That's a Lie

by Victoria Klahr

  I feel like my chest is about to explode, but so is my dick, especially when she backs her ass up so my fingers rub against her clit. I move my fingers so they’re inside of her, and I stroke her softly while I watch her squirm.

  “Say it again,” I say unevenly, bringing my lips to hers.

  “I love you, Seth.”

  I crush her lips with mine and slide my tongue into her mouth, hard. I kiss her until we both forget to breathe, and at that point we know that breathing is no longer as important as continuing this kiss. My fingers inside of her follow the same frantic and needy cadence of my tongue. Every emotion she’s been keeping from me, not just in the past three months but for four years, is reflected in the desperate way she kisses me back. With every moan she lets into my mouth, I kiss her harder and rub my erection against her harder.

  I need to make her mine.

  I take my finger out, and grab the string of her thong and yank it until it rips off of her hips, shredding the pretty, but unnecessary fabric. She yelps and jumps, but sighs as soon as I grab her hips and stand behind her ass. Putting the useless thong in my pocket, I check one more time to make sure no one is around, and then I pull down my jeans and boxers.

  I’m not fucking waiting, and I sure as hell am not going to miss this opportunity to claim her. I want her to stop hiding from me, so it’s only right for me to show her exactly how I wanna fuck her when I look at her. Hard. Rough. And with more love than she has ever felt.

  I rub my dick along the crease in her ass and then down between her thighs. She grinds against me, ready for me to take her. I grip one hand on her hip, and grab some of her hair in the other. Still bracing herself against the tree, Josie pants and moans when I bend my head down to kiss her neck. I suck on it hard and then give her one last look.

  I see her trust, lust, and love reflected in that look and I smile.

  “No more hiding, Pussy Cat. I’ve got you…” She returns my smile, and then inhales sharply when I move my hips up so I’m inside of her.

  I start thrusting into her, patience completely depleted. I use both of my hands to grip her waist and move her ass so it bounces perfectly on my cock. I slide her out to the tip of my dick and then shove back inside of her, filling up her tight pussy. She’s so tight and feels better than I remembered or dreamed. Each time I pull out, I feel her insides trying grip me back inside. It’s the sexiest thing I’ve ever felt.

  Her screams and moans make me need to fuck her harder, so I push my chest against her back until she’s up against the tree completely. I brace one of my arms on the tree for some leverage while I grind my hips into her at a much faster pace. I grab one of her tits, squeezing it roughly then rubbing it softly, so she feels the mind-blowing mixture of rough and sweet.

  “Oh god, Seth!” she screams, throwing her head back and closing her eyes. Her toes are barely touching the ground as I fuck her against the tree, and I moan into her neck, sucking and biting it as I move inside of her. She starts shaking, and I know she’s close to coming.

  “Josie,” I say severely, making sure she looks at me. I slow down my pace, and wait for her to open her eyes. I have never seen anything as beautiful as this look from Josie. Her mouth is open, moans still escaping it as she pants. Her eyes are wide with unadulterated fervor and devotion. Her cheeks have a rosy tint from the passion she’s letting herself succumb to. Her hair is a wild mess, strands blowing in the breeze. She is perfection- the most beautiful woman I will ever see.

  “Tell me you’re mine,” I urge, enraptured by her beauty and unable to let her go until I know she’s mine.

  Her smirk is so sexy when she looks at me. “I’ve been yours since I was six years old… I’ve just been too scared to admit it.”

  “Say it,” I plead, biting her shoulder bone and still grinding my hips into her slowly.

  “I’m yours, Seth.”

  “No more hiding from me.”

  “Never again.” I see her sincerity in her eyes, and I know she’s telling me the truth. She’s giving me the chance to love her, something I’ve wanted for so long, it almost doesn’t feel real.

  What is real is her pussy clenching around my cock.

  I rock in and out of her, reaching in front of her to rub her clit so she experiences every sensation possible. I’m relentless as I rub her vehemently, never getting enough of the screams and my name spilling out of her in pure ecstasy. Her moans get louder and I have to hold her up against me, since she’s no longer standing.

