by Lisa Hobman
Friday the ninth was the long-anticipated night of our trip, and I called to collect her at seven that evening. The two of us had been getting on well. We were back to… hmm… I was going to say normal, but I don’t think there was such a thing where we were concerned.
As I drove through the rain to Oban, we chatted about music. It turned out that Mallory used to sing in a choir, and I was intrigued by that fact. The trouble was, it only made me love her more. Stupid images of us doing a duet in the pub played in my mind like some sappy teen movie where we’d fall in love across the stage. It was all in soft focus as she gazed lovingly at me from her place beside me.
To top all of that off, she mentioned that she once sang ‘Martha’s Harbour’ by eighties folk rock band, All About Eve, and it was a song that I absolutely loved; it sent shivers down my spine every time I heard it. I decided right then, I had to manufacture a way to get her to sing it. I simply had to. Even if she did insist that I did nothing of the sort. My mind was working overtime.
Just like the last time I’d been to the open-mic place, it was heaving busy and the atmosphere was alive with music and voices. This was something I loved. I got such a buzz from being around musos with a penchant for performing. It made me feel alive. Being here with Mallory just iced the cake and put the cherry on the top.
We grabbed a table and got some drinks. We listened to a few of the acts performing, and I slyly watched Mallory smiling up at the stage. Some young guy was singing ‘Yellow’ by Coldplay, and her eyes were filled with tears as she listened. She’s just too bloody cute.
The next singer was a girl with long titian hair and vivid green eyes. Her resemblance to Mairi was staggering and I was suddenly mesmerised. Mairi couldn’t sing for toffee, but if she could have, I imagined that this was how she’d have sounded. I felt someone squeeze my arm and I glanced to the side to find Mallory watching me with a knowing expression.
I wiped at the moisture around my eyes and smiled. ‘I’m… erm… just nipping to the gents’. Won’t be long,’ I told her as I stood and backed away, feeling a little silly for my outward expression of emotion over the complete stranger on the stage.
Once inside the men’s room I went to the sink and stared at my reflection. Being with Mallory just did something good for me. I looked so much more vital. Gone were the dark circles I’d been plagued with and now I looked like me again. She had well and truly saved me. I just wished she would let me do the same for her.
I splashed cold water on my face and took some calming breaths. I was about to put my plan into action, and I was scared she’d slap me or be so angry that our fragile friendship would once again be on the rocks. On the way back to the table, I chatted to the guy taking names of performers and gave him the information he needed. He told me I was up next and so I dashed back to Mallory and grabbed her arm. She followed me with a frown on her face but didn’t ask questions, although I saw that she had plenty.
‘You know you sang “Martha’s Harbour” as a solo in your choir that time?’
She frowned. ‘Yes, yes, of course I remember. We were just talking about it.’
‘Aye, well, I hope you remember the words, ’cause it just so happens it’s one of my favourites, and we’re just about to perform it live on stage.’ I, of course, knew it like the back of my hand.
She pulled her arm to try and free herself from my grip, but I just grinned and held on tighter. Yep, she’s gonna kill me.
Her eyes widened. ‘You must be mad! There’s no way I’m—’
Too late. The announcer’s voice came over the sound system. ‘Ladies, gentleman, it’s time for a duet now. Next up this evening we have Greg McBradden accompanying Mallory Westerman as she sings “Martha’s Harbour”.’
She sat down on the stool beside mine and gawped open-mouthed in the direction of the audience. The stage lights were bright and so she would be able to make out only shadows as I could. I began to strum the opening chords of the song and gazed at her encouragingly, hoping she wouldn’t freeze.
She closed her eyes and began to sing. She had an amazing voice. My heart and stomach flipped simultaneously and I almost fell backwards off my perch. I tried my best to focus on my playing so as not to let her down, but honestly, I just wanted to stop and listen instead. My insides turned to mush. My God, can this woman get any more perfect? Seriously, God, you’re having a laugh now with your bloody tormenting. I glanced skyward for a moment and then back to the angel beside me as she sang the song with such feeling that my stupid eyes began to sting again. This woman turned me into a bloody emotional wreck in the best possible way.
