Mind in Motion

Home > Other > Mind in Motion > Page 38
Mind in Motion Page 38

by Barbara Tversky


  counting by, 131

  gesturing by, 112–114

  goal-directed behavior, 20

  intentions of the actions of others, understanding, 21

  recognition by, 34

  thinking by, 19–20

  training joint action, 27

  vocabulary acquisition and gestures, 131

  word acquisition, 36

  cholera (1854), map of, 200–201

  circles, 131, 134, 167–169, 209, 227

  cities, layouts of, 72–73

  cocktail napkins, 262

  cognitive behavior therapy, 273

  cognitive collage, 83

  cognitive design principles, 193–194, 199, 201

  Cognitive Laws, 289

  First, 15–16, 39, 51, 150, 157, 169, 194, 240, 274

  Second, 18

  Third, 42

  Fourth, 13, 36, 55, 64

  Fifth, 57, 73, 81

  Corollary of Fifth, 60

  Sixth, 72, 142, 165

  Seventh, 78, 244

  Eighth, 190

  Ninth, 280

  cognitive load, 127, 146

  cognitive maps, 72, 82–83

  cognitive reference points, 81

  coherence, check for, 261

  collaboration, 29, 136–137, 284

  color, 44

  comics, 240–255

  advantages of, 241–243

  beginning of, 243

  connections in, 245

  contrasting word and picture, 249–250

  disconnection in, 245–246

  effectiveness, 241

  end of, 246

  figures of depiction, 250–253, 251 (fig.)–253 (fig.)

  meaning created by, 247–255

  middle of, 243–246

  motion expressed in, 246

  multiple meanings expressed by, 252–255

  multiple views in, 247–249, 248 (fig.)

  rule breaking by, 242

  scrutiny encouraged and rewarded by, 242–243

  segmentation, 243–245

  splash pages, 243

  visual anaphors to establish continuity, 245

  written language in, 249

  common fate, 74–75

  communication, redundancy in, 47–48

  competence judgments, 46

  completeness, check for, 261

  complex systems, 132

  conceptual maps, 71–72, 201

  conducting, gestures and, 138–139

  confirmation bias, 56–57, 273

  congruent mapping, 94, 129, 134–135, 208

  construction, mental, 95–97, 95 (fig.)

  constructive perception, 266

  containers, 230

  context, map use in, 199

  continuity, 245–246

  continuous data, 230–231

  continuous gestures, 236

  conversation, 29–30, 136, 240

  cooperation, 27, 41, 282–283

  coordination with others, 26–30

  correspondence, principle of, 193–194, 201, 208, 210, 235

  counting

  by children, 131

  exact number system (ENS), 177

  gestures and, 124, 134

  notation systems for, 177

  taboos against, 205

  tallies, 203–205, 204 (fig.), 208

  as tool of thought, 206

  creating, drawing and, 262–267

  creative thinking, 263

  creativity, 267–271

  cultural differences in math diagrams, 207–208

  cycle/cyclicity, 134, 167

  da Vinci, Leonardo, 140, 257–259, 261, 270

  dance, 138, 211–212

  data stories, 240

  deictic center, 143–144, 164, 170

  deictic gestures, 117

  depictions

  of events, people, places, and things, 214–216

  figures of, 250–253, 251 (fig.)–253 (fig.)

  descriptions, 72, 126, 127–128, 143, 144–145, 146, 148, 149–150, 152, 227, 233–234, 239

  design

  empathetic, 269

  gestures and, 137–138

  reliance on drawing, 262–267

  spatial language of the designed world, 286–288

  designed world as diagrams, 287–288

  designing the world, 277–280, 277 (fig.)–280 (fig.)

  diagrams

  abstraction, 288

  advantage over text, 238

  animations compared to static graphics, 235–236

  arrows in, 232–235, 234 (fig.)

  benefits, 261

  comics as, 241

  contrasting to a natural scene, 222

  creating effective, 238–239

  discourse forms, 239–240

  effectiveness of, 237

  Euler, 209, 209 (fig.)

