Five Mafia Captors’ Virgin: A Reverse Harem Romance

by Casey, Nicole

  “Well then what’s the issue? Are they not into the sharing?” Jordan asked.

  “No, they’re fine with it. They encourage it,” I responded.

  “Then what’s the problem?” Jordan asked.

  “I’ll direct you back to the headline of literally every newspaper and trash T.V. channel,” I said.

  “You just have to wait that stuff out,” Jordan said. “It’ll blow over eventually. Someone else will do something even more scandalous and you’ll recede back into the area of fame where William Hung and ‘Cash Me Outside’ exist, except please don’t do a talk show circuit.”

  “I can barely talk about it with the guys around the house, I think I’d pass out doing a talk show,” I responded. “Five guys and the media has me pictured with all of them.”

  “Well, at least I can learn from your mistakes. I’m a nanny in this circle of single dads down in Texas, and they’re all smoking hot, and not mobster hot, sensitive, sweet men who love their children hot.”

  “Oh, you’re definitely in trouble,” I said. As I was talking to Jordan, my phone beeped that someone was calling. I looked at my phone and my heart dropped. “Uh oh, Jada’s calling.”

  “Ooh, better get it. I’m sure she’s heard the news by now,” Jordan said. “Wish me luck.”

  “Don’t go outside,” I said, and then clicked over to the other line. “Hey.”

  “Hi,” Jada sounded oddly positive. “Having a tough time are we?”

  “I know you must think I’m an idiot,” I began, but Jada started chuckling. “What?”

  “Sadie, are you forgetting my situation? I had four lovers on that ranch in Montana,” she said.

  I sighed. “I guess that’s true. Things ended up working out for all of you, right?”

  “They did,” Jada replied. “Ask mom and dad if you don’t believe me. It had to be going well for me to be willing to tell them about it, although they had it tough enough learning I had four significant others, so they might truly lose their shit now that they know you have five. I’d avoid them for a little bit.”

  “I don’t know what to do with all of this media coverage,” I whined.

  “Just be patient. Nothing in the news lasts longer than a week anyway,” Jada said. “Believe me, you’ll be yesterday’s news before you know it. Just batten down with your gorgeous guys and wait it out.”

  “Really?” I said.

  “Trust me on this,” Jada said. “I’ll talk to mom and dad for you, and when this all blows over, you can have a more honest conversation with them. Times have changed, it’s just a little difficult for them to get used to.”

  I really did love my sister. “Thanks, Jada.”

  “Of course, squirt. I gotta go, but just be safe, and I’ll talk to you soon, okay?”

  “Okay. Love you,” I said.

  She giggled. “Love you too. Bye.”

  After talking to Jordan and Jada, I felt much better. I wanted to talk to Dante and let him know that I was okay, so I left my room, for the first time in almost 24 hours, and made my way for his room. I was just about to turn the corner when I heard Apollo.

  “Yeah, it’s not good, boss. Four major investors pulled their funding from a few different businesses and so many shareholders have bought out, that the company is going to take a huge hit,” he explained. “We’ve got a few more investors threatening. They don’t like bad publicity.”

  Dante sighed, and I hated the sound of defeat in his voice. “I’m not worried.” I could tell that he was. “It’ll pass with time, and I have plenty of money to keep us going until then. Besides, what are undercover businesses for, if not this exact thing?”

  I felt horrible.

  All of the fallout was because of me. Simply because I was there, Dante was losing millions on his businesses, and it was the above board stuff that didn’t get him shot. Now he was going to have to do more seedy stuff? What if he didn’t survive a gunshot the next time? Maybe I should just go. They weren’t supervising me anymore. I could disappear without them being any the wiser.

  I sat there listening to them talk for a while. I couldn’t get over it. What was I thinking? Why would I go out with all of them? Why would I kiss all of them in public places? I was a model. I knew better than anyone how quickly exposure could go south. I’d spent half my career avoiding it.

