Foul Play [Merricks, Montana] (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour)

by McKinlay Thomson

  Blake quickly divested himself of his jeans and boxers and stroked his cock from base to tip. Sarah was watching him through half-closed eyes. She licked her lips as pre-cum leaked from his tip.

  James grabbed one of her legs and put it over his shoulder, spreading her wide. Blake watched as he entered her channel with two fingers and pumped them back and forth. James then went back to licking at her clit. Sarah’s moans grew loader with each swipe of his tongue.

  Blake stroked his cock in rhythm with James’s fingers. The faster James moved them in and out of her slick cunt, the quicker Blake would pump his fist along his length. He never took his eyes off her face. She watched him in return. Blake felt connected to Sarah as if his cock was pumping inside of her.

  It wasn’t long before she was screaming her orgasm, long and loud. Blake followed her over, his spunk shooting from his cock to land on his chest. He watched as James slowed his rhythm, bringing Sarah down from her high and leaving her slumped in the chains.

  Blake moved toward the bathroom to clean up, as James unclipped Sarah from the chains and moved her over to the bed. He wiped off his cum and grabbed a clean cloth to take out to Sarah.

  James had taken of her cuffs and was massaging her shoulders and arms. They didn’t want her arm to be sore from hanging there for so long. Blake moved over and cleaned her up before getting rid of the cloth. Sarah lay on the bed drained of energy, but with a smile on her face.

  Fuck, she was amazing. He could feel himself getting hard again and he had only just blown. He wasn’t a young man anymore, and it usually took a little longer to recover. That just told him how special Sarah was, that he could get up this quickly. He was screwed. She had grabbed onto his heart with both hands. He was in love and he was man enough to admit it. At least to himself.

  * * * *

  Sarah lay on the bed panting. She couldn’t believe how strong her orgasm had been. The paddling she had received had hurt like buggery. Just like the spanking, the pain had turned into heat and the heat went straight to her pussy. By the time they had reached twelve swats, Sarah could feel the juices from her pussy starting to run down her inner thighs.

  She wanted to object to her punishment. Getting punished for putting herself in harm’s way was silly to her. But her men seemed to feel strongly about it, so she had let them have their way. She would have thought it was because she had embarrassed them by making a scene. They didn’t seem to mind that, though, happy that she had stuck up for herself. James said he was proud of her for telling everyone that he belonged to her. She hoped Blake didn’t feel left out.

  She loved them both and had seen green when that woman had been hanging off James. She was going to be in a world of hurt when they grew bored with her. Or when she had to go home.

  Sarah sighed as Blake ran a wet cloth over her pussy. James ran his finger around her nipple making it pebble and harden. He leaned forward and kissed her, his tongue entering her mouth and tangling with hers.

  Sarah moaned when his hand moved down to her pussy, and more juices ran out and down the crack of her ass. She was so hot for the two brothers, she was turning into a wantonness, and she was too in love with them to care. Fuck the consequences. As long as she didn’t tell them that she was in love with them, when it was all over she could slink off and they would be none the wiser as to how badly she had fallen for them.

  “Get on top and ride me, little darling,” James said when he stopped kissing her. He helped her throw a leg over his waist and hoist herself up. Sarah leant down and took one of his brown nipples into her mouth, swirling her tongue over the flat disk. James grabbed her ass in his big hands. They were rough from hard work, and she sucked in a breath as they rubbed against her already-abused cheeks.

  “Blake is going to put some cream on your sore ass, baby, and then we are going to stretch your little bottom hole. Have you ever been taken there before?” Sarah froze, lifting her head to look at James.

  “No, sir.” Sarah didn’t like the idea of stretching her back hole. Though she had never been fucked that way before, she knew it involved a lot of lube and some very big butt plugs that she would probably have to wear. Not to mention the size of her men’s cocks. Those beasts were huge. They would have trouble getting inside her tight hole, and the person to suffer would be her.

  James spread his legs, and Blake got onto the bed behind her. James moved his fingers up to play with her nipples, pinching and pulling on them. It wasn’t enough to distract her from Blake, and she stiffened as he started to apply the soothing lotion to her butt.

