomanry, 1920–1956 (Birmingham: Regimental Association, 1971), pp.56–57.
36. Bolitho, The Galloping Third, p.278.
37. Mick Collins, ‘One Man’s War’, 92/1/1, IWM Documents.
38. Mick Collins, ‘One Man’s War’, 92/1/1, IWM Documents.
39. Private papers of A.D.R. Wingfield, PP/MCR/353, IWM Documents.
40. Currie, disregarding the risk, was sat on top of his tank. Calling Grosvenor to join him, he informed him, ‘Well, we’ve made a gap in the enemy anti-tank screen, and your brigade has to pass through, and pass through bloody quick’. Grosvenor replied, ‘I have never seen anything, sir, that looks less like a gap’. This story appears in C.E. Lucas Phillips, Alamein (London: Pan Books, 1965), p.293. However, it does not claim to be based on a personal experience account and may well be an imagined conversation. Nevertheless, it’s a good story!
41. Private papers of A.D.R. Wingfield, PP/MCR/353, IWM Documents.
42. Private papers of A.D.R. Wingfield, PP/MCR/353, IWM Documents.
43. Private papers of A.D.R. Wingfield, PP/MCR/353, IWM Documents.
44. Quoted in Bernd Hartmann, Panzers in the Sand Volume Two 1942–45: The History of the Panzer-Regiment 5 (Barnsley: Pen & Sword, 2011), p.62.
45. Quoted in Hartmann, Panzers in the Sand Volume Two, p.62.
46. B.H. Liddell Hart [ed.], The Rommel Papers (New York: Da Capo Press, 1953), p.318.
47. Liddell Hart [ed.], The Rommel Papers, p.318.
48. Figures quoted on the Axis History Forum http://forum.axishistory.com/ and transcribed from records held by the US National Archives and Records Administration (from National Archives Microfilm Publication T313 Records of German Field Commands: Panzer Armies, Reels 467,470, 471) suggest the two armoured divisions had a total of only eleven Mark IVs of this type available on 1 November. My thanks to the members of this forum for the very useful material they have published across various threads.
49. Arthur Reddish, El Alamein: A Tank Soldier’s Story (Wanganui, New Zealand: Wanganui Newspapers, 1992), p.27.
50. Reddish, El Alamein: A Tank Soldier’s Story, p.23.
51. Reddish, El Alamein: A Tank Soldier’s Story, pp.27–28.
52. OH, Vol. IV, p.67.
53. Leo Harry Lyon interview, 22335, IWM Sound Archive.
54. OH, Vol. IV, p.69.
55. Martin Kitchen, Rommel’s Desert War: Waging World War II in North Africa, 1941–1943 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009), pp. 339–40; Liddell Hart [ed.], The Rommel Papers, pp.318–19.
56. Kitchen, Rommel’s Desert War, p.341; OH, Vol. IV, p.68 [fn] and p.69; Niall Barr, Pendulum of War: The Three Battles of El Alamein (London: Pimlico 2005), p.392.
57. OH, Vol. IV, Appendix 3(a) Rommel to OKW, No. 135/42, 19.50 [German Time], 2November.
58. Barr, Pendulum of War, p.391 and Ronald Lewin, The Life and Death of the Afrika Korps: A Biography (Barnsley: Pen and Sword, 2003), p.173.
59. Alex Danchev and Daniel Todman (eds) Field Marshal Lord Alanbrooke: War Diaries, 1939–1945 (London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson, 2001) [henceforth Alanbrooke War Diaries], p.332. By ‘GHQ’, Brooke was referring to the German High Command.
60. Private papers of D.A. Main, 87/35/1, IWM Documents.
61. OH, Vol. IV, p.70.
62. Private papers of D.A. Main, 87/35/1, IWM Documents.
63. Private papers of D.A. Main, 87/35/1, IWM Documents.
64. Private papers of D.A. Main, 87/35/1, IWM Documents.
65. Private papers of D.A. Main, 87/35/1, IWM Documents.
66. Private papers of D.A. Main, 87/35/1, IWM Documents.
67. R.H.W.S. Hastings, The Rifle Brigade In The Second World War 1939–1945 (Aldershot: Gale & Polden, 1950), p.160.
68. Barr makes the valuable point that losses were almost as heavy as those in the action at ‘Snipe’ on 27–28 October. Barr, Pendulum of War, p.394.
