Naughty & Nice: A MFM Christmas Romance (Surrender to Them Book 7)

by Kelli Callahan

  “You’re gonna make me cum!” She tightened her grip on the shelves. “Oh god.”

  “Cum for me baby.” I grabbed her hair and pulled her head back until her ear was against my lips. “I want you to show me how much you love my cock.”

  “Damn it!” She grimaced and moaned. “It’s so fucking good.”

  It didn’t take Holly long to cum at all. Her body started to shake and I felt her beautiful orgasm begin. Her pussy spasmed on my cock, and that was all I could take. It was the best feeling in the world, and after I thrust myself into her quivering pussy several times while she was cumming, I felt my balls getting tight. I had to pull out. I couldn’t cum in her. I didn’t even know if she was on the pill—I lasted as long as I could and started to pull away, but she wasn’t done. Her pussy was still spasming and another orgasm was coming. I finally started to pull out, but as soon as the head of my dick got to her labia, she reached back and grabbed me. She slid down my shaft before I could turn away and started moving her ass as fast as she could.

  “No, don’t stop—please!” She moaned and bit down on her hand.

  “I’m gonna cum.” I felt my jaw tighten up. “I need to pull out.”

  “Cum in me—just do it.” She started to shake as the orgasm surged through her body.

  Rational thought refused to overcome my lust. I drove my dick deep inside her and growled into her ear as the spasms squeezed my cock. The cum surged through my shaft and then I started to unload inside her. Feeling my cum for the first time without a condom made her orgasm even harder, which drained every drop from my balls. I thrust into her a few more times until the final spasm was done, and then started to pull out. I pulled up my pants and she turned around to wrap her arms around me. I didn’t regret what we did, but I couldn’t help but worry that we took it too far. If she got pregnant—what would we do? I would never abandon my child. I wasn’t that kind of man. I certainly wouldn’t ask her to get rid of it—a baby was still a miracle, no matter how the life was conceived.

  “That was incredible.” She exhaled sharply and purred into my ear. “I should have been stalking Santa backstage from the beginning.”

  “I wish I could keep my arms wrapped around you forever, but the break is almost over.” I sighed and kissed her neck. “You’ll be coming by the house tonight, right?”

  “I wouldn’t miss it for the world.” She leaned back from our embrace and grinned.

  I made sure the coast was clear before we left the storage closet. We shared one more kiss before she left and I put the suit back on. The taste was still on my lips when I returned to the chair and started welcoming kids to get their photo with Santa while rattling off their list. I was definitely looking forward to seeing Holly again, even if I was a little concerned about what we did. Every moment I spent with her made the inevitable that much harder. I didn’t want to lose her once we were done playing Santa Claus and went back to school, but I had no idea how to make that a reality. I didn’t even mind sharing her with Andy if that meant we were able to be together. I wondered if that sort of thing could actually work—twin brothers sharing the same woman and having a real relationship. It seemed crazy, but I was starting to get so attached to Holly that I wasn’t sure it was as impossible I once thought.

  Holly

  Later that day

  My head was spinning when I left the mall, but I had a huge grin on my face. I was apprehensive when Zach pulled me into the storage closet, but I didn’t regret one second of what we did once the door was closed. It was quick, dirty, and oh so fucking delicious. I probably should have let him pull out, but I was so consumed with my lust that common sense went completely out the window. I had no idea what would happen if I actually got pregnant, but I was pretty sure I was closer to menstruation that ovulation. It wasn’t something I had ever tracked—I never really needed to. Thinking about it did start to make me worry as I drove back home to get ready to head to their house. There was nothing I could do about it, regardless, and I wasn’t going to let it completely ruin Christmas. I only had a couple more days with the twins before our normal lives would tear us apart.

  “Did you do anything fun today?” I stepped through the front door and Andy immediately wrapped his arms around me.

  “No.” He shook his head back and forth. “Until now.”

  I barely made it through the front door before Andy started to kiss me. His lips set me on fire every time I felt them crushing mine. That kiss was no exception. I could sense the hunger as he pushed his tongue into my mouth and began to kiss me with more ferocity. I had to pull away before I soaked the panties that had only been around my hips for an hour. Both of the twins were so fucking irresistible. Just looking into their eyes was enough to make me wet. I suppressed my desires, but not for long. As soon as we made it to the living room and sat down on the couch, he started kissing me again. His lips moved against my neck and he nibbled my ear—so much for not soaking my panties. I could already feel the lust spreading to the fabric between my legs. Andy unbuttoned my jeans, but before he could slide his hand into my panties, the front door opened and Zach walked in.

  “Getting started without me?” He chuckled and tossed the Santa suit on the chair in the living room.

  “I think we got started without Andy.” I looked at Zach and winked.

  “What are you talking about?” Andy titled his head in confusion.

  “Santa got a special treat today at the mall.” Zach sat down on the other side me and put his hands on my shoulders. “Best day ever.”

  “Oh fuck, really?” Andy blinked in surprise as the realization spread across his face. “Now I regret not wearing the suit today.”