  “Your ass is nice and red back here, baby. You have been well punished. Now hold still,” Blake said. Easier said than done, Sarah thought. She heard a cap pop and tried to hold still despite what was coming next.

  “Come down here and kiss me, little darling. Try to relax your ass and let Blake in.” James grabbed the back of her neck and pulled her down. She kissed him, biting and nipping at his lips.

  When Blake applied cold lube to her crack, she pulled on James’s lip with her teeth. She heard him chuckle, his big chest vibrating under her flattened breasts. Trying to relax, she went back to kissing James. He had such soft lips, and even though he let her dominate the kiss, there was power in his lips and tongue. She could lay here kissing him all night.

  Sarah felt Blake circle her hole with his finger as he spread around the lube. Then he slipped a finger into her ass. She stilled at the strange sensation. Clenching her muscles around his finger, she tried to trap it and stop its progress. She was unsuccessful, as it moved slowly in and out of her dark passage.

  “That’s it, baby girl. Let me in,” Blake encouraged. Sarah wasn’t sure whether she liked the feeling of something in her ass or not. When Blake added a second finger, her hole stung and she moved forward, trying to get away.

  “Settle down, little girl. Not much longer.” Blake moved the fingers inside her ass, scissoring them back and forth. It wasn’t too unbearable, but she wanted him to stop.

  “Easy for you to say. You don’t have anything shoved up your ass.” Sarah let the comment slip before she realized what she had said. When she did she froze.

  “There’s the sassy brat I have been waiting to see,” Blake said, swatting her sore ass with his free hand. “But that would be, ‘you don’t have anything shoved up your ass, Sir.’”

  “I’m sorry, Sir,” she said, trying to placate him.

  “Don’t be, little darling. We like that you are getting confident enough with us to give us a little sass,” James said from under her. She had almost forgotten he was there. Sarah had been so distracted with what Blake was doing, she forgot about the man between her thighs. Oops.

  “Help her relax, James. I’m almost ready to put in the first plug.” Blake continued to scissor his fingers in and out. The sting was slowly receding, but the sensation was still strange.

  “Lift up, baby, and ride my cock,” James said from below. Sarah lifted herself up slightly and then lowered herself onto James’s large cock. It was a tight squeeze with Blake’s fingers in her back hole. As his large, mushroom-shaped head popped past her opening, Sarah moaned. It was such a tight fit that there wasn’t a nerve inside her pussy that he didn’t touch.

  James leant up and grabbed onto a nipple with his mouth and suckled vigorously. The triple sensation was driving her insane and she started to ride up and down on James’s cock quicker and quicker. When she thought she couldn’t take anymore and was moments away from orgasm, Blake halted her movements with a hand to her shoulder.

  “Hold still, little girl. I’m going to insert the first plug.”

  James kept up on his delicious torture to her nipples, and her clit throbbed where it rested against James’s pelvis. She was panting, trying to catch her breath. Blake removed his fingers from her ass. She felt almost empty now that her back hole wasn’t filled. But that was about to change, as she felt something hard and cold pushing against her ring of muscle.

  “That’s it, li
ttle girl. Relax and push against the plug.” Blake slid the cone-shaped plug inside and back out, each time going deeper. Sarah tried to relax her muscles and push against the plug as it demanded entry. She started to rock back and forth on James’s cock, rubbing her tender clit on his body. Her orgasm was building again, and it wouldn’t take much to finish the job.

  “Hurry up, brother. I’m not going to last much longer. Her pussy is squeezing my cock like a fist.” James threw his head back and moaned. Sarah used the opportunity to lean forward and suck on his exposed neck.

  At last the plug was all the way inside her, and as Blake sat back, James grabbed her hips and slammed her down on his cock. Sarah sat back up and rode him hard. Her large breasts bounced with her movement. She was moaning and crying out as she moved closer and closer to completion.

  “Fuck me, James. Harder, please. Oh god, it feels so good,” Sarah said. His big cock pounded her insides, and her pussy gripped him in return. The only sound to be heard was their moans of delight and the slapping of flesh when her butt slapped down onto his thighs.