69. Keith Douglas, Alamein to Zem Zem (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1979), p.26.
70. Reddish, El Alamein: A Tank Soldier’s Story, pp.27–28.
71. Private papers of A.D.R. Wingfield, PP/MCR/353, IWM Documents.
72. Lieutenant A.L. Deans, RTR, ’Report on Special Tank Squadron attached to 7th Motor Brigade from 20th Oct to 4th Nov 1942’, 8 December 1942, in private papers of Lieutenant A. L. Deans, 73/211/1, IWM Documents.
73. Private papers of A.D.R. Wingfield, PP/MCR/353, IWM Documents.
74. OH, Vol. IV, p.71.
75. Liddell Hart [ed.], The Rommel Papers, pp.320–21.
76. The full text of Hitler’s order is in Liddell Hart [ed.], The Rommel Papers, p.321 [fn].
77. Barr, Pendulum of War, p.399. Mussolini’s message is in OH, Vol. IV, Appendix 3, p.476.
78. Arrangements had previously been made for 90. leichte-Afrika-Division to assist in the withdrawal of 164. leichte Afrika-Division.
79. Private papers of D.N. Wimberley, PP/MCR/182, IWM Documents.
80. OH, Vol. IV, p.75.
81. Private papers of D.N. Wimberley, PP/MCR/182, IWM Documents.
82. OH, Vol. IV, p.75.
83. Sir Francis Tuker, Approach to Battle: A Commentary – Eighth Army, November 1941 to May 1943 (London: Cassell, 1963), p.254.
84. Private papers of A.D.R. Wingfield, PP/MCR/353, IWM Documents.
85. Nila Kanten interview, 18391, IWM Sound Archive.
86. Private papers of A.D.R. Wingfield, PP/MCR/353, IWM Documents. Captain Allen Grant Singer was the adopted son of the philanthropist Washington Singer, and Master of Foxhounds with the Hursley Hunt in Hampshire between 1936 and 1940. Sadly, he was killed on 5 November. This account contradicts suggestions that Thoma was cowering in a foxhole when captured. Wolf Heckmann, Rommel’s War in Africa (London: Granada, 1981), pp. 480–81.
87. Carol Mather interview, 19629, IWM Sound Archive.
88. Private papers of M.E. Parker, 88/4/1, IWM Documents. Parker commanded 257 Anti-Tank Battery, 65th (Norfolk Yeomanry) Anti-Tank Regiment, RA.
89. Antonio Tomba, Sabbia e reticolati. Dal diario di un carrista dell'Ariete in Africa settentrionale (Roma: Italia Editrice New, 2008).
90. Quoted in Hartmann, Panzers in the Sand Volume Two, p.63. Selmayr became Regimentsarzt on 3 November.
91. Hans von Luck, Panzer Commander: The Memoirs of Colonel Hans von Luck (London: Cassell, 2002), p.118.
92. G.P.B. Roberts, From the Desert to the Baltic (London: William Kimber, 1987), p.119.
93. Private papers of J.W. York, PP/MCR/97, IWM Documents.
94. Danchev and Todman (eds) Alanbrooke War Diaries, p.338.
95. Danchev and Todman (eds) Alanbrooke War Diaries, p.338.
96. This analysis draws on Kitchen, Rommel’s Desert War, pp.344–51.
97. Emilio Pulini interview, 2924, IWM Sound Archive.
98. Gervase Markham interview, 16716, IWM Sound Archive.
99. Nevill Howell interview, 20937, IWM Sound Archive.
100. Hans von Luck, Panzer Commander: The Memoirs of Colonel Hans von Luck (London: Cassell, 2002), p.119.
101. Barr, Pendulum of War, p.407.
102. Barr, Pendulum of War, pp.402–03.
103. According to Lieutenant-Colonel William Watson of 6 DLI, Brigadier Jocelyn Percy of 151st Brigade was dismissed by Lieutenant-General Oliver Leese shortly after the battle for failing to provide adequate motor transport for his brigade in the pursuit.
104. OH, Vol. IV, p.89.
105. Private papers of Brigadier G.M.O. Davy CBE DSO, PP/MCR/143, IWM Documents. Brigadier George Davy was Director of Military Operations, Middle East General Headquarters and strongly critical of Montgomery for his caution in operation immediately after Alamein.
106. OH, Vol. IV, p.95.
107. Private papers of C.W.K. Potts, Con Shelf & 92/28/1, IWM Documents.
CONCLUSION
1. Jonathan Fennell, Combat and Morale in the North African Campaign: The Eighth Army and the Pa
th to El Alamein (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011), p.9.
2. Tom Bird to The Times, 27 September 2001. I am extremely grateful to Tom’s son, Nicky Bird, for bringing this letter to my attention and to Tom and Nicky for permission to quote from it.