  “I’m gonna come,” she cries out, turning her head to look back at me. That look. Fuck- that’s so sexy. I shove into her hard and deep and watching her every movement as she convulses in my arms with her orgasm. My hips grind into her jerkily, until I bust.

  “I love you so fucking much, Josie,” I moan against her ear after my cock finishes twitching from the best orgasm I’ve ever had. She sags against me, and I chuckle because she looks thoroughly worn out. She stays there, both of us unable to break up the moment yet.

  “I love you too, Seth. I’m sorry it took me so long to accept that. I’m sorry about everything.”

  “We’ll talk about it later, pretty girl,” I reassure her, pushing her hair back. “We’ll work through it all. Can’t fix it all in one night.”

  She smiles languidly at me and relaxes. I kiss her bruised and lush lips, and slide out of her. I pull down her dress so we can walk back to my truck to leave, and grab her hand to pull her up to my side, wrapping my arm around her when she’s next to me. I’ve never felt so content in my life.

  “Let’s go to my place,” I suggest as we start walking to my truck. Her eyebrows knit in confusion.

  “Why not mine?”

  “I’ve been telling you since I came back that you need to move out of there, Pussy Cat.”

  “That makes no sense, Seth. Why?”

  “You get a new mattress after you were with Blake?” I ask, clenching my jaw. I didn’t want to bring that asshole up. She purses her lips to the side and it’s so cute that I can’t help but lean down and kiss them. Then I kiss her nose as she smiles. “See…. I was okay sleeping with you there because of your nightmares, but I’m not going to make my girl come hundreds of times in a bed she used with her dick ex-boyfriend.”

  She lets out a tiny giggle and shoves my shoulder.

  “You’re so dumb. Fine, we’ll go to your parent’s place.”

  “Been holding off on moving out until you agree to move in with me, you know.” She grins and looks up at me, unsure if I’m kidding or not. I’m not.

  “Really?” she asks, incredulous. I chuckle, and open up the passenger door when we get to my truck.

  “Yeah.” I grab her waist and smile at her. I lift her up, and buckle her into her seat, sliding my hand up her thigh. “So… you gonna move in with me or what, Pussy Cat?”

  Her mouth hangs open, and her eyes widen. I lean down and suck her bottom lip into my mouth. “I’ll convince you eventually.” With one last kiss on her nose, I close the door and get in the driver’s seat.

  I notice Josie fidgeting and pushing her dress in the space between her legs. I grab her hand to stop her and give her a questioning look.

  “What are you doing?” She blushes, the prettiest pink creeping into her cheeks, another image that is too gorgeous for words.

  “Your come is running down my legs,” she says, trying to hide a smile and looking away timidly. My heart pounds hard and my dick twitches in my jeans.

  I lean over the console and pull her dress up so I get a perfect view of her mound, and sure enough I see my come sleek against her thighs. I groan as I run my finger up her leg. The photographer in me wants to get a picture of her gorgeous cunt dripping with a mixture of our come, but I refrain from asking. I’ll keep the image in my head.

  I sit back in my seat, closing my eyes and bang my head against the head rest.

  “Fuck,” I whisper, roughly.

  “What?” she asks warily. I open my eyes and turn toward her,
a wry grin tugging on my lips.

  “Come here. I need to have you again.” I was hard again, the sight of my come marking her body driving me back into a state of lust.

  “What?!” Her voice is high pitched, shock unmistakable in her tone. I raise my eyebrows and grab her hand to move it to my crotch.

  “Oh my god,” she breathes, feeling my hard cock in her hand. “I can’t have sex with you in your truck in the middle of a parking lot, Seth!”

  I throw my head back and laugh sarcastically at her modesty. “Awww, Pussy Cat. I just fucked you outside, behind a building, against a motherfucking tree. You really think I give a fuck if we have sex in my car?”

  “I give a fuck!” she says, smacking my chest. I grab her hand and pull her toward me, as much as her seatbelt gives me room for.

  “Come on… it’ll look like we’re making out. Just straddle me and ride me.

  “Yeah until they see the car shaking and the windows fog up. Then you’ll be giving everyone a show of me…,” she says raising her eyebrows, challenging me. Hard decision.