  “Like you haven’t been putting your hand in the cookie jar while I’m at work.” Andy moved one of his hand down to my abdomen and flicked a finger against my unbuttoned jeans.

  “Yeah, guilty as charged.” Andy chuckled and nodded.

  “Did you at least make it to the grocery store today?” Zach pulled his hands away and leaned back on the couch.

  “Yes, of course, I did.” Andy’s tone reflected disappointment that his brother would even ask the question. “We’ll have a wonderful Christmas dinner—part two.”

  “Pie?” Zach cocked an eyebrow.

  “Yes.” Andy sighed and nodded. “I didn’t get them from the grocery store this time though. I stopped at the bakery downtown that is supposed to have the best pie in Georgia.”

  “Oh, they do!” I nodded quickly. “Can we—like eat some of that tonight? They’re so much better when they’re fresh!”

  “The only pie I want is right here.” Andy rubbed his hand along my stomach and pushed a finger into the top of my panties.

  “There will be plenty of time for that later.” Zach pushed his brother’s hand away. “I’m starving.”

  “Easy for you to say when you’ve already had her today,” Andy grumbled under his breath.

  We ate dinner, and Zach managed to convince Andy to slice into one of the pies once we finished with our meal. Once dinner was over, we made our way to the bedroom where another night of passion followed. Zach was as ravenous as ever, even after getting a visit from me at the mall. Andy decided that he deserved to fuck me twice since Zach had me earlier in the day, and I certainly wasn’t going to complain. I fell asleep between them with my body still aching from what we had done. Being there in the darkness with the two gorgeous men on each side of me was the best feeling in the world. I had no idea how I was going to crawl into my own bed once the vacation was over. I woke up the next morning and they were both in the kitchen, so I put on my clothes and walked in to join them.

  “I was just leaving.” Zach stood and sighed. “I’m sorry—I have to be there early today because it’s Christmas Eve.”

  “It’s okay. I’m sorry I slept so long.” I hugged Zach and gave him a kiss before he rushed towards the door.

  “I guess it’s just the two of us again today.” Andy grinned once Zach was gone.


  “You like that don’t you?” I walked around the table and traced his shoulders with my finger. “Having me all to yourself.”

  “I don’t mind sharing you with Zach at all.” He leaned back against me. “I do like it when it’s just the two of us though—especially when you decide to be naughty.”

  “I thought you already made me a good girl.” I wrapped my arms around his neck from behind and kissed his ear. “I seem to remember paying for everything I did wrong.”

  “That doesn’t mean you won’t find a few switches in your stocking tomorrow morning.” He reached back and put his hand on my thigh.

  “Do you really think Zach is going to let you use one of those on me?” I giggled and purred into his ear. “You wouldn’t hurt me anyway.”

  “You were begging for more when you were across my knee.” He chuckled under his breath. “I think you liked it.”

  “You know I did.” I kissed his ear again. “I liked it a lot.”

  “If you kiss my ear one more time, I might decide you’ve been naughty enough for another spanking.” He gasped and leaned back a little further.

  “Maybe I want to kiss something else.” I slid my hand down his chest and squeezed his cock through his pants.

  “That would definitely make you a naughty girl.” He exhaled sharply and I felt his cock getting hard.

  “If I’m going to get a spanking, I better make sure I earn a good one.” I walked around to the front of his chair and dropped down to my knees.

  I unbuttoned Andy’s pants and he quickly shifted his weight so that I could pull them down his thighs. Once they were around his ankles he kicked them off and I moved closer, watching as his cock became fully engorged. I stroked him with my hand until he was moaning and then started kissing along the bottom. I was still learning what guys liked from oral pleasure, but I had a pretty good idea based on the way he reacted when my lips touched the shaft. I moved my tongue from the head to his balls and licked the enormous hanging orbs. He moaned even louder, so I took one of them into my mouth and lightly sucked on it before giving the other one the same treatment. After that, I moved my tongue back to the top and started swirling it around the head. He immediately started to shift and his breathing got faster.

  “Yeah, that feels really good.” He moaned and put his hand on my head.

  I swirled my tongue around the head of his cock several times before parting my lips and pulling him into my mouth. My jaw stretched until I could wrap my lips around his shaft and after coating a few inches with my saliva, I started to move my lips along his length. There was no denying that he liked that. His body started to move and he squirmed on the chair. His fingers dug into my scalp and a loud gasp echoed from his throat. I started working my way down his shaft, taking another each time I bobbed on his length. It was so hot to be on my knees between his powerful thighs, making him squirm with nothing but my mouth and tongue. My pussy was starting to get really wet. I slid a hand into my panties and started rubbing my clit while I sucked on his cock. The feeling of bliss roared through my body and I started moving my lips on his cock faster, trying to get every inch down my throat.

  “Oh my god, your lips are so fucking amazing.” He gasped and his other hand moved to the top of my head. “You don’t know how good this feels.”

