Nichols, Tara S. - Island of Three (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour)

by Tara S. Nichols

  “Right back where she left us.” Tyler grimaced. “You’d rather we both lose her than continue on as we have been, which, in my opinion has been going pretty darn fantastic.”

  The corner of Blaine’s mouth twitched and eventually pulled in to a smile. “It has, but I just can’t wrap my head around the idea of bumping in to you brushing your teeth in a communal bathroom.”

  “That’s what is bugging you?” Tyler laughed.

  “No, but picture it, and I mean all of it.”

  “We get a place together. We share rent. We share a woman. It doesn’t mean we’re gay. It doesn’t even mean we share a bloody toothbrush.”

  “Obviously there would be some rules to work out.”

  “Obviously,” Tyler confirmed with an easy shrug.

  Blaine’s face burned. He couldn’t help his embarrassment over the whole idea. What would his family say? What happened down the road when one of them mentioned marriage or kids?

  “Dude, I know what you are thinking. Let’s take it one step at a time, okay?” Tyler swung his hand through the water and splashed a little water on Blaine’s bare chest.

  The cold water drew him out of his thoughts with a start, and he realized they’d been standing in the lake, completely naked, discussing a romance which they would both take part. He’d managed that much with surprising candor. He wondered if maybe it would be all right after all.

  “Come on.” Tyler smiled warmly. “Let’s go pitch our idea to Adele before she finds a way off this island and leaves us here with just each other for company.”

  “What a thought,” Blaine said over-emphasizing a repulsed shudder, but softened the gesture with a friendly pat to Tyler’s shoulder.

  * * * *

  Adele turned sharply, half expecting to see a herd of elephants appear at the edge of the woods rather than Tyler and Blaine, for all the noise they made. Lightfooted, they were not.

  She’d already started back, and had nearly made it to the camp when the sharp snapping and cracking on the trail ahead of her made her pause. She couldn’t even hide her relief to see it was her two lovers come after her, rather than a bear. She was still angry with them, and herself, but she knew sulking wouldn’t resolve their situation. Only a long, painful discussion about how it wasn’t going to work, and how they would try to make the best of it until they were rescued would make living together hospitable.

  “We need to talk,” she started to say when she was abruptly interrupted by Blaine who scooped her up and threw her over his shoulder.

  “What the hell Blaine!” she exclaimed, looking to Tyler for an explanation, but all she got was from him was a full faced grin and a pinch to her bottom.

  “Put me down!” she tried again but they wouldn’t stop. Craning her neck to see where they were going she saw the lake just before she was dropped in to it.

  She shrieked as the water rushed around her, then howled with fury when she surfaced.

  Standing up fast, she gave Blaine a mighty shove in the chest. The bigger man toppled easily, but Tyler proved to be a tougher case. Lunging for his wiry body, she missed completely and ended up in over her head again.

  Not one to be outsmarted, Adele groped beneath the surface where she found his ankle, then gave a mighty jerk, and dragged him under right next to her.

  The three of them floundered and splashed, one upping each other until they doubled over with laughter.

  Adele sank into the waves with a weary sigh. “Oh, I needed that.”

  “I think we all did. It was getting far too serious around here,” Blaine said sending a wall of water toward Tyler.

  “Not any more though.” He wiggled his eyebrows at Adele.

  She turned to look at Blaine to see if this was true.

  “You’re too much woman for us Adele.” He shrugged but she could tell he was joking by the playful fire in his eyes.

  “You’re a rat.” She splashed him much as he’d done to Tyler. “And a soon to be drowned rat.” With fluid motion, she dove beneath the water. A second later her head bumped into his thigh, and she followed the curve around to the tender junction between his legs. He flinched satisfactorily as she drew his flaccid cock into her mouth, but she couldn’t do much more than that, the water making it nearly impossible to perform any other function.

  When she surfaced she noticed that both of the guys were no longer watching her but were now both standing to attention, their eyes scanning the horizon. She looked around wildly. What had they heard or seen? Then she heard it, too. An engine. It was far off in the distance, but it was unmistakably there.