When the song ended, I placed my guitar down carefully and banged my hands together with the rest of the crowd. She was fucking awesome! My palms were red raw when I stopped clapping but I didn’t care. I’d just fulfilled a dream I had only just realised I had and if God had struck me down there and then I would’ve died a happy man. We stepped down from the stage and I placed Rhiannon against the wall. Scooping Mallory into my arms, I swung her around, kissing her cheeks and head. When I placed her down again, her eyes met mine and the chemistry between us literally took my breath from my body.
I leaned down and gently placed a kiss on her lips. There was nothing I wanted more in that moment than to deepen the kiss and slip my hands into her hair. The way she returned my stare told me she wanted that too, but instead she pulled away.
I huffed out a breath and shook my head. ‘You were amazing up there; do you know that?’ I told her as I ran my hands roughly through my own hair. ‘You’re a bloody good singer. You’ve been holding out on me, you sod.’
Her responding smile was wide. ‘I have to admit it felt pretty amazing too.’
‘Come on, let’s go get you a drink. I bet you need one after what I just sprang on you.’
She laughed. ‘You say that almost as if you’re sorry.’
‘Nope, can’t say that I am. How else would I have discovered your hidden talent?’
She hit my arm lightly. ‘Stop it, you’re making me blush.’
‘Aye, so I see. Pink suits you,’ I teased and she stuck out her tongue like old times, making me chuckle.
After I’d delivered Mallory’s much-needed Jack and Coke – I was very diplomatic this time and didn’t complain – I went and put my name down again to do a solo number or two. I chose my songs carefully and made sure to connect with Mallory’s eyes at key points in each song. I played my own rendition of Cyndi Lauper’s ‘True Colours’ but couldn’t make eye contact during that one. I knew my heart would break again if I did. Later I sang ‘Ever Fallen in Love’ by the Buzzcocks and gave her a cheeky grin, making her blush again.
I figured if she continued to read between the lines as she had done with the CD I’d made her, then maybe… just maybe, there was still a tiny flame of hope to be fanned.
Chapter Forty-five
As we drove home after our night out, we chatted about some of the acts we’d really enjoyed. The quality of performers had been especially good, and we both agreed that it was great to see so many talented people all in one place. I was doing my best to encourage Mallory to join me there again sometime, but she was taking some convincing. Every time I glanced over at her throughout our journey, the twinge of sadness returned – which was in total conflict with the happiness I felt just being with her and talking to her. My life was going to be such a double-edged sword and there appeared to be little I could do to change that.
Eventually we pulled up outside her cottage and I switched off the engine. Turning to face her, I bit the bullet. ‘Can I ask you something, Mallory?’ I took her hand.
She turned her face away and removed her hand from mine. ‘I’m not sure that’s a good idea.’
‘I’m going to ask anyway. I think I’ll be able to tell the real answer by your body language.’
She turned to face me once more. ‘Greg, don’t, okay? We’ve had a lovely evening. Please don’t spoil it.’
I pushed o
n regardless of her protest. ‘Mallory, can you look me in the eye and tell me honestly that you don’t want to be more than friends?’
She sighed. ‘Greg, you lied about being married. It doesn’t matter how I feel. You broke the trust we had. It will take a long time to get that back. I would always be wondering if there was more to come.’ Her eyes filled with tears, and I wished so hard that Michael J. Fox were here with his time machine. What I wouldn’t give to go back and change this whole damned situation.
I spoke again, but the emotion I was trying to keep in check did its best to betray me through my croaky voice. ‘Mallory, I don’t love her. I still love you. It’s always been you.’ I took her hand once more. ‘I know you feel something for me. I know you do. Why deny it?’
‘Greg, stop. I’m not going there again. It doesn’t matter how I feel.’