3. Howard Kippenberger, Infantry Brigadier (London: Geoffrey Cumberledge, 1949), p.190.
4. B.H. Liddell Hart [ed.], The Rommel Papers (New York: Da Capo Press, 1953), p.325.
5. Kippenberger, Infantry Brigadier, p.190.
6. Private papers of C.W.K. Potts, Con Shelf & 92/28/1, IWM Documents.
7. Private papers of C.W.K. Potts, Con Shelf & 92/28/1, IWM Documents.
8. Gervase Markham interview, 16716, IWM Sound Archive.
9. Frank Devaney interview, 2699, IWM Sound Archive.
10. Frank Devaney interview, 2699, IWM Sound Archive.
11. Private Papers of J E Brooks, 84/13/1, IWM Documents.
SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHY
Agar-Hamilton, J.A.I., and L.C.F. Turner, Crisis in the Desert May–July 1942 (Cape Town: Oxford University Press, 1952)
Barr, Niall, Pendulum of War: The Three Battles of El Alamein (London: Pimlico 2005)
Barnett, Corelli, The Desert Generals (London: Phoenix, 1999)
Behrendt, Hans-Otto, Rommel’s Intelligence in the Desert Campaign, 1941–1943 (London: William Kimber, 1985)
Churchill, Winston S., The Hinge of Fate (London: Cassell, 1954)
John Connell, Auchinleck: A Critical Biography (London: Cassell, 1959)
van Creveld, Martin L., Supplying War: Logistics from Wallenstein to Patton (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004)
Danchev, Alex and Daniel Todman (eds), Field Marshal Lord Alanbrooke: War Diaries, 1939–1945 (London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson, 2001)
Fennell, Jonathan, Combat and Morale in the North African Campaign: The Eighth Army and the Path to El Alamein (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011)
French, David, Raising Churchill’s Army: The British Army and the War Against Germany 1919–1945 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000)
Hamilton, Nigel, Monty: The Making of a General, 1887–1942 (Feltham, Middlesex: Hamlyn, 1981)
Hamilton, Stuart MC, Armoured Odyssey: 8th Royal Tank Regiment in the Western Desert, 1941–42, Palestine, Syria, Egypt, 1943–44, Italy, 1944–45 (London: Tom Donovan, 1995)
Hartmann, Bernd, Panzers in the Sand Volume Two 1942–45: The History of the Panzer-Regiment 5 (Barnsley: Pen & Sword, 2011)
Kesselring, Albert, The Memoirs of Field-Marshal Kesselring (London: Greenhill, 2007)
Kippenberger, Howard, Infantry Brigadier (London: Geoffrey Cumberledge, 1949)
Kitchen, Martin, Rommel’s Desert War: Waging World War II in North Africa, 1941–1943 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009)
Liddell Hart, Basil (ed.), The Rommel Papers (New York: Da Capo Press, 1953)
Liddell Hart, Basil, Fritz Bayerlein and G.P.B. Roberts, A Battle Report: Alam Halfa (Quantico, Virginia: US Marine Corps Association, 1956)
Lucas, James, War in the Desert: The Eighth Army at El Alamein (London: Arms & Armour, 1982)
Maughan, Barton, Australia in the War of 1939–1945: Volume III – Tobruk and El Alamein (Canberra: Australian War Memorial, 1966)
von Mellenthin, F.W., Panzer Battles (London: Futura, 1977)
Montgomery, B.L., The Memoirs of Field-Marshal Montgomery (London: Fontana, 1960)
Murphy, W.E., Official History of New Zealand in the Second World War 1939–1945: 2nd New Zealand Divisional Artillery (Wellington: NZ Historical Publications Branch, 1966)
Orange, Vincent, Coningham: A Biography of Air Marshal Sir Arthur Coningham KCB, KBE, DSO, MC, DFC, AFC (Washington: Center for Air Force History, 1992)
Phillips, C.E. Lucas, Alamein (London: Pan Books, 1965)
Playfair, I.S.O., The Mediterranean and Middle East, Volume III: British Fortunes Reach Their Lowest Ebb (London: HMSO, 1960 [Repr. Naval & Military Press, 2004])
Playfair, I.S.O., The Mediterranean and Middle East, Volume IV: The Destruction of the Axis Forces in Africa (London: HMSO, 1966 [Repr. Naval & Military Press, 2004])
Reddish, Arthur, El Alamein: A Tank Soldier’s Story (Wanganui, New Zealand: Wanganui Newspapers, 1992)
Richardson, Sir Charles, Flashback: A Soldier’s Story (London: Kimber, 1985)
Schmidt, Heinz Werner, With Rommel in the Desert (London: Panther, 1955)
Scoullar, J.L., Battle for Egypt: The Summer of 1942 (Wellington: New Zealand Historical Publications Department, 1955)
Shores, Christopher and Hans Ring, Fighters over the Desert: The Air Battles in the Western Desert, June 1940 to December 1942 (London: Neville Spearman, 1969)