  I bit back emotions as I thought about it. I could go back to a normal life. I could find another job. Even if it wasn’t as a model, with all my experience, I could find something in fashion. And I probably wouldn’t find a guy like Dante, or Kane, Brix, or the twins for that matter, but the world wasn’t entirely devoid of reasonable men. Someone had to come close…

  Right?

  “Speaking of the underground stuff, there’s already rumblings of some of the underlings trying to use this info to overthrow you,” Asher said.

  “Well, we’ll just have to deal with that won’t we?” Dante said. “Do you know who?”

  “I have a list going of everything I’ve heard. We could send some worms out to get solid info, or we could just hit the streets oursel--” I entered the room, cutting Asher off. “Sadie.”

  “I’m sorry,” I said to Dante.

  “Sorry?” Dante questioned.

  “This is all my fault.” I said. “I overheard all of this stuff that’s happening to you because of me, and if you need me to leave, I’ll understand. I’ll go without questions. I hate that I’m the reason you’re suffering.”

  Dante stared back at me and both Apollo and Asher remained quiet. It was as though I could hear them realizing that my leaving was the best option after all.

  I nodded my head. “I understand. Please just give me a little time to pack up my things, and I can leave at night so no one sees me.”

  “Sad--” Dante started.

  “No, you can’t go!” Asher yelped and I was shocked. My throat got tight at the look of desperation on his face. “We’re the closest we’ve ever been because of you. There’s no way in hell I’m letting you go. You’re the glue holding us together. You’re not going anywhere.” After he ended his exclamation, he looked around the room as though he was looking for who actually said the words that had spewed from his lips.

  He looked back at me and nodded, cementing his emotions. He pulled me into a tight hug that he ended with a kiss that he started to get lost in until he remembered where he was and who was present and released me. He looked at Dante with a nervous look on his face, but Dante just looked amused back at him and then turned his gaze to me.

  “I couldn’t have said it better myself,” Dante said with a grin. “We’ll figure this out, but any option where you aren’t here isn’t an option.”

  Relief galloped through me. I didn’t want to go. I was willing to, to protect them, but if they wanted me to stay, then I was more than happy to.

  “What will we do though?” Apollo said.

  “Yeah, how do we make something like this better?” I added.

  Asher crossed his arms in contemplation. “I don’t know. The only thing that ever trumps a scandal is a bigger one.”

  The words Jordan and Jada had said to me rang through my mind. “That’s it,” I said. “The only thing that ever trumps a scandal,” I repeated with a sly smile, “is a bigger one.”

  Asher

  Sadie was all over the news. She’d been in and out of the house with all of them at different times in the past two days, not giving a damn who saw them. Just when they expected all the media coverage to get the best of her and expecting that she was going to want to stay in the house, she said that she wanted to go all together to get lunch at the most popular lunch in the city. She wanted Dante to call and have the place shut down just for them, something he did immediately upon her asking.

  “If they want news, let’s give it to them,” she said, with a look of determination on her face.

  We all went out to the popular Italian restaurant in three of the fanciest cars in our fleet. We were trying to draw a
ttention. Dante and Sadie arrived together in one, Kane and Brix in one, and Apollo and I in the last one. As we pulled up, the street was lined with paparazzi. News of the most popular restaurant in all of Chicago being shut down for the ‘Mobster Whore’ was enough to bring out everyone. We got out and Sadie immediately hooked herself to Dante, clearly promoting the romance between them. Apollo and I flanked them on either side, and Kane and Brix stood just behind us as the guards they were, staring down the reporters with thick intimidation.

  A single reporter managed to get his mic through the crowd and grabbed Sadie’s attention. “Sadie, are the rumors true?”

  Sadie turned, looked at him, and grinned broadly. “They are.” Cameras started to flash and more questions started to fly from the crowd. “I’m not going to apologize for loving all five of these men, so why would I hide it? To all who are judgmental, go ahead and cast the first stone. I promise you, I’m not thinking about you as much as you are me.” She gave Dante a quick kiss and then turned her attention away from the cameras.