  Feynman, 210–211, 210 (fig.)

  in L’Encyclopédie, 221, 221 (fig.)

  math, 207–208

  memorability, 236–237

  reasoning from, 209–211, 209 (fig.)–210 (fig.)

  semantics of, 220

  tree, 222

  world as diagrammed, 287–288

  Diderot, Denis, 220–222, 221 (fig.), 226

  differences, sensitivity to, 176

  dimensional thinking, 224

  dimensions, 51–54, 58

  of dots, lines, and enclosures, 226

  neutral, 223, 225

  value-laden, 223, 225

  direct mapping, 148, 208, 238, 261

  direction judgments, 78

  directionality, 170–171

  directions

  arrows and, 232

  egocentric perspective and, 143–144

  frame of reference and, 146–147

  route, 144–145, 146, 182

  sketch maps, 145

  discourse, forms of, 239–240

  discrete data, 230–231

  discrete gestures, 236

  distance

  quality or value as symbolic, 173

  symbolic, 173, 175

  distance judgments

  distortion related to perspective, 81–82

  reference points as proxy for, 80–81

  spatial categories as proxies for, 78–79

  distant perspective, 181

  distortion

  of approximate number system, 176

  on maps, 199, 201

  in time, 166–167

  divergent thinking, 266, 269

  dots, 157–158, 163

  drawing

  artists, 274–275

  to create, 262–267

  as empirical method, 258–259

  in the mind, 94–97

  new interpretations, discovering, 264–267, 265 (fig.)

  to see and discover, 257–259

  to understand and learn, 259–261

  unintended discoveries, 264

  See also sketches

  dynamics, 132–133

  edges, 157

  ego, moving, 164–165

  egocentric body-centered framework, 66–67, 149, 150–151

  egocentric perspective, 65–66, 142–146, 153, 183

  egocentric reference frame, 151

  Einstein, Albert, 140, 163

  embedded figures, 266

  embedded perspectives, 274

  emblems, 116

  embodiment, 23

  emojis, 242

  emotional mirroring, 112

  emotions

  appraisal of, 44

  cooperation and, 41

  eyes and, 45–46

  faces and, 41–45

  gestures and, 121–122

  judgments of, 43

  positive and negative, 42

  valence, 42, 47

  empathetic design, 269

  empathetic perspective, 269–270

  empathy, 42

  emotional mirroring, 112

  lack of, 184

  perspective taking, 273

  empirical research, drawing as form of, 258–259

&nbs
p; empirical semantics, 227

  enclosures, 226–227

  entorhinal cortex, 68–71, 147, 156

  entrainment, 29–30, 111, 137

  environment

  gestures and descriptions of, 126

  spatial perspective in new, 64

  epidemiology, 201

  error, 17, 29, 39, 47, 75–80, 83, 86, 89, 91, 94, 97, 133, 148, 174–175, 181, 192, 208

  estimates, 174–175, 182, 208

  Euler diagram, 209, 209 (fig.)

  events

  actions distinguished from, 216

  background, 247

  cyclical, 167–169

  depictions of, 214–216

  distortions in time, 166–167

  ordering in time, 170–172

  segmentation, 243

  evolution, 70, 110–111

  exact number system (ENS), 174, 177–179, 208

  expertise, 263, 265–266

  explanations, 35, 102, 103, 123, 127, 133, 144, 168, 182, 190, 193, 201, 216–221, 235, 239

  knowledge and understanding increased by creating, 260

  verbal, 259–261

  visual, 259–261, 260 (fig.)–261 (fig.)

  exploration, 274–275

  eyes, 20, 29, 39, 40, 45–46, 48–49, 59, 62–63, 90, 118, 122, 180, 222, 262, 284

  face blindness, 41

  face-to-face communication, 242–243

  faces

  emotion and, 41–45

  eyes, 45–46

  memory for, 41

  recognizing, 40–41

  traits and, 46–47

  far, perspective and, 181

  feet, enhancements of, 281

  Feynman, Richard, 58, 253–254

  Feynman diagram, 210–211, 210 (fig.)

  figures of depiction, 250–253, 251 (fig.)–253 (fig.)