Stewart, Adrian, The Early Battles of Eighth Army: Crusader to the Alamein Line, 1941–42 (Mechanicsburg, PA: Stackpole, 2010)
Tuker, Sir Francis, Approach to Battle: A Commentary – Eighth Army, November 1941 to May 1943 (London: Cassell, 1963)
Walker, Ian W., Iron Hulls, Iron Hearts: Mussolini’s Elite Armoured Divisions in North Africa (Marlborough: The Crowood Press, 2006)
Walker, Ronald, The Official History of New Zealand in the Second World War 1939–1945: Alam Halfa and Alamein (Wellington: NZ Historical Publications Branch, 1967)
Related Titles
epub ISBN SERIES TITLE
9781849088404 General Military Red Eagles
9781780962207 General Military Tank Spotters guide
9781849086509 General Military Soldier I
9781849086516 General Military Loose Cannons
9781849086530 General Military Fubar
9781849086523 General Military Counter-insurgency
9781849087292 General Military Conquer or Die
9781849088275 General Military Zombies
9781849088619 General Military Silent Killers
9781849088671 General Military Battlefield Angels
9781849089593 General Military Tonight we die as men PB
9781849089906 General Military Hitler's war on russia
9781849089920 General Military Sniper: A history of the US Marksman
9781849089944 General Military Samurai and the Sacred
9781849088725 General Military A Pocket History of the Civil War
9781849088749 General Military Secret Weapons
9781849088756 General Military Out of Nowhere
9781780960760 General Military Shadow warriors PB
9781780960784 General Military SEALs PB
9781780960807 General Military Hell in the Pacific
9781849089913 General Military Samurai: World of the Warrior
9781849089937 General Military Warriors of Medieval Japan
9781849088695 General Military They Shall Not Pass
9781849088848 General Military Knight
9781849088855 General Military Always Faithful
9781849088862 General Military Hitler’s Armies
9781849088879 General Military The road to victory: From Pearl Harbor to Okinawa
9781849088978 General Military Backbone
9781849088992 General Military The SAS in World War II: An Illustrated History
9781780962214 General Military Iran at war
9781780962221 General Military No greater Ally
9781780962238 General Military SAS Heroes
First published in Great Britain in 2012 by Osprey Publishing,
Midland House, West Way, Botley, Oxford, OX2 0PH, UK
44-02 23rd Street, Suite 219, Long Island City, NY 11101, USA
E-mail: info@ospreypublishing.com
OSPREY PUBLISHING IS PART OF THE OSPREY GROUP
© 2012 Bryn Hammond
All rights reserved. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study, research, criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, electrical, chemical, mechanical, optical, photocopying, recording o
r otherwise, without the prior written permission of the copyright owner. Enquiries should be addressed to the Publishers.
Every attempt has been made by the Publisher to secure the appropriate permissions for material reproduced in this book. If there has been any oversight we will be happy to rectify the situation and written submission should be made to the Publishers.
A CIP catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Print ISBN: 978 1 84908 640 0
PDF e-book ISBN: 978 1 78096 452 2
EPUB e-book ISBN: 978 1 78096 453 9
Page design by Myriam Bell Design, UK
Index by Mike Parkin
Typeset in Rockwell Condensed and Cambria
Originated by PDQ Digital Media Solutions
Printed in China through Worldprint Ltd
12 13 14 15 16 17 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Osprey Publishing is supporting the Woodland Trust, the UK’s leading woodland conservation charity, by funding the dedication of trees.
www.ospreypublishing.com
Front Cover: British infantry on patrol near the German lines. (Imperial War Museum, E 14582)
© Osprey Publishing. Access to this book is not digitally restricted. In return, we ask you that you use it for personal, non-commercial purposes only. Please don’t upload this pdf to a peer-to-peer site, email it to everyone you know, or resell it. Osprey Publishing reserves all rights to its digital content and no part of these products may be copied, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording or otherwise (except as permitted here), without the written permission of the publisher. Please support our continuing book publishing programme by using this pdf responsibly.