  Beneath a litany of questions and pictures, we entered the restaurant and enjoyed our lunch in solitude, with the restaurant's bodyguards keeping everyone at bay outside. By the time we got back to Dante’s the news was already abuzz with Sadie’s shocking confession, but people weren’t nearly as negative as they had been before. When there was room to guess what we were doing, everyone could assume the worst, but with Sadie having embraced our lifestyle publicly, there was no room left for extravagant accusations. Her plan had worked.

  We cracked open a bottle of wine and started to celebrate Sadie’s brilliance. The more she drank the looser she got, and she was going around kissing us each, and taking sneaky moments to feel us all up, until she finally stood in front of all of us with her cheeks a delectable red color.

  “I’m all riled up from today. Energized,” she bit her lip, “horny.”

  Dante looked back at her with a grin on his face. “How horny?”

  “Horny enough that I want all of you, right now,” she replied.

  I wasn’t alone in instantly becoming aroused. We’d always only shared women, two or three at a time at the most, but never all five of us at once. It was going to be a first for us all and the excitement in the room was palpable.

  We made our way up to Dante’s room, and as the boss, he got first dibs. He sucked Sadie into a kiss as his hands splayed across her body, removing every article of her clothing. She shook her hips and swayed her body as he stripped her, creating a show for us all. She was dangling a big, juicy steak in front of five tigers, and she was about to drop it in the cage.

  Once she was naked, Dante tackled her to the bed and started to kiss her. He snapped his fingers and Apollo and I sprang into action, me licking her pussy while Apollo sucked and teased her breasts. Sadie mewled with delight at our ministrations, and after briefly stepping out, Kane and Brix joined the fray with a few toys they’d gone to retrieve. We repositioned Sadie so that she was on her hands and knees, and Dante placed himself in front of her, with his cock poking at her face. She looked like a bitch in heat, clamoring forward so she could take him into her mouth, but Kane pulled her back, placing a collar around her neck, pulling her back with the attached leash.

  I moved so I was on my back, and continued to lick her pussy and suck her clit, loving the way she was begging to suck Dante’s dick. Brix plugged in a vibrator and laid on the other side, and ducked it under to tease clit. I moved down a little and stuck my tongue in her hole while Brix held the vibrator in place. Sadie whimpered and, for a moment, she wasn’t trying to get at Dante’s dick, she was just trying to stay up on her hands and knees. Brix was biting at the flesh of her stomach, pressing the vibrator against her more each time he sunk his teeth in. I swirled my tongue around Sadie’s opening, and alternated pushing it in and out. The muscles of her hole kept clenching against my tongue and I could sense she was getting close. I clawed my fingers into the meat of her thighs and pulled her down so get my tongue as deep in her as it would go. It pulled her down firmly against the vibrator as well.

  “I’m gonna come!” Sadie screamed, and when she did, Brix and I both stopped, laughing at our intuition. “Please.” Sadie begged.

  We were letting her come, we were letting her do what she wanted, and she was behaving like a wild animal. Apollo lined up behind Sadie, covering his condomed dick in a copious amount of lube.

  “Fuck her ass, Apollo,” Dante ordered.

  “Yes boss,” Apollo responded, and shoved into her asshole in one long thrust.

  Brix and I continued to pleasure her pussy and Dante slid forward and Kane released the leash enough for Sadie to finally slurp up his dick with hunger. She began giving Dante a blow job that must have been outstanding for the way Dante huffed “fuck,” at her. Eventually, my dick got so hard it hurt. I repositioned myself enough to line my dick up to her pussy. I quickly adorned a condom and then shoved my cock as far in as it would go. Brix moved the vibrator from her pussy to her nipple and placed his head under her to suck the other. Sadie screamed out, and then a few minutes later, she was ejaculating all over my dick.

  Apollo slapped her ass, and she yelped out with glee. Kane pulled out his dick and started to stroke it, but Apollo wasn’t the kind to leave a friend hanging. He removed himself from Sadie, an action that elicited a dissatisfied yip from her, and presented her to Kane. He wrapped himself in a condom as quickly as he could, and then plunged his dick deep, pulling on the leash to arch her back and to fuck her hard.