  First General Fact Worth Remembering, 14

  fixation, release from, 266, 268

  forecasters, 271–273

  forms, 156–157

  in designed world, 288

  ideas and, 284–286

  qualities of, 156

  in space, 285–286

  frame of reference, 74, 143, 146–147

  language differences and, 150–151

  mixed when talking, 149

  frames, 247

  Freud, Sigmund, 160–161

  future, planning for, 71, 190–191

  games, cooperation and, 282–283

  Gasoline Alley (comic strip), 247, 248 (fig.)

  gender differences, 101, 103

  General Cognitive Design Principles, 193–194, 199

  geography, 72–83

  geometric analogies, 95–97, 95 (fig.)

  geometry, 156–157, 209

  gestures, 48, 109–140

  abstraction, 115, 130, 284–285, 288

  as actions in space, 115–116, 130

  as actions on invisible objects (ideas), 284

  by babies, 112–114

  beats, 117, 133

  benefits, 148

  cardinality understanding helped by, 131

  circular, 106, 131, 134, 168

  continuous, 236

  deictic, 117–118

  directionality, in describing events, 171

  discrete, 236

  emblems, 116

  entrainment, 111, 137

  environmental descriptions, 126

  explicit nature of, 137

  graphics compared to, 114–115

  how representational gestures work, 130

  iconic, 118

  to locate things when face-to-face, 148

  metaphoric, 118–119

  mismatches with words, 120–121

  one-to-one, 120, 130

  points, 117–118

  in primates, 110–111

  reasons for using, 113–114

  role in guiding and teaching, 283

  as social glue, 136–140

  space, time, and causality represented by, 121–123

  spatial communication, 104

  as spatial-motor, 126, 128

  talking aided by, 124

  thinking aided by, 124–130

  thought revealed by, 119–121, 125, 130–131

  thoughts of others changed by, 131–134

  truncated action, 111

  types, 116–119

  words compared to, 110

  glyphs, 220, 226–227

  goal-directed behavior, 20

  grammar, 110, 114, 116

  graphics, 284–285

  gestures compared to, 114–115

  See also diagrams

  graphs, 223

  bar, 230–231, 230 (fig.)

  lines, 230–232, 230 (fig.)

  gravity, 1, 63, 187, 223

  grid cells, 69–72

  grouping, 74, 75–77

  Guidonian hand, 135–136, 135 (fig.)

  gutter, 244

  habituation of looking, 20

  handedness, 63

  handprints, 192

  hands, 284

  enhancement of actions of, 282

  Guidonian, 135–136, 135 (fig.)

  pointing by, 232

  use in math or counting, 134–135, 178, 179

  hierarchical organization

  kinds, 159

  partonomies, 77–78, 159

  spatial, 77–79

  trees, 159–161

  hippocampus, 68–71, 147, 156

  homeostasis, 169, 271

  homunculus, 11–13, 12 (fig.)

  horizontal direction as neutral, 223–224

  horizontal plane, 170–172

  hypotheses, perception overridden by, 55–57

  iconic gestures, 118

  icons, 220, 236

  ideas

  actions on, 86

  arrays of, 156

  brain structure and, 156

  forms and, 284–286

  gestures and, 284–285

  metaphoric gestures depictions of, 118–119

  new, 85

  nodes for, 155

  points and lines in, 157

  thinking and, 284

  images

  animating, 97–98

  creating, 94–97

  imitation, 22, 30, 31, 283

  improvisation, 267

  inference, 55, 57, 72

  categories and, 77

  gesturing and, 126

  from line graphs, 230–232

  order and, 173–174, 175, 176

  from tables, 231–232

  transitive, 172, 173–174, 176

  innovation, 267–268

  inside perspective, 182, 273

  insider knowledge, 23–24

  instructions, 216–220, 218 (fig.), 219 (fig.)