I was way past the safe zone now. The ice beneath my feet was cracking and I was about to plummet into the deep, dark chilling depths of loneliness again when she told me to get the fuck out of her life, but I continued on my suicide mission because I couldn’t stop myself from at least trying to make her change her mind. ‘Just let me kiss you. It’ll all melt away; all your doubt.’ I leaned forward and ran my hand through her hair, grazing her cheek with my thumb.
Her lip trembled and a tear escaped her eye. ‘I can’t,’ she whispered as she pulled her hand away. Without any further words she climbed out of the car and closed the door behind her.
I swallowed hard and closed my eyes briefly. Okay. Enough now, McBradden. Time to move on. I started the engine and pulled away from her cottage with a resigned feeling of failure.
*
I had a call from CAT with details of my first gig a few days after the open mic night. And I made my way to a club over by Oban the following Friday night. Once I was set up, I went to the bar to get myself a drink. The woman behind the bar came over to take my order; she smelled like Mallory, and my eyes drifted to meet hers. She was very pretty. Not stunning like Mallory, but attractive. She had friendly, warm brown eyes and full lips. In the back of my mind I wondered if maybe this would present itself as an opportunity to get Mallory out of my head even if she was firmly rooted in my heart.
‘Hi there, what can I get you?’ she asked as she came to a halt before me.
‘Just a pint of cola, please.’
‘So I’m guessing you’re Greg?’ She placed my drink on the mat before me with a sultry smile.
I turned up one side of my mouth even though I didn’t feel the smile internally. ‘Aye, guilty as charged.’
‘My dad showed me the clip online of you playing “Fields of Gold” by Sting. I have to be honest and tell you it made me cry.’
I laughed. ‘Was it that bad?’
She smiled back. ‘No, silly, it was beautiful.’
‘Why, thank you… erm?’
‘Kate. My name’s Kate Walker.’ She held out her hand and I took it.
‘It’s a pleasure to meet you, Kate.’
‘And you too, Greg.’
Unsure really as to why, I suddenly felt that things were maybe getting too flirty, and a sense of betrayal niggled at the back of my mind only this time it related to Mallory rather than Mairi.
I changed the subject. ‘So, you mentioned your dad?’
‘Yes, he owns the place. I just help out every so often. I’m actually training to be a nurse.’
‘Hmm, very admirable.’ I nodded as I took a swig of my drink.
‘Very tiring.’
When it was time to perform I smiled out at the audience and introduced myself to the gathered crowd. ‘Evening, all. So, my name’s Greg and I’m a muso-holic.’ A chuckle travelled the room and relief washed over me. They weren’t as lively as my usual crowd but maybe they would grow to love me. Who knew?
The night went really well and I played ‘Fields of Gold’ especially for Kate. I’d liked her instantly and it was evident that she liked me too by the way she touched her hair and fluttered her eyelashes when I addressed her. She seemed very warm and she was curvy in all the right places… rather like Mallory. Urgh! Will I spend every waking hour comparing every woman to Mallory? We chatted after the gig before I set off back home, and she accompanied me to the car. Once I loaded my guitar into the Landy, I turned to where she stood beside me, arms folded.
‘So… you’re here again next week, aren’t you?’ she asked with hope in her voice.
‘I am, Kate, aye. I’ll look forward to it.’
‘Me too. And thanks for playing that song for me. That was really sweet.’
‘You’re very welcome. It was a pleasure to meet you.’ I shook her hand and she squeezed mine before I climbed into the Landy and rolled the window down. ‘Will you be here next time too?’
She bit her lip and smiled shyly. ‘I wouldn’t miss it for the world.’
Okay… she’s flirting again, so why don’t I feel anything? ‘Great. See you then.’ I wound the window back up and drove away, waving as I left.
I let the smile fall from my face like a stiff mask. Mallory didn’t want me; she’d made it abundantly clear. So why did trying to move on feel… wrong? Maybe I was trying too hard? Or maybe it was too soon?