  “Fuck, baby. I’m so close. Come now, Sarah.” James gave her the permission she needed and she screamed her completion. Wave after wave of pleasure washed through her body. James screamed under her. She felt his hot cum fill her cunt as he exploded inside her.

  Sarah lay on his chest panting, her body slick with sweat from her exertion. James wrapped his big arms around her body and pulled her close.

  “You are incredible, little darling,” he said. He too was out of breath. His chest was rising and falling under her head. They lay like that for a while before James rolled them over and slowly slipped his cock from her pussy. He got off the bed and went to the bathroom as Blake’s face filled her vision.

  “Don’t forget about me, baby girl,” Blake said.

  “I don’t think I could ever forget you.” Sarah smiled up at him and held out her arms to him. His big body came down on hers, and she spread her legs wider to let him in. His mouth lowered to hers, and he kissed her. One big hand moved to play with her nipples. Sarah was instantly ready again. What was it about these men that had her libido so charged and ready at a moment’s notice? One touch from her men and juices leaked from her pussy. Even after two orgasms she was raring to go again, with no sign of slowing down.

  “Hurry, Blake, please. I need you so badly.” Sarah wrapped her legs around his hips and encouraged him in. Blake reached down and lined up his cock with her channel. In one swift move he entered her to the hilt, his big cock butting at her womb.

  “Yes, sir. That feels so good,” she told him. Where her confidence came from when she was in the throes of passion, she had no idea. The words just flew from her mouth.

  “God, baby girl. So tight, so hot. Fuck, you feel good.” Blake pumped slowly in and out. The pace was driving Sarah nuts. She needed to be fucked hard and fast. She grabbed onto Blake’s butt cheeks and tried to control his movements. He retaliated by taking her hands and holding them above her head.

  “Please, Blake. I need you to move faster. Please, you’re killing me.” Blake chuckled at her and continued to keep the pace slow and even. He bent his head to take her mouth once more. He was not in a hurry to finish, and it was making Sarah hot and frustrated.

  Sarah bit and nipped his lips in aggravation and tried to pump her hips under him. Nothing she did had any effect on Blake. He slowly entered her again and again. Just when Sarah thought she couldn’t take anymore and was going to scream, Blake pulled all the way out of her, leaving her empty and bereft.

  “Roll over, little girl. On your hands and knees,” Blake said. “Someone is trying to top from the bottom, James. So now she’ll get what she wants, but she might not like it.” Sarah did as she was told, rolling over and moving into position. James joined them back on the bed and sat against the headboards, smiling at her.

  Blake moved in behind her and gave her a slap to her already red ass. He rubbed his large cock up and down her slit before entering her once more. Grabbing onto her hips, he pulled her back along his cock. His movements were rough and quick, giving Sarah the speed she wanted. Sarah was soon back to moaning, getting louder and louder as her orgasm approached.

  “Give Sarah something to keep her quiet, James,” Blake said as he pumped his hips. James moved to kneel in front of her. Palming his cock, he waved it in her face. She opened her mouth and took the large purple head between her lips. Sarah sucked hard, hollowing out her cheeks as James’s cock moved back and forth. She swallowed when he bumped the back of her throat.

  As she sucked James’s cock, Blake continued to take her hard from behind. The first slap to the side of her ass took her by surprise, and she nearly choked as James hit the back of her throat. Blake slapped the sides of her butt alternatively. Every time he withdrew, he would slap her butt before he rammed his cock back into her tight cunt.

  Sarah could barely concentrate on sucking James’s cock as Blake rode her. She was grunting and moaning with need, so close to completion, but unable to go over.

  “Don’t stop sucking his cock, little girl. You don’t get to come until he does.” Blake followed his statement up with an extra slap to her butt. She had never been taken this way before. And that was just what Blake was doing. It was rough and hard and primal. She loved every minute of it. Her already sore ass hurt like buggery, but that just added to the excitement and thrill of the intensity in which Blake was fucking her.