  In an instant, all three of them scattered. Moving quickly, she pressed her body against the closest rock and crouched down out of sight. Her reaction to the sound surprised her. Why was she hiding instead of jumping up and down and shouting as loud as she could? She came out into the open again only when the sound had receded into the distance.

  She turned around to see the same quizzical expression on the faces of the guys, and immediately she felt ashamed.

  As she emerged from the water, both of the guys came forward to meet her. They stood there naked and dripping.

  Then Blaine smiled knowingly, which confused her even more. “Yeah, I saw you hide behind that rock. You didn’t want them to see you, did you? And I don’t think it had anything to do with being naked either,” he said rather than asked.

  She chewed her lip edgily. “So.” She shrugged. “Maybe I’m not in a hurry to go home.”

  Both of the guys seemed to be looking at her differently now. Was that admiration she saw in their eyes, or was it lust?

  “Funny,” Blaine said with a soft snort. “That was my reaction, too.”

  Blaine’s confession surprised her. She thought he had rushed to shore to flag them down, and here he was admitting he had run to hide, same as her.

  Tyler chuckled. “I nearly asked you to douse the fire.”

  Adele just blinked.

  “What a bunch of hypocrites we are,” Blaine said, pointing to the words spelled out on the shore and gave his head a shake. “We like it here. We like living the fantasy. Who wouldn’t?”

  Tyler walked over to the small rocks spelling out the word ‘help’, and with a mischievous glance over his shoulder, he sent them scrambling, dispersing them into the water.

  The corner of Adele’s mouth twitched. It was going to be all right, she realized. It didn’t have to end. It wasn’t going to end, at least, not yet.

  “Naughty girl.” She heard Blaine’s voice, a low, throaty growl close by her ear. “Teasing pilots like that. They’ll think they saw a mermaid.” She felt his hands snake around her front and cup her breasts. His fingers entwined around each nipple, and he tugged on them gently, rolling the taunt little buds and igniting fireworks between her legs.

  She blushed under the contact, feeling the fire that had nearly consumed her earlier reignite.

  Dropping one hand, Blaine found the slit between her legs, and with two fingers, he slid them along her slick groove. At the same time, she felt him urge her forward toward the boulders. She allowed him to guide her until she came up against a rock as high as her waist. Using the flat of his hand, he urged her down against the warm stone. Her breathing quickened at the gesture as she felt her excitement intensify. This is what she wanted. She wanted to be taken, hard and fast, no coddling or asking for permission, just right there and right now.

  She felt the weight of Blaine’s body press down on hers. Pinned beneath him, she could go no further. “You want it, don’t you, Adele? You want it like you gave it to Tyler earlier.”

  She raised her hips up against him, grinding her pelvis into his hard bulge. “Yes,” she said breathily. “Yes, this is exactly what I want.”

  Tyler approached, the box of condoms in his hand. She looked up into his smiling face and felt her heart do a back flip.

  “You’ve been naughty, Adele, and you almost got caught.”

  She nodded docilely in agreement.


  “How would you like it if …” She heard Blaine’s voice, low and husky behind her as he took a condom from the box and rolled it over his erection. “I gave you exactly what you’ve been longing for? What if I took you from behind, out here, in the open where everybody could see?” He rolled his groin against her buttocks, his hard shaft nudging against her opening. His hands explored her skin, caressing and kneading it with growing determination. Using the side of his foot, he spread her legs. The pressure at her entrance increased as he crossed her threshold, penetrating her in one sharp burst. She caught her breath.

  “They might circle around, you know. They could catch us at any moment.” His lusty words continued. “They could fly over that ridge and see what I was doing to you, see my cock deep inside of you, and Adele, I promise you, I won’t stop. I’ll let them watch as I fuck you. I’ll let them witness you writhe and beg for more.”

  His voice and the things he was saying were driving her wild.

  “That’s right. I’m going to fuck you until you are begging me.” He gave her a quick thrust, and she gasped with pleasure.