My journey home was one of introspection. I wondered if I ever actually would move on. I’d clearly moved on from losing Mairi. Although the pain of losing her was still there, it wasn’t as strong as the agony I felt inside at all the mistakes I’d made with Mallory. Why was that? As I drove, the lyrics of ‘Better than Me’ by Hinder floated around the car, and my heart clenched as Austin Winkler’s emotion-filled voice spoke the words that expressed exactly how I felt. Mallory could definitely do better than some grumpy barman with a penchant for sad songs and making mistakes.
Mallory was worth ten of me. And I wanted her to be happy, but the thought of her being with someone else knotted my insides and took my breath away. I pulled over and stopped the car for a moment to calm myself down and fight the tears stinging my eyes.
Resting my head forward on the steering wheel, I remembered my words to Mallory, uttered in a lucid moment when I was drunk and she had rescued me from myself. ‘I don’t want to be alone. I hate it.’ And I did hate it. But I was torn between being alone for the right reasons and forcing myself to be with someone for the wrong ones.
The more I tossed the thoughts around my mind like papers on the wind, the more I decided that maybe my moving on would help Mallory to do the same. She deserved to be loved by someone worthy. So maybe I should do this… maybe I should find someone else. Maybe I should do it… for her.
*
The night after my gig, Mallory and I had a shift together at the pub. I left my car at home and walked down to the village in the crisp October evening air, enjoying the starry canopy overhead. When I arrived, Mallory was already there behind the bar and she smiled as I walked in.
As the night progressed and things quietened down, I decided to ask Mallory’s advice about Kate. I really liked her and seeing as I was single – kind of… aside from the small matter of my marriage still being legal – and seeing as Mallory didn’t want me, I was thinking of asking Kate out for a drink or meal or something. But this time I would be honest from the start. See, I do learn from my mistakes.
I hoped that Mallory would see I was doing what she had asked of me and after I’d rambled on about Kate for a while, Mallory simply said, ‘Well, maybe you should just go for it.’ Her voice was devoid of enthusiasm and emotion. I’d clearly bored the head off her.
‘Aye, maybe I will.’
*
The following week I arrived again at the club owned by Kate’s father. The place was buzzing and quite a crowd had gathered. Adrenaline coursed through my veins for more than one reason. I was excited about the gig, obviously, but I’d also decided to ask Kate out on a date – something I hadn’t done in a very long time. She hadn’t been wearing a ring on her left hand when we met, and she had flirted with me, so I figured why the fuck not?<
br />
She was sitting at the bar rather than standing behind it, and I went over to say hello. She looked lovely in a royal-blue dress that dipped low in the front but not in a tasteless way. As I approached her, she turned and smiled.
‘Well, hello there, Greg. Looking very handsome again, I see.’
I’d made a special effort and worn a new shirt with my black jeans, so I was glad she’d noticed. ‘Thank you. You’re looking rather stunning yourself, Kate.’ She blushed, which was really sweet. ‘So, not working tonight, eh?’
‘No, I decided I wanted to give you my full attention tonight.’
She was definitely interested. ‘Look, Kate, I was wondering… would you maybe like to go out for a bite to eat with me sometime?’
A wide smile appeared on her face and she pulled her bottom lip into her mouth, something she seemed to do when she was flirting. ‘I’d love to. I was hoping you’d ask.’
That was it. It was easier than I’d expected. We arranged a night out and I went to play. She watched me and sang along when she knew the words, but I didn’t mind really. She had a lovely smile and it stayed in place for the whole evening.
At the end of the gig I asked how she was getting home. I wasn’t sure if she lived locally or even if she maybe lived above the venue with her father.
‘I was going to get a cab, why?’
‘I could always drop you at home. That way I know where to pick you up from on our date.’
‘Good idea. Come on, then,’ she called over her shoulder as she headed towards the exit.
I followed and opened the door for her to climb in.
Chapter Forty-six
After following Kate’s directions, we arrived at a small block of flats on the outskirts of Oban and I switched off the engine.
‘Do you mind if I don’t invite you in?’ Her question gave me a flashback of Mallory, and I had to shake my head slightly to dislodge the thought of her from my mind.
‘Erm, no, I wasn’t expecting you to. We’ve only just met, after all.’