  My phone blares Of Mice and Men, making my decision for me. She laughs, and leans back in her seat. She’s so fucking cute. I smile at her satisfied expression as I answer my phone.

  “What’s up?”

  “Dude, you guys okay?” Brandon asks. “Is she ok?”

  “What the fuck do you think I did to her? Of course she’s okay,” I answer, turning the key in my truck.

  “You looked pissed as hell, I don’t fucking know. Brooke was worried.”

  “We’re fine. I’m taking her back to my house.” Josie turns to me and gapes. I crease my eyebrows in confusion as I look at her.

  “Ohhhhhh, I see how it is,” Brandon says, a note of humor in his voice. I pull out onto the street and head home.

  “Whatever. I’ll talk to you later, man.”

  “Wait! You’re just now leaving? Did you already have sex with her?”

  “Bye, Brandon.” I push end on my phone and throw it in the cup holder.

  “Why’re you looking at me like that, pretty girl,” I ask, seeing Josie’s expression in my peripheral vision.

  “You told him we were going to your house. He’s gonna know what we’re doing.” I glance over at her and give her a disbelieving look.

  “Are you fucking kidding me? Who the fuck cares? And Brandon’s a dumbass anyway. He has no clue what’s going on.”

  This isn’t happening, she’s not fucking pulling this shit already. I don’t plan on pretending with her and she needs to understand that now. I pull into an abandoned parking lot and face her, irritation motivating my words.

  “Let’s get this straight, now. This is not something I’m going to hide from everyone again. You saw what that did last time.” She cringes as she remembers what happened- me getting head from some other girl, then ending what we had together. She jerks and turns to face the window. I grab her hand, and rub my thumb over her knuckles. “I didn’t mean I would cheat on you, Jos. I just mean that things went to shit because we weren’t honest and weren’t open about what was going on between us. If we hadn’t kept it a secret then maybe I wouldn’t have wasted so long being afraid to tell you I was in love with you.”

  She turns and faces me, listening to what I have to say. “I’m not trying to hide it, I just don’t want them to think I’m a whore.” Then it clicks. For one negative thing that someone said to her months ago, she needs fifty more positive ones to reassure her that she’s not a bad person.

  “Fuck that, Pussy Cat. You know they wouldn’t think that.” I bring my hand up to cup her cheek, loving the way she leans into it without any more hesitation. “You’re not a whore… trust me I know a few… hell, I used to be one,” I tease.

  She laughs lightly and rolls her eyes. I lean in and kiss her smiling mouth, kissing her over and over again until she’s grinning widely and laughing. When she tries to pull away from my assault, I grip the back of her neck and keep her face planted in front of mine so I can keep kissing her. I leave quick, wet smooches over her laughing mouth, and then spread them to the rest of her face.

  Her laughter increases as my kisses increase, and it gives me a warm feeling inside to see her looking so relaxed. I lean my cheek against hers, and say quietly, “I love you, Josie… And feel free to bring your inner whore to my bed any day.”

  She barks out a laugh and shoves me away from her.

  “Drive!” she says, pointing to the steering wheel and incapable of hiding her smile. I put my hands up in a surrender, and then put the truck back in drive, keeping my foot on the brake.

  “Damn, Pussy Cat. If you’re that eager to get back into my pants, we can have a little quickie right here,” I say suggestively, looking over at her with a small seductive smile and give her a wink.

  “I guess…,” she says alluringly, gliding her hand across my thigh. I look over at her and she’s biting her bottom lip, staring at my growing boner. I groan, and debate putting the truck back into park. She grabs my crotch and rubs it in her hand, making me harder. Then her hand moves to her mouth as she stifles a fake exaggerated yawn. “Ahh, but I’m so tired, I don’t really feel like it, anyway.”

  I put the car in fucking park.

  I fling my seatbelt off and reach over to undo hers. Before she knows what’s happening, I grip her waist and pull her into my lap. Once she’s straddling my hips, I push her hair out of her face so I can see her eyes. I watch the dark blue hue change from a shocked expression into smoldering interest as I grind my hips up against her.