  Kane’s action pulled her off of Dante, but he wasn’t disappointed. “You like being fucked by my men?” he asked.

  Sadie nodded. “I love being fucked by your men.”

  “You love those two dicks in you?” he growled at her.

  Sadie took my and Kane’s dicks deep inside her like a champ. “I love having two dicks inside me while you watch.”

  Dante started to stroke his own cock. He stood up on the bed, and Kane pulled the leash back even further, so Sadie was almost upright, putting her in a mind-numbing position on my dick.

  “Fuck,” I growled. “Keep her steady, Kane, I’m gonna fucking bust with you moving her like that.”

  Dante started to stroke his cock right over Sadie’s face. “You like when my men take turns with you while I watch?”

  Sadie nodded. “I love having all my holes stuffed while you come on me!” she screamed.

  She reached down and started to stroke Brix’s cock with one hand while Apollo moved over to her mouth and she immediately turned and sucked him in. Dante started to pull at his dick harder and faster, and the collective sighs and breaths in the room got faster, and shallower. Kane was the first to go, grunting as he slammed into Sadie’s ass, pulsating with a massive orgasm. Sadie started to shake as he came, and came again herself, shuddering and gyrating around me, wiggling her pussy to ride it out. It snatched me over and I came with a loud moan.

  “Fuck,” Apollo hissed. “Swallow it.” He grabbed the back of her head and buried himself down her throat, coming with a loud grumble of his own.

  Sadie’s handjob pulled Brix over next and as he came, he pressed the vibrator to its max level, sending shivers down Sadie’s spine and making her come again, clamping down on Kane and I, who hadn’t yet pulled out and each experienced an additional, dry orgasm.

  Last was the boss. Watching everyone come in and on his woman pulled him over the edge and he slid his hand up and down his dick until his seed came out, splashing against Sadie’s face in long, hot ribbons. None of us moved for a long time, apart from Sadie, who collapsed on top of me.

  Once we had all recovered, Kane, Brix, Apollo, and I started packing up to leave. The three of them got out ahead of me, but I straggled behind just enough to hear Dante sweetly tell Sadie that he was impressed with how brave she was.

  “I’m only going to live once, so why waste it conforming to other people’s ideas of what’s ‘normal?’” Sadie replied. I liked that. “Besides, my
sister has four husbands too. I guess it runs in the family.”

  I was shocked, and I could see Dante was as well. I made my way out of the room, pulling the door closed behind me, just in time to hear Dante murmur, “I’d like to meet your sister.”

  Dante

  No matter what I did, I felt like I wasn’t doing enough to keep Sadie distracted and happy. She tried reaching out to her mother to talk to her about everything that happened, but her mom wasn’t responding to her. She told me that her mom had never ignored her once in her entire life; she was downright depressed about it. I was doing everything in my power. We went out every day to any play she would like, and every night, we made love. I rotated in the guys to give her different things that I knew she loved, but no matter how hard I tried, she was still sad every day when she woke up. It was breaking my heart.

  “What can I do?” I asked her finally. “I don’t want you to be sad anymore.”

  She smiled at me. “It’s getting better. I know my mom will get over it. I am getting a little bored though. I don’t know how much I enjoy being a ‘kept woman.’”

  I hadn’t even considered the thought of Sadie going back to work. For so long it was about not letting her leave the house, and then after that she didn’t want to. Now she wanted to work again, that was difficult for me, but if it would make her happy, I was glad to support her.

  “Chicago has a huge modeling scene,” I told her. “I can--”

  “No,” Sadie cut me off. “No pulling strings. No intimidation. I want to get jobs on my own. I can go back to go-sees and scraping the sewers for jobs. I did it before, I can do it again.” I pursed my lips. Why would my woman scrape sewers for jobs when I could snap my fingers and get her any job she wanted.

  “Dante,” Sadie growled.

  I cracked my neck, a tick I did when I was annoyed. “Fine. I’ll be good. I believe in you.”

  Sadie gave me the first genuine smile she’d give me in a long time. “Thank you.”