  She loved everything he was doing. She wanted it rougher, harder, deeper, faster. She wanted more. She wanted that plane to circle around. Images of the shocked expressions on those pilot’s faces filled her mind. They would be appalled at first, but then they would quickly grow curious, turned on, and maybe they even would land.

  “You are dripping wet, Adele. You want everyone to see how turned on you are, don’t you?” He pinched her nipples roughly, sending pinwheels spiraling down her center. Another thrust forced a cry of encouragement from her lips.

  “Yes, oh yes,” she said through ragged breaths. She was getting close, but she fought it, trying to prolong this ecstasy. He continued to squeeze her nipples at the same time, thrusting into her mercilessly.

  “I can feel that you are getting close, Adele. You’re so tight, you’re milking my cock.” She heard his grunts of pleasure, his moans of satisfaction, his lust-filled voice as he narrated everything he was doing to her.

  Tyler inched closer, leaning against a large boulder two feet away, his eyes taking it all in. She saw his hand wrap around his swollen cock. He began to caress it with long, even strokes then quickly fell into rhythm with Blaine’s enthusiastic thrusts, but that was as close as he ventured. He seemed to have decided this was Blaine’s turn.

  “See, Adele, now Tyler is watching you. He is watching me fuck you, too.”

  Adele saw that Tyler had walked over. He stood, bulging cock in hand, inches away from her face. Looking up, she met his eyes and knew exactly what he wanted.

  He groaned with pleasure the moment his cock felt the warm, wet heat of her mouth. Wrapping her lips around his shaft she struggled to keep her balance as Blaine continued to bury his cock in her. She raised herself up on the rock just enough to slide her hands under her breasts, but even bracing against the rock with her hands didn’t help bear the weight of Blaine’s aggressive thrusts. Eventually, she conceded that she couldn’t do both at once. That gave her an idea.

  “Blaine, hold up,” she called out.

  She felt Blaine pause.

  “Let’s move this down to the ground where I can have you both.”

  Tyler’s eyes went wide. “Are you suggesting, at the same time?”

  She managed to nod. “We have the lube after all, we may as well use it.”

  “Oh, honey.” Tyler beamed, drawing closer.

  She felt Blaine withdraw and waited for him to lie down on the shore. Then, straddling his legs, she inched her way up along his body until the head of his cock pressed once against her clit. Using her fingers, she gently urged him back then up into her, feeling the familiar ache as his girth filled her full.

  “Mmm.” She purred at the sensation. “Okay, Tyler, now, but go slow.”

  She felt Tyler’s warm thighs as they covered the backs of her own, then the pressure as he pressed the cool lubricant into her using one finger. She felt pressure as the head of his cock strained against her entrance, and she braced herself for the unknown.

  “Try and relax,” Blaine encouraged her from below. His hands went immediately to her breasts, massaging them until she moaned with pleasure.

  “Mmm, that helps,” she said, relaxing a little.

  Hearing that, Tyler urged himself in a little deeper, and when she didn’t protest, he went deeper again until he was a little more than halfway inside of her. She felt resistance again and then ease as her body accepted the intrusion.

  “Slow!” she suddenly gasped, feeling the uncomfortable warning she was getting tense. Tyler halted and waited. She listened to the two men breathing on either side of her and focused on both of their throbbing cocks. Thinking about their excitement, their desire for her, helped her relax and forget the larger picture. She wanted this.

  “Okay, Tyler,” she said softly. “Push it in a little further.”

  He applied more pressure until Adele felt herself expand. Suddenly it seemed a lot easier.

  Soon he was able to withdraw a bit and pump in again, slowly at first then faster and harder when she didn’t resist. In fact, the feeling was glorious. She closed her eyes, reveling in the new experience.

  “We did it!” she exclaimed, mildly surprised. “And it feels so good!” She threw her head back with an elated giggle.

  “Man, does it ever,” Tyler said with a groan. “I’m rock hard.”

  “Me, too,” Blaine said. Cupping both of her full breasts within his hands, he began to knead them again, pinching them now just a little.