  intentions, 21, 48–49

  Ishango bone, 204, 204 (fig.)

  joint action, 27–29

  judgments, 46–47, 72–73, 79, 82

  Kandinsky, Wassily, 229–230, 249

  Kanizsa figures, 229, 229 (fig.)

  kinds, 158–159

  Klee, Paul, 229–230, 232, 259

  knowledge, dissemination and accumulation of, 190

  Krazy Kat (Herriman), 250, 253 (fig.)

  labels, 36–39, 158

  landmarks, 80–81, 147–148, 152, 228

  language

  allocentric perspective and, 147

  alphabetic, 194

  anaphors, 245

  in comics, 249

  describing space and action in space, 184–187

  development of, 186

  discourse forms, 239

  evolution of, 110–111

  gestures and graphics compared to, 115

  logographic, 194

  manner of motion, expressions of, 246

  ordering and, 175

  perspectives and, 150–151

  points and lines in, 157

  semantic congruity, 175–176

  spatial of the designed world, 286–288

  thought and, 90, 186

  time and, 164, 170–171

&nbs
p; writing, 192, 194

  Last Supper (da Vinci), 140

  laws in the world, 287

  laws of cognition. See Cognitive Laws

  L’Encyclopédie (Diderot and d’Alembert), 221, 221 (fig.)

  line graphs, 230–231, 230 (fig.)

  linear bias, 168–169

  lines, 229–230

  aliases of, 156

  asymmetric, 180

  as basic building blocks, 157

  boundaries and, 179–180

  in designed world, 286–287

  directionality, 170–171

  edges, 157

  illusory, 229 (fig.)

  inferences from, 230–232

  inside perspectives, 182

  in Kanizsa figures, 229, 229 (fig.)

  meanings of, 238

  in the mind and in the world, 163

  movement and, 228–230

  order and, 163, 171–172, 175, 180

  as polysemous, 227

  on sketch maps, 228

  time on, 163–165

  ubiquity of, 229

  links

  in networks, 161

  nodes (boxes) connected by, 155–156

  patterns of, 156

  Little Nemo (McCay), 250, 251 (fig.)

  Little Sammy Sneeze (McCay), 250, 252 (fig.)

  logic, Euler diagrams, 209, 209 (fig.)

  logographic writing, 194

  London tube map, 198–199

  looking, habituation of, 20

  mapping

  abstract concepts to space, 224

  congruent, 134–135

  direct, 148, 208, 238, 261

  reading/writing order and, 223–225

  maps, 194–203, 283

  as allocentric, 183–184

  ancient and historic, 94–199, 195 (fig.)–197 (fig.), 200 (fig.)

  in the brain, 68–71

  conceptual, 71–72, 201

  effect on the world, 192

  flattened spatial framework, 67

  history of, 67–68

  London tube, 198–199

  math notation compared, 207–208

  in minds as cognitive collages, 72–73

  perspective, 146–148

  pitch, 211

  representations, 87

  rotation and alignment errors in fictional maps, 74–77

  route, 227–228, 228 (fig.)

  rules of thumb for design, 201–203

  sketch, 145, 227–228, 228 (fig.), 285

  spatial, 71–72

  of stars, 195

  stories and, 68

  as surveys, 182–183

  use in context, 199

  uses for, 199–201

  marking, 138

  marks in space, 220, 226–227

  Marshall Islanders, 196, 196 (fig.), 198

  math notation, 192, 206, 207–208

  mathematics, 203–208

  diagrams and culture, 207–208

  number systems, 174–179

  skills, spatial skills and, 102

  space in, 208

  tallies, 203–205, 204 (fig.)

  use of hand in, 134–135

  meaning

  elements of, 238

  expression of multiple, 252–255

  mechanical system, 97, 101, 102

  memorability, 236–237, 239

  memory, 34

  brain structures involved in, 70–71

  for faces, 41

  perception overridden by, 64

 

‹ Prev