  “That’s it, little darling. Swallow everything I give you,” James said. He grabbed her head between his hands and took control. Sarah relaxed her throat and let him fuck her face as she prepared to swallow his cum.

  After a couple more strokes, his cock grew in her mouth and erupted, shooting cum onto her tongue. He tasted salty and sweet, his jism filling her mouth and dripping down her chin. She swallowed all she could. She stuck out her tongue to swipe at his retreating rod.

  “Fuck, that was good, baby. You look so hot with my cum on your chin.” James slumped onto the bed next to her. Blake kept up his brutal pace behind her.

  “Come, little girl. Now!” Blake delivered three more hard swats to her tender behind. He reached under her and rubbed his fingers on her throbbing clit. She screamed his name and exploded in the most intense orgasm yet. It was soon followed by Blake’s loud bellow as he came, grabbing her hips and stilling his movements. His hot cum shot into her channel. They slumped into a pile on the bed.

  Sarah lay there completely spent. She was totally exhausted from the multiple orgasms her men had given her. She never realized sex could be this good. She was soon drifting off to sleep, a smile on her face. She felt one of the men cleaning her up and tucking the blankets around her. They pulled her into their arms and she snuggled into them as sleep took over.

  Chapter Fifteen

  Sarah woke the next morning alone in the big bed. She rushed naked into the bathroom and quickly took care of business before jumping in the shower. She was tender down in her girly parts, and her butt was sore from the punishment she had endured last night.

  She soaped up her body, thinking back to the events of the night before. She couldn’t believe that she had said what she had at the bar. She was going to look like a fool if she ever showed her face in public again. Not to mention she was supposed to be in hiding. Candy had really gotten to her. Sarah’s feelings for the brothers were so new, and that added to the anxiety she felt. When she had seen Candy hanging off James, Sarah had not only felt jealousy, she had felt used. That made her see red. She had said and done things she normally wouldn’t.

  Then when they had gotten home, she was punished not for her behavior, but for starting a fight that she could have gotten hurt in. That had opened her eyes to a world she barely knew and sensations she was eager yet scared to explore.

  She was still confused at how she could get turned on by pain. When Blake and James had chained her up, she was apprehensive, but turned on. The paddle had hurt and been amazing at the same time.
The resulting orgasms were like none she had ever experienced. They were so intense, and she had felt so connected to the two brothers.

  Blake and James must be right. She must be submissive. Oh, she always knew she wanted a man who took charge in the bedroom, but she never realized that she wanted all the kinky stuff that went with it. When Blake had flipped her over and taken her from behind, she was amazed that she could like sex that was so raw and dirty. The brothers weren’t gentle and there was no flowery stuff, yet she still felt loved and cherished. It was amazing and she wanted more.

  Sarah finished cleaning herself, noting that the butt plug was gone. They must have taken it out when she was sleeping. Sarah smiled to herself. She didn’t like the butt plug all that much and hoped she didn’t have to wear it too often. She knew she would, if she wanted to take the brothers at the same time.

  She turned off the water and dried herself. When she walked back into the bedroom the bed was made. Clothes were lying on the end of the bed for her to wear. Sarah let out a big sigh. Who kept doing that? She was perfectly capable of choosing her own clothes. Why would someone want to decide what she wore? It boggled the mind.

  Sarah got dressed in the clothes left for her and made her way downstairs. She really needed to ask the brothers which one it was. They always did it when she was in the shower, so she never saw them. She bet it was James. That seemed more like something he would do. He had ordered for her when they ate out.

  She walked into the kitchen to see James at the table bent over and reading the paper. He was so good-looking in his worn jeans and checkered shirt. His light-brown hair had fallen over one eye. His brow scrunched as he concentrated on his page. She stood there staring at him until he lifted his head and smiled in welcome.

  “Morning, baby. Did you sleep well?” James asked her. He patted his lap, motioning her over. She didn’t need any more encouragement than that. She rushed over and plopped down on his lap, wrapping her arms around his neck. He kissed her good morning, and Sarah moaned into his mouth. His lips were soft under hers, but held strength at the same time.