  I kept moving down his shaft and when his cock reached the back of my throat, I swallowed and took every inch. I started moving along his entire length in one motion, savoring every moan. His grip tightened and he started to control some of my motions, forcing me to keep his cock deep in my throat when I went all the way to his balls. My finger kept moving against my clit and I was moaning right alongside him, getting close to an orgasm. The pressure inside of me was begging to be released. I felt his cock start to throb and I knew he was close as well. I started moving my lips as fast as possible, feeling him pulsate when he went deep in my throat. I tasted the salty pre-cum on my tongue and it made me crave his eruption. I felt the cum surging through his shaft a second later, and I pulled him into my throat as soon as it started to rush into my mouth.

  “Fuck! Oh god!” Andy’s hips started to move erratically and his cum splattered into my throat.

  Feeling him cum was enough to send me over the edge. I swallowed his cum while the pleasure rushed through my veins and an orgasm seized my body. We stayed locked in that moment for almost a minute, both of us erupting in bliss as our bodies reached the climax of our lust. I drained the last drop of cum from his shaft and leaned back, slowly pulling my hand from my panties. Andy pulled me up into his arms and I sat on his lap, snuggled against his chest as I settled into the afterglow of my dwindling euphoria. I really did like spending time with both brothers, but having some time alone with each of them was good as well. I wished I could have spent more time alone with Zach, especially since our time was growing short, but it was hard to do that when he worked most of the day.

  “I guess you found a way to be naughty after all.” Andy slid his hand into my panties and rubbed against my pussy. “So fucking wet—you made quite a mess.”

  “I just got a little too turned on.” I moaned when he pushed into the saturated labia kept going until his finger was all the way inside me.

  “I think you were just trying to make sure you got a good hard spanking once you finally went over my knee.” Andy leaned against my ear and nibbled the lobe.

  “Maybe…” I purred into his ear. “Did it work?”

  “You’re about to find out.” Andy shifted his weight and lowered me down across his knee.

  I was already starting to feel the same desires coursing through me as he pulled my jeans down and ran his fingers across the back of my panties. They quickly joined my jeans around my knees and my ass was bared for him to punish. I still didn’t quite know why I got so turned on from being spanked, but I knew after the first time that I loved it. That was definitely going to be an adjustment once our time came to an end. How would I ever find a guy that was perfect in every way—and willing to put me over his knee? I was going to be so lost trying to navigate the dating world after they basically ruined me for other men. I didn’t want to think about that, because I was finally getting what I had craved since he spanked me the first time, and I was going to enjoy that moment regardless of what the future held.

  SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK!

  “Ow!” I bounced on his knee and my legs kicked involuntarily. “You’re spanking me harder than last time!”

  “Yeah, because I know you can take it—naughty girl.” He chuckled and then his hand started falling again.

  SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK!

  It didn’t take long for that sensation of pleasure and pain to collide together inside me and create unbelievable excitement. I squirmed on his knee and tried to rub my legs together, just to create a little friction and alleviate the pressure that started to build. Andy wasn’t haven’t any of that. He yanked my jeans down to my ankles and then freed one of them. His hand forced my thighs apart so that I couldn’t get even a fraction of pleasure before he started spanking me again. It was a little different without having his finger tease me while he spanked me. I noticed the sting a lot more than I did the last time I was over his knee. There was a fire that was stronger than the sting burning inside me though, and no matter how much I tried to douse it by rubbing against his leg or grinding my hip into him, he immediately put a stop to it.

  SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK!

  “Come on, Andy. You’re getting me so turned on. I need a little bit.” I reached back and grabbed his hand. “Just a touch—please.”

  “You’re going to get a lot more than that once you’ve been properly punished for your naughty behavior—but until then, you’re going to get the spanking you deserve.” He growled and pulled away from my grasp.

  SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK! SMACK!


  I needed something—anything at that point. A light graze or a gentle rub would do. I just needed to feel that bliss coursing through me while I got my spanking. The need was growing into a fever that spread through my body and made me taste desperation on my breath. I would have done anything to feel it. He could have done anything to me he wanted in exchange for a few seconds of euphoria. I squirmed and writhed on his knee, begging with every smack that followed, yet obediently raising up to greet the next echoing sting. The desire was maddening. I finally couldn’t handle anymore. I could barely feel the spanking over my own lust surging through my veins and toying with my thoughts. I shoved my hand underneath my thigh and started furiously rubbing my clit as fast as possible.

  ‘Oh god!” I moaned and before I could even think about what was happening, I was erupting with an orgasm.

  “Enjoy it, because that orgasm is going to cost you.” Andy stopped spanking my ass and waited until I was done satisfying my lust.

  “I can’t help it!” I shook as the orgasm seized every muscle in my body and vibrated deep into my soul.

  I was a naughty girl that never got the chance to be good. If he would have given me the same bliss I got the last time I was over his knee, I could have held out until the spanking was over. It was just too fucking good to hold back and control my lust. After the orgasm was done, my thoughts began to cloud over. He made me wait the first time—he even tortured me before he let me cum. He probably wanted to do the same thing again. I slowly lifted off his knee and looked at him, feeling a little guilt, and worried that I had upset him. It wasn’t my intention, but my desires just got away from me. I hoped he wouldn’t be angry, but I saw eyes that reflected a hint of disappointment staring back at me.