  “Don’t tease, Pussy Cat.” I grab the back of her head and bring her mouth down to mine. I play with her lips, biting them and sucking them into my mouth. I love the way she reacts when I kiss her, and I love making it impossible for her to ever experience a kiss as good as the ones I give her.

  “Never,” she whispers, smiling against my lips. I reach my hand out and slide it up her leg and under her dress. I glide it to her still-wet pussy and groan. I pull away and lean my seat back so she has more room, and she falls adorably against my chest.

  “You’re so beautiful,” I whisper, admiring the way she’s laying against me- eyes ravishing, hair a gorgeous mess, and body molded into mine perfectly.

  “I have a secret to tell you,” she whispers back. I raise my eyebrows and smirk. She bites her bottom lip, hiding her grin. “I’ve kinda had a crush on you since sixth grade.”

  “Really?” She nods her head. She’s so fucking cute. “I have a secret to tell you, too.” She raises her eyebrows in return. “I’ve been getting a hard dick around you since sixth grade.”

  She giggles and tosses her hair to the side. Her hand slides down my chest and reaches the zipper on my jeans. She drags it down painstakingly slowly, a sexy ass smile on her lips, and reaches in to pull out my hard dick, stroking it while looking at me. I grab her hand and put it on my shoulder, before grabbing her waist and picking her up to position her so I can get inside of her.

  I slide her onto me, getting even more turned on as I watch her mouth part and feel her hands claw the front of my shirt. Her head tilts back when I’m all the way inside, and seeing her neck open to me is too good of an offer to refuse. I’m an ass guy but I’m also a neck guy, and I want to fucking ruin her throat with my teeth, leaving marks all over so no one else ever touches her.

  I lean up and suck on the side of her neck while my hands move her hips up and down on my cock. I suck her skin into my mouth every time I hit the back of her pussy, bite her when I lift her up all the way to the tip of my dick, and lick her as I roughly shove myself back into her. The truck fogs up quickly with our hot breath, and it rocks as we get a good movement going.

  There’s something different this time with Josie. I don’t know if the fact that I was always so careful with her before blocked some of the passion that we could have had, but it’s fucking incredible with her now. I’m not worried about hurting her, because she knows I love her. I’m only concerned about making it im
possible for her to ever move on from this. I’ll never let her go again, and she sure as hell won’t be able to be with anyone else without thinking about how hopeless it is to get better than me.

  She fists my shirt in her hands, and looks at me with the most sexual look in her eyes. It turns me on so much that I start moving her more forcefully against me. I move my hips up so I’m further inside of her when I bring her back down.

  “Play with your clit,” I growl, knowing I’m close and I need her to come with me. She follows my instruction quickly, and starts rubbing herself in front of me. “So sexy,” I rasp, tightening my grip on her waist.

  She leans into me and starts shivering, unable to control herself while she rubs her clit. The arm she has clutching onto me breaks out into goose bumps, and I smile at the obvious and repetitive sign of when she’s coming. Good fucking thing, because there’s no way I’m going to last any longer. As she screams her release next to my ear, I shove myself into her two more times, and bust inside of her.

  “Why the fuck did I wait so long?” she wonders a minute later, lethargic and worn out against me. Perfection.

  “Told you we’re good together.”

  “Not just good… That was…,” she looks up at me and has a small smile on her face, shaking her head slightly. “You’ve ruined me for anyone else.”

  That’s the point, Pussy Cat.

  Chapter 17

  Josie

  I feel like I can breathe again.

  I’ve been suffocating since Seth left two years ago, and I haven’t been able to breathe right since. I’ve gone everyday living in an abyss of darkness that only got worse as time went on. I latched onto the love I thought I had with Blake, but even that couldn’t bring me back to the level I’m feeling with Seth right now. I see the difference now that I’m letting myself be free with him. He makes me feel alive, liberated, and blithe, and that’s something I haven’t felt in so long.

  I learned to cope with the depression that clung to my soul until I got to a point where I thought that was who I was. It became normal for me to live in that sadness, and I didn’t realize how much I needed him until he got me to admit it aloud.