  “Oh! Believe me, I know.” She laughed.

  Blaine tipped his pelvis slightly, rocking slowly in and out of her. Having both of them riding her was intense and far better than she could ever have imagined.

  “You like it, Adele?” Blaine’s voice was thick and affected. He seemed to have mastered himself, even giving her two quick thrusts.

  “Oh, yes. Oh, fuck yes!” she answered enthusiastically. “It’s a dream come true finally having both of you!” Before she even knew what was happening, Adele began to climax, the sweet tingling that swelled between her legs and then washed over her in waves. She cried out without warning, feeling the climax bubbling inside of her.

  She was vaguely aware of the guys own echoing laughter and the sensation of their eager thrusts. Her head felt as though it were full of cotton balls, and her mouth felt dry, but the one thing she was certain of was the intense satisfaction surging throughout her body. When Tyler stiffened and grew still, she couldn’t hold off one second longer. She cried out over and over as Blaine’s cock bobbed in and out of her, driving her orgasm up, up, up into her hips, her abdomen, her tits, her throat where it burst forth a joyful scream that echoed off the water. Soon after, a loud groan more like the roar of a bear sounded from below her as Blaine’s orgasm echoed across the landscape.

  * * * *

  Adele returned from the lake where she washed up, feeling like the luckiest woman alive, and laid down on the beach in between her two lovers.

  “I have never come so much in my life,” Tyler announced wearily as he propped himself up against a large stone. “How do you feel?” Tyler asked, pulling her up out of her euphoric state. “Sore at all?”

  She opened her eyes and blinked under the sunlight. Tyler grinned, seeming to enjoy her disorientated expression.

  She ran her fingers through her hair to gather her wits. “Just the teensiest bit,” she admitted with a sheepish smile. “But it was well worth it.”

  A row of squabbling ducks skirted the edge of the shore. Adele watched Blaine’s eyes follow them with a hungry stare.

  “Do you think there’s good eating on those?”

  She shook her head and chuckled. “Of course. They’re considered a delicacy.”

  Tyler’s laugh came from the boulder. “I’m betting we’ve never eaten this well in our lives.”

  Adele had to agree. A few days ago she was pushing keys at her comp
uter desk, snacking on popcorn because she was too busy to cook a full meal.

  “How long do you think we could stay here, anyway?” Blaine asked still sizing up the straggler duck.

  “Are you seriously thinking about making fucking me your career?”

  “What? Just pay me in nuts.”

  “You’re as mad as a squirrel,” she said giggling.

  Blaine grew serious. “What do you two think about relocating?”

  “You mean somewhere a little less obvious to any possible rescuers?” Tyler asked, raising his eyebrows quizzically.

  “Yeah. Not that we couldn’t come down to the shore to fuck Adele publicly now and again, it’s just…you know.” He shyly kicked his toe along the ground.

  Adele’s heart leapt. “I don’t want this to end either.”

  He came over to her put his arm around her shoulder affectionately and kissed her cheek. “I’m with you.”

  Chapter Sixteen

  After skirting the entire island for a better location, they finally found a spot that looked perfect along the northwest side. It was a large, cave-like alcove that would provide shelter from both the wind and the rain. It was open to the water yet surrounded by trees, so they wouldn’t be easily seen. Ferns fringed the edges, and the floor was a downy-soft mat covering of pine needles and moss. There was enough room for all three of them to stretch out, or perform acrobats as the case may be. What was best of all was how near it was to the large open space in the middle of the island and to the raspberries.

  There were a few modifications necessary to do to the new shelter but they were soon settled in with all of their gear, and the other hovel was torn down. They tried to erase all evidence of their existence, but try as they might, they could not remove the charred mark left behind from their fire.

  Feeling secure now that they had agreed not to leave, Adele started to think of the days ahead and their survival. She set about the task of filling her backpack half full of raspberries, and she noticed she wasn’t the only one thinking about the future. Blaine had returned from his hazelnut stash, and Tyler had busied himself with catching more fish. Earlier he had announced that he would try his hand at smoking some of them.